Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To learn to drive in manual.. lecturing DP

160 replies

Pinkflamingogo · 04/01/2023 17:54

I'm learning to drive and have chosen to learn in a manual car. I have my first lesson this evening.

DP (who doesn't drive btw) has gone on and on on about how automatic is better, how manual cars will soon be a thing of the past etc.

I was obviously struggling to hide the fact I was getting annoyed by it as he became defensive and said he just wouldn't say anything and stormed off.

I know IANBU to learn in manual but would you find his incessant droning on and on about how automatic is better, annoying?

OP posts:
58percent · 04/01/2023 18:31

...and as others have said, if you ever need to borrow a car or do a favour for a friend who has a manual, you're snookered. Just recently one of my friends was on holiday and her car got broken into/damaged. She'd left her keys with her housemate so I was able to take her car to the garage and get it secured/fixed before she got back. Simple things like that...manual gives you loads more possibilities.

Oakbeam · 04/01/2023 18:30

It’s only in the UK that manuals are still in such widespread use

Are you sure about that? According to this 2020 article, 80% of the cars sold in Europe have manual gearboxes.

The current percentage is likely to be lower, but I doubt the rest of Europe have completely ditched manual cars since.

TreadSoftlyOnMyDreams · 04/01/2023 18:29

What makes him the expert, this non-driving man?
He's male and therefore an expert. Naturally?

Hotpinkangel19 · 04/01/2023 18:29

Oblomov22 · 04/01/2023 18:27

I deliberately taught ds1 in a manual. I think it's an important skill. Dh and I both drive automatics now, but did drive manuals until recently. I'll teach ds2 in a manual aswell. My choice.

Isn't it your DS's choice?

Whatthediddlyfeck · 04/01/2023 18:29

Until he has a full driving license he doesn’t get an opinion!

NCForQuestions · 04/01/2023 18:29

Automatic is not better, it's just different. My Dad wouldn't let me get an automatic licence and made me do my manual and he was right. I can drive anything that suits me and frequently flit between both for work purposes.

A manual licence is definitely freeing. You can still opt to drive automatic cars after you pass.

OnlyFannys · 04/01/2023 18:28

Totally up to you and manual gives you more options. I chose to drive auto in the end because I was having a horrible time trying to learn manual so much so that I was having pani attacks before my lessons. I decided a few years later to try for just auto and learnt to drive and passed my test in under 2 months so it was obviously the right choice for me but if I had more confidence I would have gone for manual

58percent · 04/01/2023 18:27

Defo stick with manual. It took me 4 attempts to pass my test and I was nearly tempted to jack it in and just do automatic only but I'm so glad I didn't! Firstly, automatic cars are (second hand) harder to find/buy plus you're quite limited with hire cars and as others have said,

illiterato · 04/01/2023 18:27

I have to say if I was learning now I probably wouldn’t bother with manual as they will die out as virtually all electric cars are automatics and I’d never choose to drive a manual as such a ball ache in traffic. I’d always be happy to pay the automatic premium. However, it’s still none of his business. Up to you and it does give you more flexibility.

FromTheFront2theBack · 04/01/2023 18:27

YANBU even if he had a point about automatic (and I don't think he does.....unless you really struggle with the manual it makes sense to get the license for manual just in case) he doesn't need to bang on endlessly. He could give his opinion and shut up. He's hardly an expert with no licence himself (is he insecure?).

Oblomov22 · 04/01/2023 18:27

I deliberately taught ds1 in a manual. I think it's an important skill. Dh and I both drive automatics now, but did drive manuals until recently. I'll teach ds2 in a manual aswell. My choice.

pictoosh · 04/01/2023 18:26

"But I’d still learn to drive a manual. It’s more challenging to learn, but there’s something a lot more rewarding when you get it mastered. When you’re off the motorway, manual driving can be much more involving, and fun. And as someone above says, manual cars are much more flexible- for example, you can change down before you go up a big hill, rather than getting half way up, slowing down and waiting for the car to decide when it’s ready to."

This in buckets. I do a lot of hillwalking in remote areas which involves negotiating tiny, narrow, windy, sometimes single track mountain roads. Much more fun in a manual. As I say, I like having the control.

ImaginaryDragon · 04/01/2023 18:24

Pinkflamingogo · 04/01/2023 17:54

I'm learning to drive and have chosen to learn in a manual car. I have my first lesson this evening.

DP (who doesn't drive btw) has gone on and on on about how automatic is better, how manual cars will soon be a thing of the past etc.

