Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The gentle parenting philosophy makes me feel guiltily for having any feelings other than love

171 replies

michellet86 · 05/01/2023 17:09

Why is it not ok to show my anger? i mean appropriately and safely, not violent or aggressively. How is it ok to tell our kids their feelings are valid but then we have to suppress anything thats "negative"or only show it stoically?

I don't want to raise a kid who can't understand that he can't do whatever he wants without consequences. There ARE people in this world who will react with anger and he needs to know that.
I prefer the term "responsive parenting". My kids see when i'm getting angry. They also see how i process and handle it- if i need a few minutes to myself to help calm myself down or need to move my body to get some of that energy out, if i need to kind of check in with myself about why something is bothering me.
Sometimes i do loose my cool and yell and then they get to see how i handle that, they see that i feel bad for doing it and learn how to make amends with others when they mess up. These are all important lessons for them as they learn how to process and handle their own emotions in a healthy way. The reality is at some point parents will get angry with their kids. There might be a tiny percentage that doesn't- but that percentage probably has some combination of no outside stresses, lots of support (including the ability to have time to themselves) and that rare child that never pushes their buttons. Now if you're constantly angry and frustrated, yelling constantly somethings off and you might need to find a way to change those patterns but bei absolutely tired of your toddler whining all day for the 27th day in a row with no relief some annoyance is normal.

OP posts:
Tandora · 05/01/2023 20:25

Hardbackwriter · 05/01/2023 19:43

'Authoritarian' parenting, by the standards you seem to be using, has been near universal for most of human history, though, and still is in most cultures. Surely you don't really think that the only emotionally regulated people in existence are a small group of largely middle-class westerners who are nearly all under 30?

Lol I see your point, but I disagree on your monolithic view on parenting. I actually think there have always been a wide spectrum of parenting styles and types of parenting , albeit based more on personality differences / intuition than on philosophies of parenting. For me an authoritarian style of parenting is a “my way or the high way” type of attitude- you have to do what I say , because I said so, no compromise, no empathy, no respect for a child’s independent perspective. I don’t think that results in emotionally mature humans. It seems quite obvious that it wouldn’t..

Mojoj · 05/01/2023 20:24

It's a load of bollocks. I have boys whom I have raised with a firm hand, lost my shit more times than I care to remember, split up endless fights and always tried my best to treat them with respect, be straight with them and always, always demand respect in return. They're adults now, with whom I love spending time. They have turned out just fine. Kids need firm boundaries which includes telling them no!!

dreamingbohemian · 05/01/2023 20:17

@GentlyBen I'm so sorry, that must be so awful for you

Honestly in your shoes I would consider calling the NPCC for advice. A three year old who doesn't eat and is malnourished, who is excessively violent, who is at risk of falling through the cracks because he won't be in nursery or school -- that sounds like outside help needs to be involved.

Dystopiawarming · 05/01/2023 20:13

@Whee

My sister works in a nursery, she said there's no point in using any words after the second one when telling a child off, because most 3 and 4 year olds aren't able to properly understand more complex sentences. When I started using short phrases or single words I noticed a marked change in my sons behaviour. Turns out he had glue ear so that contributed, but even after that improved the single words or two word phrases changed things a lot. I think we misunderstand their cognitive ability A LOT as parents.

@CremeEggsForBreakfast

I will check that out, would be really helpful to have a better understanding and also a bit of a giggle. Every day is a school day on mumsnet isn't it?

CremeEggsForBreakfast · 05/01/2023 20:07

As others have said, gentle parenting was a response to angry, authoritarian "do as I say not as I do" parenting which ignored the needs of children. It has now been co-opted by permissive parents who think that "validating children's emotions" means "they can do whatever they want and they should never be sad" instead of, for example, anger is a normal reaction to being disappointed but that doesn't mean you can hit me".

Check out MummaCusses if you want a more robust and sarcastic version of gentle parenting.

The bigger problem here though is people who read parenting books or follow "parenting experts" instead of understanding how children learn and develop. A book can only give you a script because they're not in your home and hearing/seeing your child's response.

If more people understood how a child's developmental level practically affected their responses to anger, disappointed, fear, confusion etc then you would naturally respond in an effective manner.

This is why I recommend Dan Siegel books/Youtube. It's the actual science behind the principles of proper gentle parenting.

Whee · 05/01/2023 20:06

All the people I know who follow gentle parenting are adamant their children are well behaved and that they are firm but fair and frankly...they are not. Their children run rings around them, often to the detriment of my well-behaved child (e.g. not taking turns properly). The behaviour their 4 year olds demonstrate would absolutely not be accepted in a Reception classroom and I suspect these children, who mainly started school in September, have learned to follow the rules just like everyone else when they know there's no choice. I agree with a pp that the language used is often ridiculous - if you check understanding with a Y2 or Y3 class, it's often surprising how much has gone over their heads and yet these gentle parents are using long strings of language with 2, 3 and 4 year olds who are already probably not in the best state to be listening.

Dystopiawarming · 05/01/2023 20:03

Done wrong: I think it's used as an excuse by lazy and permissive parents and creates selfish spoilt kids who lack boundaries.

Done well: I think it often comes at a great cost to the parents and is therefore only available to people who have a certain amount of privilege, because not everyone has the resources to do that. Even then the kids grow up with warped expectations about the reality of human nature and the world they live in, and that can be problematic unless aforementioned privilege makes it a smooth run for them.

So my conclusion is that for most people it is unattainable, and for many it is damaging. For others it is used as an excuse for permissive parenting, either intentionally or because it is misunderstood.
Also, the movement creates a lot of parents who are judged for parenting in a more authoritarian style, even when this is the better parenting style for their kids due to temperament, familial circumstances or neurodivergence. It creates division and a lot of parental guilt, and also a lot of confusion by people who feel like they have to learn a totally new toolkit to parent now than the way in which they themselves were raised. Often the methods are counterintuitive to what feels natural, and therefore hard to implement and sustain.

There are some brilliant things that have come from parenting change, I'm over the moon about the increase in countries criminalising physical chastisement (smacking). But I do think that calling any display of negative parental emotion such as a raised voice traumatic to the child is terrifying. Because anger is not abuse, boundaries are not abuse, and the danger in calling it so is that abuse is minimised and people think it's ok to abuse others so long as they have an emotional justification, having not been set proper boundaries about this previously.

It's all such a balancing act. I don't think many parents get it right (I know I often don't, I'm no guru type 😂) and I think gentle parenting can be really good for some parents, who are naturally authoritarian and could do with being more empathetic and nurturing alongside that, but for permissive parents (and their kids!) it can be really damaging to remove words like 'no' from their vocabulary.

DrJump · 05/01/2023 20:00

We are on the whole gentle parents but… we have some pretty firm boundaries on behaviours. So we talk about why the boundaries are there, we make the process as enjoyable as possible, we try for connection and together as the starting point for behaviour management.

Cuppasoupmonster · 05/01/2023 19:56

Rhino94 · 05/01/2023 19:53

have they though?!

Apparently so!

Rhino94 · 05/01/2023 19:53

Cuppasoupmonster · 05/01/2023 19:45

But the parents being discussed here have ‘read all the books’, they’re not uninformed.

have they though?!

HaggisWurst · 05/01/2023 19:52

I don't think it's healthy to follow any kind of parenting style 100%. So I pick out the aspects of gentle parenting that make sense to me and ignore the rest. For example, validating and naming my toddlers feelings is something I think important so I do that. But I also feel making him say sorry and telling him I'm proud of him is also important (gentle parenting says not to do these). So yeah, pick out the bits that make sense to you, ignore the rest. Doing an extreme form of anything isn't right imo

Mybonnielad · 05/01/2023 19:50

IDontCareMatthew · 05/01/2023 17:10

These 'gentle parenting' kids are in for a shock when they get out in the real world

The parents too!

Good luck, buckle up

This 100%.

Ophicleide · 05/01/2023 19:49

Dystopiawarming · 05/01/2023 17:28

As a single parent to boys, any kind of gentle approach just does not seem to work. I have to be a dominant authority. Stricter than I ever intended to be, or they walk all over me. Very black and white, as well. So any violence is an immediate consequence, not an opportunity to share feelings. I'm naturally a flaky permissive parent, so I thought gentle parenting would work well for me as a midway point. But my kids behaviour was shocking until I took a strong stance as disciplinarian. If I let anything slide, it's punch ups and anarchy. I'm probably doing gentle parenting wrong, but I've read all the books, followed the TikTok's, tried loads of stuff and it just comes back to me having to be much more old school authoritarian than anything else. I feel more like a sports coach than a parent, it's all yellow cards and red cards and refereeing fights. And they are so physical, their aggression is expressed that way but also their love. I spend a lot of time just containing or separating them and setting and resetting boundaries constantly. Yes we play and have fun, but I've always got to keep in mind not to let things get too hectic or it will result in a punch up between them, or at least an argument or something getting broken. The other parents of boys, especially single parents of boys, are the same either they are strict or there kids are totally out of control. Doesn't seem to be much in the middle.

I found the same, and had a girl with big brothers. She was just as battle-ready as they were. There was a lot of refereeing, boundary-imposing etc. Still is, and they're all 18+

Cuppasoupmonster · 05/01/2023 19:45

Rhino94 · 05/01/2023 19:30

It is quite simply because they have not looked into it, taken the term gentle and assumed what they were doing was gentle parenting but it is most definitely not.

But the parents being discussed here have ‘read all the books’, they’re not uninformed.

Hardbackwriter · 05/01/2023 19:43

Tandora · 05/01/2023 19:34

Because no one learns to moderate their feelings effectively through authoritarian parenting.
being taught that your feelings don’t matter, and the people closest to you have no respect or concern for them, is the fastest route to a lifetime of emotional immaturity. You teach children emotional regulation by showing them empathy whilst holding boundaries.

