Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DS told us he knows what sex is

344 replies

BooseysMom · 05/01/2023 02:58

I never imagined this scenario. Please tell me if I'm being unreasonable. But also please be gentle. I was a child of the 70s and my mum & dad sat me down one day and told me the ins and outs of sex when I was about 13. It was a very uncomfortable experience tbh. But it seems that the job of telling DS (9) has already been done for us by no other than our neighbour's kid who's 10. Now please tell me if you think this is bad and should I go round and see his parents? Or would you just leave it? DH has told him about the birds and bees which is as far as the school have got. But i can't stop thinking that our DS's innocence has now gone completely thanks to the kid next door, who incidentally is a bit if a twat!
WWYD?

OP posts:
Bigshop · 05/01/2023 18:14

@OoooohMatron If he asked more questions then I’d tell him, but he isn’t interested in procreation…because he’s 9!

Stompythedinosaur · 05/01/2023 18:11

If you wanted your ds to hear about sex from an adult first you really should have had a conversation before they were 9!

The dc who talked about some factual information has not done anything wrong.

There's nothing wrong with DC knowing about sex.

Bigshop · 05/01/2023 18:00

@OoooohMatron he definitely doesn’t know the the full facts. He knows body parts and correct names, how the egg and sperm meet together and a baby grows in the women’s uterus, and how they’re born. He knows about periods and he knows you need/should be a grown up to have a baby.

I don’t really care if other people think my child should know certain things at a certain age. I know my child and I’ll decide what he needs to know and when. By the looks of MN, no child over the age of 5 is allowed to believe in Father Christmas either- my son still believes, that probably also makes me irresponsible and a bad parent too 🙄

So many people on this thread have made to OP out to be wrong, just for having reservations on discussing a sensitive subject. Some shocking examples of bad parenting on MN, and this isn’t one of them!

OoooohMatron · 05/01/2023 17:12

Oh and it's not other children's responsibility to keep a lid on their natural curiosity and desire to talk just because you want to 'protect' your precious darling from actual biological facts!

MasterBeth · 05/01/2023 17:11

I'm also a child of the 70s.

I can't remember when I didn't know the biological basics of sex because my parents, perfectly appropriately, explained to me at a very young age (3? 4?) through a book from the library.

One of the reasons they did this, I'm sure, was so I didn't hear second hand rumours about it in the playground from uninformed 9-year olds. YABU.

OoooohMatron · 05/01/2023 17:01

Bigshop · 05/01/2023 14:32

Despite what the majority are saying on here, not all 9 year olds know what sex is. Mine has only just started asking the odd question, but really isn’t that interested so I see no point in going into huge detail. When he asks more I will tell him.

I have a couple of books ready, but I do feel many of them go into too much detail despite being aimed at children.
I don’t think a 9 year old needs to know about how enjoyable sex is/ self pleasure or being sexually attracted others.
Why is everyone so desperate for young children to know so much detail.

If other parents are going to tell their children all the facts, then they should make sure their child is old enough and responsible enough to keep it to themselves.

Not sure what books you've bought 🤔 By 9/10 children should know how babies are made. No need to go into detail, just basic biological facts. Your son will 100% have heard things about sex at that age, probably from other 9 year olds who might be giving the wrong information so why would you not get in there first with the correct facts? If you had a daughter would you not tell her about periods, or would you rather it just took her by surprise one day?

Confusion101 · 05/01/2023 16:44

@Singleandproud you have explained the link between the two very well. But in no mind would I think "ah well my daughter knows about reproduction of plants so that's enough reproduction talk for now" 😂😂😂 I'm still laughing the "DH has told him about the birds and bees" actually meant birds and bees

Singleandproud · 05/01/2023 16:41

@GiltEdges Plant pollination and human reproduction are taught at similar times as they are similar topics and ar both processes leading to the continuation of species.

You identify the male and female structures of both flowers and humans and their function.
You learn how the male gamete gets to the female gamete so sperm/ egg and sex and pollen grain/ ovule and pollination.
You learn how the offspring develops whether that is a fertilised egg in to baby or ovule into seed and germination.

Often plant reproduction is taught before sexual reproduction to introduce the ideasand they should both be covered at Primary School and Keystage 3 in High School at different levels

Bigshop · 05/01/2023 16:23

@MiddleParking why so aggressive? It’s my choice as his parent to decide what he learns and when. I’m not stopping anyone else from teaching their kids about sex, I’d just ask that they didn’t share that information. Its nothing to do with being embarrassed , it’s just not relevant to us at this point in time.

And as for implying an increased risk of sexual abuse- what a ridiculous thing to say, no ones to blame for that except the abuser.

@Teafor1please you have children as young as 11 engaging in sexual activity? You almost make it sound like the norm and it’s acceptable..Something very wrong there.

SaintLoy · 05/01/2023 15:54

My idea of the flowers talk: When a mummy flower and a daddy flower love each other very much, they cuddle in a special way that makes them both very happy!

Teafor1please · 05/01/2023 15:49

I'm the head of year 7 in a large school. So that's age 11 on entry. There are children who have watched porn by the time they've started. There are some children engaging in sexual activity with one another and there are children who have had adults online or in person trying to sexually abuse them.
You can't just ignore the issue at age 9.

Testina · 05/01/2023 15:00

“DH has told him about the birds and bees”

If you have to resort to euphemistic crap like that even on an anonymous internet site, it’s a good job someone else stepped in and told your child.

Bigshop · 05/01/2023 14:56

@JustGotToKeepOnKeepingOn yes they do. my son knows about how private parts are private, and has done from an early age. And I’m not against telling kids if they are asking, but in an age appropriate way.
@GoldenCupidon maybe when they’re a little older perhaps but I can 100% say he doesn’t know.
I do have a very young 9 year old- no siblings, so maybe this is why he doesn’t seem as curious. But I have 3 other friends with same age kids who also don’t know about sex.

Hattie72 · 05/01/2023 14:56

This thread reminds me about the ones where parents are upset their sixteen year old was told by friends that Santa isn’t real and Christmas is forever ruined.

MiddleParking · 05/01/2023 14:51

If other parents are going to tell their children all the facts, then they should make sure their child is old enough and responsible enough to keep it to themselves.

It’s your position that’s irresponsible, not theirs. Who on Earth would read so many pages of people telling OP so and then decide to say ‘nah, I’d prefer my kid to be at elevated risk of embarrassment among their peers at best and sexual abuse at worst and I want other people to instruct their kids to support me in that thanks’?

JustGotToKeepOnKeepingOn · 05/01/2023 14:40

Children will talk... you can't stop that. But what you can stop is your child mixing misinformation with fact.

GoldenCupidon · 05/01/2023 14:39

There’s often a touching belief on MN that children tell their parents everything they’ve heard. In that case my mum probably still thinks I don’t know what sex is.

JustGotToKeepOnKeepingOn · 05/01/2023 14:39

Children need to know the facts from a safeguarding perspective.

My DD wasn't very inquisitive and asked very few questions. I had to push the conversation along. She was very grateful and said she didn't want to find out the facts of life in the playground - she wanted to talk to me in a safe environment, where she knew she'd get the truth.

Bigshop · 05/01/2023 14:32

Despite what the majority are saying on here, not all 9 year olds know what sex is. Mine has only just started asking the odd question, but really isn’t that interested so I see no point in going into huge detail. When he asks more I will tell him.

I have a couple of books ready, but I do feel many of them go into too much detail despite being aimed at children.
I don’t think a 9 year old needs to know about how enjoyable sex is/ self pleasure or being sexually attracted others.
Why is everyone so desperate for young children to know so much detail.

If other parents are going to tell their children all the facts, then they should make sure their child is old enough and responsible enough to keep it to themselves.

londonrach · 05/01/2023 14:26

I have a six year and will be answered any questions in an age appropriate way. We have had a few questions. Tbh any child bought up on a farm know was a very early age. I remember learning at school aged 10. Not a issue. Aged 13 is vv late especially if you start periods before then. I'm a child of the 80s school.

GoldenCupidon · 05/01/2023 14:24

You've got off lightly, I was told at 7 and honestly it sounded pretty gruesome. Thankfully I found a book that had all the right stuff in it - an Usborne book that wasn't for girls or boys but for anyone, and had good info on periods, puberty and the basics of sex.

As you say this was a taboo subject for you growing up so I expect there's some inherited concern that this is a bigger deal than it is. But as PP have said, kids around him will be going through puberty and it's actually not far on him or them to leave him in the dark.

And importantly, you can't put this genie back in the bottle, so once you've vented your ire on the people next door think about making sure he's properly and appropriately informed about the basics.

chillibop · 05/01/2023 14:16

It's a bit Hmm that you're so emotionally invested in this 9 year old boy who you 'hate' and thinks of as a 'twat.'
What if your son asked him?

Maybe stop your child from hanging around with him then. And also have a frank discussion about sex and reproduction with your son. It's your responsibility.
Just because the school follow a strict curriculum it doesn't mean you need to.

Please don't go and speak to the boys mum. Unless it's incest / porn he's done you a favour as frankly a talk about plants and pollen quite obviously hasn't done what it needed to do.

Don't teach your son that it's secrecy and can't be spoken about between family and friends. Do you not see how unsafe that could be?

It really isn't a big deal. At all.

You need to teach your son about puberty, sex, consent and sexual assault, to know that 'no means no' etc and 9 is in my eyes a little later than norm. Along with most posters on here.

It's sex. A very natural everyday thing. Just because you're teaching him about it, it doesn't mean he's going to do anything with the information. Being informed about sex and everything else that goes with it is key. The younger the better. You'd look stupid to bring it up to the mother. If I was the boys mum I would think you're a bit bonkers / sheltered if you think no one's going to talk about it.

Namechangehereandnow · 05/01/2023 14:14

Your poor ds is probably very confused right now … you don’t make much sense really.

  1. Your OP does make it sound like your son is always in next doors house - yet you say it’s the other way around.
  2. Your dh has given the birds and bees talk - which is actually the phrase used by millions to mean the sex education talk - yet you say dh actually talked about flowers.
  3. You think 9 is too young, you were taught at 13 - some children get pregnant at 12/13! 9 is not too young.
  4. You say the child next door did your job for you - well actually no he didn’t, he just talked to his friend about what he’d learned.

So overall, your son asked you about sex, you told him about birds and flowers = very confused boy. 🤷‍♀️

whumpthereitis · 05/01/2023 14:08

BooseysMom · 05/01/2023 13:32

Plants last terms; human reproduction before the end of summer term. You have time to chat to your DS before school does it for you. Good luck.

Thank you. So it was as I thought, the kid next door is a year above DS and so decides he would do our job for us.

Yes I have been very naive but I've not done this before. Nothing has been mentioned in the school curriculum newsletter, although they have covered the human body, they haven't done reproduction apart from in plants.

I have definitely dodged a bullet by not going round to see the parents! Thank you for your honest advice.

The kid next door was doing what kids have been doing for time immemorial.

the fact that he ‘got in first’ (like he was even aware he was in a race with you) is entirely your fault for failing to educate your son earlier.

TheChippendenSpook · 05/01/2023 13:59

GiltEdges · 05/01/2023 08:47

I mean, it’s sort of missing the point, but what does pollination have to do with sex education in school?! They’re completely different subjects, it’s not as if one naturally leads on to the other. Whilst as an adult I can appreciate the link, it’s going to go above the head of an average school child. They should be learning both.

It's how they were taught in Grease 2 Grin

Swipe left for the next trending thread