Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is a wealth tax the only way?

356 replies

Cuppasoupmonster · 04/01/2023 16:36

…of raising capital for proper public service reform and not just sticking plaster ‘solutions’. Just interested to hear others thoughts.

YANBU = yes it is
YABU = no it isn’t

OP posts:
Sunsetintheeast · 05/01/2023 08:41

LemonSwan · 04/01/2023 22:57

It’s already 40%. How much higher do you want IHT to be?

And do countries with capital gains also pay stamp duty?

I am not against higher taxes. But taxes should be at the point of earning. You shouldn’t be taxed extra because your good at saving your money and putting it away rather than frittering it away. My parents have never earns mega bucks. My mum was one of six who grew up on a farm in rural Scotland and my dad the son of two poor people who grew up crammed into back to backs in the Midlands. They worked hard and made good choices. And now live on a gated street next to footballers. That’s social mobility if I ever knew it.

Well in many European countries IHT is much higher. It is seen as divisive and anti society, which in many ways it is.

Stamp duty doesn’t exist in US, but property tax is higher - weirdly!

I too will inherit a large estate (c£5m) how lucky am I? Should I be allowed to be this lucky? It certainly won’t benefit anyone apart from my DC and DGC.

If we don’t want higher taxes, we need to stop pretending we are European in service levels, whilst taxing like the US. Give up on our European attitudes and let the market rule. Half of the outraged middle on here may well sink. That’s capitalism for you!

First. Shut the NHS, bring in the market.

Second. Stop funding schools nationally. Reorg school funding so local taxes can be applied so we start funding the schools are kids attend. My kids school will
improve no end.

Third. Stop taxes at the higher rates and stop limiting pension funds to a £1m ceiling.

Cut labour controls so you can hire and fire at will, irrelevant to time served. No statutory minimums.

Cut benefits after 12 weeks. Get a job.

This free market thing is great. We will be booming very soon.

Mark19735 · 05/01/2023 07:46

You do know that corporations don't actually exist, don't you. They are a legal fiction. Every corporation has owners - usually shareholders. Sometimes there are several layers of ownership, and the true ownership is disguised or diluted through investment funds, but behind each of them are individual people. People with ISAs, people with pensions, people with investment trusts, people with share options.

Taxing corporations is morally and conceptually no different to taxing people.

StressedUpToMyEyeballs · 05/01/2023 06:51

Tax dodging corporations are where the money's at.
Wealthy individuals tend to spend money and that keeps businesses going so I'd be cautious with that. We need to make sure enough people have disposable income to spend.
Again, it's all about large multinational corporations! Heavily taxing wealthy or middle-earning individual is ideological more than anything.

Cuppasoupmonster · 05/01/2023 03:57

LemonSwan · 05/01/2023 00:15

Haha what! You want to discourage saving. You think people should be penalised for saving. You think my parents shouldn’t have saved their money to pay off their mortgage and finally buy their home outright 🤣🤣🤣

Some people are unfortunately poor through no fault of their own. You OP will be poor because you think someone else owes you everything and you take no responsibility.

Yes that’s exactly what I think, word for word 🙄 the paraphrasing on here is something else! Fortunately I’m not poor (nor am I wealthy).

OP posts:
ErrolTheDragon · 05/01/2023 00:43

Saving money isn’t a good thing for society, as it is just sat there and not in circulation.

It's not 'just sat there'. It's in building societies providing mortgages, banks providing finance, invested in companies to allow them to grow.

LemonSwan · 05/01/2023 00:15

Cuppasoupmonster · 04/01/2023 22:59

You shouldn’t be taxed extra because your good at saving your money and putting it away rather than frittering it away.

Why? Saving money isn’t a good thing for society, as it is just sat there and not in circulation. ‘Frittering’ money away means it is recirculating.

Haha what! You want to discourage saving. You think people should be penalised for saving. You think my parents shouldn’t have saved their money to pay off their mortgage and finally buy their home outright 🤣🤣🤣

Some people are unfortunately poor through no fault of their own. You OP will be poor because you think someone else owes you everything and you take no responsibility.

jcyclops · 05/01/2023 00:05

A little bit of background (copied from last year's thread on this subject, which was copied from 2020's thread):

Austria, Denmark, Finland, France, Germany, Iceland, Ireland, Italy, the Netherlands, Luxembourg, and Sweden all had wealth taxes and abolished them, leaving Norway, Spain, and Switzerland as the only countries that still have one.

France (which is the most heavily taxed country in Europe, a major reason being the retirement age of 62) keeps toying with the idea. Up to 2017 (when they mainly abolished it), 10,000 French citizens had left France taking 35 billion euros with them over the previous 15 years.

The rich find wealth taxes easy to avoid. If for example, farmland is exempt from a wealth tax, the rich purchase lots of exempt farmland, borrowing heavily to do so. The borrowing reduces the net worth of their other taxable assets.

Labour tried very hard to introduce a wealth tax in the 1970s. Denis Healey said "We had committed ourselves to a Wealth Tax; but in five years I found it impossible to draft one which would yield enough revenue to be worth the administrative cost and political hassle."

Twentypast · 04/01/2023 23:54

Cuppasoupmonster · 04/01/2023 22:59

You shouldn’t be taxed extra because your good at saving your money and putting it away rather than frittering it away.

Why? Saving money isn’t a good thing for society, as it is just sat there and not in circulation. ‘Frittering’ money away means it is recirculating.

My savings mean should I need a care home, the state won't need to pay for it.

Soothsayer1 · 04/01/2023 23:11

I can confidently predict that no amount of marketing will change the UK mindset to a Scandinavian one
I dont know if you are right @MigsandTiggs, but even if fairness is unachievable I think we still have to push for it or things will get even more unfair. Power laws and the like mean that money will always attract more money, a bit like gravity....but we still have to try and push in the other direction! (imo)

MigsandTiggs · 04/01/2023 23:01

Sunsetintheeast · 04/01/2023 22:26

Perhaps this is a marketing issue then that @Mark19735 said we should consider.

I can confidently predict that no amount of marketing will change the UK mindset to a Scandinavian one. It has taken many centuries for Nordic countries to reach the point where they believe that the individual benefits when the whole of society benefits.

What they have is a symbiotic relationship between government and people working to achieve their social, economic and political aims. Nordic countries not only have a tradition of, but more importantly, the means to fund social investments that link economic, labour market, welfare and social policies in a joined up effort.

I don't see Brits ever converting to the "all in" Nordic way of communal responsibility. The opposite of which is the ultra individualistic "Tax is theft" brigade in the USA.

Cuppasoupmonster · 04/01/2023 22:59

You shouldn’t be taxed extra because your good at saving your money and putting it away rather than frittering it away.

Why? Saving money isn’t a good thing for society, as it is just sat there and not in circulation. ‘Frittering’ money away means it is recirculating.

OP posts:
Cuppasoupmonster · 04/01/2023 22:58

FlorenceAndTheVendingMachine · 04/01/2023 22:42

And yet you can't actually answer it properly....

Answer what? You didn’t ask anything.

OP posts:
Sunsetintheeast · 04/01/2023 22:57

saltinesandcoffeecups · 04/01/2023 22:51

Might I suggest you pick one thing to debate, you’re trying to cover climate change, globalization, capitalism, equality, and technology in one post. This is after leading with wealth inequality and workers rights. All of this in a thread about taxation and wealth redistribution.

Perhaps if you focused on one or maybe two of those topics you would get some takers for your debate.

For the record that debate won’t be with me, as I already know the answer to the only question that I would ask, thereby ending the debate. “Do your employees earn the same as you and profit the same as you do from your business?”

But good luck with the topic, sadly it’s interesting, but no one ever moves from their starting position and the same tropes get pulled out over and over again.

Er sort of like economics, innit. Can’t tax what isn’t there. The whole lots linked.

Anyway, I said I’m not a communist, so no, but our earnings are single multiples of each other and I’m the MD

Anyway. I’m off too

LemonSwan · 04/01/2023 22:57

Sunsetintheeast · 04/01/2023 21:56

Ok so would higher tax on death be more acceptable? Or indeed capital gains tax if they did sell it? Both of these things happen in other countries.

I find the subject of wealth inequality interesting. Usually vast disparity of wealth in societies leads to social unrest and higher levels of violence. I personally wouldn’t want to live in a gated compound too afraid to go out. I hope the U.K. never gets to that, but if you look at the recent spate of violent robberies against footballers and other high profile celebs (Mark Cavendish I noted was a victim recently) I think the beginning of that has started to show, even in the U.K.

It’s already 40%. How much higher do you want IHT to be?

And do countries with capital gains also pay stamp duty?

I am not against higher taxes. But taxes should be at the point of earning. You shouldn’t be taxed extra because your good at saving your money and putting it away rather than frittering it away. My parents have never earns mega bucks. My mum was one of six who grew up on a farm in rural Scotland and my dad the son of two poor people who grew up crammed into back to backs in the Midlands. They worked hard and made good choices. And now live on a gated street next to footballers. That’s social mobility if I ever knew it.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 04/01/2023 22:51

Sunsetintheeast · 04/01/2023 22:42

Not too all. Innovative people are needed, but equity imbalance poisons society. Look around the world. I don’t want to live in a country where people rely on food banks, people are in fuel poverty and a days work doesn’t feed a family. How would you solve the cost of living crisis?
Globalisation is turning into a race to the bottom and many people live on rubbish dumps around the world, that’s not where I want to be.

You may be able to adapt, good for you but AI might be harder to out run than you think. I think there is an issue with unfettered capitalism. Is your position that everything is right with the direction of travel?

I’m a business owner and I want to treat my employees fairly. I don’t believe on stepping on others backs to climb higher. Every time we make a bigger profit, we all share in it. Am I a sucker?

Might I suggest you pick one thing to debate, you’re trying to cover climate change, globalization, capitalism, equality, and technology in one post. This is after leading with wealth inequality and workers rights. All of this in a thread about taxation and wealth redistribution.

Perhaps if you focused on one or maybe two of those topics you would get some takers for your debate.

For the record that debate won’t be with me, as I already know the answer to the only question that I would ask, thereby ending the debate. “Do your employees earn the same as you and profit the same as you do from your business?”

But good luck with the topic, sadly it’s interesting, but no one ever moves from their starting position and the same tropes get pulled out over and over again.

Mark19735 · 04/01/2023 22:47

Rich people enjoy status. They like paying more for stuff to demonstrate their wealth. See, for example, designer clothes. Or jewels. Or fine art. Or racehorses. Or those silent auctions at corporate events where daft people shell out £500 for a cream tea to show off how rich they are.

Funny how the same doesn't apply to taxes.

You should be able to chose your tax rate. Basic rates, for basic people. Higher rates, for higher folk. That could then be your formal designation and title, so you can show off to everyone how rich you are ... like an HRH ... Higher Rate Hero.

caringcarer · 04/01/2023 22:42

No, an alternative way is to allow say £20,000 freepay of tax then 25 percent above this rate for all. Cut out benefits for people who work less than 24 hours each week except for disabled. Offer free childcare up to 25 hours for those working 24 hours per week and subsidised childcare from 26-32 hours per week for all children over 3 months and up to school age. More employment coaches to help people back into work.

Sunsetintheeast · 04/01/2023 22:42

saltinesandcoffeecups · 04/01/2023 22:32

What we’re trying to debate. All I’m seeing is “Rich Man Bad”.

Not too all. Innovative people are needed, but equity imbalance poisons society. Look around the world. I don’t want to live in a country where people rely on food banks, people are in fuel poverty and a days work doesn’t feed a family. How would you solve the cost of living crisis?
Globalisation is turning into a race to the bottom and many people live on rubbish dumps around the world, that’s not where I want to be.

You may be able to adapt, good for you but AI might be harder to out run than you think. I think there is an issue with unfettered capitalism. Is your position that everything is right with the direction of travel?

I’m a business owner and I want to treat my employees fairly. I don’t believe on stepping on others backs to climb higher. Every time we make a bigger profit, we all share in it. Am I a sucker?

FlorenceAndTheVendingMachine · 04/01/2023 22:42

Cuppasoupmonster · 04/01/2023 22:14

Oh please 😂 if that’s your best ‘equivalent scenario’ then you’re not really up to this debate are you.

And yet you can't actually answer it properly....

saltinesandcoffeecups · 04/01/2023 22:32

Sunsetintheeast · 04/01/2023 22:29

I was trying to have a considered debate, perhaps test ideas and see how things ‘could be’, but clearly you’re not up to it.

oh well.

What we’re trying to debate. All I’m seeing is “Rich Man Bad”.

DomesticShortHair · 04/01/2023 22:32

Cuppasoupmonster · 04/01/2023 22:14

Oh please 😂 if that’s your best ‘equivalent scenario’ then you’re not really up to this debate are you.

Well, she isn’t 12 years old, if that what you mean.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 04/01/2023 22:31

Soothsayer1 · 04/01/2023 21:52

I mean they are essential to it, but they didn’t build it
he's still stuffed if he cant get people to work for him, no-one is an island

Clearly, which is why it’s in his best interest to pay a market rate for them. If Amazon finds itself not able to fill jobs, they’ll increase wages and benefits.

Sunsetintheeast · 04/01/2023 22:29

saltinesandcoffeecups · 04/01/2023 22:27

I didn’t realize Elizabeth Warren was on mumsnet… I think Elon needs to find out who Bezo’s accountant is. I think Musk ended up paying $11B In taxes last year.

as to your other rant… nah I’m not worried about being replaced by a computer. I’ll grow and change as needed to keep relevant, until I retire if someone hasn’t stolen redistributed my retirement funds

I was trying to have a considered debate, perhaps test ideas and see how things ‘could be’, but clearly you’re not up to it.

oh well.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 04/01/2023 22:27

Sunsetintheeast · 04/01/2023 21:34

A power imbalance is the issue. Starving people will work in any conditions - look at emerging markets: kids dying under looms in material factories. Just because people face legislation in the U.K. to make them give the ‘minimum’ they can get away with, doesn’t mean it’s right.

Jeff Bezoz(only an example, there are many) pays less tax than the people he employs. How can that be right for society?

If you don’t honestly think that billions of pounds that has never faced tax, that benefits no one except Jeff and his yet unproduced progeny should not face some redistribution to redress the power imbalance, fair enough. I can’t see how else you deal with the divide of the rich getting richer and the poor getting poorer.

I’m OK as I have skills that are highly sort. When I’m eventually replaced by a computer, I’ll join the growing under class.

Are you on the top or soon joining the underclass? I can tell you raw capitalism is a dream that fewer and fewer will be part of.

I didn’t realize Elizabeth Warren was on mumsnet… I think Elon needs to find out who Bezo’s accountant is. I think Musk ended up paying $11B In taxes last year.

as to your other rant… nah I’m not worried about being replaced by a computer. I’ll grow and change as needed to keep relevant, until I retire if someone hasn’t stolen redistributed my retirement funds

Sunsetintheeast · 04/01/2023 22:26

MigsandTiggs · 04/01/2023 22:24

"Absolutely. I read an article about high taxation in Scandinavian countries which was interesting, it interviewed a high earner who didn’t begrudge paying a lot of tax because he said he felt he was ‘investing in the society around him’. That he felt creating a pleasant, safe and educated community was as beneficial to him as a living environment as it was to the people who directly benefited from his taxes. I thought that was a really benevolent but also intelligent way of looking at it." OP

The difference here is that we are starting from a different cultural base. Scandinavian countries believe that each person has a collective responsiblity for everyone else in society. From this ingrained belief they are willing to pay high taxes in exchange for a high level of services that benefits all of society and supports social cohesion. There is a shared, mutual respect between government and the people that does not exist in the UK.

Perhaps this is a marketing issue then that @Mark19735 said we should consider.