Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be sick of societal expectations and 'only children' prejudices

241 replies

reddwarfgeek · 05/01/2023 18:18

I probably am being massively U here but still. Absolutely sick of hearing things about only children being lonely selfish, etc. It gives me anxiety.
I know some amazing only children . And I know some selfish bastards people who can't compromise who have many siblings. Why does this stuff continue to be peddled out?
Everywhere I go people ask me about having a second baby. I'm sure it's not to internationally upset me but after 5 years I just don't know what to say anymore. Had enough of it.

Lots of second babies have been announced this last week on social media. Even though I am pretty sure I don't think want another ...I feel pangs of sadness when I see this. Of course I'm happy for them. It's just hard to see sometimes.

1 child suits some families better. Some women, like myself, feel they can't effectively parent more than 1 child and that's ok. I know my limitations. But then I happy families with 3 or 4 children and wonder how the hell they manage.
The truth, as you can probably tell, is that I'm not quite at peace with 'only' having 1. I wish I could be, maybe it will happen in time. However there are many many reasons why having an only child suits us better and why I'll almost certainly stick with one.
I'm not particularly maternal, have poor MH and my partner nor my parents are helpful. All taboo subjects you can't admit to in RL.

I feel lonely regarding other mums at school. There are some lovely mums but they also often ask me when I'm having another. There are some only child mums but most are considerably younger than me.

I've started to gravitate towards my childfree friends, of which I'm fortunate to have plenty, and they talk about other things. I'm careful not to constantly talk about DD in their company. It's nice to be myself and not judge on my number of children.

I feel like I don't fit in to many social circles now and I wonder if anyone can relate? I'm 37, nearly 38 by the way.

This topic has been done to death, and for sounding horrible and bitter I can only apologise 🙈

OP posts:
reddwarfgeek · 06/01/2023 11:38

In case anyone is wondering my own family set up, I have a brother, close in age.

Whilst we got on well as children, we became very different people in our teens.
He's now 36, a (recovering) addict, no money and barely a pot to piss in if you excuse the phrase. Forever asking my parents and me for money and generally giving us headache. I love him very much, but siblings do not always make life better.

I have absolutely no doubt that he will not help me at all when my parents die.

OP posts:
MRSDoos · 06/01/2023 11:36

I am not a mummy yet - currently 22 weeks with our first! But I think people are like this with every aspect of your life

If you’re single, people ask when you will get a partner

Then they ask when are you getting engaged

Then they ask when is the wedding?

Then they ask you about having a baby

Then they ask you about siblings

The list continues!

I have learnt not to ask these questions. It was a killer when people kept asking when we were having a baby after our wedding because we had just miscarried twins weeks before our wedding day…

reddwarfgeek · 06/01/2023 11:34

@felulageller How will your life be harder?

I'm sorry but I really don't agree having an only child is selfish.

OP posts:
reddwarfgeek · 06/01/2023 11:33

@TempsPerdu Great post and I totally agree- rarely get comments from close friends and family, it's more the wider circle of people we know think it's an acceptable seemingly endless conversation starter! Definitely seen the comments on here and elsewhere suggesting a family of 4 is 'complete'.

It is hard to swim against the tide even when you know it is the right decision for you.

OP posts:
felulageller · 06/01/2023 11:31

Being an only has made and will in the future make my life much harder.

It is selfish.

I get the not wanting to be overwhelmed but then you can have big gaps so only one young DC at a time.

We all do selfish things though. It's not the end of the world. But own your choices and accept them.

reddwarfgeek · 06/01/2023 11:29

@Suprima You are correct-if I had more support from partner and a bigger support circle I would have been more likely to have another child.
But it is what it is and I'm trying to accept my circumstances.

OP posts:
TempsPerdu · 06/01/2023 11:25

There seems to be lots of people on MN who don't speak to their siblings. In real life, I don't know many people in this situation

I don’t know anyone who actively dislikes or has zero contact with their siblings. But I do know a lot of siblings who are pretty indifferent to each other, or who through lifestyle or circumstance have ended up with fairly distant relationships. I’m not an only child myself, but my brother emigrated several thousand miles away, and any elderly/dementia care for our parents will inevitably fall to me.

Suprima · 06/01/2023 11:23

You would be absolutely insane to have another baby with a useless partner and I think you know this

only child judgement definitely exists- but I think you are struggling because your circumstances and boyfriend’s parenting skills is stopping you having the sized family you want

SleeplessInEngland · 06/01/2023 11:23

Comedycook · 06/01/2023 11:15

There seems to be lots of people on mn who don't speak to their siblings. In real life, I don't know many people in this situation. I speak to my sister every day and see her several times a week. She has kids and my DC adore their cousins. My parents were both dead by the time I was 25... if I didn't have my sister and her family, I'd be really alone...apart from a few distant relatives.

That level of closeness to a sibling is, while nice, probably unusual. So the norm is likely somewhere in between that and no contact at all.

socialmedia23 · 06/01/2023 11:21

I only want one child and my DH's younger sister started saying that children needs siblings. Bearing in mind that she is a 20 something in a flatshare and thus has no experience of how much it costs to have children/mortgage/childcare (was saying that how can anyone afford £1k for childcare when that is standard in many places, not just the UK).

I told her that DH and I have been using natural family planning for 8 years so probably not the most fertile, would be happy to have 1 child rather than planning for multiples. That shut her up.

XelaM · 06/01/2023 11:20

Comedycook · 06/01/2023 11:15

There seems to be lots of people on mn who don't speak to their siblings. In real life, I don't know many people in this situation. I speak to my sister every day and see her several times a week. She has kids and my DC adore their cousins. My parents were both dead by the time I was 25... if I didn't have my sister and her family, I'd be really alone...apart from a few distant relatives.

My dad doesn't speak to his brother and hasn't for over 20 years. I have zero contact with my cousins from my dad's side.

Although my mum's brother and her get on, we only see him a few times a year at most as he lives abroad as do his kids (two live in the same country as him, two in a completely different country). I haven't seen my cousins from my mum's side in years.

My brother lives in the same city as me but he has his own life and we meet up every few months.

Not unusual at all.

electricmoccasins · 06/01/2023 11:20

I say, “Well, it took us eight years to have our daughter… she’s actually a miracle child”. Then, they usually shut up.

BabyOnBoard90 · 06/01/2023 11:15

XelaM · 06/01/2023 11:10

What garbage!

My best friend is one of 4 siblings close in age and one of them is her twin(!) and she is the most self-centred and selfish person I know. She actually acknowledges it and that's why she never wants kids and can't understand anyone who would want kids because she wouldn't be able to concentrate on herself/live her best life.

Only thing that's garbage is the assertion that somehow your anecdote is a superior truth to mine.

I already acknowledged this is based purely on my experiences, not a scientific study posturing an objective truth, purely anecdotal and can't be generalised to everyone - which I already said.

Comedycook · 06/01/2023 11:15

There seems to be lots of people on mn who don't speak to their siblings. In real life, I don't know many people in this situation. I speak to my sister every day and see her several times a week. She has kids and my DC adore their cousins. My parents were both dead by the time I was 25... if I didn't have my sister and her family, I'd be really alone...apart from a few distant relatives.

XelaM · 06/01/2023 11:15

The school bully was one of 5 kids

TempsPerdu · 06/01/2023 11:15

I hear you OP. We have one child, largely by choice. Still happy with that choice, but it’s hard to swim against the tide in any aspect of life, and despite one-child families statistically becoming more common, there aren’t very many others that we have come across, and 2 or even 3 children is still very much the norm.

We’re lucky in that we haven’t had many direct comments on our family size from friends and family, but I have had a few from strangers and acquaintances along the lines of ‘Oh, you definitely need to have another one or DD will be terribly lonely’. Also a certain degree of incomprehension that we are happily ‘one and done’, rather than struggling with secondary infertility - there seems to be an assumption among some people that you can’t be content with just the one, or that you’re somehow trying to dodge the stresses and strains of ‘real’ (in their eyes) parenthood.

The other thing that sometimes gets me is the frequent casual comments on here and other sites about having a second child ‘because I knew I didn’t want DD/DS to be an only’. And flippant comments among friends irl like ‘I feel like we’re a proper family now we have our second’. I certainly think it’s true that the majority of people don’t care how many DC other people have, but I also think there is still an implicit, often unconscious, idea that only children are somehow lesser, and to be pitied.

XelaM · 06/01/2023 11:13

My daughter's four closest friends are only kids and they are totally lovely and very caring girls. On the other hand, her best friend from primary was one of three and quite selfish.

Seasonofthewitch83 · 06/01/2023 11:12

I hate the whole 'I dont want my elderly care to be burdened on just one child.'

Or

'I want them to have company and play with each other.'

None of these things are assured - I never played with my brother growing up and he did absolutely fuck all help with my Dads end of life care. If anything, he was a hindrance. We dont speak.

