Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

WIBU to get involved with schools disciplinary process?

257 replies

throwawayname00 · 05/01/2023 09:25

Long story short.
Last term in my DS8 and a bunch of boys in his class were involved in some bullying of another child. it was reported and dealt with by the school.

Parents were called, kids were talked to and for the rest of that school term the 'bullying' boys were not allowed to play together. I personally felt that was a bit OTT but went with it.

We've gone back to school this term and DS has come home saying he still isn't allowed to play with the other boys, they are all being kept apart during class times, lunch times and play times.
And this was announced to them all by the teacher in front of the whole class with her saying "XYZ, you still aren't allowed to play together because I still can't trust you"

I'm intending to speak to the teacher at pick up or maybe just email the school directly.
I feel this has been dragged from one term into another by the teacher, i feel they were spoken to by teachers, head teacher and parents. They were kept apart for 2/3 weeks last term and it could have been left there.
And calling them out like that in front of their peer group is awful IMO.

I want to use this thread to check myself before I go in guns blazing.
WIBU to step in at this point?

OP posts:
BaconMassive · 05/01/2023 10:34

Although I have been defending the OP a little bit, and I do believe that mistakes can be rectified, I do also believe that the school / teachers are best placed to make the call on whether it is appropriate to allow the boys to play together again if they don't feel the situation has been resolved.

Cwcwbird · 05/01/2023 10:34

I don't think you should view this as all guns blazing or nothing. I think it's fair enough to ask the school why they are still being separated - if nothing else I would be worried it suggests there is still some undesirable behaviours going on. You could couch it as you wanting to know if that is the case.

Couldyounot · 05/01/2023 10:33

It probably took the victim's mother a good couple of weeks to extract the details from him. This process is akin to excavation with some kids (my eldest being one such).

It's good that this school have made the consequences visible, however unpalatable that may be to some. More of that in society at large wouldn't be the worst thing.

OopzIDidItAgain · 05/01/2023 10:33

, I don't think that makes your son a bad person or a bully for life.

Op will ensure that happens though by making excuses. A normal parent would be horrified.

TidyDancer · 05/01/2023 10:32

Honestly you should be pleased the school are working towards resolving this as an ongoing process rather than just sweeping it under the carpet. It is not just knee jerk punishment your DS needs, it's effectively retraining to form good friendships and understanding of how his behaviour impacts other people.

As other people have already told you, what you consider to be low level can have a significant impact on the victim decades later. I would wager that you don't have experience of being in this position because you wouldn't be minimising your DS's behaviour if you did.

If you do speak to the school about this, I would be doing so only to say you support whatever they feel they need to do to break up this nasty little bullying group your DS was part of. Being called out publicly for being part of it may help him understand the impact of being singled out.

Bellaboo01 · 05/01/2023 10:31

throwawayname00 · 05/01/2023 09:41

I think bullying was too strong a word tbh, between these boys the other kids coat was hidden, his lunch box thrown across the hall, he was chased around the playground.

However, the reports are he would also throw their lunchboxes, he would run off shouting you wont ever catch me.
One of the bullies bit him, after the bullied kid dared him to bite his arm.

I also, wonder if I feel this way as I have very little communication from the school here. I hear things from my DS and then have to corroborate them with the school, where as I feel the parents should be made aware of how the school are handling it.

I also personally feel that they all missed huge social development milestones during COVID lockdowns and as such, their social development is delayed. If this had happened in year 1 instead of year 3 they would have treated it differently.
These boys are learning those boundaries now. They made mistakes and it has been dealt with, how will anyone know if they can be trusted if they aren't allowed to try again?

Why would you want your child to play in a group of kids who bully another child? If i was you, i would be working with the school and make sure that they know that you support them in making sure that your child isnt 'playing' with these other kids.

I would encourage seperating them and i wouldn't want my child to be playing with anyone who at 8 years old bit another child.

For the record - singling out as a group by - chasing, throwing that child's property and also hiding his things - is so nasty and is bullying and probably something that in a long line of horrible things that these kids have done to this boy.

Yes covid was hard for everyone unfortunately but, still - basic manners and behaviour is still able to be applied, whatever the situation.

EndlessRain1 · 05/01/2023 10:31

PotteringAlonggotkickedoutandhadtoreregister · 05/01/2023 09:30

Your son was bullying someone and you’re cross that school has stopped that happening? Yup, you would be unreasonable to go in all guns blazing.

This.

There's always threads on here about schools not dealing with bullying. I am glad to hear of one finally taking it seriously.

Herroyal · 05/01/2023 10:31

If the teacher says they don’t trust them yet then they don’t, and it’s up to a teacher to manage a class.
speak to your son and explain to him that he needs to earn his teachers trust. He broke it, and if he wants to play with his little gang again they all need to prove they won’t be little shits together.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 05/01/2023 10:30

The thing is, OP, this is not about continually punishing your child. It is about preventing any recurrence of the same problem or something similar. The school has clearly decided that, on the basis of what they know, the dynamic between these particular children is toxic when they are allowed to play together, so it is best for everyone if they are kept apart.

The bullied child has a right to be protected from any further issues. Other children who could also become targets also need to be protected. And frankly, the bullies themselves need to be protected from the negative influence that they clearly have on each other.

The behaviour that you have described is definitely bullying and that certainly isn't too strong a term for it. It sounds horrible and would have been very damaging for the other child. Unlike some on this thread, however, I don't think that makes your son a bad person or a bully for life. He is still very young and still has plenty of time to turn things around, but he needs to be given a proper chance to do so, as do the other bullies, by keeping him away from children who clearly don't play nicely together.

Try to shift your perspective on this. Your ds needs to learn not to engage in this kind of behaviour ever again. The school are helping him to learn this by making the gravity of the situation clear to him and by keeping him away from others who might lead him astray.

CrikeySusan · 05/01/2023 10:30

The reports of the bullying are all from the bullied kid. No staff saw it happening or intervened until the kids mum said something.

Come on!

You are saying that nobody every saw anything at all but the school has come down on this group of boys like a tonne of bricks despite this?

If that is what you actually believe, then you have failed as a parent by not removing your child from the school immediately.

The minute they told you that they had not seen any bullying and nor had any other adult and none of the other children had seen a thing despite numerous incidents but they were going to punish a whole group of children regardless then you should have run like the wind as clearly the school is run by lunatics.

They must have some sort of delusional agenda to do this and the head and the teachers must all be in cahoots because in an ordinary school one of the adults would have said something.

BedfordBloo · 05/01/2023 10:29

Nimbostratus100 · 05/01/2023 10:20

I disagree, children are not defined by their behaviour

Then we’ll have to agree to disagree on that. Lord knows what on earth you think a bully is if it’s not someone who bullies people but hey ho. I bet you don’t take issue with people who define your DCs by their positive behaviours - would you tell your child that they aren’t friendly just because their behaviour is friendly? Would you tell them that they aren’t hardworking just because they work hard?

Eyerollcentral · 05/01/2023 10:29

@throwawayname00 hmmm was his father violent or manipulative before the breakdown of your relationship? I take it there must have been some level of adverse behaviours as he isn’t allowed to contact you. I’d be trying to encourage him with positive male friends of the same age. Also has he an older male influence in his life? I don’t mean to go overboard but you need to nip this in the bud now. By the time he is 13 your son could easily be physically bigger and you’ll have completely lost control of his behaviour. This is serious and you need to treat it as such. Focus on why your son thought this was ok rather than tackling the school’s policy.
As for not punishing a child continuously, give me a break. It’s in no one’s interest, including themselves, that these children play together, that’s just the way it is. They will soon find other friends.

BaconMassive · 05/01/2023 10:28

BedfordBloo · 05/01/2023 10:18

Don’t be ridiculous. If you bully people then you’re a bully. If you shoot people then you’re a shooter. If you help people then you’re a helper. People are defined by their actions, and rightly so. If OP wants her DS to be something other than a bully she needs to teach him that his behaviour wasn’t acceptable rather than that he did nothing wrong and should feel free to carry on. If and when his behaviour changes, he’ll become a “former bully”.

My son wet himself at nursery when he was 4 because he was too busy playing.

Does this make him a wetter? Or did he learn that when you need the toilet you have to stop what you are doing and go? Should he be labelled a wetter for life?

I think people who give labels to a children they don't know on the internet might be bullies.

Plumbear2 · 05/01/2023 10:28

Good, the school are handling it in the right way. Priority has to be the victim not the bullies. It's best it's tackled now otherwise your child will be spending lots of time in isolation if it carries on the secondary school.

FriedEggChocolate · 05/01/2023 10:26

I would leave the school for now and focus on support for your DS. "The school are concerned that if you, A, B and C get together again at lunchtime, you'll muck around together and other people might get hurt, like happened before. If you're not playing with A, B or C at lunchtime, who else is around that you can play with?" would be a good place to start.

Can you invite any other possible new friends roundfor a playdate outside of school?

If you want to approach the school, I'd do it in the frame of "telling this group to keep apart in front of their peers flagged to other pupils that they behave poorly and limits DS's chance of making other friends away from this group", so it's not "my DS can't play with his mates 'cause you're stopping him", more "I get why they can't be together but your action hasn't helped DS move on" which isn't quite where you're coming from at the moment. Your OP was very focused on "my son should be able to meeet with his friends again" and that's not going to happen, realistically.

Georgeskitchen · 05/01/2023 10:26

Anyone else old enough to remember the days when if you got in trouble at school and your parents got wind of it, you would get a thick ear from them ?
Nowadays the parents are storming down to school demanding apologies etc cos someone had the temerity to tell their little darling off.
And people wonder why teachers are leaving the profession in droves?

OdeToBarney · 05/01/2023 10:25

throwawayname00 · 05/01/2023 09:41

I think bullying was too strong a word tbh, between these boys the other kids coat was hidden, his lunch box thrown across the hall, he was chased around the playground.

However, the reports are he would also throw their lunchboxes, he would run off shouting you wont ever catch me.
One of the bullies bit him, after the bullied kid dared him to bite his arm.

I also, wonder if I feel this way as I have very little communication from the school here. I hear things from my DS and then have to corroborate them with the school, where as I feel the parents should be made aware of how the school are handling it.

I also personally feel that they all missed huge social development milestones during COVID lockdowns and as such, their social development is delayed. If this had happened in year 1 instead of year 3 they would have treated it differently.
These boys are learning those boundaries now. They made mistakes and it has been dealt with, how will anyone know if they can be trusted if they aren't allowed to try again?

YABVVVVVU

Your child was involved in taking and hiding another child's stuff as well as damaging it and you're upset your son and the other bullies are being kept apart? Jesus.

Herroyal · 05/01/2023 10:24

Read what you’ve written and imagine it being done to your son. Then imagine your son not wanting to go to school, coming home crying everyday. Asking you why they’re picking on him and not someone else.
And I’m sure there was a lot more to it - the throwing lunch boxes was probably just the most visible aspect of it.

Then think about whether or not those bullies should be allowed to form their little gang again, given that separating them from playing together has knocked the bullying on the head?

The school are doing you a favour. Your son needs different friends and/or to learn that his behaviour was NOT acceptable - which from the sounds of it he’s not really getting a home as you’re making ‘boys will be boys’ excuses for.
If your son and these other kids are such good friends then they can play together after school, weekends and holidays instead.

Highlyflavouredgravy · 05/01/2023 10:23

I think the word bully has an incredibly strong, emotive effect on people. Just listen to some of the words being used on here to describle children of 7 or 8 who are still learning how to act, how to be social, where they sit in the world and what society's expectations are.
I work with children of this age and I think the best approach would be for the children to be doing some work on friendships, on feelings, on what it means to be a good friend and a bad friend. Yes, absolutely keep them apart still but not writing them all off as untrustworthy.

SpicyFoodRocks · 05/01/2023 10:22

OP have a polite and calm chat with the school. Ask for a plan and a date at which they will consider removing the sanction. Ask what your son needs to do, and then relay that firmly to him.

I believe punishment was needed and the bullied kid’s feeling come first. But even most prison sentences have an end and a better outcome would be if these boys can reflect and play together again without resuming their bullying behaviour. Just keeping them apart indefinitely doesn’t teach them that much in the long term.

Has your son apologised properly to the boy and shown remorse? I may have missed that. That would be hugely important to me as a parent.

Do you think he would repeat the behaviour if reunited with his friends?

Brefugee · 05/01/2023 10:21

I think bullying was too strong a word tbh, between these boys the other kids coat was hidden, his lunch box thrown across the hall, he was chased around the playground.

bloody norah - that is fucking appalling and in your shoes I'd be questioning a) why i think that's just "bantz" and b) where my parenting went wrong that my son thinks that's ok

Your bullying son has got of lightly and you all need to think about what has happened here. This isn't about your son, it is about making the bullied child(ren) feel safe at school. They are the priority, not your bully-son.

OopzIDidItAgain · 05/01/2023 10:20

I dread to think what op thinks constitutes real bullying if those behaviours her son admits to didn't make the mark.

Very few eight year olds have the capacity to even think of much nastier behaviour than those listed. If they were setting his hair alight (like what happened to my bf in secondary) I'd consider them psychopathic, but op would probably write it off as creative thinking or something.

Oh the victim had red hair too so op would probably say it was her fault for having flame coloured hair.

Nimbostratus100 · 05/01/2023 10:20

BedfordBloo · 05/01/2023 10:18

Don’t be ridiculous. If you bully people then you’re a bully. If you shoot people then you’re a shooter. If you help people then you’re a helper. People are defined by their actions, and rightly so. If OP wants her DS to be something other than a bully she needs to teach him that his behaviour wasn’t acceptable rather than that he did nothing wrong and should feel free to carry on. If and when his behaviour changes, he’ll become a “former bully”.

I disagree, children are not defined by their behaviour

healthadvice123 · 05/01/2023 10:19

Seems like a lot of bullies on here as well
They are 8 years old and still learning boundaries and Op said the other boy stole lunchboxes etc first
OP go in and speak to the school, just in a nice way and ask what the plan is long term.
They may explain why they are still keeping separate maybe they are seeing signs all is not resolved or want to give it a bit longer or feel the friendship group is not great in other ways tpo, they may of seen an uptick in learning etc
You have a right to go in and ask what the plan is for your child
They are still kids , all grown women writing off 8 year olds as almost bully for life for one situation isn't great behaviour either

BedfordBloo · 05/01/2023 10:18

Nimbostratus100 · 05/01/2023 10:10

No, this child is not "a bully". This is a child who has bullied, please be clear on the difference . This is a child that needs boundaries and guidance and support to prevent developing into a life long bully, which he is thank fully getting at school, (maybe not at home). At this age, no child is already a permanent bully

Don’t be ridiculous. If you bully people then you’re a bully. If you shoot people then you’re a shooter. If you help people then you’re a helper. People are defined by their actions, and rightly so. If OP wants her DS to be something other than a bully she needs to teach him that his behaviour wasn’t acceptable rather than that he did nothing wrong and should feel free to carry on. If and when his behaviour changes, he’ll become a “former bully”.