Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have told friends daughter to consider something other than medicine?

39 replies

Summerishere123 · 05/01/2023 16:30

More of a friend of a friend really but got talking with her daughter about Alevels and her future plans. She mentioned wanting to be a child psychologist and going to med school. She then mentioned that she was failing Alevel chemistry.
I tried to gently point out that Med school would be a struggle if she was already failing the Alevel and that perhaps she should consider counselling or similar that didn't require medical pathway.
The daughter admitted that she needed to look into things more and that was the end of the conversation.
Now though, a week later I feel bad. Was I wrong to point out that she would struggle if she was already failing? I didn't mention to her that if she couldn't pass the Alevel she wasn't likely to even get in! I personally feel that people should be realistic about their abilities after seeing a family members dreams shattered after wanting to get into medical school and failing the same course. As a result he didn't get onto his course and his life has lost all meaning for him and he is really struggling.
In this case it really wasn't my business to say anything but it was how the conversation was going and felt okay at the time. Would you be mad at me if it was your daughter?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Rinkkk · 25/08/2023 22:05

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

drspouse · 01/08/2023 23:17

There is no such career as "child psychologist" so I'd say she REALLY hasn't done her research. She could be an educational psychologist, a child clinical psychologist (both need a Psychology degree) or a child counselling psychologist (you can qualify as a counsellor without a psych degree, at least you used to be able to).

Coffeewinecake · 01/08/2023 22:46

I’d be advising her to give a career medicine a wide berth in general. M

penser123 · 01/08/2023 22:18

Not true.

Salacia · 05/01/2023 19:42

NC fail on my behalf there…

NCXmas22 · 05/01/2023 19:39

@Oher - thank you for your lovely words. Apologies, this thread wasn’t the time or place to go off on that rant and I regret posting it (just burnt out and bitter…).

There are genuinely great things about a career in healthcare, I’d encourage your friend’s daughter to look at NHS careers for a decent overview. There’s lots of stuff that I think of as ‘hidden jobs’ (like genetic counselling for example) that can be overlooked.

Dotcheck · 05/01/2023 19:33

Really shitty of you to wade in with advice when you don’t even know the pathways through to becoming a dr OR a psychologist.

She COULD become a child psychologist. Or a mental health nurse, or do something else equally marvellous. You are not qualified, and you just ploughed in with an opinion but no real knowledge to back it up.
Shame

Oher · 05/01/2023 19:33

@Salacia Thank you for all that you’ve done. I know doctors and nurses have been treated appallingly over the past decade. If it helps at all, at least your work has had meaning and impact for many many people. My work certainly hasn’t 🙈

Oher · 05/01/2023 19:31

Cheshiresun · 05/01/2023 16:42

Many medical schools won't accept resits. So you often need A's first time

Damn right! When I have surgery I want a surgeon who gets things right first time not one who says boo hoo let me have another go.

Anyway OP sounds like she needed to hear that. Depends exactly how you phrased it really. If she wants to be a child psychologist then she should do a psychology degree, sounds like she’s been badly guided so far if she’s failing chemistry instead of excelling at something else.

I do think you should never tell a child they can’t do X (DH has been highly successful in a field his school teacher told him not to bother even trying out for) but you absolutely should tell children “If you want X you’ll need to work much harder than you are at the moment and if you aren’t willing to put in the hours maybe explore other options.”

ily0 · 05/01/2023 19:28

She mentioned wanting to be a child psychologist and going to med school. She then mentioned that she was failing Alevel chemistry.

Why is she failing though? Is it a case of her not revising? She might just not be working hard enough and being lazy. I went through a faze of doing badly at school, then got my act together and started doing well. It’s pretty insulting to assume you know that she’s not got a natural aptitude for Chemistry when you don’t know that.

Salacia · 05/01/2023 19:21

I don’t think it’s unreasonable to point out that she’ll need strong grades in chemistry to even get in to medical school (let alone get through the course and professional exams). At the very least you’ll have prompted them to do a bit more research. Getting into medical school is tough, if a well meaning comment from a mum’s friend about something as objective as admission grades is enough to completely turn her off then I think she’d struggle regardless.

That said (as a doctor) I’d be discouraging her round. Don’t sacrifice the bet years of your life to an unfeeling monopoly employer that sees you as a number on a rota rather than a person, infantilises you whilst being the first to throw you under the bus and significantly underpays you for the training/responsibility (all against a barrage of abuse from the general public, politicians and press and a culture of racism in the governing bodies to whom you hand over a chunk of your salary).

Luredbyapomegranate · 05/01/2023 18:52

Yes it would piss me off. Unless she asked for your advice and you were in some way qualified to give it (eg you are a doctor or chemistry teacher), then no you shouldn’t have done, and yes you were being a bitch - you know this I think, you are just hoping to be reassured you weren’t.

If medicine as a career sounded like an overstretch then you could have suggested she talk to her teacher or careers service to find out how she might work round a less than stellar chemistry performance, or indeed whether she needs to if she hasn’t grasped the difference between psychology and psychiatry.

If you were concerned with her being realistic, you would have suggested she talk to people who can help her find the right career.

As it is you might want to examine why you chose to put a teenager down to make yourself feel superior.

