Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dd wants to do a levels in geography, politics, English lit

188 replies

Worriedagainmum · 05/01/2023 14:05

She has no real idea what she wants to do with these land it worries me she has no plan

OP posts:
WinterFoxes · 05/01/2023 17:36

I think that is an excellent mix. Geopolitics is a growth area and having the linguistic skill to write reports on it or to market responsible, ethically sourced sustainable products - these skills will be in demand and could lead to interesting work.

Haveagentlechristmas · 05/01/2023 17:35

I'm not trying to convince you, I'm telling you what it's classified as! Geography is a social science. It's looked after by ESRC (Economic and Social sciences), the British Academy (humanities and social sciences), and AcSS (social sciences). It's a social science!

Show quote history
No it’s not. At degree level geography is a STEM subject. Physical geographers are in demand. Geography crosses the boundaries, physical geography is pure STEM

Its uniquely both a social and physical science. On our degree programmes at uni level we offer both BA and BSc variants. The student can decide whether to take a more physical or human route through the discipline (or a mixture).

huntersmum · 05/01/2023 17:33

My daughter did a similar mix and studied urban planning, did a masters and her MRTPI and at 29 earns a lot of money at a London planning consultancy. The money is secondary as she really enjoys her job. Lots of different projects and opportunities to specialise.

Haveagentlechristmas · 05/01/2023 17:33

It's a great mix. With geography and politics loads of careers will be open to her, she's chosen a great mix.

Lostinalibrary · 05/01/2023 17:32

Poodleporn · 05/01/2023 17:27

I'm not trying to convince you, I'm telling you what it's classified as! Geography is a social science. It's looked after by ESRC (Economic and Social sciences), the British Academy (humanities and social sciences), and AcSS (social sciences). It's a social science!

No it’s not. At degree level geography is a STEM subject. Physical geographers are in demand. Geography crosses the boundaries, physical geography is pure STEM.

RampantIvy · 05/01/2023 17:31

Plate tectonics is Edexcel.

I'm pretty sure that DD covered plate tectonics in her AQA geography A level in 2018 when they did natural hazards.

Lostinalibrary · 05/01/2023 17:30

Lostinalibrary · 05/01/2023 17:29

Rubbish. Physical geography is a STEM subject and is heavy on the maths, chemistry and biology. Hence why there is a 25k PGCE bursary for it as there are better options outside of teaching.

Sorry quoted the wrong person. That was in the response to the humanities post!

Lostinalibrary · 05/01/2023 17:29

NoSquirrels · 05/01/2023 14:13

Sounds brilliant to me. An arts subject, a science, a social science. Why worry?

Rubbish. Physical geography is a STEM subject and is heavy on the maths, chemistry and biology. Hence why there is a 25k PGCE bursary for it as there are better options outside of teaching.

Poodleporn · 05/01/2023 17:27

Anactor · 05/01/2023 17:11

Obviously not, but the argument that it’s a social science ignores the fact that it straddles both ‘hard’ and ‘soft’ science.

I think the AQA syllabus picks the water cycle exactly so students can see how physical and human geography interact. Plate tectonics is Edexcel.

I'm not trying to convince you, I'm telling you what it's classified as! Geography is a social science. It's looked after by ESRC (Economic and Social sciences), the British Academy (humanities and social sciences), and AcSS (social sciences). It's a social science!

Anactor · 05/01/2023 17:11

pa1ace · 05/01/2023 16:51

Geography is not just about plate tectonics!

Obviously not, but the argument that it’s a social science ignores the fact that it straddles both ‘hard’ and ‘soft’ science.

I think the AQA syllabus picks the water cycle exactly so students can see how physical and human geography interact. Plate tectonics is Edexcel.

SleekMamma · 05/01/2023 17:11

I did geography economics and politics. Good Alevels to do. Just get as high grades as possible in them, she will do just fine.

scottishnames · 05/01/2023 17:10

Good mix of subjects, showing - as previous posters have said - a nice range of useful transferable skills. Even more important at age, 16 if your DD enjoys them and therefore works hard, she's likely to get good grades.

Cannot say strongly enough how I disagree with barneshome. Doing almost anything very well (good 2.1 or 1st) at a high-ranking university shows that the student has brains and application and an ability to handle, analyse and communicate data. Just what an employer wants! Ideally with some interesting other activities - music, drama, art, sport, voluntary service etc etc as well. Targeted-to-a-job advanced numeracy - if required - can be learned later as necessary at catch-up courses. A willingness to do this always helpful.

FWIW, I did humanities. I now have a good career. My university classmates include academics, a very high-ranking diplomat, people in publishing (director level), several senior civil servants, a national newspaper journalist, lawyers, social workers, teachers etc etc. I'd defy anyone to call any of them 'soft'.

Pliudev · 05/01/2023 17:07

Those criticising this choice of subjects might like to check out the employability league tables where Geography features quite highly. The A level can lead to further study of either Physical Geography or Cultural Geography at university. Physical Geography encompasses all sorts of important research topics including climate change, environmental threat, conservation studies etc. Cultural Geography can include planning, the effects of environmental change on societies, social deprivation etc. English lit will enhance writing skills and analysis of texts and politics will combine well with these subjects. It's important to study subjects that engage the student and parental interference isn't really helpful, especially if it's based on limited knowledge.

xyhere · 05/01/2023 17:06

Honestly, it's far better that she takes subjects she's good at (and preferably enjoys). When she's the other side of university, very few employers will really care what subjects she did at A-level (unless they're very niche roles). In fact, most don't even seem to care about the subject of the degree these days, except for roles which specifically require in-depth knowledge of a particular subject.

Thing is, unless she's going for an academically-focused role, it's likely that she'd need to have a lot of the things she learned at university trained out of her in her first job anyway - that's certainly true in my world (IT and development) and I've heard it said in a lot of other areas too. Getting the degree itself is the important part, because it shows an ability to get down and work.

Basically, relax. Let her do her thing, and she'll discover where she wants to go with her life - the important part being that it's her life. That, to me, is the most critical part of university; it's where you go to learn how to be independent, and to figure out what you want to do with yourself for the next forty or fifty years. Don't put additional pressure on her to decide that right now, because whatever choice she makes under those conditions...odds are it'll be the wrong one, and she'll resent you for it for a lot longer.

RampantIvy · 05/01/2023 16:56

Yes she badly wants to go to uni. but doesn’t know what uni course she wants to do

She would be far better off taking a gap year while she decides what she wants to do. There is no point in wasting her student loan studying something she isn’t sure about. DD wasn’t sure what she wanted to do at 16, but had a rough idea that it would be something to do with healthcare. She graduated this year with a degree in biomedical sciences and is having a break from studying and is working while she applies for a post grad degree. Her degree enabled her to walk into a job straight away.

But if she does humanities at uni it is a total waste of time - not respected by employers and are soft

What was the point of your goady post @barneshome? You know perfectly well what a load of nonsense your statement was.

Landmark2022 · 05/01/2023 16:51

20 years ago admittedly so things may be different now, but I did Geography, English Lit and French. All complemented each other, developed skills like critical thinking and analysis, and were my strong subjects so got me good grades and into a good university. I did a Geography degree and people from my course went on to a range of careers: finance, consultancy, law, town planning, auditing, journalism, teaching, civil service. A number left on graduate schemes for big multi national employers (KPMG, Anderson consulting), others undertook post grad training to get to their final careers.

pa1ace · 05/01/2023 16:51

Geography is not just about plate tectonics!

Anactor · 05/01/2023 16:42

Poodleporn · 05/01/2023 16:35

It's a social science.

Exactly what part of tectonic processes is a social science?

noworklifebalance · 05/01/2023 16:37

I am sure there are plenty who found it much more straightforward!

noworklifebalance · 05/01/2023 16:36

I understand where you are coming from, @Worriedagainmum - my friends and family that did non vocational degrees, without an idea of where it would lead next struggled for many years, usually doing work they were not enjoying (but at least were employed), masters, PhDs and still feeling a bit at sea and worried for their futures. It has worked out for most of them one way or another.

Poodleporn · 05/01/2023 16:35

Anactor · 05/01/2023 15:36

Geography A level includes Physical Geography (Earth Sciences), Human Geography (Social Sciences) and Introduction to Fieldwork. It’s a science A level with experience in practical data gathering.

It's a social science.

Boating123 · 05/01/2023 16:28

Let her do what she wants to do. I wanted to study Art and Geography at Uni. My parents said but what job will I do, afterwards? so I did architecture instead. Failed the course after two years then did a degree in Geography (I missed the chance you go through clearing and the uni I was in didn't do art).

I did Geography got a 2.1 and am now a planner (there is a shortage of them so your daughter could get a job in that field is she wanted to). I am happy with the way my life has panned out but annoyed my parents didn't let me make my own decisions.

LighthouseCat · 05/01/2023 16:28

Those are sound A-levels. She'll have loads of options when it comes to looking at uni courses. Are you worried she's not doing a science/maths? What do you think are her academic strengths? We're at the same stage you are with DD trying to decide A-levels yet not knowing what they want to do at uni or for a career. I had no idea at 16 either so did A-levels in subjects I enjoyed. Then did a humanities degree, a related masters and then got a totally unrelated job and a PhD in a science!

MrsPinkCock · 05/01/2023 16:26

Anyone saying politics is a soft A Level clearly didn’t do it themselves - it was incredibly challenging when I did it, albeit it was 20 years ago!

I didn’t know what I wanted to do either but I did politics and English as 2 of mine - I then went on to do a law degree and qualified as a lawyer.

My DD picked 3 random subjects and ended up dropping one - she got an 8 in English but was working at a U for A Level. So sometimes the best laid plans just don’t work out - she is going to now have to pick up a third subject next year.

But it’s a marathon not a sprint. Let her choose what she enjoys and is good at.

Shannith · 05/01/2023 16:23

That's a great mix. Got me into Oxbridge- PPE (I did economics not politics A level).