Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be sick of societal expectations and 'only children' prejudices

241 replies

reddwarfgeek · 05/01/2023 18:18

I probably am being massively U here but still. Absolutely sick of hearing things about only children being lonely selfish, etc. It gives me anxiety.
I know some amazing only children . And I know some selfish bastards people who can't compromise who have many siblings. Why does this stuff continue to be peddled out?
Everywhere I go people ask me about having a second baby. I'm sure it's not to internationally upset me but after 5 years I just don't know what to say anymore. Had enough of it.

Lots of second babies have been announced this last week on social media. Even though I am pretty sure I don't think want another ...I feel pangs of sadness when I see this. Of course I'm happy for them. It's just hard to see sometimes.

1 child suits some families better. Some women, like myself, feel they can't effectively parent more than 1 child and that's ok. I know my limitations. But then I happy families with 3 or 4 children and wonder how the hell they manage.
The truth, as you can probably tell, is that I'm not quite at peace with 'only' having 1. I wish I could be, maybe it will happen in time. However there are many many reasons why having an only child suits us better and why I'll almost certainly stick with one.
I'm not particularly maternal, have poor MH and my partner nor my parents are helpful. All taboo subjects you can't admit to in RL.

I feel lonely regarding other mums at school. There are some lovely mums but they also often ask me when I'm having another. There are some only child mums but most are considerably younger than me.

I've started to gravitate towards my childfree friends, of which I'm fortunate to have plenty, and they talk about other things. I'm careful not to constantly talk about DD in their company. It's nice to be myself and not judge on my number of children.

I feel like I don't fit in to many social circles now and I wonder if anyone can relate? I'm 37, nearly 38 by the way.

This topic has been done to death, and for sounding horrible and bitter I can only apologise 🙈

OP posts:
adayinparis · 07/01/2023 09:55

My Mum was one of five, she was the third girl and no one cared if she existed or not, they just wanted a boy. Her parents went onto have two boys after. So she was completely in the middle. She hated growing up in a large family and chose to have one child. I love my Mum more than anything and have learnt so much from her, as I’ve grown older (I’m nearly 40 now), I actually think it was a gift being her only child.

Its okay to have shit family dynamics that stop you from wanting more than one child. Lots of people I know absolutely hate their siblings or hated being in a big family. People talk about it being selfish to have one child, but it’s so selfish to keep having kids to get the gender you want and then for the child before them to know their only ‘crime’ was that they weren’t a boy or a girl. Equally, it’s selfish to bring lots of kids into the world you can’t care for properly financially or emotionally. True love would be to say I can give everything to one, and to do that. And the child will learn their Mum tried to give them the best. They’ll learn about true giving, I’m not talking about the juvenile ‘sharing of toys’, I’m talking about giving love.

Mamma2017 · 07/01/2023 09:50

BabyOnBoard90 · 07/01/2023 09:26

Ad hominem

Nope. I’m addressing the notion you reference that those characteristics are because someone is an only child.

BabyOnBoard90 · 07/01/2023 09:26

Mamma2017 · 07/01/2023 06:25

And Iv experienced the exact opposite of this at the best of times. And it’s interesting you make the hugely sweeping assumptions that these things directly relate to the fact they are only Children and not to the multitude of varying reasons that create/shape personality. The whole kaleidoscope of reasons- the varied life experience. You simply write this all off because you know (as their personal psychologists presumably) they ARE how they ARE because they are only children! You and your DH clearly match well! 🤣 Judgemental bollocks, unintelligent and extreme short sightedness. People like you are the reason there is STIGMA because you make sweeping assumptions and generalisations.

Ad hominem

Goodgrief82 · 07/01/2023 07:09

BabyOnBoard90 · 06/01/2023 21:14

Oh wow 4 quotes.

I mean you're a stranger on the net so I genuinely care more about my next bowel movement than your kids and opinion, but good for you.

Bizarre

Mamma2017 · 07/01/2023 06:25

BabyOnBoard90 · 06/01/2023 10:37

The most common thing is

  • they are all about themselves and struggle to feign genuine interest in the lives of others, and even when they do the subject matter is quickly unintentionally diverted back to them.
  • They're also not the most confrontational, and either shy away from conflict or have poor approaches to conflict resolution. There are other traits but I'm not in the mood to offend people this AM.
  • They don't like sharing things most don't care about. Conversely expect you to share things most wouldn't ask you to share.

I remember this became a subject matter on holiday in Thailand, and my best friend was shocked and offended that we all agreed they had only child tendencies. The VERY next morning I asked my friend how they had found the holiday so far, after they answered I then proceeded to ask others at the breakfast table. My friend literally piped up and said "I just already told you?!" I said "... I know.... But there are other people on the table Ms OC". Which gave us all a good chuckle.

Of course I can't generalise to everyone, this is just my anecdotal experience, my partner has made very similar observations, and insists we have a minimum of 2 kids. There are other traits but I'm not in the mood to offend people and be quoted a thousand times.

And Iv experienced the exact opposite of this at the best of times. And it’s interesting you make the hugely sweeping assumptions that these things directly relate to the fact they are only Children and not to the multitude of varying reasons that create/shape personality. The whole kaleidoscope of reasons- the varied life experience. You simply write this all off because you know (as their personal psychologists presumably) they ARE how they ARE because they are only children! You and your DH clearly match well! 🤣 Judgemental bollocks, unintelligent and extreme short sightedness. People like you are the reason there is STIGMA because you make sweeping assumptions and generalisations.

JuneDays · 06/01/2023 23:59

YNBU.

If someone I didn't know asked me that question, they'd find me in tears as a result.

Keepingitmoving · 06/01/2023 23:40

Hate people asking when you are having another. I always wanted more than 1 child but after having several miscarriages before and after our first we didn’t know if it would happen. It is no one’s business but your own!! I totally get your thoughts but I genuinely believe there are benefits of having multiple children; sibling support for one. I had a brother who died 5 years ago at 29. My mum has just come home today from a long term hospital stay. The pressure I’ve been under trying to deal with my mother’s illness alone has been immense and, despite having great support from family and friends, I have never missed my brother being around more than I have over the last few months 😢

BabyOnBoard90 · 06/01/2023 21:14

Goodgrief82 · 06/01/2023 16:46

I have two and very happy with two and would have loved a third

I can from three and adore my siblings

but I have the… breadth of vision not to make such daft generalisations as @BabyOnBoard90 about those without siblings.

Oh wow 4 quotes.

I mean you're a stranger on the net so I genuinely care more about my next bowel movement than your kids and opinion, but good for you.

avocadotofu · 06/01/2023 19:59

I absolutely know how you feel. I only have DS4 and sometimes I really feel guilty about it because have one suits me on lots of levels.

Liveafr · 06/01/2023 19:56

UnaOfStormhold · 05/01/2023 20:47

There's a book called Parenting an only child by Susan somebody which I found very helpful in getting over the guilt of not having a second (we had fertility problems so were incredibly lucky to have our first). There's lots in there about the possible advantages having an only child and what you can do to compensate for the potential disadvantages.

Thanks for the book recommendation (although I'm not the op, I have my own questioning). That does look like an interesting and useful read.

Violashift · 06/01/2023 16:59

I have one dd nearly 15. I was a bit like you in the younger stages but now at 43 I have more of my life back as do my friends with multiple kids now at uni.

Give it untik they are teenagers then it won't matter as much.

I still find baby/ toddler talk constantly very boring.

Goodgrief82 · 06/01/2023 16:46

I have two and very happy with two and would have loved a third

I can from three and adore my siblings

but I have the… breadth of vision not to make such daft generalisations as @BabyOnBoard90 about those without siblings.

HamBone · 06/01/2023 16:45

Realistically, we all make our choices based on our own experiences and the position we’re in. If someone had a shit time with their siblings, or a great time as an only, they’ll feel completely differently on the subject!

All we can do is the best we can for our child/children and try to make life as good as it can be for them.

IMHO, Having an uninterested or selfish parent, for example, is far worse than whether you have siblings or not.

Goodgrief82 · 06/01/2023 16:44

Most odd that pjs thread entitled “AIBU to be envious of one child families”
@BabyOnBoard90 posts

There's something incredibly unfair about bringing children into the world and regretting their existence.

and yet on this thread your view seems to be pop out a second otherwise you’re going to have a selfish self absorbed child.

oh and you have one child, 7 months.

Fingers crossed you go on to have a second otherwise I suspect you’ll be very concerned how your poorly lonely selfish onesie will do

Goodgrief82 · 06/01/2023 16:37

Sorry I missed…. How many children do you have @BabyOnBoard90 ?

Goodgrief82 · 06/01/2023 16:36

BabyOnBoard90 · 06/01/2023 16:29

Indeed

Ok, good to know that perhaps your view is presumably based on…. Dozens of close friends that have no siblings? hundreds? Thousands??! 😂

reddwarfgeek · 06/01/2023 16:35

@XmasElf10 Thank you for your wonderful upbeat post.
So happy to read your story, and your DD sounds awesome!
When DD is 12 I'll be 45 too so I'm looking forward to that stage :)

OP posts:
RampantIvy · 06/01/2023 16:34

To be sick of societal expectations and 'only children' prejudices

I can honestly say that I never really encountered this. I was 41 when DD was born, and on the odd occasion that people asked if I was having any more I just told them I couldn't have any more children (which was true). It pretty much shut the conversation down.

I never felt judged for only having one (fertility issues).

reddwarfgeek · 06/01/2023 16:34

@Comedycook Maybe true about cousins. Truthfully I've never really thought of it like that as I barely know my cousins.

OP posts:
BabyOnBoard90 · 06/01/2023 16:29

Goodgrief82 · 06/01/2023 16:05

You have known “many” that have no siblings and been close enough to even to have observed the traits you outline above 🤔

Indeed

socialmedia23 · 06/01/2023 16:15

Comedycook · 06/01/2023 16:08

Absolutely and if you have an only child you are potentially denying your future grandchildren of having cousins.

Our siblings bar one are all overseas so they will never be able to play with cousins anyway. they would probably meet every three years for my DH's side of the family (DH's sisters never come back to the UK and we have to meet them in their grandfather's country; they would have nowhere to stay when their 90 year old grandfather passes on and it is likely we may see them even less). I see my sister every year as we have more disposable income to fly to Asia but its still not very often (not sure if my sister would have children!)

One big reason why I am reluctant to have more than one is that my DH has 3 sisters and his youngest (only one left in the UK) has Aspergers so would probably be homeless after his mum passes on and the house is sold to pay for care. I am really not looking forward to living with her and hope that I can buy her a property to live in (my child can stay there for free if he can't afford to rent or buy in London). If i only have one child, i could just buy a 2 bed flat. 3 bed flats would be a lot more expensive. It is what it is, would rather conserve resources for the living rather than bank my hopes on hypothetical blissful relationships. Real life problems take precedence surely.

Goodgrief82 · 06/01/2023 16:14

This issue is so black and white to some that I wonder how on earth that get on in life with such tunnel vision.

I had siblings and adore them and can’t imagine a childhood without them. And now… my friends

I have two and my two… absolutely love one another. Different sexes, similar ages, argue, debate, laugh, play, joke, loll around together over the weekends in their pjs watching films.

so worked for me and my children
for some it doesn’t

🤷‍♀️

Goodgrief82 · 06/01/2023 16:11

HamBone · 06/01/2023 15:01

@reddwarfgeek With those family stories, I'm not surprised you're sticking with one!

All I'm saying is mindful of your choices so that your child doesn't end up stretched thin trying to juggle their own life and yours, it really is hard. All parents should do this to ensure that our children aren't in that position -I've got two and I don't want this happening to them either.

This

That is one heck of an awful history.

Meanwhile here… my siblings were invaluable support when our parents passed. Such fond memories of being with them and turning sad and stressful times into giggling at childhood memories and taking the piss out of each other

Comedycook · 06/01/2023 16:08

HamBone · 06/01/2023 16:05

Cousins are sometimes underrated as potential friends. My eldest cousin, who’s nine years older than me, is the one I’m closest to now, he’s a lovely person.

Absolutely and if you have an only child you are potentially denying your future grandchildren of having cousins.

Goodgrief82 · 06/01/2023 16:08

I remember this became a subject matter on holiday in Thailand, and my best friend was shocked and offended that we all agreed they had only child tendencies

who needs “best friends” that have a round table about your short comings.