FromTheFront2theBack · 05/01/2023 18:40

If she's taking alevels she's not a young child so will probably be resilient enough to handle different points of view. You're not a career advisor so university admissions officer and you don't know much about her academics (is she struggling due to lack of effort which could be turned around or does she genuinely struggle to understand)so if she has any sense she'll be seeking more specialised advice at school anyway. If you're interested in a very competitive university subject or career path it makes sense to have a backup so the advice wasn't ridiculous anyway.

postcardpuffin · 05/01/2023 18:30

Bloody autocorrect- “previous” should have read “precious”!

postcardpuffin · 05/01/2023 18:29

YANBU. I’m not sure what all of the people in this thread saying “I would have not been keen that you discuss this with my child” think a degree, especially a medical degree, involves. Or even A-levels. A student needs to learn how to receive and assess information from all sources. Listening to the opinions and advice of a friend of your parents, and factoring it in to a range of other opinions from school, independent research, all parts of life, is exactly one of the key skills she needs to be developing.

No young person hoping to study for a degree should be encouraged to be previous about who should and who shouldn’t be allowed to talk to them about their applications and careers. They should be getting out there asking questions and taking a range of advice and backing it up with independent research. If they can’t learn that skill, they won’t be much good at a degree (or indeed A-level), and especially not a medical or scientific degree.

If she was 12 or 13 one might be indulgent of slightly unrealistic ideas, but at 16/17 it’s time to be growing up and getting real, not indulging in illusions. If she isn’t making the grade at chemistry A-level she needs to know it, so that she can either improve or change her expectations before they get dashed and she wastes time and university choices. It’s unkind to protect young people that age from developing the skills and resilience they will need to deal with real life.

Testina · 05/01/2023 18:16

In fact, she is Y12, isn’t she?
Because she said she should into it more.
If she was Y13, her UCAS deadline would in less than 3 weeks, so her application would be in!
So yeah - I’d be pissed off that some rando friend of a friend just encouraged my child to see themselves as failing.
It’s a difficult subject, and jump from GCSE is big - especially if she’s done Double not Triple Science GCSE. Unusual for a chemistry student, but possible. Even from triple, it’s a big jump, and she’s only had one term where she’s settling into a new syllabus.
Even if it’s a predicted grade on current work - though it might as I say be an actual level - then it may well be less than she’s capable of.
So yeah - YABU to stick your beak into this one.

Testina · 05/01/2023 18:09

I wouldn’t appreciate a friend of a friend wading in with my child, really. I would know that any child admitted to an A level chemistry course was bright enough to grasp university entrance requirements AND be in a school anyway where discussion will happen. On the offchance that my child was in a funk because they weren’t working hard enough or just losing a bit of confidence during a tricky term, I wouldn’t want a stranger watering that seed that they weren’t good enough. A friend maybe - who knew my child - no a friend of a friend though.

@Summerishere123 did you know that some schools grade you during the year on your current level, and it’s not your predicted grade? If she’s a Y12 one term in and currently working at a D, as her mother I’d be really pissed off that you’d encouraged her to see that as a failure!

Stompythedinosaur · 05/01/2023 18:00

While you aren't wrong, I don't think it's your place to suggest to a friend's child that they might lack ability in their chosen area.

PuttingDownRoots · 05/01/2023 17:49

Even with straight As its worth having a back up plan to medicine.

hettie · 05/01/2023 17:25

She wouldn't get into most undergraduate psychology courses with a D either (at least not the ones that give you GBR which you would need to apply for the doctorate which is the pathway for practitioner psychologists).....
Maybe she hasn't really thought about it much (which is fine) and just mumbles something about it when asked to tell Aunty X Uncle blah about what she's doing at school and what she wants to do. I wouldn't worry too much.....

Thegoodandbadlife · 05/01/2023 17:19

If she wants to study medicine at Uni then requirement is at least an A at A level. Unless she can turn it around and convince the school to predict an A she won’t even be looked at (was the case for me but had reasons why I wasn’t doing as well as expected). Sounds like she’s not investigate ms or researched enough and you’ve reminded her too. UKAT needs to be booked and sat and work experience booked and completed before October deadline for 24/25 start.

Sherbetdib · 05/01/2023 17:05

If she knows she is struggling with Chemistry at A level and doesn't think she will obtain it I would have hoped she might realise this is highly likely to rule out medical school. And perhaps she does. Hence the conversation. I wouldn't feel bad OP. She is going to have some choices to make. So long as people are friendly and supportive but realistic then that is fine.

RampantIvy · 05/01/2023 17:05

I got in with resits, it’s possible but not easy.

How long ago was this? I think it is even more difficult these days to get in with resits as it is so competitive and there are loads of students who got straight As or higher first time round, and excellent UCAT scores. Medical schools can afford to be picky.

A friend of a friend of your parent is not an appropriate person to shit on your dreams

I disagree. They are more likely to listen to someone who isn't a parent. A student getting D's in chemistry won't get into medical school that is certain.

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 05/01/2023 17:01

A 'friend of a friends' daughter'?

Why are you so invested in her choices?

OhBeAFineGuyKissMe · 05/01/2023 16:59

Floomobal · 05/01/2023 16:50

It’s none of your business really. If she doesn’t know the difference between psychology and psychiatry she won’t be getting into any med schools anyway. Better to let her do what she wants, and take the lesson when it comes.

A friend of a friend of your parent is not an appropriate person to shit on your dreams

Giving a gentle realistic nudge isn’t shitting in someone’s dreams. Just letting someone continue regardless is!

By being encouraged to do more research she can find a path that works and allows her to follow her interests (maybe a modified version of her original plan).

If a family friend doesn’t have that conversation, who should? Parents - often goes in one ear and out the other? School? Friends?

Swipe left for the next trending thread