Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be sick of societal expectations and 'only children' prejudices

241 replies

reddwarfgeek · 05/01/2023 18:18

I probably am being massively U here but still. Absolutely sick of hearing things about only children being lonely selfish, etc. It gives me anxiety.
I know some amazing only children . And I know some selfish bastards people who can't compromise who have many siblings. Why does this stuff continue to be peddled out?
Everywhere I go people ask me about having a second baby. I'm sure it's not to internationally upset me but after 5 years I just don't know what to say anymore. Had enough of it.

Lots of second babies have been announced this last week on social media. Even though I am pretty sure I don't think want another ...I feel pangs of sadness when I see this. Of course I'm happy for them. It's just hard to see sometimes.

1 child suits some families better. Some women, like myself, feel they can't effectively parent more than 1 child and that's ok. I know my limitations. But then I happy families with 3 or 4 children and wonder how the hell they manage.
The truth, as you can probably tell, is that I'm not quite at peace with 'only' having 1. I wish I could be, maybe it will happen in time. However there are many many reasons why having an only child suits us better and why I'll almost certainly stick with one.
I'm not particularly maternal, have poor MH and my partner nor my parents are helpful. All taboo subjects you can't admit to in RL.

I feel lonely regarding other mums at school. There are some lovely mums but they also often ask me when I'm having another. There are some only child mums but most are considerably younger than me.

I've started to gravitate towards my childfree friends, of which I'm fortunate to have plenty, and they talk about other things. I'm careful not to constantly talk about DD in their company. It's nice to be myself and not judge on my number of children.

I feel like I don't fit in to many social circles now and I wonder if anyone can relate? I'm 37, nearly 38 by the way.

This topic has been done to death, and for sounding horrible and bitter I can only apologise 🙈

OP posts:
Goodgrief82 · 06/01/2023 16:05

BabyOnBoard90 · 06/01/2023 11:10

How many only children have I known over the course of my life? I don't know. I'm in London so I've known many. And even dated a couple who I'm still distant friends with.

You have known “many” that have no siblings and been close enough to even to have observed the traits you outline above 🤔

HamBone · 06/01/2023 16:05

Cousins are sometimes underrated as potential friends. My eldest cousin, who’s nine years older than me, is the one I’m closest to now, he’s a lovely person.

reddwarfgeek · 06/01/2023 15:55

@Comedycook I'm from a small family too and we sort of keep ourselves to ourselves. My partner is from a large family and when we first got together the family parties they had, although fun, were a shock to the system 😅 They are all very close and although it can be nice it does have its negatives.

It is interesting to me that 3 of the 4 have an only child each (1 is childfree at the moment). DD does have cousins, 1 significantly older but one girl who is similar age at 3. I don't think they will be having any more DC (I don't ask of course) so in a very selfish way it's comforting that hopefully DD and her cousin will be a friend for each other. They are pretty close at the moment.

OP posts:
Comedycook · 06/01/2023 15:48

@reddwarfgeek I have a smallish family. I wish I had more relatives. People on these boards often talk about family events and family parties. I don't really have enough relatives to make a party! I know everyone on here seems to hate their families but from my own experiences and observations, families often provide that unconditional support you don't always get from friends and give you a sense of roots and stability.

reddwarfgeek · 06/01/2023 15:41

@Comedycook Without meaning to sound fatalistic...why is that such an issue?
Does he have friends/colleagues/his own partner and children?

I'm not hugely close to my family so maybe I'm projecting. But if my parents and my brother died (possibly, as my bro is an addict as I've mentioned previously) I'd be alone in terms of family too as my father is an only and my mum was adopted and we don't see her brother as they live at the other end of the country and always have done. I saw my cousins as a child but tbh I wouldn't know them if I fell over them now. Never known my uncle at all really.

OP posts:
Comedycook · 06/01/2023 15:20

I have a friend who's parents are both only children. Consequently he has no aunts, uncles or cousins. His grandparents are dead. His only family therefore are his aging parents. Luckily he has one sibling who is married with a child but if he had been an only child then once his parents are dead, he'd have no relatives left.

nodogz · 06/01/2023 15:12

There is something very enjoyable about showering your only child with love* in a way that wouldn't be possible with 2+.