'Authoritarian' parenting, by the standards you seem to be using, has been near universal for most of human history, though, and still is in most cultures. Surely you don't really think that the only emotionally regulated people in existence are a small group of largely middle-class westerners who are nearly all under 30?

waynesworldpartytimeexcellent · 05/01/2023 19:40

Gentle parenting is a joke, always reminds me of Willy Wonka telling Violet...No, please stop, don't... in a gentle voice. She blew up anyway.

My sister uses this bullshit parenting and her kids are absolute brats. They were meant to come to us for dinner because her child would not get dressed and the other one hit her in the face when she asked him in a "nice voice" to brssh his teeth.

She thought is was a valid reason to cancel because the kids did not want to coooperate and she respects their wishes.

Beam me fucking up.

Have no idea why some of my text his in bold, so sorry for that!

Dystopiawarming · 05/01/2023 19:37

I heard a radio thing about a gentle parent expert, who is gentle with her kid and then goes to another room for a cry and rage alone. That doesn't seem healthy to me, because obviously the parent is feeling like that because a child has crossed a line, and sometimes they need to see that they've crossed that line, not have their parents feelings totally hidden so that they have no idea they've crossed a line and upset them.

Ultimately if they continue to think it's ok to hit people, they could end up in jail down the road. Some things are that black and white, and when it comes to violence there has to be a hard line IMO

Tandora · 05/01/2023 19:34

Talaforniababe · 05/01/2023 19:28

The main thing is that the parent is in charge. I don't pussyfoot around and I lay down the law. I don't understand all the 'I know you're feeling x' stuff. In the real world you have to moderate your behaviour no matter what you're feeling. Surely children need to learn that emotions cannot dictate behaviour? You can't hit someone no matter how angry you are.

Because no one learns to moderate their feelings effectively through authoritarian parenting.
being taught that your feelings don’t matter, and the people closest to you have no respect or concern for them, is the fastest route to a lifetime of emotional immaturity. You teach children emotional regulation by showing them empathy whilst holding boundaries.

Dystopiawarming · 05/01/2023 19:32

You can do both though, honour the feeling but not accept the behaviour. Like when my son hit a bully, I came down hard on the violence, but did also honour his feelings. We talked about other outlets for anger, and walking away in future. So there is a balance, but I think a lot of gentle parents get it wrong because they are so busy honouring the feelings etc. they forget to discipline what is unacceptable at the same time.

Rhino94 · 05/01/2023 19:30

Cuppasoupmonster · 05/01/2023 19:19

Then, with respect, why do so many people who claim to be ‘gentle parenting’ end up ‘submissive parenting’? Is it because attempting the former usually ends in the latter?

It is quite simply because they have not looked into it, taken the term gentle and assumed what they were doing was gentle parenting but it is most definitely not.

Talaforniababe · 05/01/2023 19:28

The main thing is that the parent is in charge. I don't pussyfoot around and I lay down the law. I don't understand all the 'I know you're feeling x' stuff. In the real world you have to moderate your behaviour no matter what you're feeling. Surely children need to learn that emotions cannot dictate behaviour? You can't hit someone no matter how angry you are.

Dystopiawarming · 05/01/2023 19:28

@RudsyFarmer

Yes firm but fair is my mantra.
I feel like it's a battle just to keep mine from doing death defying stunts and breaking bones.
I was so sure before I had kids that gender was all about nurture, and then alone came these boys to show me what nature could do. I believe boys can cry, that girls can achieve all the same things, etc. but I also believe that their is something different in them which, unlike girls who seem to get socialised out of being wild and fool hardy pretty early on, boys seem to always want to push the boundaries physically. Climb the highest, run the fastest, be the top dog. They seem to be naturally territorial, and being small and female and not having a bigger male presence in the house any more, I feel it was harder for them to accept me as the leader and I have to constantly remind them of it as my dominance is less automatic. I don't want them thinking they can bully women, so I think that every time they hit or hurt me, that actually when I say that's ok or let it slide, what I'm actually doing is setting them up to think that if they have a big feeling it's ok to hurt someone, and that could be mirrored over so easily into their romantic relationships some day. Im hoping this is the groundwork to them being decent young men some day. But who knows. The proof is years away still!

Tandora · 05/01/2023 19:25

Huh? I don’t think gentle parenting means you can never show you are angry?

Noodledoodledoo · 05/01/2023 19:22

In my daughters class there is a perfect correlation between gentle parenting and class bully in a number of children! A year group who missed vital years at school due to covid and learning social skills.

Another friend struggles to keep nanny's as her kids and her parenting dont seem compatible, apparently asking child to put on shoes is not acceptable!!!!

Cuppasoupmonster · 05/01/2023 19:19

Greydogs123 · 05/01/2023 19:16

Google gentle parenting and permissive parenting and all those of you bashing gentle parenting will realise that what you are witnessing is permissive parenting. There’s a huge difference.

Then, with respect, why do so many people who claim to be ‘gentle parenting’ end up ‘submissive parenting’? Is it because attempting the former usually ends in the latter?