Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is a wealth tax the only way?

356 replies

Cuppasoupmonster · 04/01/2023 16:36

…of raising capital for proper public service reform and not just sticking plaster ‘solutions’. Just interested to hear others thoughts.

YANBU = yes it is
YABU = no it isn’t

OP posts:
BlueBellIris · 04/01/2023 20:17

The problem in this country is most people think tax increases are good if it doesn’t impact them.

I have no problem with a wealth tax. Me and DH are high earners, but we come from working class backgrounds. No help with deposits etc. We’ve chosen to send the children to private school so compared to lots of our contemporaries we have a relatively small house and big mortgage. Low assets.

My friend who is a SAHM, husband high earner, with a lovely house (huge help with deposit) and Trust that pays kids school fees would think a wealth tax is outrageous and we should just tax high earners a bit more.

And then we have those who just shout “tax Amazon more” and forget we are in a global economy and it’s not like loads of other countries get lots of tax from them.

Cuppasoupmonster · 04/01/2023 20:16

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 04/01/2023 20:08

'Oh dear, I floated the idea of a wealth tax, can't define wealth or rich or how it would work and some people have pointed out the flaws and disagreed with me. How spiky and defensive can you get, eh?'

😂 back again Mrs d? Are you stalking me as you’re on almost every thread I post on 😱

OP posts:
EngTech · 04/01/2023 20:15

At what level is a wealth tax triggered ?

It will hit the very people that need help and I would consider retiring if I felt it was not worth workin 😳

Michellexxx · 04/01/2023 20:14

I’m not sure why everyone is so obsessed with taxing to solve the economic issues. The main problem in the UK is growth, and taxing capital gains on selling companies etc will only make people less likely to keep own wealth or build a company here. As others have said, it will go elsewhere, to other countries..

Taxing ‘rich’ individuals isn’t going to solve the mismanaged NHS or the covid black hole.

Sunsetintheeast · 04/01/2023 20:09

ErrolTheDragon · 04/01/2023 20:07

My concern about rent is that it is unearned income.

Is it? DH dealt with renting out his mother's house when she had to go into a nursing home. It was actually quite a lot of work for him, ongoing maintenance etc. and barely broke even on it.

Well if you barely broke even you won’t have paid tax!

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 04/01/2023 20:08

FloydPepper · 04/01/2023 20:03

And some economically illiterate ones…

'Oh dear, I floated the idea of a wealth tax, can't define wealth or rich or how it would work and some people have pointed out the flaws and disagreed with me. How spiky and defensive can you get, eh?'

ErrolTheDragon · 04/01/2023 20:07

My concern about rent is that it is unearned income.

Is it? DH dealt with renting out his mother's house when she had to go into a nursing home. It was actually quite a lot of work for him, ongoing maintenance etc. and barely broke even on it.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 04/01/2023 20:05

FloydPepper · 04/01/2023 19:57

What are you on about?
a final salary scheme just refers to how it’s calculated/built up, not how much it is.

and how do you know they can pay a large tax bill out of a small regular income?

yoh don’t. You’re just saying people don’t deserve their assets

My final salary pension is the grand sum of £ 3,600 a year. And I do pay tax on it.

Sunsetintheeast · 04/01/2023 20:05

FloydPepper · 04/01/2023 19:59

There we have it
people with wealth (which you haven’t defined) only have it through other people do deserve it to be taken away

Surely wealth built on the sweat and suppression of others, that couldn’t be achieved without those people, should be taxed - if they’re not going to share their gains.

Jeff Bezoz couldn’t be successful without his work force. The value in his company remains UNTAXED until he sells shares. He’s one of the richest men on earth and his tax bill is proportionately small.

There are many like him.

FloydPepper · 04/01/2023 20:03

Cuppasoupmonster · 04/01/2023 20:02

There’s an awful lot of very defensive and spiky people on here…

And some economically illiterate ones…

Cuppasoupmonster · 04/01/2023 20:02

There’s an awful lot of very defensive and spiky people on here…

OP posts:
Cuppasoupmonster · 04/01/2023 20:02

FloydPepper · 04/01/2023 19:59

There we have it
people with wealth (which you haven’t defined) only have it through other people do deserve it to be taken away

Yes that’s exactly what I said. 🙄

OP posts:
FloydPepper · 04/01/2023 19:59

Cuppasoupmonster · 04/01/2023 19:48

I see what you mean but to me, very wealthy people are generally only very wealthy due to the labours of others. I don’t think such taxes would dampen aspiration, the very wealthy will still be very wealthy after a wealth tax, and much better off than the rest of us. That won’t change.

There we have it
people with wealth (which you haven’t defined) only have it through other people do deserve it to be taken away

Sunsetintheeast · 04/01/2023 19:59

My concern about rent is that it is unearned income.

People hoard wealth and it’s not good for society. I am part of the problem, but accept that higher taxes for people like me are needed.

SchoolQuestionnaire · 04/01/2023 19:59

This reply has been withdrawn

Withdrawn at poster's request

FloydPepper · 04/01/2023 19:57

Cuppasoupmonster · 04/01/2023 19:33

If it’s final salary then you can easily afford to pay tax on it.

What are you on about?
a final salary scheme just refers to how it’s calculated/built up, not how much it is.

and how do you know they can pay a large tax bill out of a small regular income?

yoh don’t. You’re just saying people don’t deserve their assets

SchoolQuestionnaire · 04/01/2023 19:57

MarshaBradyo · 04/01/2023 19:49

Well true. A bit like people on the other side saying tax more, more funding, pay me more but someone else is footing the bill.

Quite.

Kendodd · 04/01/2023 19:55

I agree OP.
And I'd be massively affected by this.

Bard6817 · 04/01/2023 19:49

There’s already a wealth tax on pensions…

Its called the lifetime allowance. Anything above it incurs an additional 25% rate of income tax, or you get hit for 55% if you take it as a lump sum.

Some People don’t realise just how hard that’s going to hit them in a decade or two.

I buy into the idea of applying CGT to all property. That’s because i don’t own any. Same rationale as people who have no assets talk about taxing the rich. Might as well be open about it.

If a real wealth tax came in, the market in trusts, annuities, rentals would expand overnight, for those who wish to make relatively simple maneuvre to avoid it.

MarshaBradyo · 04/01/2023 19:49

Cuppasoupmonster · 04/01/2023 19:47

It’s quite funny MN is quite a left leaning website that believes in the distribution of wealth. Just… not their own wealth.

Well true. A bit like people on the other side saying tax more, more funding, pay me more but someone else is footing the bill.

Cuppasoupmonster · 04/01/2023 19:48

jtaeapa · 04/01/2023 18:58

I don't know.

It's debatable what the "super rich" people's share of the payment ought to be. Rishi's wife is super rich but I'm not sure why she has to pay for the rest of us to live. People who earn more pay more tax. And might consume fewer public resources - private chauffeur, education, healthcare. And they might even pay more workers - cleaners, drivers, assistants etc.

If you go out with someone who's richer than you, do you suppose that their share of a dinner you both ate is more than 50%? I don't think so.

Rich people are internationally mobile anyway.

I see what you mean but to me, very wealthy people are generally only very wealthy due to the labours of others. I don’t think such taxes would dampen aspiration, the very wealthy will still be very wealthy after a wealth tax, and much better off than the rest of us. That won’t change.

OP posts:
Mark19735 · 04/01/2023 19:48

Sunsetintheeast · 04/01/2023 19:17

Ah but there’s the rub. Occupiers pay, nothing to do with the landlord. I can own 1000 homes and pay nothing on them if I rent them out. That’s not a wealth tax.

Well, by charging rents, you're just replacing a hypothetical tax liability based on wealth to an alternative one based on income. That's my point - no conceptual or moral difference between the two.

I suppose you could argue that you have the right to charge peppercorn rents below the market rate and thereby remain below any income tax threshold ... so you could technically fully avoid any tax (wealth or income) as an owner of multiple properties.

But then see my earlier post about rich people avoiding taxes by not creating any disclosable records of financial transactions liable to taxation. The one advantage of taxing wealth instead of income would be that this would be harder to do. Probably also why so many people instinctively dislike the idea ...

Cuppasoupmonster · 04/01/2023 19:47

It’s quite funny MN is quite a left leaning website that believes in the distribution of wealth. Just… not their own wealth.

OP posts:
ErrolTheDragon · 04/01/2023 19:45

Problem is - we actually need people to spend to boost the economy. Saving might be viewed as more virtuous, but it's crap for keeping businesses afloat.

Where do you suppose the money for investment in companies comes from? The money building societies lend? The country needs savings and investments too.
Spending money on foreign imports otoh ... helps some sectors but doesn't necessarily grow our economy in the most beneficial way.

AreOttersJustWetCats · 04/01/2023 19:41

Mark19735 · 04/01/2023 19:37

Only by raising taxes higher on those affluent people ... making them less affluent. That won't entrench inequality - the inequality is already there. Taxation just changes who gets the final say on how money is spent ... it doesn't 'create' money, nor does it destroy it. Just moves it about.

In many ways, having it in the hands of a government that definitely will spend it is better for the economy than having rich people saving it all offshore.

And, having a single-payer system for public goods means the taxpayer has some protection against profit-gouging by unscrupulous companies (see insulin costs in the USA, for example). The trick is identifying which services are better run by the public, and which are better run privately. Private Water - nope. Private Trains - nope. Private supermarkets ... seems OK. Private Health ... seems better sometimes, worse others. Private education ... who knows?

(lobs grenade and retreats for tea)

At an individual level, both the affluent and poor people will be taxed at a level they can afford though. But that will have a far bigger impact on the poor than the affluent.