Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel disappointed in my manager telling me I’m not supporting women??

131 replies

UniCred1 · 04/01/2023 18:23

Okay please bear with me. I come from an Arab country. I watched women being treated like second class citizens since my childhood and promised myself that I’m never gonna let that happen to me. I supported women in my area as a volunteer since I was 14 years old. I’m always vocal when I see male relatives making misogynistic jokes and a lot of them stopped saying anything like that in front of me. I kind of gained a reputation of being “strange” “not feminine enough” within the family but I honestly don’t care.

When I got married, I informed my husband that I don’t want a traditional marriage like back home. That he will be expected to work just as much as I do in the house. That I won’t be a maid and won’t be the official chef of the household. That my opinions won’t change overnight and I’m quiet stubborn. He didn’t have any issue with that and tbh he has been always kind even when I was quiet mean and provocative at the beginning of our marriage. He supported me during my Uni years and was an amazing husband throughout. Now where’s the problem?

A few years ago I realised that I want to be a SAHM even before I gave birth. I had a terrible morning sickness so I left my job and was the happiest woman ever. I spent my pregnancy doing lots of leisure activities and travelled with my husband. He expanded his business and started working long hours as a result. Financially we are comfortable and I don’t need to work however I went back to work because I wanted to. I’m very good at cooking and I enjoy it. My husband cooks occasionally but I’m the one who does most of it. I’m also a good cleaner despite it being the worst chore for me! Husband hates cleaning and he’s crap at it. I decided that I will hire a cleaner every now and then if I’m tired, and I will continue to be the main cook of the house. What this means is that I’m back to the traditional model that I promised myself that I won’t become!! However I’m okay with it!

It doesn’t bother me at all. I don’t contribute financially to the household at all and I spend most of my salary left and right however I want it. I save a lot as well and my husband thinks that every family works differently and that this is what works for us. We’re all happy this way. He’s the provider and he’s expected to pay for everything and support me if I decided to leave work again. I run the household and I became so much better at managing my time and efforts so that I’m not exhausted at the end of each day.

This morning my manager was telling me that women who leave work during pregnancy are holding other women back by acting like it’s a disability. She said that they shouldn’t do that and shouldn’t accept that their OH do nothing around the house. I told her about my situation and she raised her eyebrows saying it’s a shame that there are women like me still allowing men to get away with not doing anything. And she thought the fact that I don’t contribute is weird and controlling! I felt a bit upset at the language she used and for the fact that she thought I’m definitely not a feminist nor do I support women’s independence!

AIBU?

OP posts:
UniCred1 · 04/01/2023 22:18

Isthisit22 · 04/01/2023 20:57

Basically he's doing a shit job to get out of doing it.
Just hire a cleaner if you don't want to address his lack of care/ misogyny.

Misogyny? Wow is that how you live your life usually? Throwing insults at people you don’t know?
I wouldn’t get married to a misogynist if he was the king of the universe. Not once he spoke about women disrespectfully throughout 17 years of being together and 15 years of marriage.

OP posts:
BadSkiingMum · 04/01/2023 22:02

This thread is intriguing because you have been given quite a hard time yet remain quite comfortable, even ebullient. You come across as happy, which is good to see.

What may be irritating others (perhaps even your boss?) is that you don't acknowledge that some of the happiness you experience in your current position is down to good fortune and/or potentially may alter in time. It is at that point that you may see the true nature of your current position.

Judging by the timelines given in your post you are in your mid-to-late twenties. Although marrying young, you had the opportunity to complete your education before becoming pregnant, which many women in traditional societies are not able to do. You are young, lively and probably attractive. Your husband is supportive of your views, because he is in love with you - which of course he is, so early on in a marriage. His love for you reciprocates your love for him. He is hardworking, ambitious and full of energy, so you are happy to care for him. Your job is enjoyable and you seem to have pleasant family around you. Everything is in balance and I hope for your sake that it continues.

But it would be wise to take a look around and reflect on how life looks for women who live in a traditional style but who are not so fortunate; women who have outlived their husband's love, who have a husband who does not treat them kindly, or who outright disrespects them via infidelity, boorish behaviour or abuse. Love fades and life happens - as many women on Mumsnet are only too aware.

If you have time, money or energy to spare, Southall Black Sisters, https://ikwro.org.uk/ or https://www.al-hasaniya.org.uk/about charities might be of interest.

Glitteratitar · 04/01/2023 21:51

Your manager was an arse. You did and said nothing wrong.

I come from an Arab background myself but married a white guy. I had similar thoughts as you and was adamant things would be 50/50. My situation is also similar in that we both earn well but my salary is for me as DH’s is enough to support the household (I want my career so went back to work). In reality, the split is more 70/30. I think despite wanting to change things and being adamant we won’t fall into the traditional roles, as that is what we grew up with, it is somewhat ingrained and we end up fulfilling those roles. It’s harder to change than we realise and we may think it’s our choice, but in reality, we are perpetuating those gender stereotypes as it has been instilled in us our entire lives.

amispeakingintongues · 04/01/2023 21:49

Testina · 04/01/2023 21:10

You sound quite naïve to be honest, and I’m guessing mid to late 20s. Coming back when you’ve had another 10 years of cleaning up after him and see how 🥰 you feel then.

Or just read AIBU for a couple of weeks for a glimpse into that future self 😉

You sound incredibly bitter it's borderline embarrassing now. Leave the OP to her happy marriage 🥰

Peacelily38 · 04/01/2023 21:37

UniCred1 · 04/01/2023 21:27

That’s very unfortunate! I’m surprised that people select which choices women make are feminists and which ones aren’t. I’ve explained that I’m happy with the setting I used to criticise in the past. It works for me and my family. No argument no grudges both sides are happy.

Exactly the boxes are nonsense.

You do what makes you and your family happy that's the most important thing.

ScreamingBeans · 04/01/2023 21:35

I'd be disappointed in my manager saying that because it's bloody unprofessional, particularly the bit about your colleague going off early. Some women need to stop working early because of their pregnancies and demanding that pregnant women behave as though they are not pregnant, is not an exemplary feminist position.

As for you, sounds like you've got an ideal set up for you.

FOTTFSOFTFOASM · 04/01/2023 21:34

A man who works 70 hours a week is a shit husband and father

That's bollocks, too.

My dad worked those kinds of hours and he was, and is, an excellent husband and the best dad anyone could ever want.

UniCred1 · 04/01/2023 21:33

Isthisit22 · 04/01/2023 20:55

Why do you both work so much if you don't need the money?
Tbh it is not fair or feminist for you to work full time and still do all cleaning etc. You should either hire a cleaner or share chores more fairly. It is not your fault he chooses to work such long hours.

I work 30 hours a week because I love my job. I was a SAHM before but I chose to go back to work. I might become a SAHM again and that’s fine too. He works long hours because we’re planning to retire early and relocate somewhere else. We want to make sure that the kids are able to pay Uni fees and have a deposit for a house when they grow up.

OP posts:
Chickenly · 04/01/2023 21:31

UniCred1 · 04/01/2023 21:23

I’m so sorry that happened you during pregnancy. It must have been very difficult and draining. Hope you’re doing well now 💗

Thank you - it was awful but (as the cliche) worth it. I still have serious pain in my teeth and gums, I’m still anaemic, my hair still has large bald patches and I still can’t cope with foods that are too spicy/salty/sour on my tongue. I’m still trying to build muscles back up. But I’m improving - and I’m ok. I just wish more people understood how awful pregnancy can be for some people and had a bit more understanding.

amispeakingintongues · 04/01/2023 21:31

OP ignore her stupidly offensive and obviously jealous attitude. People like her love to call themselves feminists when in actual fact they just want women to behave like men. It's so ironic that it's utterly ridiculous.

She has no right to judge anyone and I expect she's a miserable person. Has she ever been on mat leave herself? I'd suspect not.

I too was the happiest woman in the world while a SAHM. And my aim in life is to afford to be one again by the time i have my second.

FOTTFSOFTFOASM · 04/01/2023 21:31

No one is actually crap at cleaning though are they

I am, by many people's standards. Clean loos, basins and kitchen sinks are necessary, but not much else. There are people on MN who clean their skirting boards and "mop" regularly. I have no idea what they're mopping.

UniCred1 · 04/01/2023 21:28

Testina · 04/01/2023 20:54

“had a friend who used to do everything at home because his wife was lazy.”

Gosh, isn’t it useful that you’ve got an opposite example for that, as well as for the role reversal sibling / in law 🤣

Do you not have friends with opposing characters, personalities, hobbies, preferences?

OP posts:
Peacelily38 · 04/01/2023 21:27

RoseslnTheHospital · 04/01/2023 21:18

@Peacelily38 nothing you've said in response to my last post is contained in what I wrote. I disagree entirely with your interpretation of what I said. However, I feel like continuing to respond on this is derailing the OPs thread so I'm not going to respond in detail here.

That's your perception but you needn't reply I didn't ask you any questions.
Just like I didn't before you tagged by original post.
Have a good night.

UniCred1 · 04/01/2023 21:27

Peacelily38 · 04/01/2023 20:41

This is why I don't subscribe to feminism because it's often on a purity spiral and there are certain boxes you have to fit into or you are ousted.
It isn't actually kind or good to women and doesn't value motherhood.
Saying things like you let yourself down is absolute nonsense and downright nasty.
I support women's rights but I don't subscribe to the crap like putting down a woman for living her life how her and her family is happy to live it.

That’s very unfortunate! I’m surprised that people select which choices women make are feminists and which ones aren’t. I’ve explained that I’m happy with the setting I used to criticise in the past. It works for me and my family. No argument no grudges both sides are happy.

OP posts:
LaughingCat · 04/01/2023 21:25

MarshaMelrose · 04/01/2023 21:22

You live your life how it makes you happy. It's no one else's business. I'm one of those lazy arse, useless housekeepers. My husband is much better at it than me. Who knows on a MN scoresheet if that makes me more or less a feminist?! And, honestly, who cares?

This made me snort 😂. I once put up a moany post on a facebook group of smut authors that I used to cowrite with, asking for tips on how I could get my OH to do more around the house. Over half said they couldn’t help because they were the ones that were shit at it but if I found the solution, to tell their husbands 😂

UniCred1 · 04/01/2023 21:23

Chickenly · 04/01/2023 20:35

I’d report her to HR (if you have one). That’s not an opinion she’s allowed to express in a workplace.

I had hyperemesis and I almost died. I was bed bound, hospital bound and required a wheelchair. All my hair fell out, I weighed less when I was induced than when I conceived, I lost some toenails and my teeth rotted at the back of my mouth - I couldn’t get the filling done because when they tried I bled too much. The skin came off my tongue, and off the inside of my nose from the stomach acid repeatedly burning away at it. My ketones were 4+ every single time they were tested (which was at least every other day). I didn’t take in anything that wasn’t through an IV. . I was incredibly close to having to have an abortion and I was even told my pregnancy wasn’t viable. Women with pregnancies like mine are unheard of because we hide away the entire time it’s happening and aren’t allowed to talk about it afterwards because it’s deemed to be offensive to our children and to those who can’t get pregnant.

She also has no right to comment on how you divide jobs within your marriage or any other aspect of your personal life - the fact she’s also making an indirect comment on your culture and upbringing just multiplies how outrageous this is.

YANBU. She’s a dick and incredibly ignorant.

I’m so sorry that happened you during pregnancy. It must have been very difficult and draining. Hope you’re doing well now 💗

OP posts:
MarshaMelrose · 04/01/2023 21:22

UniCred1 · 04/01/2023 21:14

Thank you 💗

You live your life how it makes you happy. It's no one else's business. I'm one of those lazy arse, useless housekeepers. My husband is much better at it than me. Who knows on a MN scoresheet if that makes me more or less a feminist?! And, honestly, who cares?

Schoolchoicesucks · 04/01/2023 21:22

Maybe you could sign your husband up for 4 years in the army? He'd learn how to clean. Maybe he'd have more quality time at home when on leave than with his current gruelling 70 hour 7 day week role?

UniCred1 · 04/01/2023 21:20

StrawberryAnnie · 04/01/2023 20:31

Everyone gets tired and hungry, men and women. If you are home earlier in the evening, it makes sense for you to cook.

Does that mean that for the rest of the week only you should be responsible for the upkeep of the house and cleaning?

You say you have taken on this role to avoid conflict in your relationship. You may have had different standards, but I think that where compromise comes in when a relationship is equal.

Could you have shown him how to do tasks ‘properly’ as you say, rather than redoing them? Explained why it’s important to you?

Or divided tasks based on what your preferences are? For example, hoovering and taking the bins out is pretty self explanatory. Dusting, emptying dishwasher etc.

Have you claimed all domestic tasks as something you and only you are responsible for, or will he cook and run hoover around on a day he isn’t working?

Yes he vacuums the stairs and the loft on his day off. He empties the dishwasher every morning. He does the odd school pick up. He cooks once or twice a month. He takes the cars to be cleaned weekly. He bathes the little one once a twice a week and drop off and collect our eldest from after school activity once a week. If we’re having guests then yes he takes the day off and does a lot more around the house or takes the kids out for a few hours when I’m busy. I think that’s it really.

OP posts:
RoseslnTheHospital · 04/01/2023 21:18

@Peacelily38 nothing you've said in response to my last post is contained in what I wrote. I disagree entirely with your interpretation of what I said. However, I feel like continuing to respond on this is derailing the OPs thread so I'm not going to respond in detail here.

Greensleevevssnotnose · 04/01/2023 21:16

UniCred1 · 04/01/2023 20:32

It’s great that you don’t have to “nag” for things to be done amazingly by your husband. Nearly every women I met said that she had to nag, roll eyes, argue for things to be done at home by their husbands. These aren’t women from my background either but from the “progressive” sides of the world. Some men are crap at housework and that’s a fact. Some men are great at it and that’s also a fact. Replace “men” with “women” and that’s similarly true. I had a friend who used to do everything at home because his wife was lazy. They ended up divorcing because he’s had enough. She would leave dishes in the sink for days when he’s abroad. That’s just how some people are. You can’t change them. A lot of men are lazy as a lot of women. A lot of men are not lazy but they don’t do a good job at home, as is the case for a lot of women.

Perhaps they are not so good, but does it matter? We take everything in turns and yes it might be a takeout when it's his turn to cook and I might have to wipe up again but that's how it is. We love each other and share jobs.

Testina · 04/01/2023 21:15

“My brother was in the army and I can’t thank them enough for how they transformed him.”

Why would you thank them? Why would you care whether he’s shown that yeah - when told to by other more senior men, that a man can learn to be clean?

*apologies if his commanding officer was a woman but… I think not

5128gap · 04/01/2023 21:15

LaughingCat · 04/01/2023 21:03

Just off-topic, but when I saw you had responded, I realised I was gritting my teeth as there’ve been a few really combative threads on MN tonight and I was fully expecting to get both barrels in response, and so I was steeling myself to take a hit of verbal abuse and quietly finding another thread. Thank you, @5128gap for restoring my faith in reasoned and calm debate!

Thank you!😊
I realise that my initial questions to you sounded rather interrogatory and I do appreciate you answering them. I must admit this is an issue I struggle with, and am genuinely interested in other POV.

ClaryFairchild · 04/01/2023 21:15

Genuine question - what would your DH do if suddenly you weren't there/able to do your share?

Women aren't the only ones who can become single parents. If, God forbid, you does or developed a severe physical condition, what would he do?

My guess would be your family would step in and make sure your DC were ok and your DH would continue working all of of the day because "money is important". Perhaps he would even hire a nanny.

A man who works 70 hours a week is a shit husband and father. He's absent in all important ways.

You, on the other hand, would just co tiniest doing what you're doing if something happened to him, you would run around after your DC while juggling work but never doing too many hours to the detriment of your DC.

And that is that makes your DH a pathetic excuse for a "man".

Describe it in whatever way you want, but you are not furthering feminism, you're taking advantage of a patriarchal system because it happens to suit you.

UniCred1 · 04/01/2023 21:14

MarshaMelrose · 04/01/2023 20:29

As far as I can see, her explanation to her manager wasn't about being a feminist. She was just explaining to her manager why she was leaving in response to feeling under attack that she was letting women down. Her earlier explanation of how she has stood up for women was just to illustrate that she is a feminist so she feels it's unfair to be criticised as letting the side down.

Thank you 💗

OP posts: