Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell you the NHS is a frightening failure for children?

332 replies

redorbreak · 05/01/2023 20:19

I suppose when we read headlines it's A&E waiting times and often focused on adults

But I'm here to give a personal account of how dangerous it is for children, something we haven't shone the light on as much as adult care and waiting times being horrible right now.

DD was born very prematurely and she had some awful breathing this morning, which then worsened into sucking in a lot at the rib cage (not that unusual for her but it seemed worse than usual). She couldn't stay awake much

I knew an ambulance would take a long time and needed the car, so I was going to drive her myself. I went to put her into her car seat and she went floppy, like a rag doll. Limp and floppy. I screamed and luckily H was there who phoned an ambulance

I explained calmly but seriously on the phone what was going on. The phone operator said 5 hour wait. I said please, she's gone floppy. Please help us. She said sorry, but 5 hour wait times. Can I take her myself?

I explained I could take her myself but I wouldn't be able to see if she was okay or not? I'd be driving. She said that was safer than waiting for an ambulance

I put the phone down and took her in, frightened, petrified for her life. I got there after 25 minutes and rushed to her. She was still not responding. She was triaged straight away. Her Sats were sitting at 69/70.

She is currently in PICU (intensive care) and I don't know when she will wake up. Nobody seems to be straight with me. I'm not getting a clear picture here. My H is on his way up now and hopefully they will tell me straight what this means for her now

The NHS is fucked.

OP posts:
Goosefatroasts · 06/01/2023 14:14

@FurryDandelionSeekingMissile

It goes without saying we could improve services. We are talking specifically about the current crisis that is happening right NOW. Personally I would prioritise children under the age of 18 over the very elderly.

Goosefatroasts · 06/01/2023 14:12

@Scalottia

It is not just every parent that would think that way. A lot of people with and without kids are able to think objectively about these sorts of matters.

FurryDandelionSeekingMissile · 06/01/2023 14:11

Goosefatroasts · 06/01/2023 13:25

@Scalottia

So two calls come in and they are both equally as urgent. Both categorised as cat 1. The problem is there’s only 1 ambulance available….

Who should the ambulance go too first? The floppy/unresponsive 2 year old or the 90 year in cardiac arrest?

How about, two calls come in, both equally urgent, both categorised as cat 1. Only one ambulance available.

Who should the ambulance go to? The floppy/unresponsive baby, or the 24 year old in cardiac arrest?

The 24 year old has already received many years of expensive public investment into his development, health, education and training, which is about to start paying off in economic contribution, and his parents would be as devastated at losing him as the baby's parents would be. He will have a massive network of family, friends, colleagues, partner, perhaps children of his own, all of whom will be profoundly affected by his death. Apart from the emergency, he's a young fit man at the peak of physical condition who could make an excellent recovery. He can't be picked up and moved and will have to stay where he is until an ambulance gets there.

From a cold economic standpoint, babies have no dependents to need looking after by someone else if they die, they've not yet had much public money spent on developing their economic and other potential, and a new baby of equivalent potential can be quite quickly produced. Babies are also quite delicate in some ways, can suddenly go downhill, and it could be that the chances of saving the baby aren't that great — in all societies, babies die quite a lot. The main people who will be upset by the baby's death are her close family — she doesn't have any friends, colleagues, classmates, or children. She can be easily picked up and taken to hospital by any adult, though of course that lacks the medical resources and expertise of an ambulance and its crew.

And if you argue it's about remaining years, then that means you have to shuffle people with conditions that reduce life expectancy like Down's syndrome down the priority list. If the baby above has Down's her life expectancy is about thirty years less than that of the 24 year old man — and those making the unpleasant economic arguments would have to accept those are less likely to be highly economically productive years.

Prioritising children means prioritising them over everyone, not just 90 year olds.

Or we could prioritise patients based on need and urgency and chance of survival and the usual other relevant factors, include age only where it has an impact on those things (as I mentioned initially, it can be relevant because young children can be hard to assess and deteriorate fast), and most importantly improve the system so we can provide emergency ambulances as fast as they're needed to everyone who needs one.

Scalottia · 06/01/2023 14:01

Cuppasoupmonster · 06/01/2023 13:56

Aaah yes, the right thing to do. In your opinion

And probably 98% of the public’s, if you cared to start a poll.

Look, for some reason you are really desperate for someone to start a poll. I have no interest in starting one because I already know that most of the responses will be to save the baby or child. I am not an idiot - any parent that votes on a poll such as this will choose baby or child! That is biology. I am also not saying that it is wrong to want to prioritise the baby or child, if that is your opinion. It simply is not mine. How difficult is this to grasp?

If you really want a poll, start one.

OP, I am hoping that all goes well with your little one. I will bow out of the debate too because I do not believe that this thread is the right place to continue it. Best wishes to you.