I was obviously struggling to hide the fact I was getting annoyed by it as he became defensive and said he just wouldn't say anything and stormed off.

I know IANBU to learn in manual but would you find his incessant droning on and on about how automatic is better, annoying?

DH is your first , but wont be your last back seat driver. Ignore him! As other have said Manual give you more choice and more cost effective car choice.

DomesticShortHair · 04/01/2023 18:21

He’s right, electric cars are all automatic so there some day won’t be any need to be able to drive a manual. I now do a lot of motorway miles in my current job, a lot stuck in motorway traffic, so my next car will be an automatic.

But I’d still learn to drive a manual. It’s more challenging to learn, but there’s something a lot more rewarding when you get it mastered. When you’re off the motorway, manual driving can be much more involving, and fun. And as someone above says, manual cars are much more flexible- for example, you can change down before you go up a big hill, rather than getting half way up, slowing down and waiting for the car to decide when it’s ready to.

Good luck with learning to drive. The day my examiner told me I’d passed was still one of the best days of my life. The freedom!!

pictoosh · 04/01/2023 18:21

Aquamarine1029 · 04/01/2023 18:10

He who doesn't drive doesn't have the luxury of advising anyone on how to learn.

Couldn't agree more. What makes him the expert, this non-driving man?

HitMeWithAHotNoteAndWatchMeBounce · 04/01/2023 18:20

It’s only in the UK that manuals are still in such widespread use, so as you’re presumably in the UK, it would make sense to learn in a manual.

Meanwhile, in much of the rest of the western world, manuals are virtually (if not, actually) obsolete.

When we left the UK, we brought our manual with us, and DH was like many on this thread - manuals are better, give you more control, yada, yada. Then we needed to buy a new car and manuals weren’t an option. He would never willingly buy a manual now.

Squarerootofpi · 04/01/2023 18:18

My friend drives an automatic (grew up in America) and it massively restricts what cars you can drive. She's had a nightmare finding good second hand cars, can't borrow a friends car, can't hire a cheap van, etc.

Mentalpiece · 04/01/2023 18:14

He doesn't drive, so what does he know about it.
It's always better to learn in a manual because then you have a choice of what type of car you want to drive. If you learn in an automatic, then you're limited to automatic unless you resit your test in a manual.
He won't be complaining when he's wanting a lift somewhere will he.
Tell him to learn to drive himself being as he knows so much.

Danni7297 · 04/01/2023 18:13

I have a licence just for automatics. I did some lessons in a manual and also a crash course when I was 17,and just couldn’t get used to the clutch for some reason. My whole leg used to shake and I used to stall constantly. I think it was probably just nerves at the time.

So I did a crash course in automatic and it was a lot easier. In my mind I would give myself a couple of years to get more confident then do some manual lessons and test. But I’ve never needed to.

I’ve had my license for almost 20 years and have never needed to drive a manual. If I’ve needed a courtesy car I always get given an automatic. My husband has a manual license and he much prefers to drive automatic especially because we live in a city he finds it easier with the traffic and alot of family have auto cars for the same reason.

Every car I have wanted I have been able to get in an automatic, although I’m sure there are some cars you can’t.
it can be more expensive than a manual, especially brand new too. And obviously depending on what you do for work an automatic license can limit you.

you definitely are not being unreasonable in learning in a manual. You then get the choice of both and means you are limitless when purchasing a car.

Beebumble2 · 04/01/2023 18:11

Manual definitely, as others have said, you can then drive anything. Cars with gears are real drivers cars.

minionsrule · 04/01/2023 18:11

Tbh learning in a manual is just a bit trickier whilst you master clutch control, a few lessons in that becomes a doddle.
I'd also point out that auto cars are less available in the second hand market and therefore more expensive.
Restricting yourself to an automatic in the early days is madness and I suspect it will quite a while yet till autos replace manuals

crazycrypty · 04/01/2023 18:11

AnuSTart · 04/01/2023 17:58

It's a ridiculous move to just learn automatic. Your DP is just threatened by your get up n go.

Why is it ridiculous? I've never had a problem driving an automatic, it's great.

Aquamarine1029 · 04/01/2023 18:10

He who doesn't drive doesn't have the luxury of advising anyone on how to learn.

whataboutsecondbreakfast · 04/01/2023 18:09

I've driven both but did my test in a manual car - as everyone says, it gives you more options and when it comes to rentals and second-hand cars, it's often cheaper too.