Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell you the NHS is a frightening failure for children?

332 replies

redorbreak · 05/01/2023 20:19

I suppose when we read headlines it's A&E waiting times and often focused on adults

But I'm here to give a personal account of how dangerous it is for children, something we haven't shone the light on as much as adult care and waiting times being horrible right now.

DD was born very prematurely and she had some awful breathing this morning, which then worsened into sucking in a lot at the rib cage (not that unusual for her but it seemed worse than usual). She couldn't stay awake much

I knew an ambulance would take a long time and needed the car, so I was going to drive her myself. I went to put her into her car seat and she went floppy, like a rag doll. Limp and floppy. I screamed and luckily H was there who phoned an ambulance

I explained calmly but seriously on the phone what was going on. The phone operator said 5 hour wait. I said please, she's gone floppy. Please help us. She said sorry, but 5 hour wait times. Can I take her myself?

I explained I could take her myself but I wouldn't be able to see if she was okay or not? I'd be driving. She said that was safer than waiting for an ambulance

I put the phone down and took her in, frightened, petrified for her life. I got there after 25 minutes and rushed to her. She was still not responding. She was triaged straight away. Her Sats were sitting at 69/70.

She is currently in PICU (intensive care) and I don't know when she will wake up. Nobody seems to be straight with me. I'm not getting a clear picture here. My H is on his way up now and hopefully they will tell me straight what this means for her now

The NHS is fucked.

OP posts:
MrsRinaDecker · 05/01/2023 23:30

Thinking of you OP and praying your daughter is on the mend soon.
On the off chance you’re in Scottish city D, with hospital beginning with N, I’m local to you and happy to drop off a meal / coffee / phone charger / anything you need.
Absolutely shocked at what you’ve gone through today, I knew it was bad, but not how bad. And agree with others.. you’re a rockstar of a mum for getting you both there safely.

BabyFour2023 · 05/01/2023 23:30

WoolyMammoth55 · 05/01/2023 23:29

Ugh you are vile.

OP, like us all, like our parents and grandparents before us, has ALREADY PAID for her and her family's healthcare through taxes and NI contributions.

Because she, and all of us, HAVE ALREADY PAID for our healthcare, we should expect the same standard of excellent care that was delivered consistently by the NHS for many decades, peaking in 2008.

Since then the Tory government has destroyed it. Therefore, as OP points out, the system has failed her child today. As the nurses on strike for the first time ever in this country are pointing out, the system is failing patients at an unprecedented rate. NHS leaders went on record this week to call the crisis 'unprecedented': www.theguardian.com/society/2023/jan/02/intolerable-nhs-crisis-to-continue-until-april-health-leaders-warn

OP is doing nothing wrong here. She is speaking the truth and is well within her rights to do so.

Whatever assumptions you are making about her and her child's right to access healthcare, are odious and misinformed.

@redorbreak sending you love and solidarity, wish these brainwashed Tory trolls would find their basic human compassion for once and/or just STFU <3

But she hasn’t been failed… her child is in PICU being cared for and said in her previous Post that she was given care as soon as she walked in.

WoolyMammoth55 · 05/01/2023 23:29

dollymixtured · 05/01/2023 23:15

I appreciate that the OP is no doubt extremely distressed and therefore I will assume that she didn’t think through what she was saying. However it leaves something of a bad taste for someone to rant about the NHS being a ‘frightening failure’ for children when it will be NHS treatment at likely a cost of 10s if not 100s of thousands of pounds that is the sole reason this child even survived.

Ugh you are vile.

OP, like us all, like our parents and grandparents before us, has ALREADY PAID for her and her family's healthcare through taxes and NI contributions.

Because she, and all of us, HAVE ALREADY PAID for our healthcare, we should expect the same standard of excellent care that was delivered consistently by the NHS for many decades, peaking in 2008.

Since then the Tory government has destroyed it. Therefore, as OP points out, the system has failed her child today. As the nurses on strike for the first time ever in this country are pointing out, the system is failing patients at an unprecedented rate. NHS leaders went on record this week to call the crisis 'unprecedented': www.theguardian.com/society/2023/jan/02/intolerable-nhs-crisis-to-continue-until-april-health-leaders-warn

OP is doing nothing wrong here. She is speaking the truth and is well within her rights to do so.

Whatever assumptions you are making about her and her child's right to access healthcare, are odious and misinformed.

@redorbreak sending you love and solidarity, wish these brainwashed Tory trolls would find their basic human compassion for once and/or just STFU <3

ImustLearn2Cook · 05/01/2023 23:28

@redorbreak You must have been absolutely terrified. I hope your baby makes a good recovery. Sending love and well wishes 💐🌺🌸

ImustLearn2Cook · 05/01/2023 23:26

@Kendodd you are absolutely right.

Kendodd · 05/01/2023 23:24

EYProvider · 05/01/2023 23:14

There are far fewer people in Australia. The UK is full to bursting and we don’t have the infrastructure to cope with it.

Someone from a remote Scottish or Irish village will be along in a minute to argue that this isn’t the case, but they should try living in London to grasp the reality of what is happening here.

Sorry but how is being 'full to bursting' (don't agree btw) relevant? As long as public services keep pace, numbers shouldn't be a problem. There are other, more densely populated areas of the world. We have made a political choice in the UK to have low provision.

ImustLearn2Cook · 05/01/2023 23:24

I’m also from Australia and I can tell you right now that the level of medical care and availability of doctors and specialists, availability of ambulance, availability of bed spaces in hospitals etc is not consistent across the whole country.

Melbourne and Sydney have many hospitals, doctors, specialists. But, that is only a small part of our country.

mackthepony · 05/01/2023 23:23

Hope you and your DD are doing OK op, what an awful situation.

Yes the NHS is fucked - the government does not care though.

madamovaries · 05/01/2023 23:21

This is awful, I'm so sorry.
Your daughter is in my thoughts - hoping for a v quick recovery.

nolongersurprised · 05/01/2023 23:17

Goosefatroasts · 05/01/2023 22:47

@wyntersuhn

Sounds good. What country?

I’m not the poster but this sounds like Australia, where I live.

The issue on MN is that, in Australia, there is an option for all medical care to be free, just like the NHS but there is a cost to prescriptions, albeit very low if you are a low earner or pensioner or have a chronic condition.

Whenever this is discussed, a MN poster inevitably says : “If I had to pay 3 pounds for a prescription I would have to do without food. I’ll stick with our wonderful NHS, thanks”.

ImustLearn2Cook · 05/01/2023 23:15

@Cuppasoupmonster Everyone has the equal value and importance and right to be treated humanely. Whether you’re a baby or a 90 year old. It is not about how much is potentially left in your lifespan. It is about now. What if that 90 year old is in extreme pain and suffering? Does being 90 years old mean that they do not need to have medical attention so that their pain and suffering can be alleviated?

This is real life, with real people not a philosophical argument.

All people deserve to be treated humanely. We shouldn’t be in a position to have to choose who deserves humane treatment and who doesn’t.

The problem that many people are saying they are having with the NHS is that there is a supply and demand problem. Not enough ambulances available, not enough bed spaces available for the amount of people needing them.

That problem isn’t solved by deciding who is more worthy of being prioritised.

Oh, and triage shouldn’t be based on philosophical arguments. It should be based on practical need.

dollymixtured · 05/01/2023 23:15

I appreciate that the OP is no doubt extremely distressed and therefore I will assume that she didn’t think through what she was saying. However it leaves something of a bad taste for someone to rant about the NHS being a ‘frightening failure’ for children when it will be NHS treatment at likely a cost of 10s if not 100s of thousands of pounds that is the sole reason this child even survived.

EYProvider · 05/01/2023 23:14

wyntersuhn · 05/01/2023 22:43

I live in another country and I'm horrified by what I'm reading about the state of the health system in the UK. I can get a GP appointment today if I need to. At several different clinics, and at all different times of the day. I can also access telephone appointments, and an online prescription service (with a video consult). After hours, I can ring for a visiting GP who brings a range of medications so if I need antibiotics they can give me my first dose then I get a script filled the next day. I have private health insurance, but can use the public system free of charge as well (if I had cancer I'd go private, if I had a head injury I'd go public and then follow up with private therapy). I took DS to hospital for an x-ray of a suspected broken arm recently, in and out within 90 minutes and my GP called to follow up yesterday, video consult booked for next week as we're away on holidays.

Our system isn't infallible and we do have ambulance ramping at times, but an urgent call like yours would have received an ambulance in minutes. I don't know where you start fixing a problem like the NHS but something has to be done.

There are far fewer people in Australia. The UK is full to bursting and we don’t have the infrastructure to cope with it.

Someone from a remote Scottish or Irish village will be along in a minute to argue that this isn’t the case, but they should try living in London to grasp the reality of what is happening here.

B1rds · 05/01/2023 23:14

I don't know when people will stop voting for these people. Do we have to wait until their own relatives are lying in the gutter before they stop excusing it?

Pleasepleasepleaseno · 05/01/2023 23:13

Sorry @dollymixtured but that's nuts. The OP didn't need the ambulance for a bloody lift. She needed the medical assistance to care for her child while en route to the hospital. An elderly person who can't be moved should not be higher priority. My own gran died last year. The ambulance was with us in an hour and a half or so but frankly if we'd waited longer because a BABY was the same priority level so jumped the queue I would not have disagreed with that prioritisation. And you know what, neither would my gran have!

Kendodd · 05/01/2023 23:11

With regard the general state of the NHS and public services, as always, we get what we vote for, everyone know the Tories run public services into the ground. It astonishes me people are still happy to vote for them, I guess they just don't imagine they'll ever need an ambulance.

dollymixtured · 05/01/2023 23:11

Kendodd · 05/01/2023 23:05

Perhaps you missed my post where I said if I had to choose between my own 85 year old mother and my 11 year old daughter, absolutely no doubt who I'd choose. In fact if I had to choose between my own 85 year old mother and someone elses 11 year old, I'd like to think I'd still choose the 11 year old.

I can only assume you don’t like your mother as if not that is a seriously warped way of thinking. Most parents would prioritise their own child over anyone that’s hardly news, that’s why they should have no role in making decisions in situations and policies that require any sort of equity.

Thatboymum · 05/01/2023 23:09

The nhs is looking very bleak, I feel for the staff so much , lastnight I took my 75yo gran in for a burst appendix she hasn’t been in a hospital in 36 years and she was traumatised by the experience she went in at 10pm and wasn’t even seen or admitted until 11.30am the next day left to sit in a packed waiting room on a hard chair in agony being sick everywhere couldn’t even get pain relief till a doctor seen her, she was joined by about 30 others through the night and there was 7 ambulances parked outside for about 10 hours full of patients one of which the priest came out to and she passed away in the ambulance shortly after! The nurse on the base sat with my gran and cried apologetically saying how hard it was to see her but not be able to help her sooner and kept saying the issue is the government and no funding for people upstairs bed hogging needing care homes or packages which makes a&e now more like a ward than an emergency base. It was very eye opening to experience and I truly hope we never need there services anytime soon

Kendodd · 05/01/2023 23:05

IneedanewTV · 05/01/2023 23:00

Not if it’s your mother. Easy to say on social media.

elderly were given priority during Covid that’s why we were all locked up. Children didn’t go to school, teenagers didn’t sit exams because the priority was to keep the NHS going to support the elderly and at risk.

ultimately the nhs has either been under funded for 20 years, wasted finances, growing population but less GP surgeries, inefficiencies whatever. This was inevitable .

Perhaps you missed my post where I said if I had to choose between my own 85 year old mother and my 11 year old daughter, absolutely no doubt who I'd choose. In fact if I had to choose between my own 85 year old mother and someone elses 11 year old, I'd like to think I'd still choose the 11 year old.

karmalama · 05/01/2023 23:04

There's nothing useful I can add about the state of the NHS , the care you received was appalling. Just wanted to send good wishes for your little one

Dyra · 05/01/2023 23:04

I am genuinely gobsmacked that there was a 5 hour wait for a floppy unresponsive baby. That's just horrendous. Only time I needed an ambulance (10week baby, sucking chest, rattly breathing), it was with me within an hour, and we certainly weren't a high priority. I'm glad you managed to get her to hospital, and she's being looked after. Hoping she recovers swiftly.

I am now terrified what would happen if my 2 DC were to fall that ill. Our car broke down last week, so DH couldn't get them to the hospital, and I can't drive anyway. Guess we all need to start planning for the eventuality of what we'd need to do if the worst happens, and help isn't forthcoming any time soon. I think my best bet would be to sprint to the closest GP office if in the day time. At night, bang on neighbours doors and pray someone will take us in. I've had a child first aid app on my phone since DC1 was born, and it's never getting deleted.

dollymixtured · 05/01/2023 23:03

If course babies and children shouldn’t be prioritised on the basis of age. In reality the OP was perfectly capable of getting her child to A and E probably quicker than an ambulance to get to them and then back to the hospital so it seems correct that this wouldn’t be top of the list. I would far prefer an ambulance to be sent to an elderly person who cannot be moved than to a baby who has a parent with a car who can get them to A and E themselves.

Pointerdogsrule · 05/01/2023 23:02

IneedanewTV · 05/01/2023 23:00

Not if it’s your mother. Easy to say on social media.

elderly were given priority during Covid that’s why we were all locked up. Children didn’t go to school, teenagers didn’t sit exams because the priority was to keep the NHS going to support the elderly and at risk.

ultimately the nhs has either been under funded for 20 years, wasted finances, growing population but less GP surgeries, inefficiencies whatever. This was inevitable .

Elderly weren't given 'priority' , the most likely to be killed by Covid were, which were elderly and those with certain underlined conditions.

IneedanewTV · 05/01/2023 23:00

Goosefatroasts · 05/01/2023 22:27

I agree children should be given priority over a 90 year old having a cardiac arrest.

Not if it’s your mother. Easy to say on social media.

elderly were given priority during Covid that’s why we were all locked up. Children didn’t go to school, teenagers didn’t sit exams because the priority was to keep the NHS going to support the elderly and at risk.

ultimately the nhs has either been under funded for 20 years, wasted finances, growing population but less GP surgeries, inefficiencies whatever. This was inevitable .

Bubblesandsqueak1 · 05/01/2023 22:59

5 hours is fast in todays time it was going to be 14 hours for my fil when he had a major heart attack 5 weeks ago now has 4 stints but if neighbours couldn't get him into a car he would be dead

Swipe left for the next trending thread