Not that you love them more, just that you can tell them they are your favourite and you do get more time together. I always think this at bedtime, they don't have to share my time or cuddles.

I'm a great parent of one and I'd be an alright parent of two.

  • not in a weird way, in a nurturing age-appropriate way that meets their needs. I'm not looking for them to live their life with me forever. And I don't think a one size family fits everyone so whilst one suits me, it's not for everyone. I imagine my only may have more children than me but that's because they have good, secure attachment and healthy confidence from their happy childhood.
HamBone · 06/01/2023 15:02

Comedycook · 06/01/2023 14:17

As well as ensuring they have good extended family ties

True...but the thing is in order to have extended family, you need people to have multiple children. So if you have an only child, ok, they may have aunts, uncles and cousins, but if they grow up and marry another only child then future generations are going to miss out on have extended family. You only get a wider extended family if people have more than one child.

My friend has an only child, he has aunts, uncles and cousins but his future kids might not...depends on if he marries a woman with siblings.

@Comedycook Yes, my children don't have any cousins as DH's siblings have chosen to be childfree.

HamBone · 06/01/2023 15:01

@reddwarfgeek With those family stories, I'm not surprised you're sticking with one!

All I'm saying is mindful of your choices so that your child doesn't end up stretched thin trying to juggle their own life and yours, it really is hard. All parents should do this to ensure that our children aren't in that position -I've got two and I don't want this happening to them either.

XmasElf10 · 06/01/2023 14:53

I can reassure you that it does get better. I have an only by choice. I discovered when I had a baby that I don't enjoy babies! It's a bit of flippant under-statement. Having a baby is HARD and my baby was sick and screamed all the time and never slept and it was Mega HARD. TTC was also tough for us and gave me some proper anxiety. We had some losses that also impacted my MH.
I'd always seen myself having two and when DD was 2 we started trying again and my anxiety ramped up and I realised I just couldn't go through with it. I was going to be miserable for years and that would impact DD and so DH and I said no more.

Oh the people trying to convince me I'd change my mind. It was never ending. I had a great GP though who told me she had been an only and loved it and fitted my coil despite the previous one refusing as I'd "be wanting it back out again any moment to try for no. 2". I had a few stock phrases I'd use when people asked me when number 2 was coming along or say how sorry they felt for poor DD being all lonely.

DD will be 12 this month and the nagging stopped when I got divorced (she was 7). Suddenly I was too old to start again (I'm 45 now). She is the absolutely apple of my eye. She has never wanted a sibling. She is not spoiled or lonely. She is funny and sassy and chatty and slightly obsessed with frogs at the moment. She is independent but loving and we cuddle up on the sofa every evening and talk about our days. Having an only isn't for everyone but neither is having a brood. I am delighted I stuck with my decision and I think I did the best for me but also for DD. I don't envy those with 2 or more kids (nor do I think bad things about them - each to their own).

Stick with it and eventually everyone stops nagging you!

reddwarfgeek · 06/01/2023 14:50

I don't hold with this 'I'm having more than one child so my only doesn't have to be alone when I die' stuff.

I've seen many examples of siblings causing problems in this scenario.

When my parents die, it'll fall to me as my brother has no sense or the ability to do anything helpful.
When my grandparents died, my uncle and his wife tried to steal money and possessions that were left to her from my mother.
MIL is one of 8. With little exception she was the sole carer for her elderly parents. None of her siblings lived that far away either.
When FIL died, my BIL robbed his money from his bedroom that was meant to be split 3 ways.
My best friend, when her uncle died, it was down to my friends mum to sort things out as his children hated each other and could barely be in the same room.

Maybe I'm focusing on the negatives but it certainly is not unusual for things to be like this in families with siblings.

