Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why are people normalising antidepressants?!

283 replies

mumyes · 05/01/2023 21:04

Just watched yet another reel on Instagram about "the thugs that make me happy"...coffees with friends, downtime, fresh air...and my antidepressants.

It feels like the entire world thinks it's normal to take them.

I am in no way judging those who do, it just feels bloody tragic that life is so shit for so many people that this is now becoming what seems like the norm.

Lessen stress on people, pay them more, treat workers better.

Oh no, let's treat people like shit & shovel pills into them so they don't care.

Surely this is not a good thing.

OP posts:
AlienatedChildGrown · 06/01/2023 17:05

I’d just like to add, I genuinely tried for decades to do all the good stuff people suggested. But it didn’t make a dent. I wanted to die. To make life go away. But didn’t want to hand my bucket of pain to my little sister, then later my husband & son. You would never have known after interacting with me what was going on in my head.

My baseline was so low that nothing I tried could pull it up. And I was basically knackered from pushing the thoughts away I had very little energy left over. It became my normal. I bristled when my Doc. suggested them as I was recovering from Covid. I’d lived with it so long I thought my normal, was normal.

Took them. Improved massively within 3 months. For an entire year and one month I’ve used the fabulous app to do all the “good stuff” anti depressants & anxiety solutions. Exercise, better diet, walking, meditation, gratitude, drinking water, forgiving myself, mindfulness.

It’s all fucking amazing ! I can’t believe how transformed I am. I don’t just want to live, I want to live well. But the ADs were required to lift my baseline high enough so I could help myself. I needed both. But one had to kick in before I could embrace the other. I climb the mountains to be the best I can be everyday. It’s not a slog, it’s my “journey” (as much as I hate the word, but it does feel like one, so I get over the inner chuntering about sounding like an aged hippy)

I can’t be the only person who just got used to having a way too low base line and thought their shit head space was normal, to be expected and lived (not well) with it. Perhaps the change is that more people are aware their base line is too low, so are less resistant to medication than I was ?

Also… if I had grown up in the age of SM I genuinely think my baseline would have shifted even lower. Thank god my idiocy/not coping days were not recorded and uploaded for all the world to see and share. Thank God there weren’t gaggles of people all too willing to jump into my spiral of doom days with an overload of empathy and/or their own misery, which ALWAYS (even in the real world on a very much smaller scale) dragged me down deeper. I did better when I told nobody, “pulled my socks up” and walked through the world with a brave face on. Alone in my bad headspace. Which helped contain it to some extent. But that isn’t very fashionable, or is considered actively harmful, these days. And wasn’t much fun.

JamSandle · 06/01/2023 17:00

Eyesopenwideawake · 06/01/2023 16:28

If the medicine worked more than "marginally better than a placebo", if the medicine didn't have horrendous side effects and if it was easy to discontinue the medicine once it had worked then you might possibly have a point.

Ever seen the meme "it's not good enough to just keep pulling people out of the river, we need to find out why they are falling in"?

Maybe if governments invested in mental wellness education (teaching the basic tenets of CBT to 12 year olds rather than insisting maths be learnt until 18, as an example) big pharma's profits would be cut slightly. They'd survive.

A lot of the time we know why people are falling in the river. The powers that be simply don't want to make things any easier for most people.

AlienatedChildGrown · 06/01/2023 16:42

I started taking them about 2 years ago. Stopped suicidal ideation (every single day when not so bad, constantly when bad) that started in May 1984.

I’m a product of the early popularisation of “children are resilient” and “children can’t be happy if one or both of their parents aren’t, so parents should prioritise their own happiness, cos that is what best serves their kids”.

It obviously won’t be the whole or majority reason why AD use is up. But I think the above mantra & happiness equation produced ever growing numbers of my ilk, which may have played a part in the rise of AD usage.

KimberleyClark · 06/01/2023 16:35

Not everyone takes anti depressants for depression. Some like me take them for anxiety. And they work

pinkpotatoez · 06/01/2023 16:33

They kind of are the norm, it's hardly shocking hearing someone's on antidepressants. It's so easy to get them from GP and life is shit for a lot of people

Eyesopenwideawake · 06/01/2023 16:28

Littlepuddytat · 06/01/2023 14:31

My point was made tongue in cheek, in response to the suggestion that the AD industry is too big and that is a concern. Nobody suggests too many people are taking insulin, or viagra, or painkillers.

So taking medicine for physical problems is absolutely fine, but apparently not for mental. Which just goes to show that poor mental health still isn't regarded as a proper medical condition.

If the medicine worked more than "marginally better than a placebo", if the medicine didn't have horrendous side effects and if it was easy to discontinue the medicine once it had worked then you might possibly have a point.

Ever seen the meme "it's not good enough to just keep pulling people out of the river, we need to find out why they are falling in"?

Maybe if governments invested in mental wellness education (teaching the basic tenets of CBT to 12 year olds rather than insisting maths be learnt until 18, as an example) big pharma's profits would be cut slightly. They'd survive.

Littlepuddytat · 06/01/2023 14:33

Within that average is a group of people who experience much better results on antidepressants

So they do work then.

Littlepuddytat · 06/01/2023 14:31

smooththecat · 06/01/2023 08:58

Ridiculous to compare depressive states to the condition of either having a stiffy or not. Yes, sure, that might have MH implications but, honestly?

My point was made tongue in cheek, in response to the suggestion that the AD industry is too big and that is a concern. Nobody suggests too many people are taking insulin, or viagra, or painkillers.

So taking medicine for physical problems is absolutely fine, but apparently not for mental. Which just goes to show that poor mental health still isn't regarded as a proper medical condition.

mumyes · 06/01/2023 11:27

MastieMum · 06/01/2023 10:34

Sedated by James Davies provides a very readable discussion of the reasons behind increases in anti-depressant use, for anyone who'd like to explore more about this.

Thank you

OP posts:
BHRK · 06/01/2023 11:25

It’s wrong to say they have been proven not to work, that’s just not true. Researchers don’t understand the exact mechanisms by which they do work, but the evidence from millions of experiences are that they can be effective. www.rcpsych.ac.uk/mental-health/treatments-and-wellbeing/antidepressants

Onebelow · 06/01/2023 11:13

chocolateflapjacks · 06/01/2023 06:49

It's talked about as nauseum at the moment. Just go on tik tok.

ADs have been proven not to even work

Proven where? By whom? If you’ve no experience, why even comment. It’s better to sit and be quiet and look dumb, than to open your mouth and remove all doubt 😉

Follycastle · 06/01/2023 10:56

chocolateflapjacks · 06/01/2023 09:54

Research suggests antidepressants on average do work marginally better than placebos (dummy drugs people are told could be the real thing). There are debates among researchers about how significant this difference is.

Within that average is a group of people who experience much better results on antidepressants - doctors just don't have a good way of knowing who those people are when prescribing. And there is a group who will fare much worse.

While there are risks to leaving depression untreated, some people will experience serious side-effects from antidepressants - which the serotonin study's authors say need to be more clearly communicated.

Quotes from the BBC article

I’ve read this three times and still don’t see where it says antidepressants have been proven not to work, which is what you claimed.

MastieMum · 06/01/2023 10:34

Sedated by James Davies provides a very readable discussion of the reasons behind increases in anti-depressant use, for anyone who'd like to explore more about this.

procrastinator8 · 06/01/2023 10:30

chocolateflapjacks · 06/01/2023 09:54

Research suggests antidepressants on average do work marginally better than placebos (dummy drugs people are told could be the real thing). There are debates among researchers about how significant this difference is.

Within that average is a group of people who experience much better results on antidepressants - doctors just don't have a good way of knowing who those people are when prescribing. And there is a group who will fare much worse.

While there are risks to leaving depression untreated, some people will experience serious side-effects from antidepressants - which the serotonin study's authors say need to be more clearly communicated.

Quotes from the BBC article

Clearly explained. Thank you for pointing this out.

procrastinator8 · 06/01/2023 10:29

Clearly explained. Thank you for pointing this out.

Mylittlesandwich · 06/01/2023 10:26

My citalopram saved my life, more than once. I wasn't offered them as a first line though. I was referred for CBT. However I became suicidal while waiting so a prescription was written. Mental health is a minefield. It's so personal and what helps one doesn't help another. I've had counselling and CBT and the only thing that has reliably allowed me to live and enjoy my life is that little white pill I take in the morning. I did however feel like I'd "failed" because I hadn't just been able to pick myself up and dust myself off. So for me, to see other people taking similar medications makes me feel normal. Like I'm not the only person in the world that couldn't work out their problems and move on.

chocolateflapjacks · 06/01/2023 09:54

@Follycastle

chocolateflapjacks · 06/01/2023 09:54

Research suggests antidepressants on average do work marginally better than placebos (dummy drugs people are told could be the real thing). There are debates among researchers about how significant this difference is.

Within that average is a group of people who experience much better results on antidepressants - doctors just don't have a good way of knowing who those people are when prescribing. And there is a group who will fare much worse.

While there are risks to leaving depression untreated, some people will experience serious side-effects from antidepressants - which the serotonin study's authors say need to be more clearly communicated.

Quotes from the BBC article

OopsAnotherOne · 06/01/2023 09:19

I have paracetamol when I have a temperature, aspirin or ibuprofen when I have a headache and I take steroids when my autoimmune condition flares up. I have steroid cream for my eczema which I will have to use on and off for the rest of my life to prevent my eczema returning. I take a rizatriptan tablet whenever I get a migraine so I can (usually) function normally after an hour or so.

I take antidepressants for my depression, which allows me to be motivated enough to do the non-medical treatments too, such as therapy, exercise, meditation etc.

It's just another medication and I just think the stigma has been removed rather than any sort of "normalisation" that means antidepressants are being taken unnecessarily. It's the same as "why are people normalising insulin for diabetes?!". Antidepressants are known to be an effective way to treat and reduce the symptoms of depression, allowing people to function better. They're just tablets which reduce the negative symptoms of an illness, like any other medication does.

While I do think the nation's mental health shouldn't be so poor that so many people do need antidepressants, I don't think removing the stigma over a medication which has been proven to help so many people is anything but a positive action and normalising seeking/receiving help for mental health problems shouldn't be looked down upon.

Tandora · 06/01/2023 09:17

Of course it’s a good thing. It’s a medicine that improves the quality of people’s lives like many other medicines. Would you tell someone with rheumatoid arthritis it was no good thing they were taking DMARDS?

Follycastle · 06/01/2023 09:11

Read this www.bbc.com/news/health-62286093.amp

You absolutely cannot say that antidepressants have been proven not to work, FFS.

smooththecat · 06/01/2023 08:58

Ridiculous to compare depressive states to the condition of either having a stiffy or not. Yes, sure, that might have MH implications but, honestly?

chocolateflapjacks · 06/01/2023 08:55

Why are we normalising erectile dysfunction? Why are GPs throwing drugs at these men? We shouldn't be normalising this. These men should put up with no sex life while doctors run tests to find out why they've got problems.

The global insulin industry was valued at 22.3 billion usd in 2021. Why are we normalising insulin? Why are doctors throwing insulin at people when surely the patient should look at their lifestyle first so as to ensure that we aren't over prescribing insulin?

These are physical conditions where it's clear the drugs work. ADs aren't as simple.

mumyes · 06/01/2023 07:12

blackheartsgirl · 06/01/2023 00:36

I’d be dead now if I hadn’t started taking antidepressants.

I’ve suffered since I was 14 and the events in my life in the past 18 months have taken a massive toll on my mental health.

it’s not a get up and go pill ffs, I was already doing way way to much of that trying to cope with all the shit. It’s literally a save my life, and get me back living again.

im not A little bit down, or poorly paid, or not spending enough time with my family, these are not the reasons I need anti ds

My psych would agree, even my gp is out of her depth with me.

I'm so sorry you've been through crap. I hope you're doing better Flowers

OP posts:
Littlepuddytat · 06/01/2023 07:06

Eyesopenwideawake · 05/01/2023 22:40

Someone with depression - whether it be caused by their situation/environment, negative self view due to a less than ideal childhood, or genetics - looks to their GP for a solution.

Within that typical 8 minute consultation, with a doctor who hasn't specialised in mental illness, there is little time or opportunity for the doctor to do anything other than prescribe what the patient desperately wants - a pill to make them feel better. If the antidepressant does that then the patient is going consider it a success. Sometimes simply the placebo effect will be sufficient to get the patient through a shitty situation or maybe there will be a sustained positive effect. If it works, great. All you then have to deal with are the nasty side effects of withdrawal and, if your life hasn't improved while taking them, being right back to square one.

What is clear is that the antidepressant market is a massive part of the pharmaceutical industry - valued at around $16 billion in 2022 and growing fast. Therapy does not generally produce any profit for the drug companies or the people who lobby on their behalf.

This video is enlightening for those who want to know more;

The global erectile dysfunction drugs market was valued at USD 2.30 billion in 2021.

Why are we normalising erectile dysfunction? Why are GPs throwing drugs at these men? We shouldn't be normalising this. These men should put up with no sex life while doctors run tests to find out why they've got problems.

The global insulin industry was valued at 22.3 billion usd in 2021. Why are we normalising insulin? Why are doctors throwing insulin at people when surely the patient should look at their lifestyle first so as to ensure that we aren't over prescribing insulin?

The global analgesics market is predicted to reach 149.3 billion usd by 2030. That's too much. We are overmedicalising people who are in pain. GPs need to stop throwing painkillers at people because ... Um... Too many people are in pain? We shouldn't normalise taking a painkiller when someone's in pain. They should continue to suffer daily while doctors do some tests. Those people should go for a walk or do yoga or something. I'm sure there's more they could do to help themselves so that we aren't normalising painkillers.