Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is a wealth tax the only way?

356 replies

Cuppasoupmonster · 04/01/2023 16:36

…of raising capital for proper public service reform and not just sticking plaster ‘solutions’. Just interested to hear others thoughts.

YANBU = yes it is
YABU = no it isn’t

OP posts:
MigsandTiggs · 04/01/2023 22:24

"Absolutely. I read an article about high taxation in Scandinavian countries which was interesting, it interviewed a high earner who didn’t begrudge paying a lot of tax because he said he felt he was ‘investing in the society around him’. That he felt creating a pleasant, safe and educated community was as beneficial to him as a living environment as it was to the people who directly benefited from his taxes. I thought that was a really benevolent but also intelligent way of looking at it." OP

The difference here is that we are starting from a different cultural base. Scandinavian countries believe that each person has a collective responsiblity for everyone else in society. From this ingrained belief they are willing to pay high taxes in exchange for a high level of services that benefits all of society and supports social cohesion. There is a shared, mutual respect between government and the people that does not exist in the UK.

Soothsayer1 · 04/01/2023 22:16

Cuppasoupmonster · 04/01/2023 22:01

So by extension no, people sitting on hoarded of wealth and at loathe to ‘distribute’ any of it cannot really complain about living in a run down society. They’re only wealthy because somebody else isn’t.

or they are only wealthy because they are able to maneuver themselves into a position where they have enough leverage to get others to sell thier labour at a price set by them
or they are only wealthy because they have the means to hide thier money offshore
etc etc,
loads of people are more clever than wot I am, harder working, but no-one can have 1000 x the smarts of another person, or work 1000 x harder, yet the disparities in wealth are this great...orders of magnitude greater even!

Mark19735 · 04/01/2023 22:15

Marketing matters, too.

Very few people think that subsidising buses through taxes is a great idea. Most would argue that passengers should pay a fare each time they travel, for the journey they make, and that fare should be set to cover the costs of that journey. The idea of contributing to the costs of running the network for journeys they don't or won't make is horrifying to most people.

But many people subscribe to a TV streaming service with more channels than they can physically watch. They are happy to contribute to the costs of them all, because what they've bought is the right to watch them whenever they want.

So why not take the same approach to buses? You have a right to ride any bus, any time, for a nominal fare. (In fact - why not make it free?). But you have to subscribe to Busflix. Your subscription will be paid through PAYE and collected by HMRC.

Now take that idea and stretch it to NHS Prime. You have bought the right to attend any A&E department in the country, any time you like. Knock yourself out. (Actually, please don't ... ). Many other public service could be marketed in the same way. But they are not ... and that is a political choice, too - just as the amount spent on them is.

Sky does it really well, and the government could learn from them.

Cuppasoupmonster · 04/01/2023 22:14

FlorenceAndTheVendingMachine · 04/01/2023 22:10

You seem to feel entitled to their money simply because they have more of it than you.

Imagine going for a meal with your friends and saying "you're paying the bill, Rachel, because you've got more money than the rest of us".

Oh please 😂 if that’s your best ‘equivalent scenario’ then you’re not really up to this debate are you.

OP posts:
Findwen · 04/01/2023 22:13

I think this would put a whole lot of UK land, national treasures and assets in the hands of foreign nationals... not kindly ones either.

For example, you would have farmers who have huge areas of land and expensive machinery having to sell up to pay the tax bill... but who to ? Everyone else in the UK also needs to pay their wealth tax bill, so these distressed sales would go to (for example) rich oil men from Khazakstan looking to launder their money. Same for stately homes, art and rare treasures (e.g. first edition books).

Once all the UK wealthy have been shaken down and the NHS gets the billions from the Russian Oligarchs and Oil men from America, how will it pay for the following year... and the one after that ? You can only steal from the rich for so long.

FlorenceAndTheVendingMachine · 04/01/2023 22:10

Cuppasoupmonster · 04/01/2023 21:58

Then why tax anyone at all? If it’s their money not to be taken away from them?

You seem to feel entitled to their money simply because they have more of it than you.

Imagine going for a meal with your friends and saying "you're paying the bill, Rachel, because you've got more money than the rest of us".

Sunsetintheeast · 04/01/2023 22:06

That he felt creating a pleasant, safe and educated community was as beneficial to him as a living environment as it was to the people who directly benefited from his taxes. I thought that was a really benevolent but also intelligent way of looking at it

This is exactly it. Tax should be reframed. Every man and woman for themselves is a sad and miserable society. Communism doesn’t work, but neither does pure unadulterated capitalism.

I would willingly pay more tax.

Cuppasoupmonster · 04/01/2023 22:01

So by extension no, people sitting on hoarded of wealth and at loathe to ‘distribute’ any of it cannot really complain about living in a run down society. They’re only wealthy because somebody else isn’t.

OP posts:
Cuppasoupmonster · 04/01/2023 22:00

Sunsetintheeast · 04/01/2023 21:56

Ok so would higher tax on death be more acceptable? Or indeed capital gains tax if they did sell it? Both of these things happen in other countries.

I find the subject of wealth inequality interesting. Usually vast disparity of wealth in societies leads to social unrest and higher levels of violence. I personally wouldn’t want to live in a gated compound too afraid to go out. I hope the U.K. never gets to that, but if you look at the recent spate of violent robberies against footballers and other high profile celebs (Mark Cavendish I noted was a victim recently) I think the beginning of that has started to show, even in the U.K.

Absolutely. I read an article about high taxation in Scandinavian countries which was interesting, it interviewed a high earner who didn’t begrudge paying a lot of tax because he said he felt he was ‘investing in the society around him’. That he felt creating a pleasant, safe and educated community was as beneficial to him as a living environment as it was to the people who directly benefited from his taxes. I thought that was a really benevolent but also intelligent way of looking at it.

OP posts:
Sunsetintheeast · 04/01/2023 21:58

Soothsayer1 · 04/01/2023 21:52

I mean they are essential to it, but they didn’t build it
he's still stuffed if he cant get people to work for him, no-one is an island

Exactly. I think the Quakers of old got it right, well except the sobriety 😂

Cuppasoupmonster · 04/01/2023 21:58

FlorenceAndTheVendingMachine · 04/01/2023 21:54

It's still their money though.

Then why tax anyone at all? If it’s their money not to be taken away from them?

OP posts:
Sunsetintheeast · 04/01/2023 21:56

LemonSwan · 04/01/2023 21:50

Because it’s not wealth unless they sell it. It’s their home!

Ok so would higher tax on death be more acceptable? Or indeed capital gains tax if they did sell it? Both of these things happen in other countries.

I find the subject of wealth inequality interesting. Usually vast disparity of wealth in societies leads to social unrest and higher levels of violence. I personally wouldn’t want to live in a gated compound too afraid to go out. I hope the U.K. never gets to that, but if you look at the recent spate of violent robberies against footballers and other high profile celebs (Mark Cavendish I noted was a victim recently) I think the beginning of that has started to show, even in the U.K.

FlorenceAndTheVendingMachine · 04/01/2023 21:54

Cuppasoupmonster · 04/01/2023 16:51

@Songlyrics many extremely wealthy people are where they are through inheritance, family wealth or unearned gains.

It's still their money though.

Soothsayer1 · 04/01/2023 21:52

I mean they are essential to it, but they didn’t build it
he's still stuffed if he cant get people to work for him, no-one is an island

LemonSwan · 04/01/2023 21:50

Sunsetintheeast · 04/01/2023 18:05

Explain why unearned wealth is unfair?

Because it’s not wealth unless they sell it. It’s their home!

Cosmos123 · 04/01/2023 21:48

Cuppasoupmonster · 04/01/2023 16:46

To me it seems we need a one-off, enormous amount of cash. I can’t see a way of this being raised through any other means.

It will be blown and wasted by incompetent corrupt politicians.

The wealthy will afford to emigrate which they will do so we will be worse off.

So idea is not great.

Sunsetintheeast · 04/01/2023 21:34

saltinesandcoffeecups · 04/01/2023 21:17

Is Bezos paying less than minimum wage? No.. then you have no argument there. Unless I missed a news article about Amazon.

As for the minimum wage workers building an empire, I mean they are essential to it, but they didn’t build it. It’s a good thing they are able to trade their labor for part of the revenue that that company makes.

A power imbalance is the issue. Starving people will work in any conditions - look at emerging markets: kids dying under looms in material factories. Just because people face legislation in the U.K. to make them give the ‘minimum’ they can get away with, doesn’t mean it’s right.

Jeff Bezoz(only an example, there are many) pays less tax than the people he employs. How can that be right for society?

If you don’t honestly think that billions of pounds that has never faced tax, that benefits no one except Jeff and his yet unproduced progeny should not face some redistribution to redress the power imbalance, fair enough. I can’t see how else you deal with the divide of the rich getting richer and the poor getting poorer.

I’m OK as I have skills that are highly sort. When I’m eventually replaced by a computer, I’ll join the growing under class.

Are you on the top or soon joining the underclass? I can tell you raw capitalism is a dream that fewer and fewer will be part of.

ImaginaryDragon · 04/01/2023 21:17

YABU - Revenue raising needs something better and more sustainable than a wealth tax. It's just really the squeezed middle being shafted again.

What is wealth anyway?
According to the article linked '‘Wealth’ would be defined to cover all assets (including homes and pensions)' According to many people on Mumsnet and in RL it just seems to be anyone earning more than them. This is the usual heavy handed, indiscriminate and grabby approach to revenue raising IMO.
People wont have to worry about the very wealthy signing up to this, they have the best tax advisors, wealth managers and accountants and can exploit every legal loophole known to man. There would be war if people were told they were going to pay a one off/ additional tax on on their future income, let alone future income which is not guaranteed.

-One off/additional tax your main home - We have that already, its called Stamp Duty and it is based on the value of the house at purchase. Houses and pensions go up and down in value. Nor does your home necessarily correlate to your earnings if you have bought and sold well. Will any tax adjust for this discrepancy, no, too complicated as we saw with child benefit when they introduced salary limits. Will we get a refund if the sale price is lower at the point of sale if we down size? Not likely!

-One off/additional tax on pensions?
Great idea with the huge pension black hole we are hurtling towards.

The discussion of taxes should always go hand in hand with discussions on spending and accountability otherwise it's good money after bad. Most people don't mind paying a fair amount of tax they object to an unfair tax burden and inefficient spending. Lets face it the government's record on spending is hardly amazing. Track and trace, anyone? PPE?

saltinesandcoffeecups · 04/01/2023 21:17

Sunsetintheeast · 04/01/2023 21:01

Minimum wage jobs to build one of the biggest empires the world has ever seen? Really you think that’s right?

You do realise that without minimum wage legislation people would be exploited to below the ability to live. Look at history.

Is Bezos paying less than minimum wage? No.. then you have no argument there. Unless I missed a news article about Amazon.

As for the minimum wage workers building an empire, I mean they are essential to it, but they didn’t build it. It’s a good thing they are able to trade their labor for part of the revenue that that company makes.

CMZ2018 · 04/01/2023 21:02

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Sunsetintheeast · 04/01/2023 21:01

saltinesandcoffeecups · 04/01/2023 20:40

So those workers get nothing?

Oh yeah, that’s right they get a wage in exchange for their labor. Seems fair to me.

Minimum wage jobs to build one of the biggest empires the world has ever seen? Really you think that’s right?

You do realise that without minimum wage legislation people would be exploited to below the ability to live. Look at history.

underneaththeash · 04/01/2023 21:01

Cuppasoupmonster · 04/01/2023 16:51

@Songlyrics many extremely wealthy people are where they are through inheritance, family wealth or unearned gains.

I live in beaconsfield which is one of the wealthiest towns in the U.K. - average house price is 1.1 million. Almost everyone I know here went to a normal comp, made sound decisions and worked hard.
we already pay a massive amount of tax - why more?

saltinesandcoffeecups · 04/01/2023 20:40

Sunsetintheeast · 04/01/2023 20:05

Surely wealth built on the sweat and suppression of others, that couldn’t be achieved without those people, should be taxed - if they’re not going to share their gains.

Jeff Bezoz couldn’t be successful without his work force. The value in his company remains UNTAXED until he sells shares. He’s one of the richest men on earth and his tax bill is proportionately small.

There are many like him.

So those workers get nothing?

Oh yeah, that’s right they get a wage in exchange for their labor. Seems fair to me.

FloydPepper · 04/01/2023 20:37

BlueBellIris · 04/01/2023 20:17

The problem in this country is most people think tax increases are good if it doesn’t impact them.

I have no problem with a wealth tax. Me and DH are high earners, but we come from working class backgrounds. No help with deposits etc. We’ve chosen to send the children to private school so compared to lots of our contemporaries we have a relatively small house and big mortgage. Low assets.

My friend who is a SAHM, husband high earner, with a lovely house (huge help with deposit) and Trust that pays kids school fees would think a wealth tax is outrageous and we should just tax high earners a bit more.

And then we have those who just shout “tax Amazon more” and forget we are in a global economy and it’s not like loads of other countries get lots of tax from them.

People like tax increases that don’t impact them

I have no problem with a wealth tax

[we have] low assets

Sunsetintheeast · 04/01/2023 20:19

EngTech · 04/01/2023 20:15

At what level is a wealth tax triggered ?

It will hit the very people that need help and I would consider retiring if I felt it was not worth workin 😳

Over £5m would be my suggestion and then only unearned assets or gains.

Swipe left for the next trending thread