Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To stop breastfeeding cold turkey

53 replies

Newmama93 · 05/01/2023 04:28

Hi mums,

I still bf my 21.5 month old, he wakes me up 15/20 times a night to feed, screaming for hours on end if I say no, I give in and feed. I’m tired, I have stopped ovulating due to the constant night feeds and want another baby.

my husband was doing nights and my son slept so good, only feeding in the morning. He got sick and reverted straight back to wanting me all night and is feeding 5 times in the day, all naps, whenever he gets hurt or tired. I can’t do it anymore, it takes me an hour and a half to get him to sleep at he swaps sides and sucks and sucks then lays down then sits back up and sucks again.

my husband is off work and I ha e said I’m going to stay at my mums and get him to put DS to bed, my DH said I need to totally wean in the day as well or this won’t work and he’ll revert back soon (km going away with DS in 2 weeks where it’ll just be me ahh help)

some people are saying this is cruel to my son and I should wean slower at his pace,
but I’ve tried, it doesn’t work, he cries for hours until I give in. I’m tired, help

OP posts:
FlorrieFosdyke · 05/01/2023 06:50

I weaned both of mine cold turkey. First was just after her third birthday. I had cut down to just feeds when hurt and bedtime / morning but then I had DS and for the final 4 months I was tandem feeding both and she reverted to feeding like a newborn. I continued for the four months so that she wouldn't resent her brother but it was hard. So, in the end, I weaned her when she was used to having breast milk a lot.

I prepared her for stopping by saying that when she is three she needs to stop because it's just for babies and she's a big girl. We had a little party (made cupcakes together - yes they were decorated like boobs Blush) and she got a present to celebrate stopping. She picked a soft toy, so afterwards if she asked to feed I reminded her she was a big girl and that she got her toy and she would give that a cuddle.

I was also donating breast milk to the local milk bank and so I could remind her that the milk needed to go to the sick babies.

With DS, I weaned when he was 2. He was still feeding a few times in the day and a lot at night. My husband did bed times until he got used to it. I made sure that I wore tops that he couldn't pull up or down during the day and used distraction. I would give him a chocolate biscuit sometimes if he was really upset and I pointed out that babies can't eat chocolate biscuits but now he is a big boy he can eat nice things like that because he doesn't have breast milk. If I went to bed with him then I wore a sports bra so he couldn't access himself.

For me, I would wean after you have been away, as I would find it easier to get my little one to sleep with feeding. I think two weeks probably isn't long enough for him to get used to not having it. But, that might not be the right decision for you. What will you find easier?

I hope this helps.

P.s. my two don't seem traumatised at all. Good luck!

Twiglets1 · 05/01/2023 06:45

Newmama93 · 05/01/2023 06:38

Thank you - it has become horrendous!

he’s the one making me do this, I’ve been holding onto it for some
strange reason, but I think I need to do it now.

thanks again

It’s easy for mums to feel guilty about things like this, but your husband is right that enough is enough. You’ve breastfed for longer than many people could cope with so you don’t need to feel any guilt at all for wanting to reclaim your body now.
Your husband just needs to really help you & your son over the next 2/3 days & nights which may be difficult. Probably easier for him to get up to your son in the night and try to coax him back to sleep than you because your son will see you and immediately think Milk 😂

Newmama93 · 05/01/2023 06:38

Twiglets1 · 05/01/2023 06:35

God that sounds absolutely horrendous. I agree you need to wean him asap for the sake of your mental (& possibly physical) health.
Your husband should be supporting you a bit more with this I feel. It is very reasonable for you to insist that you can’t do this any longer and you and your husband need to come up with a plan together and stick to it. Let your husband take the brunt of it as you are the one who has been taking the brunt of it up until now. You must be exhausted.

Thank you - it has become horrendous!

he’s the one making me do this, I’ve been holding onto it for some
strange reason, but I think I need to do it now.

thanks again

OP posts:
Twiglets1 · 05/01/2023 06:35

God that sounds absolutely horrendous. I agree you need to wean him asap for the sake of your mental (& possibly physical) health.
Your husband should be supporting you a bit more with this I feel. It is very reasonable for you to insist that you can’t do this any longer and you and your husband need to come up with a plan together and stick to it. Let your husband take the brunt of it as you are the one who has been taking the brunt of it up until now. You must be exhausted.

Newmama93 · 05/01/2023 06:31

Talaforniababe · 05/01/2023 06:30

Of course it's fine to stop cold turkey. My mum did it with me for the exact recommended time - 6 months, and immediately stopped. I am a healthy strapping 41 year old and I don't think I'm traumatised by it.

The recommended time is now 2 years

OP posts:
Talaforniababe · 05/01/2023 06:31

And incidentally, my mum was a GP.

Talaforniababe · 05/01/2023 06:30

Of course it's fine to stop cold turkey. My mum did it with me for the exact recommended time - 6 months, and immediately stopped. I am a healthy strapping 41 year old and I don't think I'm traumatised by it.

Newmama93 · 05/01/2023 06:28

chocolateflapjacks · 05/01/2023 06:20

Agree

Why because my son feeds a lot?

you realise it takes 9 months for a baby to come? That’s if I get I can even ovulate again. Your mean girl comments are very obvious

OP posts:
chocolateflapjacks · 05/01/2023 06:20

dolor · 05/01/2023 04:30

Not sure you should be having another baby just yet.

Agree

CupOfAnxieTea · 05/01/2023 06:04

You can go cold turkey but just want to make you aware - this will cause a pretty severe shift in hormones for you and can leave you feeling very depressed. The hormonal shift is easier to manage if you wean slowly but I appreciate sometimes it is easier to go cold turkey. If you do choose to do this just make sure you try to get some self care in and look after yourself as it can make you feel very low. Good luck with it all :)

MissSmiley · 05/01/2023 06:04

@Newmama93 they understand so much more than you think, be firm he'll soon get the message.

