Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it wrong for a 3 year old to carry a cuddly toy 24/7

111 replies

Curiosity101 · 04/01/2023 18:37

I was discussing this with someone earlier and they were concerned my 3 year old (3y4m if it makes a difference) was wanting to carrying a cuddly toy with him 24/7. They were worried it was an issue as it means he's doing everything 1 handed ie. Eating one handed, drawing one handed etc. They also said he's too old for it now, and he shouldn't need to take it everywhere with him.

I figured we can very easily take the toy from him or get him to set it down to one side whilst doing an activity. But I can't actually see why it's an issue. If he needs 2 hands he uses 2 hands, if he can make do with one then he'd rather hold his cuddly in the other hand/arm.

He forms really strong attachments to things in general. For example his favourite bag of marbles that goes everywhere with him (that he also sleeps with).

I'm going to do a bit of research and chat further with the person. Because I'd like us to figure something out that works for everyone. But until today I'd not considered it was in any way abnormal or a problem.

If you think IABU and you'd be willing to elaborate I'm really curious.

OP posts:
Afterdinnerchocs · 04/01/2023 21:06

My youngest child was obsessed with Fred from big hero 6, with his spikey superhero suit on. Nursery let him take it in and would sit it on a shelf so it was there but safe, he now just uses it in the bath. Most children have a favourite toy, I don't think its anything to worry about.

Afterdinnerchocs · 04/01/2023 21:01

My 11 yr old still sleeps with the blanket I knitted him when he was a baby, I've offered to add more to it so it becomes a proper blanket but he said he prefers it how it is.
My 23 yr old still has his winnie the pooh teddy from when he was a baby and the cheap spare that his granma got him so we could wash his teddy during the night. He will grow out of it eventually, his still so young. Let him have something to cuddle but maybe try to keep it at home or in the car so it's not an issue for the cm to worry about.

BellePeppa · 04/01/2023 21:01

AlwaysGinPlease · 04/01/2023 20:29

Rude to ignore it when posts mention it and that's ridiculous. Why you would even risk it is beyond me.

It’s unbelievably arrogant and foolhardy of the OP to think her son is safe unsupervised with a bag of marbles yet worries if he’s too attached to soft toys. 🙄

AnyFucker · 04/01/2023 21:01

Can people stop going on about the bloody marbles?

No

Curiosity101 · 04/01/2023 20:59

OnceRuralNowUrbanbliss · 04/01/2023 20:44

My twenty year old (tattoos, smokes and goes clubbing) lives in a hose share still sleeps with his Doggie and has him (or what's left of him) draped round his neck whilst gaming.

His twin sister is the same with her Bunny. We got back ups as they were so attached. Bunny got lost a few times (airports and accidentally sold under a toy pram in a charity shop)
These are the things you should mitigate against everything else about you attachment is fine and very sweet

That's incredibly sweet ☺️

OP posts:
GreenDanglyearrings · 04/01/2023 20:58

One of my children was obsessed (the others weren't bothered at all). She spend her early years with a bar of soap in one hand and a small Thomas the tank engine in the other. I thought it was incredibly odd but since I was busy with the other children, I chose my battles and just let her get on with it.

The bar of soap would wear down and she had a little stack of them to use as replacements.

She is an intelligent, sociable and lovely teenager now. She stopped at about 3 1/2. We do like to remind her about the soap though! She remembers that she liked the smell

Curiosity101 · 04/01/2023 20:57

@PeekAtYou the attachment thing is a weird one. He will hyper fixate on a particular cuddly, then something happens and seemingly overnight he switches. But up until then he's utterly obsessed with that particular toy.

They aren't allowed in the bathroom with him at home, they have to wait outside 🤢. So yes, no issue with hand washing. When we're at the park they sit on the pushchair depending on what he's doing.

I reckon he might just be struggling a bit with the transition back to the CM after being home with us over Christmas... This is only his second day back and she's not raised the issue previously. We'll figure it out though, it's particularly about him being too old to need a cuddly that threw me. Cause I assumed it was normal.

OP posts:
Daisybuttercup12345 · 04/01/2023 20:57

Marbles. NO!!!
Soft toy fine.

thirdtimeluckyorwhat · 04/01/2023 20:56

Curiosity101 · 04/01/2023 19:05

He does go to nursery/preschool but we'd already told him he couldn't take his cuddlies to nursery for many of the reasons listed above. He only attends nursery for 5 half days a week. The rest of his time he's with his childminder who he has been with full time from being 12 months old.

She's the one who's concerned about the cuddly situation and feels he's too old and that he should be using two hands for everything. I'll have to chat her with her properly as this was quite a quick (5-10mins) at pick up.

We'll have to figure something out that suits everyone. Worst case scenario, cuddly of the day will need to just stay in the car at drop off if it's a problem.

Maybe keep the cuddly in his bag at the childminders so he knows it's there but his not holding it all the time. I would listen to the childminder she must know what's she's doing to be honest and he should be using two hands.

hiredandsqueak · 04/01/2023 20:55

Dgs is very attached to his kitty and likes to carry it round. Dd generally tells him put kitty over there so that it doesn't get food/paint etc on him which seems to work.
I have a son and daughter with autism, ds used to carry till receipts around with him which wasn't so much a problem as he'd readily drop them but dd used to carry a spoon or a toothbrush and wouldn't let go for love nor money which limited her participation in other activities.

thirdtimeluckyorwhat · 04/01/2023 20:53

I think the things should be kept at home and not taken out and about unless needed for a nap. They won't let him cart it around at preschool or school.

jamimmi · 04/01/2023 20:50

Ummm is now the time to admit I have a 15 yr old who still wonders round the house with her stuffed toy ..? She's left handed but.i don't think that's the reason. No other issues though

MysteryBelle · 04/01/2023 20:47

OnceRuralNowUrbanbliss · 04/01/2023 20:44

My twenty year old (tattoos, smokes and goes clubbing) lives in a hose share still sleeps with his Doggie and has him (or what's left of him) draped round his neck whilst gaming.

His twin sister is the same with her Bunny. We got back ups as they were so attached. Bunny got lost a few times (airports and accidentally sold under a toy pram in a charity shop)
These are the things you should mitigate against everything else about you attachment is fine and very sweet

Love this!

reallyhatewinter · 04/01/2023 20:46

I think having a soft toy with him all the time is fine at that age when with you. He'll grow out of it eventually.
That said, I think the nursery and childminder are completely different. My CM never let any soft toys or any toys at her house. Not only in case they lost it, but if she'd allow it for one child, then all the others want to do it. Then you end up with certain children taking inappropriate toys (a 3 yr taking a car perhaps whilst there is a crawling baby who puts everything in their mouth) and it gets stressful for CM. Easier to say no toys/teddies at all.

PeekAtYou · 04/01/2023 20:46

The marbles are a worrying issue. One day ds will be able to open the bag or he'll do what mine would have gone and try to get it open by other means like hunting for scissors or something.

I think that not having a cuddly at the CM is a good idea so that it's not lost and she's not having to be hyper vigilant about keeping it clean.

It sounds like your son isn't over attached as you say that if he lost it then you'd be able to deal with it. I don't think that anyone can answer the question about the effect on development because we don't know your son. Would he still do a 2 handed activity like climb or would he hesitate because he's got the cuddly? If he leaves the toy, climbs and returns to the toy then I wouldn't worry. Presumably he still washes both hands after he goes to the loo ?

Angelicat · 04/01/2023 20:46

Herejustforthisone · 04/01/2023 20:43

My toddler takes loads of Lego (not Duplo) to bed. He’s yet to try to randomly eat them.

Just because that may be true doesn’t make it a safe thing for him to do. Common sense says you don’t give a three year old choking hazards unsupervised , especially not at the time they’re the least supervised it’s possible to be. Weird to make giving your kids unsafe stuff to sleep with a kind of badge of honour….

OnceRuralNowUrbanbliss · 04/01/2023 20:44

My twenty year old (tattoos, smokes and goes clubbing) lives in a hose share still sleeps with his Doggie and has him (or what's left of him) draped round his neck whilst gaming.

His twin sister is the same with her Bunny. We got back ups as they were so attached. Bunny got lost a few times (airports and accidentally sold under a toy pram in a charity shop)
These are the things you should mitigate against everything else about you attachment is fine and very sweet

verytired42 · 04/01/2023 20:44

a favoured soft toy is a transitional object (helps them cope with separation from you) and as such is 1.) healthy and 2.) should not be taken away. It would be cruel to do so. Ignore childminder who doesn’t seem to understand attachment and coping with separation properly.

ClubhouseGift · 04/01/2023 20:43

Herejustforthisone · 04/01/2023 20:43

My toddler takes loads of Lego (not Duplo) to bed. He’s yet to try to randomly eat them.

Why would you take that risk?

Herejustforthisone · 04/01/2023 20:43

My toddler takes loads of Lego (not Duplo) to bed. He’s yet to try to randomly eat them.

Herejustforthisone · 04/01/2023 20:40

Can people stop going on about the bloody marbles?

Newuser82 · 04/01/2023 20:40

My son was like this too until the age of about 6. He grew out of it. No problem. Marbles I may reconsider though.

trampoline123 · 04/01/2023 20:39

Curiosity101 · 04/01/2023 20:15

I'm ignoring the marble issue because I think what people are imagining is very different to the reality.

I can assure everyone he is no more at risk of accidentally swallowing a marble whilst in bed than he is when he's playing with them. The bag is sealed - he can't get them out without adult help and supervision.

Until one day when he can...

Whinge · 04/01/2023 20:39

Only mothers who have sensitive kids will understand that - sometimes all the world depends on one or two toys.

So if the child wanted to carry around a knife or scissors that would be fine?

OPs DS has shown he's flexible with the soft toys and changes favourites quite frequently, so i'm sure he would be happy with something else in a small bag. Safety comes first and I really don't want the OP to wake up one morning to a dead child.

Angelicat · 04/01/2023 20:39

Of course some kids are more sensitive than others, and attachments to a toy can be very very strong - but that doesn’t override a very clear safety reason to not allow a child to have a particular toy.