Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Family Business Issue

53 replies

ncpostingabout · 04/01/2023 22:04

Part of a family business and my sister who has been involved for not that long has become very successful within it and now wants to set up her own business to make more money.

AIBU to feel a bit sad about this?

Of course from a business perspective we out many hours and time into training her etc and just feel it's a bit premature really.

Also just feel a bit sad by it and unexpected.

NC as of course want to remain anonymous

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ncpostingabout · 05/01/2023 00:04

@Testina thank you I see your point! Very helpful advice

OP posts:
Testina · 05/01/2023 00:00

ncpostingabout · 04/01/2023 23:49

@Testina lol thank you - when you say it cold enough good for business do you mean if she tried it and it didn't work out? And came back? You think it might set a good precedence is that what you mean?

I think it’s a bad precedence if she comes back thinks she can do that over and over again!

But if she gives it a go (say it’s website design) and she sharpens her practical skills and builds up a client base but then realises she hates chasing invoices, doing tax returns, deciding how to advertise, dealing with her admin staff’s constant sickness… well, then she might be a nice increase to your business by bringing her clients and skills back in.

I’m not saying offer her the soft landing that your door is always open for a job to return to… but I wouldn’t do the opposite and warn her that if she goes, she goes. Keep it unsaid so that you can decide in your favour.

Of course, she may go from strength to strength. In which case, also good not to cut off ever working together! You might want to collaborate.

ncpostingabout · 04/01/2023 23:53

@Testina 😂 it really is so so difficult to run a business. Obviously it's possible there are many many business owners out there that manage it much more successfully than I do but fuck me IMO that people who don't run a business struggle to understand. The level of responsibility stress constant BS from staff I sometimes wouldn't wish it on my worst enemy.

OP posts:
ncpostingabout · 04/01/2023 23:49

@Testina lol thank you - when you say it cold enough good for business do you mean if she tried it and it didn't work out? And came back? You think it might set a good precedence is that what you mean?

OP posts:
Testina · 04/01/2023 23:49

“It's a shit show at the minute - running business is so hard to have time to do all these things”

As she will find out 😆
My husband has his own business and has a 50/50 partner. She only does “the job” whilst he runs it - with time away from clients carved out to do so - “office morning”. There’s no resentment - works well, they’re happy, it’s a low paid industry so there’s no reason to feel he’s carrying her for the same money. But the business would last 3 months if she was running it 😉

Testina · 04/01/2023 23:46

@ncpostingabout I’d certainly be stomping round my house muttering that she was an ungrateful bloody cow! 😉

It’s hard to suggest how to handle it without knowing the business - and I’m not trying to draw you out on that!

I’m not sure that franchising is the way to go. If her primary driver is to retain all earned money for herself, or to completely be her own boss, then you’re likely to invest more time into mentoring her and then she’ll just do the off further down the line. Same feelings, more time invested - and from a business point of view, perhaps a much bigger network / client base from the brand you built.

I don’t necessarily agree with telling you’d never have her back. If she’s good at the job, why not? Not if she’s going to yo-yo multiple times, but if in 2 years she called you and said, “sis - love the job, hate the business admin!” then she could be an even more skilled employee bringing her client base back in with her. I think you could let her go with your blessing, and say if there’s a space for her she can come back. I mean - lucky her to have such an opportunity and potential safety net, and I’d be jealous that I did it the hard way. But -could be good for your business.

But I do totally agree that she can’t develop her business on your time.

ncpostingabout · 04/01/2023 23:38

@Princessglittery thank you. I do think all of our contracts need fully reviewing absolutely. It's a shit show at the minute - running business is so hard to have time to do all these things. They already have non competition clause in them but don't have anything about training costs

OP posts:
ncpostingabout · 04/01/2023 23:36

@DomesticShortHair 😂 thank you for your posts

OP posts:
ncpostingabout · 04/01/2023 23:36

@Testina I think you've summed it up nicely! It probably partly is ego driven but I almost feel bad not slowing her to go solo on my time too and told her just as much so it's reassured me that so many posters have said this isn't acceptable too as almost felt guilty for drawing the line with this

OP posts:
ncpostingabout · 04/01/2023 23:34

@Quitelikeacatslife it is difficult because there is a lot of people involved in the business so it becomes difficult to pay someone more although I agree there is something to be said for a different type of role within the business

OP posts:
Princessglittery · 04/01/2023 23:18

@ncpostingabout you have my sympathy as it’s not a nice thing to do.

I’m going to suggest 2 things, the first is to formally set out the terms of your sister leaving the business and setting up on her own. Make it clear in writing she will get no assistance, if relevant she can’t use your businesses equipment etc. that she will not be offered a job if her business fails etc.

The second is to review your contracts for all employees. If it costs £ to train new employees it may be reasonable to require them to stay for 12 months after being fully trained to recoup your investment. Remember your time spent training is a cost.

For both get legal advice.

I would also sit down with your sister and state you are disappointed but understand. However, she needs to understand you will not provide coaching and advice if she leaves and that she has to stand on her own two feet. No coming crying to you if she can’t manage all the hidden aspects of running her own business. That you want to keep the family relationship so you must both agree no business talk at family meetings.

Theunamedcat · 04/01/2023 23:18

Seriously enforce the on competition clause in your contract stop letting people take the piss

DomesticShortHair · 04/01/2023 23:16

ncpostingabout · 04/01/2023 23:12

@DomesticShortHair yes that sounds like a very good suggestion, completely agree I think we need to work out a franchise situation

Right then, my work here is done. Just need to change my username to John Harvey-Jones, and then I’m off into the sunset. 😂

I hope however it woks out for you, that it works out for you.

Testina · 04/01/2023 23:15

ncpostingabout · 04/01/2023 23:04

@Newusernameaug technically it would be competing but I also feel like there's enough business out there so isn't really my main concern - it's just the lack of conversation and offering to perhaps consider doing something jointly so they get the coaching and mentoring long term as I have many years experience of the sector so as another poster mentioned it's just the shortsighted way she gone about it it find a bit sad

Honestly, that does sound like your ego has taken a hit! Like - why doesn’t she appreciate all my mentoring and experience?!!

I do think you have valid complaint too, as you’ve now posted that she’s taking the piss trying to go solo on your time. Nope.

But just that one post sounds like ego rather than business.

Quitelikeacatslife · 04/01/2023 23:13

If she's really good and successful and you want her to stay then offer her more money or a subsidiary that still makes you a share of the money

ncpostingabout · 04/01/2023 23:12

@DomesticShortHair yes that sounds like a very good suggestion, completely agree I think we need to work out a franchise situation

OP posts:
Testina · 04/01/2023 23:11

“it's the fact she wants to leave but not leave and set it up while working here”

Yeah, unless that’s something that can work in your favour - she’s taking the piss!

ncpostingabout · 04/01/2023 23:11

@CrapBucket it's not estate agency but I see what you mean yes because trying to do two enterprises at once is just not right IMO and I don't think I should ignore that just because she's my sister? As business everyone has to take the risk and as much as I want to support why should I do it at the detriment of myself and make it risk free for her? It's not fair or AIBU?

OP posts:
DomesticShortHair · 04/01/2023 23:10

ncpostingabout · 04/01/2023 22:55

@DomesticShortHair correct which was part of the reason very carefully considered offering her the job in the first place as I knew it was inevitable at some point there would be an issue because pretty much every member of staff creates an issue at some point but of course when it's not a family member it makes it much easier from an emotional perspective to deal with and I guess I knew this would happen but I was being selfless in wanting to create an opportunity for her and I still do but it just feels like a very complicated situation

You’re right, it’s definitely more complicated. But you are where you are.

Is there anyway you can try to turn this into an opportunity, which might get you off the hook from having a messy situation to deal with? How about offering her a franchise of the business, with your blessing and support (even if it’s not heartfelt).

She can do her own thing and run her own business, which is what she obviously craves. The business might benefit indirectly by not having all the investment wasted- she’d still be making a contribution to it. And it might help expand your business if successful. Plus, it would keep the family relationship intact.

Just trying to think of things that you could do that might work, or limit the damage.

Testina · 04/01/2023 23:10

You say she’s become very successful in it though, so you’ve possibly had your investment back already. This is business, you train employees, but you don’t have a guaranteed payback time. So you can put clauses in contracts if you are spending hard cash on training for repayment, or if it’s time - pay less during training.

Imagine your sister was working for someone else and really hit her stride at this and said - “you know what sis? I’m seriously thinking of going it alone!”
As a business owner yourself, you’d probably be proud of her!

Like I said above, for me it comes down to whether she’s been underhand. If you run a hand car wash and she’s setting up on the other side of the road having used her inside info to offer your large taxi contract 2% cheaper - she’s horrid!

But there are plenty of scenarios where she wouldn’t be.

Maybe in 5 years time her business will have taken a complimentary direction and you’ll decide to join to again in a business that’s now equipped to knock out the competition!

CrapBucket · 04/01/2023 23:09

I'm imagining this as an estate agents. So your sister has tried it out, likes it, learnt how to do it... and now wants to set up on her own but by using your company to ease the transition.

I would tell her, this often happens, and how it works in this industry is that you leave, start up a new database of your own, there is no way of doing it for two enterprises at once, thats not how life in estate agency works. Good luck.

ncpostingabout · 04/01/2023 23:05

@Stompythedinosaur there are non competition clauses on the contracts but aside from this I would never stop anyone moving on from their career at all but it's the fact she wants to leave but not leave and set it up while working here

OP posts:
aureus3012 · 04/01/2023 23:05

I would block her access to your customer contacts immediately. Hopefully your customers will be loyal. I think it is an absolutely disgraceful way to treat your family. She should be ashamed of herself.

ncpostingabout · 04/01/2023 23:04

@Newusernameaug technically it would be competing but I also feel like there's enough business out there so isn't really my main concern - it's just the lack of conversation and offering to perhaps consider doing something jointly so they get the coaching and mentoring long term as I have many years experience of the sector so as another poster mentioned it's just the shortsighted way she gone about it it find a bit sad

OP posts:
ncpostingabout · 04/01/2023 23:03

Sorry if I'm being misleading, she doesn't have any shares in the business and yes is an employee - I can't give details I'm sorry but please understand she know nothing about anything before starting and the training and mentoring has been thousands of pounds invested - understand when running a business an initial investment is made while that person trains so when people jump ship after not that long in the role the investment is short lived - hence what I mean it's premature.

OP posts: