Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to report my CF neighbour CF for doing the same thing she's reported me for to Planning?

80 replies

DividedHouses · 05/01/2023 04:54

We own part of a big old house which is divided into five "residential units" really mini houses- we each have our own front/back doors and front/back gardens. We're on one end. Over the last few years we've done some like-for-like replacements (leaky oil tank, falling down porch and steps). The adjoining neighbour put in a complaint to planning (and told us she'd done it -- she's a bit off and is always having disputes with the nice old chap the other side of her). We didn't worry thinking everything we had done fell squarely under permitted development since she's the type to report you if your bin's a bit dirty.

Wrong! Letter from planning tells us permitted development doesn't apply in divided houses and now we need retrospective planning for it all. Would she/planning have preferred us to let the old oil tank leak, the porch fall down altogether (rotting!) and my older spouse break his neck on the steps (one was missing!)? Anyway.... so the letter recommends we hire a specialist firm and get plans drawn up and request permission for what we already did.

Irony is this CF has built one of those wooden shed/pod things at the end of the garden telling everyone it's permitted development..it's large and has a veranda and 3 rooms!

AND she originally bought two of the little houses we all live in and converted them into big one, again telling us all it was permitted development.

WIBU to report her? And if I do, does anyone know planning rules for subdivided houses? Can you build a wooden hut in your garden under permitted development if you live in a divided house? Can you combine two houses into one under permitted development if they are part of a divided house?

She did both of these things more than four years ago -- does the four year rule apply (if not reported in four years they let it go)?

Thanks for replying if you have any insights! I'm resigned to spending money we haven't got to fix the problem and get retrospective approval, but I'd like to either report her or let her know she's reporting us for stuff she's done that she shouldn't (if that's the case...)

Voting:
YANBU Report the CF.
YABU No, don't report her - two wrongs don't make a right.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
mrsbrownhat · 10/02/2023 08:38

poefaced · 05/01/2023 04:59

@bestchristmasever there is no strikethrough. Must be your device.

And mine too then. Almost whole thread is lined out.

FunnyWorldWeLiveIn · 10/02/2023 08:36

Absolutely report her. Karmas a bitch
If nothing is wrong then so be it 🤔

Jins · 10/02/2023 08:28

Planner here. No point me posting because @Seeline has said it all really.

i wouldn't class your replacement oil tank or repairs to the steps as development. I can’t comment on the porch without more information.

You don’t need a specialist firm for this and I’m surprised they suggested it. I’ve dealt with retrospective applications that were supported by before and after photos

Bard6817 · 10/02/2023 08:16

I think you are being unreasonable.

Mainly because you have different responsibilities when you run a business. Which you have made your home into.

If you don’t know this - this is a good lesson to you.

Don’t care about your neighbour - sounds awfull - i wouldnt want to live next to her - but why stoop to her level. Doesn’t make you sound any better.

Seeline · 10/02/2023 08:09

Planner here.

I am assuming that you are in England, and that the property is not Listed, in a Conservation Area or within an Area of Outstanding Natural Beauty or National Park.

From your description I think the residential units are houses not flats? Flats never have permitted development rights.

I suspect when the original house was converted into 4 units there was a condition on the permission removing some or all permitted development rights.
Without seeing the exact wording of the condition it is hard to say what exactly would need PP.

I think it likely that your ndn would require PP for the outbuilding, but you would need to check the original PP for the house conversion for the conditions..

Development carried out in breach of a condition can be enforced against for a 10 year period (rather than the 4years mentioned above).

I am surprised that the Council required PP for general maintenance unless what you replaced was significantly different or bigger than the original. I am also surprised that the Council recommended a specialist firm.

Generally, the conversion of 2 houses into 1 does not require PP if there are no extensions or major external alterations required, but again the original PP for the original conversion would need checking.

KTheGrey · 10/02/2023 07:46

Yes report her. Otherwise she will escalate.

WhereIsMumHiding3 · 10/02/2023 07:43

Hope you do report her, the busybody

You simple did like for like repairs, that were needed

I doubt that converting two flats into one big flat is permitted development . Nor that adding a large building shed used for living space into garden is permitted development, you can't do that if it it's less than 10m away or takes up too much proportion of the garden or it's an excluded property

www.sheds.co.uk/planning-permission

However if she did the first change many years ago- over 10, not sure they can enforce.

I would report her. She boasted about reporting you. She has altered her property more
Fair's fair

MotherOfPuffling · 10/02/2023 00:42

So what did you do in the end, Op?!

DividedHouses · 06/01/2023 01:01

Apologies to those who see strikethrough. I have posted it below without the dash. Thanks to all who responded. To answer a few questions, it's not listed and the gardens are not communal so the structure is in her garden. I've got some great tips from you all here so many thanks.

We own part of a big old house which is divided into five "residential units" really mini houses- we each have our own front/back doors and front/back gardens. We're on one end. Over the last few years we've done some like-for-like replacements (leaky oil tank, falling down porch and steps). The adjoining neighbour put in a complaint to planning (and told us she'd done it she's a bit off and is always having disputes with the nice old chap the other side of her). We didn't worry thinking everything we had done fell squarely under permitted development since she's the type to report you if your bin's a bit dirty.

Wrong! Letter from planning tells us permitted development doesn't apply in divided houses and now we need retrospective planning for it all. Would she/planning have preferred us to let the old oil tank leak, the porch fall down altogether (rotting!) and my older spouse break his neck on the steps (one was missing!)? Anyway.... so the letter recommends we hire a specialist firm and get plans drawn up and request permission for what we already did.

Irony is this CF has built one of those wooden shed/pod things at the end of the garden telling everyone it's permitted development..it's large and has a veranda and 3 rooms!

AND she originally bought two of the little houses we all live in and converted them into big one, again telling us all it was permitted development.

WIBU to report her? And if I do, does anyone know planning rules for subdivided houses? Can you build a wooden hut in your garden under permitted development if you live in a divided house? Can you combine two houses into one under permitted development if they are part of a divided house?

She did both of these things more than four years ago. Does the four year rule apply (if not reported in four years they let it go)?

Thanks for replying if you have any insights! I'm resigned to spending money we haven't got to fix the problem and get retrospective approval, but I'd like to either report her or let her know she's reporting us for stuff she's done that she shouldn't (if that's the case...)

Voting:

YANBU Report the CF.

YABU No, don't report her - two wrongs don't make a right.

OP posts:
nardleo · 05/01/2023 09:00

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

nardleo · 05/01/2023 08:59

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

soberfabulous · 05/01/2023 08:47

poefaced · 05/01/2023 04:59

@bestchristmasever there is no strikethrough. Must be your device.

There is for me.

MajorCarolDanvers · 05/01/2023 08:46

Completely unreadable

ArabellaScott · 05/01/2023 08:44

Planning rules depend where in the UK you are, OP. They also change/have changed over time, so some of it might depend on when work was done.

I'd suggest contacting a qualified planning expert/architect to discuss. This kind of thing can be quite complicated.

www.gov.uk/planning-permission-england-wales

Dguu6u · 05/01/2023 08:41

The building might have an article 4 direction, which means permitted development rights have been taken away. They need permission for any outbuilding and for converting two units into one. Or if it's been 4 years and they can prove this, they just need a certificate of lawfulness. Contact your local planning authority for advice.

EarringsandLipstick · 05/01/2023 08:40

Clymene · 05/01/2023 08:20

The strike through is caused by using two hyphens - one either side of a phrase.

So the OP can repost without the hyphens.

Sorry I posted without seeing this!

EarringsandLipstick · 05/01/2023 08:39

The reason for strikethrough on the app is that OP has used double-dashes (copied text below from the mobile site):

-- she's a bit off and is always having disputes

On the app the double-dashes create strikethrough so all the text between the two sets of dashes is like this

Megan1992xx · 05/01/2023 08:36

Report her, dont give it if you cannot take it.

JessicaBrassica · 05/01/2023 08:25

In my experience - particularly around listed buildings - every neighbour who put in a complaint about their neighbour had already breached regulations. They'd phone up and complain about something, wed investigate and then end up having to take action against the complainant. Complaints included stripping ivy and changing the character of a building - from someone who had added velux windows to her listed building without consent. And about neighbours putting up a purgola - by someone who had demolished a curtilage building.

Check out what you can and cannot do and then report your neighbour once you've regularised your own breaches!

JuneOsborne · 05/01/2023 08:21

This reminds me of the thread where half of the posters saw a totally different title for the thread to the other half. Something about windows, or spare rooms, or house layouts or who got which bedroom.

Clymene · 05/01/2023 08:20

The strike through is caused by using two hyphens - one either side of a phrase.

So the OP can repost without the hyphens.

Suzi888 · 05/01/2023 08:20

YANBU she’s an idiot.

No strike through and it’s still readable.

HotChoxs · 05/01/2023 08:19

ShakespearesBlister · 05/01/2023 08:02

It means cheeky fucker?

Yes it usually does.

BruceAndNosh · 05/01/2023 08:17

What the OP has done sounds like maintenance and repair, not development.

GolfEchoRomeoTangoIndia · 05/01/2023 08:17

What do you want to achieve OP? Have your neighbour's changes caused any problems for you? The changing of two units into one will be a nightmare when she comes to sell if she is in breach of planning, so I'd leave natural consequences to give her her comeuppance for that.

I can understand why you're cross, but unless the thing in the garden is an issue for you I don't think that reporting her will make your life better.