Newmama93 · 05/01/2023 05:36

LaFemmeDamnee · 05/01/2023 05:32

I night weaned my toddler long before day weaning. It took 3 nights. First was horrendous, second a bit rough, 3rd ok. Go to bed wearing about 100 tops so it's difficult to give in.

Did you do it? So said no more night feeds? Yes maybe I have to be the one to do it if I’m going to keep the day one so I can go away with him and he not expect milk from me.

OP posts:
LaFemmeDamnee · 05/01/2023 05:32

I night weaned my toddler long before day weaning. It took 3 nights. First was horrendous, second a bit rough, 3rd ok. Go to bed wearing about 100 tops so it's difficult to give in.

Newmama93 · 05/01/2023 05:28

melcalfe · 05/01/2023 05:25

I "love" how your husband said you need a break and booked you a two night hotel - then gave baby to grandma for two days.

Dad of the year lol.

Hahaha I have to agree

OP posts:
melcalfe · 05/01/2023 05:25

Coolhand2 · 05/01/2023 04:47

On Friday my husband said, I booked for you 2 nights in a hotel, you are tired you need a break. I found it was a good chance for me to wean my 16mth old ds. I usually wean cold turkey. So I left her with my mother for the weekend, the first night was terrible, they didn't sleep but 2nd night was better. I came back and she tried to nurse, she cried a few times but I stuck with it. We are coming to a week now, i am glad we have stopped the breastfeeding journey. She is even sleeping longer, she used to wake up so many times during the night, I was not sleeping well too.
So I agree with your husband to do it cold turkey.

I "love" how your husband said you need a break and booked you a two night hotel - then gave baby to grandma for two days.

Dad of the year lol.

MogTheForgetableCat · 05/01/2023 05:21

Newmama93 · 05/01/2023 04:58

What do I do when I’m away with DS in two weeks without husband? He’ll be sleeping with me, I think I have to day wean as well so the milk isn’t on his mind at night and isn’t an option. I feel bad our last feed was a frustrated one and it’s ended like this.

thanks for all your tips! Feeling more confident

It'll be fine after the initial couple of days.

Not sure about day weaning, I day weaned first.

Aussiegirl123456 · 05/01/2023 05:00

Following for advice. My little girl turns 3 in a few days and still is addicted to breastfeeding. I was ready to stop at 6 months. It’s so hard. I’ve gradually cut back so it’s only nap time and getting to sleep at night that she has it now but I really want to stop. Even bribery doesn’t work. I resorted to trying to bribe her with a new bike if she stops and she said “oh don’t worry mummy Santa can bring me that instead and I’ll keep milk”! Funny but not! Doesn’t help that breastfeeding turns me into an actual nymph either, my poor husband is shattered haha!

Good luck OP.

Newmama93 · 05/01/2023 04:58

What do I do when I’m away with DS in two weeks without husband? He’ll be sleeping with me, I think I have to day wean as well so the milk isn’t on his mind at night and isn’t an option. I feel bad our last feed was a frustrated one and it’s ended like this.

thanks for all your tips! Feeling more confident

OP posts:
MogTheForgetableCat · 05/01/2023 04:55

Definitely get your husband to do it it's much easier that way.

MogTheForgetableCat · 05/01/2023 04:55

I night weaned cold turkey and DCs were fine after a bad first night or two.

If you're feeding a lot currently you might want to pump fit a couple of days though to ease off gradually and avoid mastitis.

21 months is amazing, well done for breastfeeding for that long!

Newmama93 · 05/01/2023 04:55

Interesting !!

I have tried telling him no more milk and it’s gone at night, but he cries and tantrums and at around 2 hours I give in from anger and exhaustion.

not sure now whether to try and do it and tough it out myself or let my husband

OP posts:
MissSmiley · 05/01/2023 04:51

With my eldest I just told him there would be no more milk at night, he was 15 months old but he understood, I said you can sit on my lap and cuddle or lay in bed but I'm not feeding you and he cried the first night, i stayed with him, I repeated it the second night and he knew I meant it so he just went to sleep.

agna8277 · 05/01/2023 04:49

Is he in the same room at night? Would you consider giving him water if he wakes and he can sleep once he have that drink but nothing else

Coolhand2 · 05/01/2023 04:47

On Friday my husband said, I booked for you 2 nights in a hotel, you are tired you need a break. I found it was a good chance for me to wean my 16mth old ds. I usually wean cold turkey. So I left her with my mother for the weekend, the first night was terrible, they didn't sleep but 2nd night was better. I came back and she tried to nurse, she cried a few times but I stuck with it. We are coming to a week now, i am glad we have stopped the breastfeeding journey. She is even sleeping longer, she used to wake up so many times during the night, I was not sleeping well too.
So I agree with your husband to do it cold turkey.

Newmama93 · 05/01/2023 04:40

NumberTheory · 05/01/2023 04:37

It sounds like a plan you have the capacity to put in place and that’s a big point in its favour.

Your DS will probably find it a bit of a shock, but if he’s with his dad and getting all he needs, he’ll adjust quickly enough and soon forget about it. then he’ll be able to benefit from a mother who isn’t beside herself with exhaustion, which will also be a huge benefit.

Thank you, I guess people have worried me when they’ve made comments like what a sad way to end 21 months of feeding and that it’s traumatic.. he’s done it before and was sleeping with my husband for months he’s only reverted back for the past 2 weeks.

appreciate the advice

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread