Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lodger cranks up heating to 25

582 replies

Mumskisail · 05/01/2023 10:37

My partner left a few years ago and I had time off work for burnout and now in a less stressful (lower paid) role so on a tight income. I rent 2 rooms to help cover my mortgage and bills (about 40%).

The house is heated to 18-21 degrees depending on the room / personal preference, using Nest thermostats (called TRVs) on each radiator. It is lowered at 11pm until 5.30am, meaning it's warm for about an hour after going to bed and it heats up for a few hours before the lodgers get up.

One lodger is very happy with this and prefers a cooler room so sometimes turns it down.

But the other constantly overrides this and heats his room to 25. When I've tried to speak to him about it he answers his door in a tshirt and is only wearing normal socks. The rest of us have warm clothes, slippers and big fleece hoodies on winter evenings, and use fleece blankets to stay cosy on the sofa.

We seem to be in a battle of wills. He goes along with my suggested times and temperatures in discussion but has done everything including claiming his radiator and the TRV don't work, disconnecting the TRV but trying to make it look as though it's connected, saying it won't connect and pulling the little pin out with a pair of pliers to force the heating on. He leaves it on all night. The thermostat when it's reading says 25-26.

The other issue in this old Victorian house is that the heating pumping out all night causes banging in the pipes and keeps myself and the other lodger awake, or wakes us up in the night. So we prefer lots of layers and a quiet night unless we're in a cold patch.

I've offered him extra duvets and blankets (his looks thin) and a hot water bottle but he refuses. I've asked him to discuss the times he wants the heating on and to talk about the heating.

He says the temperature reading is wrong so I gave him a wireless thermostat which showed the same temperature as the TRV and showed it was correct.

I've explained about the increasing cost of gas and showed him my bills. I've showed him the temperatures in the rest of the house and that we are comfortable.

This is the second winter we are having these issues. Last year his sister died so I just kept my mouth shut and left him to it but I felt really unhappy.

Do I just suck it up, winter will be over soon and I'm not making a loss. Or do I tell him it's not acceptable and ask him to leave? Or is it better the devil you know, this is the only issue.

A friend suggested a locking cover to go over the TRV, I'm so irritated it's tempting but is that really ethical? And anyway would he then just get an electric heater? I don't go into his room and I would never snoop.

He's a 44 year old man having to rent a room and it must be his sanctuary and private space.

Do I just let him win the battle and chill out?

OP posts:
LessSugarIn23 · 09/01/2023 16:49

I don't understand why he's not wearing more clothes.

snowlolo · 09/01/2023 16:41

Flapjackquack · 09/01/2023 16:27

Heating at 25 degrees is pretty “out there” to me.

To you being the operative words there.

The fact is it's pretty standard for there to be something in a lodger agreement about heating.

If a landlord states that heating is included in bills and doesn't specify a limit, sorry but that's their mistake.

A tenant moves in on the basis of unlimited heating. The landlord can't then complain when the tenant puts up the heating, because they've given them a free pass to do so.

Obviously OP now needs to take charge of this and give some notice of increasing bills, but she made a mistake from the off in not anticipating something like this.

billy1966 · 09/01/2023 16:39

25 degrees is just more MN madness 🙄.

I live in an older house and 18 degrees is a very comfortable temperature.

We have several stoves which do give off a lot of heat but above 21 and doors have to be opened.

We most certainly wear cosy fleeces in the house and always have done.

25 degrees is ridiculous and expecting someone to indulge your teeshirt wearing preferences during an energy crisis is madness.

I hope you get rid of him and don't give him a reference.

His interference with your heating system is damage to your property and completely unacceptable.

Flapjackquack · 09/01/2023 16:27

snowlolo · 09/01/2023 16:04

Normal lodger agreements tend to include something around respectful use of communcal spaces.

Variations in temperature comfort are not exactly unexpected or 'out there'. Some people put a jumper on, some people crank up the heating. If the latter annoys you then put it in the agreement. It's not complicated.

Heating at 25 degrees is pretty “out there” to me.

snowlolo · 09/01/2023 16:04

Flapjackquack · 09/01/2023 12:28

But at what point does it end?

“My contract didn’t say I couldn’t sit around in the nude all day, watching reruns of Jerry Springer and eating Surströmming, therefore I’m not unreasonable.”

An agreement has to assume some level of “normal” otherwise it would be thousands of pages long trying to cover every eventuality.

Normal lodger agreements tend to include something around respectful use of communcal spaces.

Variations in temperature comfort are not exactly unexpected or 'out there'. Some people put a jumper on, some people crank up the heating. If the latter annoys you then put it in the agreement. It's not complicated.

Calphurnia88 · 09/01/2023 13:14

CurlyGirlMumma · 09/01/2023 12:41

I might be the only one. But surely he had a right to be comfortable, and heating is part of that? Tell him rent it going up online with increasing costs.

I'm pretty sure that there isn't a single person on this thread who wants this man to be uncomfortable.