Cuppasoupmonster · 06/01/2023 13:59

Yes I did say that, because I see it in terms of do we prioritise somebody who has lived a full life, or somebody who hasn’t even had the opportunity to get started? Absolute no brainer

Cuppasoupmonster · 06/01/2023 13:58

I would send the ambulance to the one who had the most chance of recovering with minimal future medical issues

That would basically always mean sending it to the baby as elderly people have statistically many, many more medical issues than younger people. As for ‘recovering’, what if they recovered then died of old age 6 months later? A worthy sacrifice of a child would you say?

Scalottia · 06/01/2023 13:57

Goosefatroasts · 06/01/2023 13:46

@Scalottia

Sensible response. I should imagine that criteria would have them going to the child first in the majority of cases.

Perhaps, yes. I realise that they do not have time to go through the medical history in emergency. I realise also that it is not that simple. But in my perfect world, there would be enough resources to help everyone. In the real world, there are not, and decisions (shitty ones), have to be made. I am simply stating that for me it is not so black and white - I would not always prioritise the baby just because it is a baby. However I am not saying that I would never prioritise the baby! My decision would always rely upon circumstance.

The issue that I am having with Cuppasoupmonster is that this PP has flat out said that babies and children must always be the priority. There is no flexibility in this statement at all. I am trying to bring a more balanced view by saying no, there should not be any one age group that should be prioritised above all others.

Cuppasoupmonster · 06/01/2023 13:56

Aaah yes, the right thing to do. In your opinion

And probably 98% of the public’s, if you cared to start a poll.

Goosefatroasts · 06/01/2023 13:48

@Scalottia

But in emergencies they simply haven’t got time to start going through everybody’s clinical medical histories so whilst a sensible criteria in one respect, completely not logistical.

Goosefatroasts · 06/01/2023 13:46

@Scalottia

Sensible response. I should imagine that criteria would have them going to the child first in the majority of cases.

Scalottia · 06/01/2023 13:40

Cuppasoupmonster · 06/01/2023 13:28

Which is why we make objective judgements. A stranger would put the child before your dad, even if they didn’t know either of them. Because it would be the right thing to do.

Its all very well chanting ‘all lives matter’ but that sidesteps the fact we don’t have the resources to act that way. Hence OP’s appalling experience. So who would you choose to send the ambulance to - 90 year old in cardiac arrest or a floppy and unresponsive baby?

Aaah yes, the right thing to do. In your opinion - which you are 100% allowed to have.

I would send the ambulance to the one who had the most chance of recovering with minimal future medical issues. This would be dependant on the general health of the patient to start with. Perhaps the 90 year old has less chance of surviving, perhaps the baby. It is not a nice decision to have to make. However I would never just choose the baby because it is a baby, nor would I choose the 90 year old because that person is a 90 year old.

Goosefatroasts · 06/01/2023 13:34

@Scalottia

I know it is an emotive subject and of course we all hold our own nearest and dearest close to our hearts. It is an ethical dilemma for sure, however we are in crisis times here and so it is interesting to hear of peoples views on this.

My own personal opinion on this theoretical but highly likely scenario is that if you have two category 1 calls and only 1 ambulance,
then of course the child should be prioritised over the person nearing the end of their life. Ultimately I think that is fair and decent.

Cuppasoupmonster · 06/01/2023 13:28

Scalottia · 06/01/2023 13:26

Fucking hell I hate this attitude! EVERY life is important, regardless of age. Beginning of life, end of life, middle of life....none of us have the right to dictate which part of life is more important, which age should be saved over another.

Much more tragic indeed - my father dying would be much more tragic to me than your child dying would be (to me). Your child dying would be much more tragic for you than if it were my father. See where I am going with this?

Which is why we make objective judgements. A stranger would put the child before your dad, even if they didn’t know either of them. Because it would be the right thing to do.

Its all very well chanting ‘all lives matter’ but that sidesteps the fact we don’t have the resources to act that way. Hence OP’s appalling experience. So who would you choose to send the ambulance to - 90 year old in cardiac arrest or a floppy and unresponsive baby?

Scalottia · 06/01/2023 13:26

Cuppasoupmonster · 05/01/2023 21:56

Frankly they should also get priority as they’re babies and children, they’re at the beginning of their lives - it would be much more tragic if anything happened to them because of ambulance delays.

Fucking hell I hate this attitude! EVERY life is important, regardless of age. Beginning of life, end of life, middle of life....none of us have the right to dictate which part of life is more important, which age should be saved over another.

Much more tragic indeed - my father dying would be much more tragic to me than your child dying would be (to me). Your child dying would be much more tragic for you than if it were my father. See where I am going with this?

Goosefatroasts · 06/01/2023 13:25

@Scalottia

So two calls come in and they are both equally as urgent. Both categorised as cat 1. The problem is there’s only 1 ambulance available….

