Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To learn to drive in manual.. lecturing DP

160 replies

Pinkflamingogo · 04/01/2023 17:54

I'm learning to drive and have chosen to learn in a manual car. I have my first lesson this evening.

DP (who doesn't drive btw) has gone on and on on about how automatic is better, how manual cars will soon be a thing of the past etc.

I was obviously struggling to hide the fact I was getting annoyed by it as he became defensive and said he just wouldn't say anything and stormed off.

I know IANBU to learn in manual but would you find his incessant droning on and on about how automatic is better, annoying?

OP posts:
HelpMeGetThrough · 04/01/2023 18:55

Manual every time. All the cars I've had have been manual, apart from loan cars. Getting my first auto for 33+ years on Monday and not worried about driving it at all.

Learn in a manual and you can change between the two easily.

OverCCCs · 04/01/2023 18:54

I only ever hear this question come up amongst a UK audience where the anti-automatic luddites are convinced anything other than manual isn’t “real” driving. The rest of the world has moved on, save for fun hobby and racing cars.

Pestering you is obnoxious, though, OP, unless he truly thinks you aren’t capable of passing your exam in a manual (and you’d find that out for yourself eventually!).

amylou8 · 04/01/2023 18:54

Absolutely get a manual license, especially if you plan on buying a second hand car, only having an automatic license will really restrict you. My daughter is learning in an automatic as she just couldn't get to grips with the gears, but she did at least try. At least she won't be able to borrow my car 😁

leithreas · 04/01/2023 18:53

I suspect we're still a long way from universal ownership of electric cars so the view that all electric cars being automatic is the future, is just that, something that will apply in the future.

I wouldn't be so sure. 44% of new cars bought in my country are hybrid or electric. Even if people don't want to go fully electric lots see the benefit of hybrid.

BogRollBOGOF · 04/01/2023 18:53

Generally I'd still encourage manuals because you've got the full range of choice avaliable. The pool of automatics in the second hand market is still more limited, especially if you're not ready to go EV yet.
If there's issues such as dyspraxia that make learning/ coordination harder, that's a different issue.

DH has an automatic, it's just what was there when he bought it. I'm not won over yet. I feel more in control in a manual. I have to anticipate more for things like hills or overtaking, and I like being more physically engaged in driving as part of being mentally engaged. I don't like passively being in charge of a tonne of glorified go-kart.

I know the time will come, but I'm not rushing into it yet.

A manual licence has no limitations on what you can drive.

Adelant · 04/01/2023 18:52

I have amazing clutch control, which I wouldn’t have learned on an automatic.

Manual all the way.

pigsDOfly · 04/01/2023 18:51

I passed my driving test in the early 70s in a manual.

I got my first automatic about 15 years later and have only ever bought automatics since as I much prefer them and would never go back to manual.

However, I would always advise someone to pass their test in a manual.

I suspect we're still a long way from universal ownership of electric cars so the view that all electric cars being automatic is the future, is just that, something that will apply in the future.

As pps have said, automatic cars are always a little more expensive than manuals, so that's a consideration, but having always bought used cars for many years now, I've never ever had difficulty finding good quality automatic cars. I agree though, they are a lot rarer to source than used manuals, so yes, the choice is very limited.

I bough my latest, used, car about 6 months ago and there were very few automatics available.

How your DP has managed to come to his opinion about the matter is a bit puzzling if he doesn't drive. Does he often has strong opinions about thing he knows nothing about?

Make your own decision OP, you're the one that is going to be driving the car, but for what it's worth. I'm another one say go with a manual for your driving test it'll will give you a wider scope when it comes to buying or hiring a car.

Pixiedust1234 · 04/01/2023 18:50

Tell him your dream career is to become a lorry driver and they have an obscene amount of gear changes. Watch him go white 😂

Honestly, tell him if he wants to only learn in an automatic (in the future) you won't think less of him...

leithreas · 04/01/2023 18:50

I wouldn't be arsed learning to drive a manual. We have a hybrid now and will get a fully electric next. Manuals are a thing of the past for us.

Claudia84 · 04/01/2023 18:49

I have to say that now I drive an automatic I do wonder why I put myself through learning in a manual. Yes it gives you choices but if my choice is always to have the automatic then so what. I'd recommend any new learner to go automatic to be honest.

However, that doesn't take away from the fact that yes, he is droning on and it's your choice. If he wants to learn in an automatic then he better crack on.

Yarrawonga · 04/01/2023 18:49

How are you going to drive your £300k vintage classic car

We have a manual classic car (not worth £300k) and you need to double declutch to change gear. My manual driving lessons didn’t teach me that.

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 04/01/2023 18:48

illiterato · 04/01/2023 18:44

I do understand why petrol heads like the manual experience but given the op is only learning to drive now she’s probably not one 🤣 Also unless you live somewhere where you get a lot of clear tarmac, the downsides of having to constantly change gears in town outweigh the joy of a manual Porsche on a clear country road.

I have driven an automatic around Stroud and Forest of Dean. Never again. Waiting for it to catch up with the change in road inclination was bloody awful. It's not a matter of being a 'petrol head'.

ArtixLynx · 04/01/2023 18:47

yanbu. Always learn manual, leaves your options open in future.

i have two cars, one of each, and i LOVE driving my manual, its a thrill (and i go racing sometimes) but i also have a disability and some days, driving it hurts and i'm unable to safely change gear, so i take the automatic and whizz around quite happily in that, my only gripe is that in an auto, when i put my foot down its not as responsive if i need a sudden burst of speed... but i'm sure there are models out there where that isn't an issue.

illiterato · 04/01/2023 18:44

Summerfun54321 · 04/01/2023 18:42

How are you going to drive your £300k vintage classic car when you're super rich and successful if you can only drive an automatic?

It’s fine- my driver has a manual license 🤣

illiterato · 04/01/2023 18:44

Oakbeam · 04/01/2023 18:37

Where is the fun in driving and changing up and down gears.

Exactly. Which is why I prefer autos.

I do understand why petrol heads like the manual experience but given the op is only learning to drive now she’s probably not one 🤣 Also unless you live somewhere where you get a lot of clear tarmac, the downsides of having to constantly change gears in town outweigh the joy of a manual Porsche on a clear country road.

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 04/01/2023 18:43

He stomped off saying he just wouldn't say anything then?

Of course he shouldn't.

  1. He can't drive.
  2. You are the one who decides what she will and will not learn in

Is he always an Instant Expert?

Oblomov22 · 04/01/2023 18:43

@Hotpinkangel19
Well both. But I'd suggest / recommend manual.
Like @DomesticShortHair says (thank you) he has a choice! Wink

We (Dh then me) practically taught ds1, then he had a few lessons. Worked nicely.

Summerfun54321 · 04/01/2023 18:42

How are you going to drive your £300k vintage classic car when you're super rich and successful if you can only drive an automatic?

lobsterkiller · 04/01/2023 18:38

What does he know about it?

Learn in the manual, you won't regret it. I drive manual but if I'm doing very long journeys I like automatic as I personally find it less tiring.

Please don't Learn in automatic, its restrictive and (I think) automatic cars are dearer.

Oakbeam · 04/01/2023 18:37

Where is the fun in driving and changing up and down gears.

Exactly. Which is why I prefer autos.

DomesticShortHair · 04/01/2023 18:36

Hotpinkangel19 · 04/01/2023 18:29

Isn't it your DS's choice?

Surely it’s the DS’s choice whether they wants to lean in an automatic or a manual? And its equally @Oblomov22‘s choice as to what type of car they are prepared to teach their DS. If that doesn’t align with the DS’s choice, then they’ll be getting taught by someone else.

illiterato · 04/01/2023 18:33

I guess the counter argument is that it takes longer to learn to drive a manual and therefore costs more in lessons. If you don’t think you’ll ever drive a manual other than in unforeseeable situations, you need to weigh that .

Tunnocks2022 · 04/01/2023 18:33

I think you should do exactly what you want to do, and I only ever drive an automatic.

By the time my DC learn I suspect they’ll be no point learning manual. But right now it would give you more flexibility as previous posters have said

takealettermsjones · 04/01/2023 18:31

Mansplainer. Ask him if he's planning to advise you on proper use of a tampon next. 🙄

Spectre8 · 04/01/2023 18:31

I once had an automatic car whilst my manual was being repaired, ir was a company car so had no choice. Fuck no never again. Where is the fun in driving and changing up and down gears.

So glad to get my manual back!