Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

WIBU to get involved with schools disciplinary process?

257 replies

throwawayname00 · 05/01/2023 09:25

Long story short.
Last term in my DS8 and a bunch of boys in his class were involved in some bullying of another child. it was reported and dealt with by the school.

Parents were called, kids were talked to and for the rest of that school term the 'bullying' boys were not allowed to play together. I personally felt that was a bit OTT but went with it.

We've gone back to school this term and DS has come home saying he still isn't allowed to play with the other boys, they are all being kept apart during class times, lunch times and play times.
And this was announced to them all by the teacher in front of the whole class with her saying "XYZ, you still aren't allowed to play together because I still can't trust you"

I'm intending to speak to the teacher at pick up or maybe just email the school directly.
I feel this has been dragged from one term into another by the teacher, i feel they were spoken to by teachers, head teacher and parents. They were kept apart for 2/3 weeks last term and it could have been left there.
And calling them out like that in front of their peer group is awful IMO.

I want to use this thread to check myself before I go in guns blazing.
WIBU to step in at this point?

OP posts:
starfishmummy · 05/01/2023 10:56

And calling them out like that in front of their peer group is awful IMO.

His peer group will already be well aware of the situation.

The only awful thing here was what your son and this gang did.

Nimbostratus100 · 05/01/2023 10:55

throwawayname00 · 05/01/2023 10:54

I'm confused about where I've said my son hasn't stopped?
There seems to be a lot on this thread where people are commenting about how I'm not dealing with it or how my son has done XYZ.
He absolutely has stopped, reparations were attempted (the mum refused to speak to any of the other mums - I for one immediately texted her upon finding out and asked that my DS apologise to her son and her face to face but she didn't reply so we wrote a letter which she handed back to the school unopened)

But the vast majority of replies on this thread seem to suggest that he hasn't stopped bullying or that I am egging him on and finding it all utterly hilarious.
I'm asking for advice as I'm on my own here, and this is a learning curve as i have not done this before.

The mother is quite right not to engage with you in any way. This is being dealt with formally through the school

BedfordBloo · 05/01/2023 10:55

throwawayname00 · 05/01/2023 10:54

I'm confused about where I've said my son hasn't stopped?
There seems to be a lot on this thread where people are commenting about how I'm not dealing with it or how my son has done XYZ.
He absolutely has stopped, reparations were attempted (the mum refused to speak to any of the other mums - I for one immediately texted her upon finding out and asked that my DS apologise to her son and her face to face but she didn't reply so we wrote a letter which she handed back to the school unopened)

But the vast majority of replies on this thread seem to suggest that he hasn't stopped bullying or that I am egging him on and finding it all utterly hilarious.
I'm asking for advice as I'm on my own here, and this is a learning curve as i have not done this before.

The teacher said it, in your OP. The teacher said he can’t be trusted to not bully others so can’t be with the other bullies.

10storeylovesong · 05/01/2023 10:54

My son was bullied through year 3 and 4. He has just been referred to the pathway for suspected ADHD. He has a very strong fight instinct, and when bullied would respond by either losing his temper and shouting, or trying to turn it into a game to protect himself. From the outside, without understanding the context, it would have looked like he was engaging or playing. I was in and out of school who minimised it saying he was playing along. It took a self harm attempt after I spotted bruises in the bath (over a week after the incident as he hadn't told me about it) before school took it seriously. Funnily enough, it took calling out the children in class in front of their peers to stop the behaviour.

Nimbostratus100 · 05/01/2023 10:54

BedfordBloo · 05/01/2023 10:48

I have just as much experience as you do and I disagree. All you’ve pointed out is that calling him a bully is going to be more effective at conveying that it’s unacceptable.

I am very surprised that someone with any sort of experience in child development would be prepared to label a young child like this

throwawayname00 · 05/01/2023 10:54

BedfordBloo · 05/01/2023 10:35

The difference is that OP’s DS hasn’t changed his behaviour. That’s the huge, huge, huge difference between a child being a bully and a child being a former bully. Your child wet themselves, they were a “wetter” (is that even a word for someone who wets themselves?). But he stopped, so no, not “labelled for life”. OP’s child isn’t “labelled for life” either - they’re labelled for the time that they keep behaving inappropriately. The teacher has said that they still can’t be trusted not to bully other children and they’ve absolutely bullied a child just a few weeks ago - that makes them a bully. It’s not “labelling for life” to say someone is a bully based on their current continuation of behaviour that was acknowledged to be bullying behaviour just a few weeks ago.

I'm confused about where I've said my son hasn't stopped?
There seems to be a lot on this thread where people are commenting about how I'm not dealing with it or how my son has done XYZ.
He absolutely has stopped, reparations were attempted (the mum refused to speak to any of the other mums - I for one immediately texted her upon finding out and asked that my DS apologise to her son and her face to face but she didn't reply so we wrote a letter which she handed back to the school unopened)

But the vast majority of replies on this thread seem to suggest that he hasn't stopped bullying or that I am egging him on and finding it all utterly hilarious.
I'm asking for advice as I'm on my own here, and this is a learning curve as i have not done this before.

OP posts:
Hoppinggreen · 05/01/2023 10:54

booboo82 · 05/01/2023 10:10

Wow just wow ! Your son is a bully ! Your attitude absolutely stinks and makes me think the apple didn't fall far from the tree! Do you have any idea of how bullying affects the victims ? I doubt it I reckon you were just the same as your son at school! Bullys breeding more bully's!

If you read OPs subsequent posts if the apple didn’t fall too far from the tree it may be that it’s the father rather than OP that’s probably the issue

BedfordBloo · 05/01/2023 10:53

Highlyflavouredgravy · 05/01/2023 10:52

You are wrong.

What a compelling argument, I fully accept that I must be wrong because you say so. By the way, all the people on this thread saying how rare it is for schools to bother taking bullying seriously and complaining that staff care more about the bullies feelings that about protecting others from bullying - they’re talking about you!

Unexpecteddrivinginstructor · 05/01/2023 10:52

My dc was bullied aged 8, half their lifetime ago but still see the impact now.

I agree it might be useful to ask the school for a plan of how your ds can redeem himself but I would be pleased that he is being encouraged away from a less healthy friendship group.

Have you and ds wached the film Wonder? I think it deals really well with bullying. Watch it together and have a discussion with him.

Highlyflavouredgravy · 05/01/2023 10:52

BedfordBloo · 05/01/2023 10:48

I have just as much experience as you do and I disagree. All you’ve pointed out is that calling him a bully is going to be more effective at conveying that it’s unacceptable.

You are wrong.

SpottyBumPony · 05/01/2023 10:52

But @throwawayname00 he does have another chance. He hasn't been excluded, he has another chance to make new friends and not bully again. Thus showing he he has changed and can be trusted.

PeekAtYou · 05/01/2023 10:49

I'd be delighted that the boys were being kept apart. During the 2/3 weeks, did your son play with some new kids? Did he get into trouble ?

You are massively underplaying what happened. Obviously I wasn't there but "You can't catch me" isn't necessarily a challenge to chase him. It could easily be a way of saying "I'm going so leave me alone" I think that you've fallen into the trap of thinking bullying victims and bullies are a certain way. Maybe the victims need to cry, beg the bullies to stop and so on?

It's unusual for schools to take this seriously imo. Stuff like this is often dismissed as banter or silliness when it can have a major effect on the self esteem.

Sometimes kids can be mean. Mine are great kids but have had their moments and they've probably learned plenty from their mistakes. Talking about bullying openly is a good thing. Even adults can't recognise it - I've read lots of posts on here asking if an OP is over sensitive or being abused?

Your son isn't destined to be a bad person because he messed up in this case but avoiding the other boys is a good idea. The pandemic has meant less unsupervised playground time but instead of blaming it and asking for the school to overlook the bullying isn't the answer. Kids need to learn and primary school is an appropriate time to learn that this kind of behaviour isn't ok. If he was the target, he'd want support from the adults around him.

BeeDavis · 05/01/2023 10:49

Do you not understand that children have killed themselves over being bullied? It’s serious no matter their age/circumstances. It’s better to be stamped out now than when they’re older and the consequences are more dangerous.

BedfordBloo · 05/01/2023 10:48

Nimbostratus100 · 05/01/2023 10:45

because it is damaging, particularly for children.

Labelling this child a "bully" at this age is likely to be a self fulfilling prophesy

Labelling a child a "hardworker" is setting them up for a load of pressure and expectation, with nowhere to go to improve

Labelling a child a "a good girl" for being friendly and compliant sets them up for a life time of being a door mat.

It is far more constructive to talk about the behaviour.

"What you did in this incidence was bullying" not "you are a bully"
"Well done, you worked really hard on that" not "you are a hard worker"
" I am proud of how kind and friendly you were to x individual today" not "you are friendly"

30 years in education, (including in youth prisons) 10 years foster carer

I have just as much experience as you do and I disagree. All you’ve pointed out is that calling him a bully is going to be more effective at conveying that it’s unacceptable.

Nimbostratus100 · 05/01/2023 10:45

BedfordBloo · 05/01/2023 10:38

It would be acceptable for you to label me a “drinker”, yes. Someone who drinks alcohol is a “drinker” by definition. If I stopped drinking alcohol then I’d be a “former drinker”. Why does that concept offend you?

because it is damaging, particularly for children.

Labelling this child a "bully" at this age is likely to be a self fulfilling prophesy

Labelling a child a "hardworker" is setting them up for a load of pressure and expectation, with nowhere to go to improve

Labelling a child a "a good girl" for being friendly and compliant sets them up for a life time of being a door mat.

It is far more constructive to talk about the behaviour.

"What you did in this incidence was bullying" not "you are a bully"
"Well done, you worked really hard on that" not "you are a hard worker"
" I am proud of how kind and friendly you were to x individual today" not "you are friendly"

30 years in education, (including in youth prisons) 10 years foster carer

BedfordBloo · 05/01/2023 10:45

Highlyflavouredgravy · 05/01/2023 10:42

No not a drinker. A drunk.
Once you got drunk therefore you are a drunk.

A negative label that stays with you.

That’s not what that word means though. If you change the meaning of words in order to (try and) make a point then obviously it’s offensive. Using the correct term isn’t offensive.

Highlyflavouredgravy · 05/01/2023 10:42

No not a drinker. A drunk.
Once you got drunk therefore you are a drunk.

A negative label that stays with you.

Catswhisky · 05/01/2023 10:41

I would speak to the teacher. I would ask how your ds can move forward in a positive way. Is there anything specific you need to work on with him ( other than not to bully, be kind etc that you are hopefully doing anyway) and have they noticed any seeds of friendship with anyone you can encourage as he’s feeling lost without his previous friends.

You are minimising serious bullying, the school are handling it well in keeping these boys apart, but I hope they are also finding positive ways to move them on rather than just the needed discipline.

BedfordBloo · 05/01/2023 10:41

Nimbostratus100 · 05/01/2023 10:37

I would avoid defining any young child by their behaviour, it really isn't helpful at all

You’re right. The most “helpful” thing to do is to tell a child that bullying others doesn’t mean they’re a bully and to just carry on making other people miserable. Heaven forbid a child understand that the way they choose to behave impacts how people view them, it would be awful if bullying children ever thought that their actions had negative consequences for them and not just for other people.

BedfordBloo · 05/01/2023 10:38

Highlyflavouredgravy · 05/01/2023 10:37

So if you have been drunk once. It would be be ok for me to label you a drunk?

It would be acceptable for you to label me a “drinker”, yes. Someone who drinks alcohol is a “drinker” by definition. If I stopped drinking alcohol then I’d be a “former drinker”. Why does that concept offend you?

MichelleScarn · 05/01/2023 10:38

The reports of the bullying are all from the bullied kid. No staff saw it happening or intervened until the kids mum said something.
so what does your son say? Does he admit he did it? You must believe he did as so you not also say the other child started it?* *

Nimbostratus100 · 05/01/2023 10:37

BedfordBloo · 05/01/2023 10:29

Then we’ll have to agree to disagree on that. Lord knows what on earth you think a bully is if it’s not someone who bullies people but hey ho. I bet you don’t take issue with people who define your DCs by their positive behaviours - would you tell your child that they aren’t friendly just because their behaviour is friendly? Would you tell them that they aren’t hardworking just because they work hard?

I would avoid defining any young child by their behaviour, it really isn't helpful at all

Highlyflavouredgravy · 05/01/2023 10:37

BedfordBloo · 05/01/2023 10:29

Then we’ll have to agree to disagree on that. Lord knows what on earth you think a bully is if it’s not someone who bullies people but hey ho. I bet you don’t take issue with people who define your DCs by their positive behaviours - would you tell your child that they aren’t friendly just because their behaviour is friendly? Would you tell them that they aren’t hardworking just because they work hard?

So if you have been drunk once. It would be be ok for me to label you a drunk?

PerpetualFailure · 05/01/2023 10:36

Pleased school is dealihg with this.
No harm asking when the boys will be allowed to play again. But politely, not "all guns blazing".

BedfordBloo · 05/01/2023 10:35

BaconMassive · 05/01/2023 10:28

My son wet himself at nursery when he was 4 because he was too busy playing.

Does this make him a wetter? Or did he learn that when you need the toilet you have to stop what you are doing and go? Should he be labelled a wetter for life?

I think people who give labels to a children they don't know on the internet might be bullies.

The difference is that OP’s DS hasn’t changed his behaviour. That’s the huge, huge, huge difference between a child being a bully and a child being a former bully. Your child wet themselves, they were a “wetter” (is that even a word for someone who wets themselves?). But he stopped, so no, not “labelled for life”. OP’s child isn’t “labelled for life” either - they’re labelled for the time that they keep behaving inappropriately. The teacher has said that they still can’t be trusted not to bully other children and they’ve absolutely bullied a child just a few weeks ago - that makes them a bully. It’s not “labelling for life” to say someone is a bully based on their current continuation of behaviour that was acknowledged to be bullying behaviour just a few weeks ago.