OP posts:
HamBone · 06/01/2023 14:38

Baconand · 06/01/2023 14:21

My best friend has 4 brothers, none of them help at all with their elderly and ill parents. They won’t engage in any conversations, never show up, do absolutely nothing at all. Not been seen in years. My friend (female) is carrying the entire burden. But the inheritance will go 5 ways you can guarantee!
Siblings don’t necessarily make any difference at all.

DH has a brother and sister, they have been NC for 30 years with their father (who is an arsehole I admit). DH won’t get any support there either.

@Baconand Of course there’ll always be extreme situations like those you’re describing, but that’s not usual. Most families share the load to some extent.

All I’m saying is that when you’re an only like me, everything really is down to you so as the parent, you must try to minimize the strain. Some people will be lucky with healthy, easy-going parents who sort themselves out; others aren’t so lucky. I’ve joked recently that I need to clone myself as it’s so hard to keep everything going.

Baconand · 06/01/2023 14:21

HamBone · 06/01/2023 14:03

As well as ensuring they have good extended family ties, it's also really important to ensure that you're as independent as possible when you get older. I think that's true for everyone, tbh, but it's especially hard to be an only child dealing with a difficult elderly parent. I'm right in the thick of it now and it's so hard not having anyone else to even discuss matters with.

My DH is one of four and he'll never go through what I'm currently dealing with.

Just being completely honest about it.

My best friend has 4 brothers, none of them help at all with their elderly and ill parents. They won’t engage in any conversations, never show up, do absolutely nothing at all. Not been seen in years. My friend (female) is carrying the entire burden. But the inheritance will go 5 ways you can guarantee!
Siblings don’t necessarily make any difference at all.

DH has a brother and sister, they have been NC for 30 years with their father (who is an arsehole I admit). DH won’t get any support there either.

Comedycook · 06/01/2023 14:17

As well as ensuring they have good extended family ties

True...but the thing is in order to have extended family, you need people to have multiple children. So if you have an only child, ok, they may have aunts, uncles and cousins, but if they grow up and marry another only child then future generations are going to miss out on have extended family. You only get a wider extended family if people have more than one child.

My friend has an only child, he has aunts, uncles and cousins but his future kids might not...depends on if he marries a woman with siblings.

HamBone · 06/01/2023 14:03

As well as ensuring they have good extended family ties, it's also really important to ensure that you're as independent as possible when you get older. I think that's true for everyone, tbh, but it's especially hard to be an only child dealing with a difficult elderly parent. I'm right in the thick of it now and it's so hard not having anyone else to even discuss matters with.

My DH is one of four and he'll never go through what I'm currently dealing with.

Just being completely honest about it.

Comedycook · 06/01/2023 13:53

Actually having another baby is purely for the benefit of the parents - not the existing child. When my parents had my brother I absolutely hated it, as prior to that I had their full attention/praise/time/money etc etc. My own daughter is even jealous of my relationship with our dog and would hate to have a baby sibling which would mean I would have less time for her/her activities

This is odd. Loads of kids love having siblings. I remember when my sister was born and my dad picked me up from school and told me...I remember jumping up and down with joy. Some of my best memories from childhood are related to my sister. Why is extra time with parents seen as better than having time with siblings? Actually I wish my parents had had more children. I wouldn't have wanted to swop my sister for extra parental attention at all.

XelaM · 06/01/2023 12:56

felulageller · 06/01/2023 11:31

Being an only has made and will in the future make my life much harder.

It is selfish.

I get the not wanting to be overwhelmed but then you can have big gaps so only one young DC at a time.

We all do selfish things though. It's not the end of the world. But own your choices and accept them.

Actually having another baby is purely for the benefit of the parents - not the existing child. When my parents had my brother I absolutely hated it, as prior to that I had their full attention/praise/time/money etc etc. My own daughter is even jealous of my relationship with our dog and would hate to have a baby sibling which would mean I would have less time for her/her activities

TIGTBTSCIH · 06/01/2023 12:16

Goodgrief82 · 06/01/2023 10:32

Me neither asked but you’re not right and you’re not wrong.

We can’t expect others to be sensitive to issues that are impacting us but at face value…. Aren’t sensitive issues.

So asking where someone is going on holiday. Face value? Not a sensitive issue. But what happens if the respondent is enduring serious financial hardship and the very notion of a desperately yearned for holiday is completely out of the question

I agree that we can't be expected to tiptoe around conversations on the off chance that something is a sensitive topic.

However, to me your holiday example is not at all comparable with asking about someone's family plans. I think it should be obvious these days that having children IS a sensitive topic, with everything we know the high rates of baby loss/fertility issues (and that's before you even consider all the other factors that go in to a decision to have additional children, which OP has clearly articulated).

Within the past year I've stood next to my friend at a wedding while she politely cooed over someone else's new baby. Only for the conversation to then turn to 'do you think you and X will have children soon?'. I knew that at that very moment she was going through a miscarriage and that surface innocent question (when the asker likely didn't even care about the answer) was going to be salt in the wound.

reddwarfgeek · 06/01/2023 11:58

@TIGTBTSCIH

You have hit the nail on the head for me. Totally. Don't know how to quote but this particularly stood out:
'Oh, it's back to this again. I can't just exist in the world being valued for what I do offer without it quickly being turned around to this thing in my life which hasn't gone well'

I've thought of trying to make them uncomfortable but in a workplace scenario I'm conscious of it sounding like I'm weird or argumentative. Your response is great.

OP posts:
Headabovetheparakeet · 06/01/2023 11:54

The issue with anecdotal evidence is that you can find some to suit almost any point of view and many people have low awareness of confirmation bias.

TIGTBTSCIH · 06/01/2023 11:53

donttellmehesalive · 05/01/2023 18:40

When you're dating, people ask when you're going to move in together or get married.

Then they start asking about babies.

Then they start asking about siblings.

It's just small talk. There is no intent to upset you. Nobody gives a shit, surely, how many babies someone else has.

This is true. But it's also quite a nosy type of small talk when you think about it and when you've been on the end of this type of 'small talk' question being painful/difficult to answer you tend to change what you ask. I have better conversations now btw.

OP, I completely get what you mean - it's a flippant way of asking something that it sounds like you have agonised over and it brings up that difficult decision at a time when you might not have been thinking about it and aren't in a position to answer frankly because it wouldn't be socially appropriate to be so open/vulnerable. I have it with 'are you married' all the time - such an obvious/inoffensive/open question but it makes me feel like 'oh, it's back to this again. I can't just exist in the world being valued for what I do offer without it quickly being turned around to this thing in my life which hasn't gone well'.

If you feel able, and particularly given the same people are repeatedly asking you (which is odd!) - I would actually not be flippant in response but make them feel a little bit uncomfortable for having asked such a personal question. No need to be rude or anything but make it clear that you think it's an intrusive/unwelcome question. 'That's a very personal question. Nothing's changed since we last spoke about this Simon. Now, how's little Johnny?'.

reddwarfgeek · 06/01/2023 11:49

@XelaM Wow, I'm wondering if we know the same people! I know a set of twins who were from a family of 5 children. Of those 5, only 1 had DC, and she had only 1. The other twin says she doesn't want kids as they are hard work and take too much away from your freedom.

So coming from a big family can have the opposite effect.

OP posts:
Thedaysthatremain · 06/01/2023 11:47

felulageller · 06/01/2023 11:31

Being an only has made and will in the future make my life much harder.

It is selfish.

I get the not wanting to be overwhelmed but then you can have big gaps so only one young DC at a time.

We all do selfish things though. It's not the end of the world. But own your choices and accept them.

It's not actually a choice for all of us.

Mariposista · 06/01/2023 11:47

I am an only to a single mum. I am many things but not selfish. I regularly fly home from Europe to help her care for my elderly gran.
My mum is 1 of 4. Her siblings are selfish. They do absolutely nothing to help my gran and dump all the work on her.

How many siblings you need not be an indication of how selfish or otherwise you end up.

reddwarfgeek · 06/01/2023 11:41

@MRSDoos People always ask questions don't they. I've never understood why! I don't ask these things about anyone!

Sorry for your losses Flowers and congratulations on your pregnancy!

OP posts: