Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is a wealth tax the only way?

356 replies

Cuppasoupmonster · 04/01/2023 16:36

…of raising capital for proper public service reform and not just sticking plaster ‘solutions’. Just interested to hear others thoughts.

YANBU = yes it is
YABU = no it isn’t

OP posts:
FloydPepper · 04/01/2023 19:03

Mark19735 · 04/01/2023 19:00

People aren't getting it because they can't see beyond the immediate fear that this might hurt them.

Most companies employ tens, sometimes hundreds of tax advisors to work out how much corporation tax they should pay. And most companies make about 10% profit each year, and pay around 20% corporation tax. Sometimes more, sometimes less, but ballpark that's about right for most companies, most years.

It would be exactly the same as issuing 2% new shares each year and giving them to the government (to sell). A 'wealth tax' of 2% that takes one clerical assistant 5 mins to calculate with zero scope for error, compared to an 'income tax' (called corporation tax) that takes hundreds of people the best part of a year to calculate with often a great many errors requiring hundreds of hours of audit time to find and eliminate.

There's no conceptual or moral difference between the two.

(Unless you work in financial services, and earn your living as an auditor, or are a politician, and want to make the tax code so confusing that people can't see you skimming off public money for private beneficiaries)..

I think you’re missing the fact that any new issue of shares dilutes sd therefore devalues those already in circulation. It doesn’t create any value, and doesn’t mean the company is paying anything, the shareholders are.

if that’s what you’re trying to do, ok

Violinist64 · 04/01/2023 19:02

Cuppasoupmonster · 04/01/2023 18:25

@Ledwood85 you don’t ‘work for’ property gains Confused they just happen because you buy at the right time, sit back 30 years and suddenly your house is worth double what it was.

Ah, here we go again. People in my age group and older who bought our houses when, admittedly, they were more affordable. People who worked hard all their lives, who perhaps had negative equity in the early nineties, who faced raging inflation (not just a modern problem), people who bought homes for their families and who were relieved when their mortgages were paid off. Yes, our houses are now worth considerably more than we could ever have imagined but it does not mean that we are any wealthier in terms of spending or having money to spare.

Favouritefruits · 04/01/2023 19:01

No, going after tax evaders is a better option. I just mentioned this is another thread, if everyone paid the right amount of tax most of our problems would be dealt with.

FloydPepper · 04/01/2023 19:00

But yeah op. Let’s now say 2.5

how are you proposing all those assets get valued? The report you posted is just a vague set of aspirations and many on here don’t think a wealth tax is either fair, or workable (I appreciate those are 2 separate arguments)

Mark19735 · 04/01/2023 19:00

People aren't getting it because they can't see beyond the immediate fear that this might hurt them.

Most companies employ tens, sometimes hundreds of tax advisors to work out how much corporation tax they should pay. And most companies make about 10% profit each year, and pay around 20% corporation tax. Sometimes more, sometimes less, but ballpark that's about right for most companies, most years.

It would be exactly the same as issuing 2% new shares each year and giving them to the government (to sell). A 'wealth tax' of 2% that takes one clerical assistant 5 mins to calculate with zero scope for error, compared to an 'income tax' (called corporation tax) that takes hundreds of people the best part of a year to calculate with often a great many errors requiring hundreds of hours of audit time to find and eliminate.

There's no conceptual or moral difference between the two.

(Unless you work in financial services, and earn your living as an auditor, or are a politician, and want to make the tax code so confusing that people can't see you skimming off public money for private beneficiaries)..

jtaeapa · 04/01/2023 18:58

I don't know.

It's debatable what the "super rich" people's share of the payment ought to be. Rishi's wife is super rich but I'm not sure why she has to pay for the rest of us to live. People who earn more pay more tax. And might consume fewer public resources - private chauffeur, education, healthcare. And they might even pay more workers - cleaners, drivers, assistants etc.

If you go out with someone who's richer than you, do you suppose that their share of a dinner you both ate is more than 50%? I don't think so.

Rich people are internationally mobile anyway.

FloydPepper · 04/01/2023 18:58

Cuppasoupmonster · 04/01/2023 18:55

Middle earners don’t have 1.5m plus assets. I think only the top 4% do (from memory). But I would be open to raising it if practical, to 2.5 etc.

1.5m across a property and a pension fund when someone retires is very much middle earner territory. I don’t think you understand how much a pension fund could be, especially if it’s a final salary scheme

(that’s putting aside how hard it is to value those!)

Cuppasoupmonster · 04/01/2023 18:55

NeedToChangeName · 04/01/2023 18:50

In principle, I'd be up for this. Higher taxes and better public facilities. Scandinavian approach

But, my worry is that middle earners end up paying more and the super rich find ways to avoid paying their share

Middle earners don’t have 1.5m plus assets. I think only the top 4% do (from memory). But I would be open to raising it if practical, to 2.5 etc.

OP posts:
Violinist64 · 04/01/2023 18:53

Whenever this sort of idea is mooted, it never, ever affects the people who are its target because they have expensive lawyers who can get round every loophole under the sun. The people it always, always affects are those who are fairly comfortably off but with no spare cash for extras. People like me.

Idratherbepaddleboarding · 04/01/2023 18:52

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn at author's request

NeedToChangeName · 04/01/2023 18:50

In principle, I'd be up for this. Higher taxes and better public facilities. Scandinavian approach

But, my worry is that middle earners end up paying more and the super rich find ways to avoid paying their share

saltinesandcoffeecups · 04/01/2023 18:49

Cuppasoupmonster · 04/01/2023 18:44

Then how do you have all this wealth?

I’m assuming a trick question since you have yet to quantify ’wealth’.