Who should the ambulance go too first? The floppy/unresponsive 2 year old or the 90 year in cardiac arrest?

Cuppasoupmonster · 06/01/2023 13:20

What gives someone the right to say that a childs life is more important than that of an adult?

Common decency? As I said before this type of judgement would be used in life threatening situations only.

Scalottia · 06/01/2023 13:18

Cuppasoupmonster · 05/01/2023 21:09

Children should be number 1 priority for ambulances, and nobody will persuade me otherwise. I’m livid on your behalf OP and hope your daughter makes a good recovery xx 💐

In this case, this child should have been a no. 1 priority. However, I dont agree that 100% of the time children should be the no. 1 priority. What gives someone the right to say that a childs life is more important than that of an adult? It should be based on urgency, not age.

Goosefatroasts · 06/01/2023 13:09

@Cuppasoupmonster

I do agree and I think essentially that will happen but it will be a slow drip, drip. My husbands boss was prioritised for a liver transplant not too long ago (it was not an alcohol induced problem that he had).

I’ve worked in stat MH services for a while now and there is much more emphasis on personal “recovery”. Recovery essentially meaning empowering the individual to take greater control of their MH and to essentially have more responsibility in managing themselves.

We absolutely do need more out of hours services and i suspect a fee to see your GP might be introduced at some point, like Ireland perhaps.

Forgooodnesssakenow · 06/01/2023 13:07

My son had a 50 minute seizure (in hospital thank God) in October, I watched his oxygen drop into the 50s and didn't believe he could come back from it. Aside from his enw epilepsy diagnosis he's a cheeky, energetic 5 yr old and after a week of hell and obviously with my ownental health entirely destroyed, he's doing amazing. I hope it's the same for you. X

Cuppasoupmonster · 06/01/2023 13:01

I think a change of government is a good start but the problems run so deep now that I fear it can never be pulled back.

I fear this as well. It hasn’t just been lack of funds and mismanagement etc - our ‘needs’ as a society have rocketed in the last 30 years. Mainly due to an ageing population but also obesity, addiction, older parenthood and the avalanche of mental health issues.

I feel we’ve reached the point that our society can no longer provide the level of medical support needed, even if there was funding - you can’t make 10% (for instance) of the population train as nurses/doctors/healthcare workers, nor should our economy exist just to prop up the NHS while other resources suffer.

It’s incredibly worrying and the only way out I can see is:

  1. A personal responsibility drive for the obese, addicted etc - rather than letting them carry on as they are and just prescribing pills
  2. A level of privatisation (yep, I said the P word)
  3. Giving healthcare workers a proper pay rise
  4. Improving medical facilities which are between the GP and A&E - essentially out of hours. There should be walk-ins and we need more of them.
SlashBeef · 06/01/2023 13:00

It's massively worrying and its not just the NHS. I had to phone the police for a road traffic accident a few months back and I was on hold before I even got through to an operator. Thank god it wasn't life or death! I was really surprised.

I hope your little girl is okay

dollymixtured · 06/01/2023 12:52

Kevinyoutwat · 06/01/2023 12:49

My dad is 87. If he died tomorrow, I would be sad. But he’s lived a long life and death at that age is expected. I’d get over it.

If one of my children died, I would be inconsolable, I don’t know if I could go on. They haven’t lived their lives. They shouldn’t die before me.

If that makes me weird, so be it.

No one has said that at any point at all! In fact that exact point has been made and agreed with.

Goosefatroasts · 06/01/2023 12:50

@Cuppasoupmonster

I agree. My mum and sister are both nurses but trained under labour whereby they had the generous bursary scheme. It all went a bit tits up for nurse recruitment when the Tories came in and relied on nurses from overseas.

I think a change of government is a good start but the problems run so deep now that I fear it can never be pulled back. In the meantime tough clinical decisions do need to be made in times of scarcity and crisis.

Kevinyoutwat · 06/01/2023 12:49

dollymixtured · 06/01/2023 12:10

No they are not. What is wrong with you? Like that weird post earlier about how the parents would be devastated in a child but when the elderly die it’s all just fine as it’s to be expected! Who actually thinks that they can rank the grief of others.

My dad is 87. If he died tomorrow, I would be sad. But he’s lived a long life and death at that age is expected. I’d get over it.

If one of my children died, I would be inconsolable, I don’t know if I could go on. They haven’t lived their lives. They shouldn’t die before me.

If that makes me weird, so be it.

Cuppasoupmonster · 06/01/2023 12:48

Lasttraintolondon · 06/01/2023 12:45

The NHS is not going to triage patients based on what mumsnet decides.

This is not in anyone's power here. What is though, is actual political change.

If mumsnet was in charge of political change we would never have had a Tory government to start with.