But that doesn't mean that OP should accept any or all actions he takes to to make himself comfortable in her home, regardless of whether he is paying her to stay there. This includes overriding the heating system by causing damage to her property, so that he can enjoy constant 25 degree heat in the middle of winter whilst wearing only a t-shirt, currently at OPs expense.

Calphurnia88 · 09/01/2023 13:11

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

KateKateLee · 09/01/2023 12:57

I'd tell him you and the other lodger can no longer afford to pay for the excessive temperature of his room. He either pays for the heating he uses, has the same temperature as the rest of you or leave.

CurlyGirlMumma · 09/01/2023 12:41

I might be the only one. But surely he had a right to be comfortable, and heating is part of that? Tell him rent it going up online with increasing costs.

Flapjackquack · 09/01/2023 12:28

snowlolo · 09/01/2023 11:53

YOU start by doing that (and so would I).

But maybe not everyone does. Not everyone is the same. When you are letting out your house/ room, you can't make assumptions that everyone has the same thought process as you. That's why you have a contract.

If it wasn't in his contract that he couldn't turn up the heating then he would be perfectly within his rights to turn up the heating. It's completely irrelevant whether or not you think he should. It needs to be in the agreement.

But at what point does it end?

“My contract didn’t say I couldn’t sit around in the nude all day, watching reruns of Jerry Springer and eating Surströmming, therefore I’m not unreasonable.”

An agreement has to assume some level of “normal” otherwise it would be thousands of pages long trying to cover every eventuality.

Calphurnia88 · 09/01/2023 12:18

I’m gobsmacked at the number of people on this thread thinking that the lodger is being reasonable.

Same @MrsSkylerWhite

Likewise the number of people who seem to think that expecting someone to wear a jumper in winter is a violation of their human rights.

snowlolo · 09/01/2023 11:55

DesertIslandCondiment · 08/01/2023 10:08

Then he needs to pay more towards the bills If he is such a delicate soul who refuses to put more clothes on. He is a dick.

Yes. I agree.

OP needs to actually request more money towards the bills, and not make assumptions that he 'should' behave in a certain way which is actually arbitrary if it hasn't been stated/ agreed.

snowlolo · 09/01/2023 11:53

WorriedWarrier · 08/01/2023 00:48

If you are cold, in winter, you start by putting on socks and a jumper, plus trousers. He’s done neither

YOU start by doing that (and so would I).

But maybe not everyone does. Not everyone is the same. When you are letting out your house/ room, you can't make assumptions that everyone has the same thought process as you. That's why you have a contract.

If it wasn't in his contract that he couldn't turn up the heating then he would be perfectly within his rights to turn up the heating. It's completely irrelevant whether or not you think he should. It needs to be in the agreement.

Flapjackquack · 09/01/2023 09:29

I’m thinking back to the summer heatwave where at one point I cried because it wouldn’t go below 30 at night for about 4 days!

MrsSkylerWhite · 08/01/2023 22:53

Pam100127 · 06/01/2023 22:13
I know exactly how you feel. We run an Airbnb in the apartment we previously lived in before having kids.
A youngish couple, when booking, asked if they could use the heating & we said sure. We keep the thermostat at about 19 & always have the heating on for an hour before guests arrive.
The night day/night they stayed, it was about 9-10 degrees outside.
When they left & we went inside the heat was suffocating.
They’d all the radiators up full & the thermostat at 35🥵
On checking the meter, they’d used about £16 of gas in a 21 hour stay (& they were out for about 4 of those 21 hours)
This means we have to put our prices up to cover the few who really take advantage.
These were not old frail people.
Very frustrating & spoils it for reasonable guests.“

We were booked into a beautiful hotel in Lincoln a few years ago, a former church or monastery, can’t remember which.
We let ourselves into the room and the heat hit us like a wall. The management were unable to do anything, the radiator valve was broken, so they immediately offered to refund our fee and found us alternative accommodation elsewhere, at no charge.
They brought a thermometer in at one point and it was 29. 35 must be absolutely stultifying. How on earth could anyone tolerate that?

I’m gobsmacked at the number of people on this thread thinking that the lodger is being reasonable.

WorriedWarrier · 08/01/2023 22:42

NandorsFamilar · 07/01/2023 10:54

I am rather surprised someone wants the heating on at 25deg.
I am in Australia and we are trying to cool our house from 24deg- it makes it too hot. So trying to warm a place to 25 sounds mad- environmentally and practically.

Sorry I would give him the heave-ho. To be trying to break something to manipulate the temperature would be enough for me.

Winter and summer temperatures are different. In winter the air is humid in the uk.

DesertIslandCondiment · 08/01/2023 10:08

snowlolo · 07/01/2023 17:16

So why on earth does he want the thermostat on 25 degrees when according to you, he's more comfortable at 19-22?

Answer: He's actually not more comfortable at 19-22. Because if he was, he wouldn't be putting up the temperature.

Either the thermostat isn't actually heating the room to the temperature it says, or he is just someone who is more comfortable at a higher temperature.

Regardless of the dispute about energy bills, you can't tell him what temperature his body feels comfortable at 🙄

Then he needs to pay more towards the bills If he is such a delicate soul who refuses to put more clothes on. He is a dick.

WorriedWarrier · 08/01/2023 00:48

snowlolo · 07/01/2023 17:16

So why on earth does he want the thermostat on 25 degrees when according to you, he's more comfortable at 19-22?

Answer: He's actually not more comfortable at 19-22. Because if he was, he wouldn't be putting up the temperature.

Either the thermostat isn't actually heating the room to the temperature it says, or he is just someone who is more comfortable at a higher temperature.

Regardless of the dispute about energy bills, you can't tell him what temperature his body feels comfortable at 🙄

If you are cold, in winter, you start by putting on socks and a jumper, plus trousers. He’s done neither

Mollymoostoo · 07/01/2023 23:10

Soontobe60 · 05/01/2023 10:46

Id put his rent up - call it a ‘heating supplement’

This. If he wants more heating he needs to pay for it.

snowlolo · 07/01/2023 17:16

Oher · 05/01/2023 16:51

Temperature is not “entirely subjective”. The optimal living temperature for humans has been thoroughly researched and it’s 19-22 degrees celsius.

So why on earth does he want the thermostat on 25 degrees when according to you, he's more comfortable at 19-22?

Answer: He's actually not more comfortable at 19-22. Because if he was, he wouldn't be putting up the temperature.

Either the thermostat isn't actually heating the room to the temperature it says, or he is just someone who is more comfortable at a higher temperature.

Regardless of the dispute about energy bills, you can't tell him what temperature his body feels comfortable at 🙄

VeganStar · 07/01/2023 13:07

Ask him to leave. He’s a dick and he’s going to do exactly as he wants regardless.
Even if you raised his rent it’s not going to stop the noise at night.
Whats wrong in wearing a pair of joggers and a warm hoodie,or some kind of non restricting lounge wear or pyjamas as most people do indoors wintertime.
Im sure he adjusts his clothing according to how cold it is when he goes outside so why doesn’t he do it indoors.
indoors if I’m dressed and not doing anything much I wear a t shirt,a long sleeved top under a hoodie or jumper, then if I get chilly I put a huge fleecy Oody over the top. This is during the day when the heating is off. In the evening pjs, Oody and fleecy throw while watching tv. I have two small heater in the living room, a halogen heater and an oil filled radiator which we alternate between depending on how cold it is so that we don’t have to turn the heating on. If it’s freezing obviously we turn it on but surely at the moment given the energy prices this is the norm in most homes so why does he think he should be any different?

Mummyoflittledragon · 07/01/2023 12:28

Pam100127 · 06/01/2023 22:13

I know exactly how you feel. We run an Airbnb in the apartment we previously lived in before having kids.
A youngish couple, when booking, asked if they could use the heating & we said sure. We keep the thermostat at about 19 & always have the heating on for an hour before guests arrive.
The night day/night they stayed, it was about 9-10 degrees outside.
When they left & we went inside the heat was suffocating.
They’d all the radiators up full & the thermostat at 35🥵
On checking the meter, they’d used about £16 of gas in a 21 hour stay (& they were out for about 4 of those 21 hours)
This means we have to put our prices up to cover the few who really take advantage.
These were not old frail people.
Very frustrating & spoils it for reasonable guests.

We stayed somewhere recently. The heating automatically went down to 17.5 or 18 degrees after a couple of hours if manually boosted in the house. It was managed by hive. I know this as I accidentally managed to override the 17/18 degree setting. Idk how. I wanted to put the temperature up to 21 to heat upstairs as the radiators were off in one of the bedrooms and it was cold up there. I kept on trying to reduce the heat and ended up sweltering. I called the owners, who reset it remotely for us. Perhaps you could get hive?

angela99999 · 07/01/2023 11:31

I'd ask him to leave, explaining that you can't afford his gas bill.

Talia99 · 07/01/2023 11:30

NandorsFamilar · 07/01/2023 10:54

I am rather surprised someone wants the heating on at 25deg.
I am in Australia and we are trying to cool our house from 24deg- it makes it too hot. So trying to warm a place to 25 sounds mad- environmentally and practically.

Sorry I would give him the heave-ho. To be trying to break something to manipulate the temperature would be enough for me.

This. My flat hit 25 degrees according to the thermostat during the 40 degree heatwave last year. I arranged a business trip (knowing the office I needed to visit was climate controlled) for the two worst days and stayed in an air conditioned hotel overnight.

NandorsFamilar · 07/01/2023 10:54

I am rather surprised someone wants the heating on at 25deg.
I am in Australia and we are trying to cool our house from 24deg- it makes it too hot. So trying to warm a place to 25 sounds mad- environmentally and practically.

Sorry I would give him the heave-ho. To be trying to break something to manipulate the temperature would be enough for me.