Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Don't want to join the teaching strike

464 replies

SweetRascal · 05/01/2023 19:17

I'm a primary school teacher of 12 years and with the NEU. For my own reasons, I don't want to vote yes to striking but will this be judged negatively by other teachers? I just don't feel comfortable with the disruption it causes.

OP posts:
ilovesooty · 07/01/2023 19:56

Those teachers who took industrial action in the 80s are the reason you have a right to a lunch break.

Things are very different now Apparently they are. The profession appears to have apathetic teachers who aren't prepared to fight for decent pay and conditions because parents might be a bit cross.

Doesn't the crisis in recruitment and retention tell you anything?

Pumperthepumper · 07/01/2023 19:52

Spicyveggie · 07/01/2023 19:47

It matters because we need them on side. If the perception is that teachers (or nurses, or whoever) are lazy and work shy then the government are quite happy - they don’t have to give us what we want. If the perception is one of outraged injustice they are more likely to back down.

@InsomniacVampire i genuinely hope the strike works, I just can’t ignore my belief that it will not, hence I can’t support it. We can’t be part of something we are against, which works against as well as in favour.

No, we don’t need them onside. They need us to do our jobs, and we’re currently leaving those jobs in droves. Being too scared of parents’ reactions will change absolutely nothing.

Spicyveggie · 07/01/2023 19:47

It matters because we need them on side. If the perception is that teachers (or nurses, or whoever) are lazy and work shy then the government are quite happy - they don’t have to give us what we want. If the perception is one of outraged injustice they are more likely to back down.

@InsomniacVampire i genuinely hope the strike works, I just can’t ignore my belief that it will not, hence I can’t support it. We can’t be part of something we are against, which works against as well as in favour.

InsomniacVampire · 07/01/2023 19:43

Spicyveggie · 07/01/2023 19:38

Or do something that will create more ill will, achieve nothing but hey - we can say we did something?

Because that’s what you’re honestly asking me to do. I believe there are problems in education but I also don’t think there’s been a time there haven’t been problems in education. Strikes don’t tend to solve them, and as identified above, given we can only strike about pay and that doesn’t seem to be what most of us are complaining about, that makes it all the more futile.

Ill will has been demonstrated from the side of the govermnet for years. I don't care if Rishi Sunak dislikes me because I go on strike. He does not care much for us really.
Your artitude is that of complacency, just sitting on your bum, unless you have a magical ways for getting our point across in a different way? Remember, strike IS the last thing people wanted, and it's been brewing for YEARS. What has the govermnent done to create good will form our side, aside for cuts? Nothing.
There have always been problem, sure, but unprecendented shortage of teachers is a very new things, you have to be blind (or extremely naive, ot just very wealthy not to have to care about what is happening with the profession) not to see it.

Pumperthepumper · 07/01/2023 19:43

Spicyveggie · 07/01/2023 19:42

From the general public, primarily. This has always been my feelings with strikes: they don’t actually cause any problems for the people we want to take notice (the government) but do create a nuisance for parents, which often (not always) doesn’t go down well, and for many, the perception is that we were taking the piss over covid as it was. Obviously, I’m not saying this perception is true or even fair but my feeling is that we aren’t going to come out of it well. And to be frank here I don’t trust the unions to support their members when they need it.

But what’s the issue with ill will from the public? Why does that matter?

Spicyveggie · 07/01/2023 19:42

From the general public, primarily. This has always been my feelings with strikes: they don’t actually cause any problems for the people we want to take notice (the government) but do create a nuisance for parents, which often (not always) doesn’t go down well, and for many, the perception is that we were taking the piss over covid as it was. Obviously, I’m not saying this perception is true or even fair but my feeling is that we aren’t going to come out of it well. And to be frank here I don’t trust the unions to support their members when they need it.

Pumperthepumper · 07/01/2023 19:39

Spicyveggie · 07/01/2023 19:38

Or do something that will create more ill will, achieve nothing but hey - we can say we did something?

Because that’s what you’re honestly asking me to do. I believe there are problems in education but I also don’t think there’s been a time there haven’t been problems in education. Strikes don’t tend to solve them, and as identified above, given we can only strike about pay and that doesn’t seem to be what most of us are complaining about, that makes it all the more futile.

Ill will where? And what’s the end result of that ill will?

Spicyveggie · 07/01/2023 19:38

Or do something that will create more ill will, achieve nothing but hey - we can say we did something?

Because that’s what you’re honestly asking me to do. I believe there are problems in education but I also don’t think there’s been a time there haven’t been problems in education. Strikes don’t tend to solve them, and as identified above, given we can only strike about pay and that doesn’t seem to be what most of us are complaining about, that makes it all the more futile.

InsomniacVampire · 07/01/2023 19:35

Spicyveggie · 07/01/2023 16:37

If the strike achieves what we want it to then I will come back and eat humble pie Smile

But I don’t think it will.

So yeah, in the meantime, easier to do f.. all and do nothing and hope for the best, right? 😂
If this approach of you works, I'll eat my words, in the meantime, I'll strike.

Pumperthepumper · 07/01/2023 19:34

Spicyveggie · 07/01/2023 19:34

No idea. That’s why I’m in teaching, not politics. I am fairly certain the strike (assuming it goes ahead) will not achieve what it wants to achieve, though.

A change in government will doubtless bring about change in education and some of those changes will hopefully be positive - not all will be.

Ah ok. Guess the strike is worth a go regardless.

lbnblbnb · 07/01/2023 19:34

Spicyveggie · 07/01/2023 19:26

I thought PPA was part of the task agreement? I don’t think that was achieved by strike action but willing to be corrected - just before my time. I remember it was all over the TES in my training year Smile

Lunch time duties was way back in the 80s. Things were very different then.

The strike action in the 80s (when I was at school) was about lunch duties etc. Directed time, PPA etc was fought for. Not just given.

Spicyveggie · 07/01/2023 19:34

No idea. That’s why I’m in teaching, not politics. I am fairly certain the strike (assuming it goes ahead) will not achieve what it wants to achieve, though.

A change in government will doubtless bring about change in education and some of those changes will hopefully be positive - not all will be.

Pumperthepumper · 07/01/2023 19:31

Spicyveggie · 07/01/2023 19:26

I thought PPA was part of the task agreement? I don’t think that was achieved by strike action but willing to be corrected - just before my time. I remember it was all over the TES in my training year Smile

Lunch time duties was way back in the 80s. Things were very different then.

What do you think is a better way to force change @Spicyveggie?

Spicyveggie · 07/01/2023 19:26

I thought PPA was part of the task agreement? I don’t think that was achieved by strike action but willing to be corrected - just before my time. I remember it was all over the TES in my training year Smile

Lunch time duties was way back in the 80s. Things were very different then.

lbnblbnb · 07/01/2023 19:18

I don't think strike action is a perfect way of dealing with things, but:

PPA (yes it is too little and ignored in some schools) - won by strike action
Not having to do duties during lunchtime - won by strike action

I am sure there are more.

noblegiraffe · 07/01/2023 17:37

If you’re sick of the NEU phoning you, join a different union, I can recommend the NASUWT who also helped me out individually with an issue related to being part time.

noblegiraffe · 07/01/2023 17:35

On the other hand during my PGCE I saw a very effective use of collective action to force change against a HT who was doing nothing to protect teachers from repeated pupil assaults. It was quite heartening, too, to see colleagues standing in solidarity with each other to say enough was enough.

Pumperthepumper · 07/01/2023 17:29

Spicyveggie · 07/01/2023 17:25

I’m not too concerned with the lessons Johnny will miss. I genuinely don’t think the strike will achieve what you/we want it to and I don’t believe the unions have the clout to bring change about. Remember the headteacher who was struck off just before Christmas (you were on the thread IIRC) - the one who had been breaking every law about maternity discrimination over several women over several years? (Citing that because maternity is one area HTs normally tiptoe around) - the unions couldn’t help, and in two years that woman will be back.

It’s shit, but losing a days pay won’t make it any less shit.

What do you think will force change?

Serialcatmum · 07/01/2023 17:28

I’m a member of NEU. I wasn’t originally. I was with a union that did not strike but then they went and “merged” with NEU.

im sick of them stalking me. I blocked the number that texts me often, sometimes 2/3 a day and they actually called me from a different number!!! Leave. Me. Alone.

I see it as I pay them, not the other way around.

Spicyveggie · 07/01/2023 17:25

I’m not too concerned with the lessons Johnny will miss. I genuinely don’t think the strike will achieve what you/we want it to and I don’t believe the unions have the clout to bring change about. Remember the headteacher who was struck off just before Christmas (you were on the thread IIRC) - the one who had been breaking every law about maternity discrimination over several women over several years? (Citing that because maternity is one area HTs normally tiptoe around) - the unions couldn’t help, and in two years that woman will be back.

It’s shit, but losing a days pay won’t make it any less shit.

TheMoth · 07/01/2023 17:23

noblegiraffe · 07/01/2023 17:16

What it does do is get parents muttering about covid closures

I imagine the mutterings of primary parents will be very different to those of secondary where I work, who don’t need childcare.

What we learned from covid closures is that both parents and the media only really care about what’s happening in schools when there’s closures looming. Look how silent they have been on the shitshow that has been going on since they reopened.

We couldn’t buy the publicity for educational issues that potential school closures would bring.

And yes, the Daily Mail will slate us, but they slate us anyway. Others may have their eyes opened, particularly if teachers talk openly about it.

If teachers don’t strike when the ambulance workers, the nurses, the doctors and so on are willing to refuse to work when they are responsible for patient healthcare and teachers back off because Johnny will miss a few lessons, then a) that’s pretty weak given the impact on Johnny of the shit state of education and b) people will assume that education can’t be in that bad a state then if teachers aren’t willing to make a stand when others are.

This is what worries me. And the fact that is we give in here, we may as well give in to everything. I've been teaching over 20 years, so maybe i was influenced by thosewho had fought for proper break times and less adminetc when I was still in school, but I honestly can't understand any teacher who wouldn't do anything they could to get the point across. But then, I don't think teachers tend to be as militant as other professions, sadly.

Wonder if some subjects are more inclined to strike than others. Must be some data on that somewhere.

noblegiraffe · 07/01/2023 17:16

What it does do is get parents muttering about covid closures

I imagine the mutterings of primary parents will be very different to those of secondary where I work, who don’t need childcare.

What we learned from covid closures is that both parents and the media only really care about what’s happening in schools when there’s closures looming. Look how silent they have been on the shitshow that has been going on since they reopened.

We couldn’t buy the publicity for educational issues that potential school closures would bring.

And yes, the Daily Mail will slate us, but they slate us anyway. Others may have their eyes opened, particularly if teachers talk openly about it.

If teachers don’t strike when the ambulance workers, the nurses, the doctors and so on are willing to refuse to work when they are responsible for patient healthcare and teachers back off because Johnny will miss a few lessons, then a) that’s pretty weak given the impact on Johnny of the shit state of education and b) people will assume that education can’t be in that bad a state then if teachers aren’t willing to make a stand when others are.

mynameisnotkate · 07/01/2023 17:06

FormerAcademic · 05/01/2023 19:34

I was opposed to university lecturers striking, and didn't go along with it although I was a member of the AUT. I taught as normal. It meant crossing a picket line, but they were people I'd never seen in my entire life, so it wasn't as if I was losing friends over it. If I'd gone on strike, I'd only have given myself an even more horrendous week later on in which I'd have had to make up everything the students had missed. It suited me better to stick to the timetable.

I think you’re missing the point of strikes. They’re not convenient, though usually extremely difficult - they’re done because the majority believe conditions are so bad that the pain and expense is worth it. And making up for work you’ve missed during a strike is effectively strike breaking.

Morally, I feel that the point of being in a union is to work together, so you have to go with the views of the majority. I would never work through a strike my union had voted for. If I really felt I couldn’t support it, I would leave the union.

Spicyveggie · 07/01/2023 16:45

I get that but in terms of what it actually achieves i don’t think they care.

What it does do is get parents muttering about covid closures and closing for QEs funeral and ‘now this again’ - obviously unfair but that’s how it’s perceived in some parts.

noblegiraffe · 07/01/2023 16:43

If it’s a protest generally then fair enough

I think a lot of it is about protest generally. Look at the state of the country and tell me you don't want to stick your middle finger to the government in some way.