I often wonder if money wasnt the main issue for our decision to stop at one, would we have another? I dont think I would. I am 40 this year, I know my risks for having a child that may be ND is higher and I know I would struggle.

Instead we are able to offer our child a wonderful life of travel, security, expenses and our time, whilst also having time just for us as adults.

XelaM · 06/01/2023 11:10

BabyOnBoard90 · 06/01/2023 10:37

The most common thing is

  • they are all about themselves and struggle to feign genuine interest in the lives of others, and even when they do the subject matter is quickly unintentionally diverted back to them.
  • They're also not the most confrontational, and either shy away from conflict or have poor approaches to conflict resolution. There are other traits but I'm not in the mood to offend people this AM.
  • They don't like sharing things most don't care about. Conversely expect you to share things most wouldn't ask you to share.

I remember this became a subject matter on holiday in Thailand, and my best friend was shocked and offended that we all agreed they had only child tendencies. The VERY next morning I asked my friend how they had found the holiday so far, after they answered I then proceeded to ask others at the breakfast table. My friend literally piped up and said "I just already told you?!" I said "... I know.... But there are other people on the table Ms OC". Which gave us all a good chuckle.

Of course I can't generalise to everyone, this is just my anecdotal experience, my partner has made very similar observations, and insists we have a minimum of 2 kids. There are other traits but I'm not in the mood to offend people and be quoted a thousand times.

What garbage!

My best friend is one of 4 siblings close in age and one of them is her twin(!) and she is the most self-centred and selfish person I know. She actually acknowledges it and that's why she never wants kids and can't understand anyone who would want kids because she wouldn't be able to concentrate on herself/live her best life.

BabyOnBoard90 · 06/01/2023 11:10

Goodgrief82 · 06/01/2023 10:47

Out of interest, how many people are we talking about here?

How many only children have I known over the course of my life? I don't know. I'm in London so I've known many. And even dated a couple who I'm still distant friends with.

BabyOnBoard90 · 06/01/2023 11:08

reddwarfgeek · 06/01/2023 11:03

@BabyOnBoard90 That's a bit shitty to your friend isn't it? Picking her bad points out with your other friends and telling her it's due to her being an only child?

I'm not denying these traits exist, it's very annoying when anything negative about a personality HAS to equate to them being an only child.

Well we all have traits, which was part of the conversation.

Oldest child traits, youngest child traits, middle and only child traits. Doesn't make us bad or defect, just part of our character. The traits you can deal with will be dependent on your own traits.

E.g. I'm the oldest sibling, so used to control and direction. My partner is the youngest sibling. The inverse relationship works for us.

Kevinyoutwat · 06/01/2023 11:04

Comedycook · 06/01/2023 10:41

I'm sure only children can have perfectly happy upbringings. My only concern would be that their future children will have no aunts, uncles or cousins on that side of the family. I'd worry about future loneliness in next generations as families shrink. My parents died young...I'd be so alone if I hadn't had a sibling.

Yes, that can happen to some of us.

I am all along dealing with my only surviving parent (lost one in childhood) and their dementia. I wish I had a sibling. I know that relationships break down, siblings don’t speak but not always. I need help and support with my father. I need a break from it relentlessly just being me. If I had a sibling, there would be a fighting chance of having that, at least. Or, I could have been the arsehole sibling to have thrown the towel in - it might have saved my mental health from nosediving.

I was also incredibly lonely growing up.

My son was an only child until he was 11 and I made sure he wasn’t lonely, but it was hard work sometimes. So different to his two younger sisters now who have him and each other. Even with the age gaps, they are all so close and I wish I had experienced that.

reddwarfgeek · 06/01/2023 11:03

@BabyOnBoard90 That's a bit shitty to your friend isn't it? Picking her bad points out with your other friends and telling her it's due to her being an only child?

I'm not denying these traits exist, it's very annoying when anything negative about a personality HAS to equate to them being an only child.

OP posts:
Squirrelsnut · 06/01/2023 11:02

My only DS (15) is a delight. I read some of the threads on the Teenagers topic and am aghast at what some parents are experiencing.
Now I'm not saying he's a delight because he's an only child, but it clearly hasn't caused any selfish or domineering tendencies.

emmetgirl · 06/01/2023 10:53

I only have one child who is now 27. I don't recall ever being asked about stuff like this. If I had, it would have pissed me off too. People need to mind their own damn business.

Swipe left for the next trending thread