I could be the proudest owner of multiple investments/multiple houses/large bank account, a modest house/retirement funds/run of the mill bank account, or a cardboard box/chewing gum wrapper/a few coins in my pocket.

All 3 scenarios can be considered wealth.

I still haven’t heard what you do for a living?

FloydPepper · 04/01/2023 18:47

Cuppasoupmonster · 04/01/2023 18:46

does this mean society is on the hook to bail out or refund those who have made a loss when they have to sell in a negative equity situation

It did Confused it was called the bank bailout.

Now I know you’re either trolling or don’t understand anything financial

Cuppasoupmonster · 04/01/2023 18:47

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 04/01/2023 18:45

I'm going to assume that made sense when you typed it.

If you can’t understand it that’s not my issue.

OP posts:
Cuppasoupmonster · 04/01/2023 18:46

does this mean society is on the hook to bail out or refund those who have made a loss when they have to sell in a negative equity situation

It did Confused it was called the bank bailout.

OP posts:
MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 04/01/2023 18:45

Cuppasoupmonster · 04/01/2023 18:41

Because it’s a figment of your imagination. And I thought the point of threads, according to you, is only to discuss precise figures and complex ideas rather than just ‘opinions’?

I'm going to assume that made sense when you typed it.

Cuppasoupmonster · 04/01/2023 18:45

@Ledwood85 of course it’s envy! Perfectly justifiable too. Would you say the same to somebody in a third world country who was ‘envious’ of our lifestyle and situation?

OP posts:
Cuppasoupmonster · 04/01/2023 18:44

saltinesandcoffeecups · 04/01/2023 18:43

Bog standard middle manager, you?

Then how do you have all this wealth?

OP posts:
Mark19735 · 04/01/2023 18:43

It's all just different accounting treatments. In a normal, functioning economy with no perverse incentives, things you own are recorded in your personal ledger as "assets", and those assets are used to generate rents/dividends which are recorded in your personal ledger as "income". In a perfect capitalist market-based economy, all ownership of assets will tend towards optimal resource allocation, with values rising and falling as demand rises and falls, and all assets should eventually generate the same 'normal' level of income, adjusted for risk.

The thing is, our markets aren't perfect. So firstly, nobody sane rents their own house from themselves. If they did, they'd have more "income" and would be liable for more income tax. (There is actually a strong case for this - called imputed rent). Secondly, wealthy people don't actually pay for many goods/services they consume. They stay in their rich mates villas and yachts, fly in their private jets, wear custom made clothes hand made by a couture tailor which they get for free. They provide services and connections to each other for free on a reciprocal basis. None of these transactions are taxed because they are invisible. Only the plebs pay VAT, Air Passenger Duty, Income Tax etc. etc. Because being wealthy is seen as a mechanism to avoid having to make (taxable) transactions, manipulating wealth rather than engaging in normal financial transactions is actually a method for avoiding tax. That is why people see wealth taxes as an infringement - it's because they don't currently pay the income taxes/VAT etc. that the little people are already paying because they don't own the assets and means of production.

Think about it ... why do people want to own their homes? Because renting money from a bank feels different to renting housing from a landlord. And the promise at the end of it is that one day, your housing costs will be zero. (Not quite true c.f. see council tax ... but that's the general sentiment).

If we fixed some of those things, and let the consequences settle down and people got accustomed to the new ways, there should be no difference at all between taxing wealth or taxing income. Not economically, anyway. Psychologically, there's still a difference. But then ... why go to all that trouble, and why not stick with taxing income - and do it properly?

saltinesandcoffeecups · 04/01/2023 18:43

Cuppasoupmonster · 04/01/2023 18:40

What do you do for work can I ask?

Bog standard middle manager, you?

Ledwood85 · 04/01/2023 18:42

Cuppasoupmonster · 04/01/2023 18:25

@Ledwood85 you don’t ‘work for’ property gains Confused they just happen because you buy at the right time, sit back 30 years and suddenly your house is worth double what it was.

Citing property equity gains is just pure envy. And I state that as someone who has not benefited from this. Like any investment, you work to afford the upfront cost; whether it goes up or down is out of your control.

On that note, if you are going to tax gains in equity, does this mean society is on the hook to bail out or refund those who have made a loss when they have to sell in a negative equity situation?
If you want to socialize the gains - you have to socialize the losses too, right? That's how it works with shares.

Cuppasoupmonster · 04/01/2023 18:41

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 04/01/2023 18:35

You raised the issue, I'm giving my opinion, which I assumed was the point. Still, we've reached page 5 without you mentioning taking money off 'rich pensioners.'

Because it’s a figment of your imagination. And I thought the point of threads, according to you, is only to discuss precise figures and complex ideas rather than just ‘opinions’?

OP posts:
Cuppasoupmonster · 04/01/2023 18:40

saltinesandcoffeecups · 04/01/2023 18:35

I am, it seems that every time I turn around someone has a bright idea to rob me blind redistribute my wealth.

What do you do for work can I ask?

OP posts:
Cuppasoupmonster · 04/01/2023 18:40

dollymixtured · 04/01/2023 18:37

Thinking that because you, by an accident of birth, were born in the same country as a wealthy person, it means you should be entitled to some of their wealth is greedy.

Plus isn’t inheritance an ‘accident at birth’ as well?

OP posts:
Cuppasoupmonster · 04/01/2023 18:39

dollymixtured · 04/01/2023 18:37

Thinking that because you, by an accident of birth, were born in the same country as a wealthy person, it means you should be entitled to some of their wealth is greedy.

By that logic, you must feel all tax is unfair? And greedy?

OP posts: