Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To learn to drive in manual.. lecturing DP

160 replies

Pinkflamingogo · 04/01/2023 17:54

I'm learning to drive and have chosen to learn in a manual car. I have my first lesson this evening.

DP (who doesn't drive btw) has gone on and on on about how automatic is better, how manual cars will soon be a thing of the past etc.

I was obviously struggling to hide the fact I was getting annoyed by it as he became defensive and said he just wouldn't say anything and stormed off.

I know IANBU to learn in manual but would you find his incessant droning on and on about how automatic is better, annoying?

OP posts:
Nat6999 · 04/01/2023 20:23

I like driving a manual car but what has been a game changer has been having an electronic handbrake, I would rather have that than an automatic.

LondonQueen · 04/01/2023 20:18

neverknowinglyunreasonable · 04/01/2023 18:03

Tell him you plan to buy a Porsche (if these are available in automatic insert the name of another fancy manual car. Sorry for my lack of research)

It's harder to buy a new car with a manual gearbox than an automatic transmission now, I've had automatic Porsches before.

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 04/01/2023 20:16

@mamagicofthefae I know I sound like I am looking for excuses but we don't have lampposts either. Well, there are 2 on this wholly residential High Street with only 3 houses with off street parking.

We had a town debate about it and the middle of town, almost 4000 car owning adults, would have great difficulty finding regular recharging options even if the town centre carpark was 100% electric charging stations.

Medieval houses and roads just weren't made to adapt to 21st century electrification. And yet even our MP, the newest Transport Minister, doesn't seem to want to listen.

LondonQueen · 04/01/2023 20:15

It's definitely easier if you have a manual license as you can drive both. Any more recent cars have been automatics and I love them but if I need to borrow a manual car I have that option. The courtesy car after my crash was manual, they had no automatics in stock.

Willyoujustbequiet · 04/01/2023 20:13

Everyone should learn in a manual unless there is a particular reason such as a disability etc..

Manual requires more skill, is more of a challenge but offers more flexibility and certainly a more enjoyable driving experience.. we have one of each and I choose the manual everytime.

honeylulu · 04/01/2023 20:12

I dont know why he's annoyed since he's the one being annoying! Seeing as he can't drive at all what's it got to do with him? It's hardly as if he only drives automatic and you're doing it to get a manual car just to exclude him from using it.

I agree it widens your options to learn manual if you can. Plus I feel like a "proper" driver because I can drive a manual which is quite satisfying. I also prefer the greater control a manual car has, even small ones!

Cas112 · 04/01/2023 20:11

What a nuisance he is. Tell him to go learn in an automatic if he wants but to leave you to it

pompei8309 · 04/01/2023 20:08

Pinkflamingogo · 04/01/2023 17:54

I'm learning to drive and have chosen to learn in a manual car. I have my first lesson this evening.

DP (who doesn't drive btw) has gone on and on on about how automatic is better, how manual cars will soon be a thing of the past etc.

I was obviously struggling to hide the fact I was getting annoyed by it as he became defensive and said he just wouldn't say anything and stormed off.

I know IANBU to learn in manual but would you find his incessant droning on and on about how automatic is better, annoying?

He is correct, manual cars are dying out but passing your test on a manual gives you the option to drive both manual and automatic , plus you never know when you may not have any options but to drive a manual ( it happened to me with a rental, they only had manual) and if you can’t, you’ll be stuck

NumberTheory · 04/01/2023 20:06

I would find him going on about it really annoying too. Especially as he doesn’t drive!

However, he’s probably not wrong that automatic cars will become pretty rare and specialist soon and that having a manual license will be of very little practical benefit.

Unless, that is, you really enjoy manuals. In which case, definitely take the manual test.

I love them, there’s a lot of pleasure to be had driving a manual, and I really like the control and sense of mastery it gives. So if you like it, and you think you might enjoy driving specialist cars and be prepared to put the money into it, it’s better to spend the small amount of extra time and money it will take to pass the manual test now.

KingOfPoundbury · 04/01/2023 20:02

Adelant · 04/01/2023 18:52

I have amazing clutch control, which I wouldn’t have learned on an automatic.

Manual all the way.

Oh gosh, I remember you!

My eyes stlll water when I think about your clutch.

Manual all the way (as you said at the time) was fine for me. 🥵

middleager · 04/01/2023 19:58

I agree with other pps. In the ice, I ditch my automatic in favour of DH's manual as I have far more control.

TurquoiseDress · 04/01/2023 19:56

Manual all the way

Then you can drive any kind of car, manual or automatic

Win win

He doesn't even drive...ignore

FictionalCharacter · 04/01/2023 19:55

@Kissedbyfire1 I agree, one of my autos had the most phenomenal acceleration of all the cars I’ve owned.
Auto gearboxes do vary, some are better than others, some have flat spots in the acceleration. And not everyone knows how to drive them optimally.

FictionalCharacter · 04/01/2023 19:51

He’s right in that in the future nearly all cars will be auto. But that’s not the point. I learned to drive manual, my first few cars were manual but I’ve only had automatics for years and would never go back. But I’ve also had to drive vans, minibuses, hire cars, pool cars at work, tractors and other people’s cars in emergencies. You’re very limited if you can only drive automatics.

Hopefully he’ll stop bleating when you’ve passed your test.

I see he doesn’t drive. Is he one of those people who thinks that if you learn to drive and take your test on manual cars, you can’t drive automatics? 🤨

People think the weirdest things. One of my friends was amazed when I told her the only difference is the gearbox, so you don’t have to change gear. She thought automatic meant the car “drives itself”. No, I have no idea what she was thinking either.

Kissedbyfire1 · 04/01/2023 19:47

My car is a Golf R, DSG gearbox which means I can drive it in auto or in manual off the steering wheel paddles. DH’s car is manual. We both passed our tests in manual and can swap cars at will. Definitely learn in a manual.
And to the pp who found that their auto gearbox lags, mine goes like shit off a shovel- they’re really not all sluggish and you can’t beat an auto in city traffic.

kingtamponthefurred · 04/01/2023 19:46

I only drive an automatic, it has never been a problem, but I would be very irritated by unsolicited advice from someone who does not drive at all. I bet your partner will be happy enough for you to ferry him around in any kind of car when you have passed your test.

SusanPerbCallMeSue · 04/01/2023 19:44

At least with a manual licence you can drive either, and even if you get an automatic you don't know if at some point in the future you might need to drive a manual.

I have had both, and I did prefer the automatic, but have a manual now and it's fine.

When I had both I'd get confused and wonder why my manual was making a noise when I'd forget to change gear. Blush

Yolanda524 · 04/01/2023 19:37

If I was learning now I wouldn’t bother learning to drive a manual. Automatics are so much nicer to drive and all electric cars are automatic.
in the last 10 years the amount of times I’ve driven someone’s else’s car is 0. And hire cars you can chooses auto or manual.

I can drive a manual and had always had manual cars until my current car. I driving manual car in the uk where it’s start stop ALL the time. I love driving manual cars back home on the open road where is not so much traffic. The UK has some strange dislike of automatic cars for some reason

soundsofthesixties · 04/01/2023 19:36

I've driven an automatic car for the last 45 years. I passed my test in one and it's never been a problem. The insurance is no dearer than a manual car, don't know why someone thought that. Everyone I know has now got an automatic even though they can drive a manual.

toocold54 · 04/01/2023 19:32

They say it’s easier to go from a manual to an automatic, than it is an automatic to a manual.

I would think they are about the same.

Learning to drive us just as much about having confidence as it is working all of the pedals and buttons.

The gears are one of the most difficult parts of learning to drive ( which is why people say it’s easier to learn in a manual then go to automatic).

But when you first start out you are also learning every other thing too which makes it even more difficult and you have no confidence.

My thinking is that if you learn in an automatic and gain the confidence and experience of being on the road without the stress of the gears, then you can always learn in a manual in the future.

That’s not to put you off learning in a manual as I did and I’m a good driver and enjoy it but I do wonder if I did it the wrong way around.

Tohaveandtohold · 04/01/2023 19:32

It’s your first lesson so I don’t see what his point is except maybe he wants you to quickly pass for one reason or the other, maybe so you can start giving him lifts 😂
However, I only have an automatic license and I’ve never regretted it, like I’ve not had a reason why I’m stuck because of it.
I initially learnt how to drive a manual when I was 18 in my home country before relocating to the UK however there, we used to drive on the other side of the road. When I got here, this part confused me a lot and also, changing from using my right hand to using my left hand to shift the gear.
When I got to the UK, I really needed to be able to drive because of work so I decided to do my test first with an automatic car so that my main focus will be the road and I can drive. I passed the first time and I’ve always said I’ll do the test in a manual but did not eventually because I can always get a car I need in an automatic, even dh that has a manual licence drives an automatic as well because he travels to work so basically, I can use any car in the house so I’ve never seen any need for it.

DisforDarkChocolate · 04/01/2023 19:29

I love my automatic but I'm glad I have a manual license. I'd need to practice on some quiet level roads to get comfortable with a manual again though.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 04/01/2023 19:28

HitMeWithAHotNoteAndWatchMeBounce · 04/01/2023 19:20

Driving manual is a more pleasurable experience.

You say that like it’s some sort of absolute.

It’s only a ‘more pleasurable experience’ if you think it’s a more pleasurable experience.

It really isn’t for many people. There is literally nothing ‘pleasurable’ about sitting in city or motorway traffic in a manual.

I've driven manual since I passed and now have an automatic, I much prefer my automatic, it's a much nicer experience. No constantly changing gears up and down, it's great.
I'd definitely get a dual license though OP, you aren't limited then.

magicofthefae · 04/01/2023 19:27

I will go against the grain...your DH might have a point. Manuals will become obsolete in time. America and Australia virtually don't use manuals anymore. It's rare in America, but common in Germany etc.

I passed my test in manual decades ago. What a complete waste of time and money learning all that extra clutch and gear stuff, when it's not essential.

Since passing I've only ever driven an automatic. For those that say it takes ages for an automatic to adapt to changing roads...it's time to drive newer models of automatic. I can assure you they speed up and adapt just as well as manual cars, if not better. It's the older model of automatics that feel like driving a Tesco trolley.

@SamphirethePogoingStickerist
Yes there needs to be more infrastructure for EV's, so that people without driveways can easily charge their vehicles. I do manage without a driveway EV charger, as some councils have public chargers installed into lampposts, or designated bays in car parks where only EVs can go, etc...but if I move area depending on where would move, it could become a problem. This needs addressing by government and councils.

Still, your DH shouldn't make you feel bad, if you disagree with him. He should accept your difference of opinion and be happy you're on the road to self improvement and transport freedom.

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 04/01/2023 19:26

HitMeWithAHotNoteAndWatchMeBounce · 04/01/2023 19:10

There is a whole world, including many car manufacturing countries, outside Europe.

And yet the reasons for different attitudes remain. As in that link.

The point being that it isn't unfathomable or faulty logic!

Swipe left for the next trending thread