Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is a wealth tax the only way?

356 replies

Cuppasoupmonster · 04/01/2023 16:36

…of raising capital for proper public service reform and not just sticking plaster ‘solutions’. Just interested to hear others thoughts.

YANBU = yes it is
YABU = no it isn’t

OP posts:
Cuppasoupmonster · 05/01/2023 13:06

They wouldn’t be forced to sell, see my previous comments.

OP posts:
snowlaser · 05/01/2023 13:04

Cuppasoupmonster · 04/01/2023 18:25

@Ledwood85 you don’t ‘work for’ property gains Confused they just happen because you buy at the right time, sit back 30 years and suddenly your house is worth double what it was.

But if you're just living in it all you actually have in practice is the same one house. The value of it might have gone up in the past, but it also can go down again (prices could easily fall 10-20% this year: they fell 15% in the 2008 recession remember). Taxing people on what their house might be hypothetically worth on the day you levy your tax seems very unfair. Taxes on investment (like buy to let properties) I could understand, but on someone's main home that they are just living in seems very unfair, especially if they are forced to sell the house to pay the tax.

Scalottia · 05/01/2023 11:50

Greatly · 05/01/2023 09:28

Well, my FIL believed this and was unbelievably tight and never frittered. Was obsessed with investing and saving. Then the stock market crashed, he lost a vast percentage and then he died and 40% went in inheritance tax.

I will certainly be spending money on my hobbies, house and holidays — enjoy it while you can.

Aaah yes, I agree, and what is considered as 'frittering away money' is different for everyone. For me, I do spend on hobbies etc, but I wouldn't if it meant that I had no savings or security. I am just saying that SOME people spend money on luxuries etc that they can't afford, then are in trouble when an unexpected bill comes along. This frustrates me because then they depend on others to help them out.

I also don't trust the stockmarket and don't really invest anything there - too risky for me.

AreOttersJustWetCats · 05/01/2023 11:44

Also, every single time that public sector pensions have been downgraded in the past (which has happened many times, chipping away gradually over the years), pay has not been increased to compensate.

If you think we have massive staff shortages in the public sector now, it's nothing compared to what we'd see if the governmt carries on with the cuts to pay/ conditions/ benefits that have been seen over the last 12 yrs.

AreOttersJustWetCats · 05/01/2023 11:41

I can guarantee that if public sector pensions were downgraded, the government would not be increasing public sector pay to compensate.

For a start, salary has to be paid now (so it is a pressure on current budgets), whereas the reduction in pension payments will only have an impact in 20, 30 year's time. If they did increase pay, they'd be hit with a short/medium term double whammy of having to fundthe current pensions (which have already accrued) plus the increased salary bill for current workers.

Climatic123 · 05/01/2023 11:21

That would be great! But it’s not what you get. For your 10% contribution (university also pays in 20%) get guaranteed maximum. £500 in retirement each year for every year that you worked in the university. So if you work for 20 years you get £10k a year in retirement, but as I said, this is the maximum and assumes for every year of your working life you earned at least £40k. If you are on £20k you would get £5k a year for your 20 years of working.

this may seem ok if you are on a poor defined contribution scheme, but the university pays well, well below private sector pay rates, so you get a private sector pension on public sector pay.

ImaginaryDragon · 05/01/2023 11:13

Climatic123 · 05/01/2023 10:56

The university sector has the past year or so downgraded their defined benefits pension scheme to make it no better than the average defined contribution scheme without giving compensatory pay rises. This is why the lecturers are striking.

but it makes sense for universities to divest themselves of the risk of defined benefit schemes which hampers their ability to give reasonable rises to current staff members.

80% of final salary for life, providing you have done the requisite number of years doesn't really seem much of a downgrade.

Climatic123 · 05/01/2023 10:56

AreOttersJustWetCats · 05/01/2023 10:21

It would also lead to even poorer recruitment/retention in the public sector though. My public sector role pays about 30-40% less than the equivalent private sector (I used to be private sector, so know this for sure, and it would be easy for me to move back across). I've done the maths and worked out that the pension and flexibility makes it worth it, but if the pension was taken away I'd simply leave.

The university sector has the past year or so downgraded their defined benefits pension scheme to make it no better than the average defined contribution scheme without giving compensatory pay rises. This is why the lecturers are striking.

but it makes sense for universities to divest themselves of the risk of defined benefit schemes which hampers their ability to give reasonable rises to current staff members.

AreOttersJustWetCats · 05/01/2023 10:45

all sectors to be able to accrue a baseline defined benefits pension

This is kind of what NI credits already do, surely?

ErrolTheDragon · 05/01/2023 10:27

The equitable solution might be for all sectors to be able to accrue a baseline defined benefits pension and then be able to choose to have a personal pension on top. No idea how that would work in practice!

AreOttersJustWetCats · 05/01/2023 10:21

It would also lead to even poorer recruitment/retention in the public sector though. My public sector role pays about 30-40% less than the equivalent private sector (I used to be private sector, so know this for sure, and it would be easy for me to move back across). I've done the maths and worked out that the pension and flexibility makes it worth it, but if the pension was taken away I'd simply leave.

Climatic123 · 05/01/2023 10:19

ErrolTheDragon · 05/01/2023 10:13

Putting public sector pensions on a more equivalent basis to everyone else might make some people realise just how much they're worth. Tbh it's not just the money that's valuable - it's the certainty. Not having to worry as you see the value of your hard-saved pension funds erode during crises, not having to manage them, worrying about what may happen with the LTA. Of course, it'd be better if everyone could access a decent secure defined benefits pension, but as that's unlikely I wish people would stop blithely proposing yet more attacks on personal pensions.

Yup, 100%. Get rid of defined benefit public sector schemes and use that money to increase public sector wages for those working in the public sector today.

ErrolTheDragon · 05/01/2023 10:13

SueVineer · 05/01/2023 09:57

by far the highest pension wealth is in public sector pensions, many of which are unfunded. We could save a huge amount by closing these and making all pensions defined contribution in the public sector.

Putting public sector pensions on a more equivalent basis to everyone else might make some people realise just how much they're worth. Tbh it's not just the money that's valuable - it's the certainty. Not having to worry as you see the value of your hard-saved pension funds erode during crises, not having to manage them, worrying about what may happen with the LTA. Of course, it'd be better if everyone could access a decent secure defined benefits pension, but as that's unlikely I wish people would stop blithely proposing yet more attacks on personal pensions.

SueVineer · 05/01/2023 10:05

StressedUpToMyEyeballs · 05/01/2023 06:51

Tax dodging corporations are where the money's at.
Wealthy individuals tend to spend money and that keeps businesses going so I'd be cautious with that. We need to make sure enough people have disposable income to spend.
Again, it's all about large multinational corporations! Heavily taxing wealthy or middle-earning individual is ideological more than anything.

companies already pay a huge amount of tax in the uK and globally. They also spend money, not least by employing people. International tax is complex but generally we can’t tax all global companies profits in the uK as they pay taxes elsewhere (and some have no connection with the uK at all). We are not the only country in the world you know!

generally we have very many rules to ensure we get our share of international companies profits and they do pay up and finance a great deal of uK government spending. The idea that there are easy tax “loopholes” is an utter myth. There are a great many highly qualified people working in this area ensuring tax is paid by large companies already.

SueVineer · 05/01/2023 09:57

by far the highest pension wealth is in public sector pensions, many of which are unfunded. We could save a huge amount by closing these and making all pensions defined contribution in the public sector.

SueVineer · 05/01/2023 09:51

SeenAndNot · 04/01/2023 16:45

Of course it isn’t. We could start with taxing multi billion dollars corporations first.

We could also invest in our economy and make investors and high tax earners want to live/work here.

The problem with this being we already tax “multi billion dollar corporations” - at least those with activities in the uK.

AreOttersJustWetCats · 05/01/2023 09:45

Greatly · 05/01/2023 09:28

Well, my FIL believed this and was unbelievably tight and never frittered. Was obsessed with investing and saving. Then the stock market crashed, he lost a vast percentage and then he died and 40% went in inheritance tax.

I will certainly be spending money on my hobbies, house and holidays — enjoy it while you can.

I agree. Having enough in the bank for a rainy day is sensible, but some people lose perspective about how much they actually need and save endlessly for a future that they never actually get to enjoy. I know too many people who have died relatively young - far better to use your money to enjoy life while you are healthy (within reason).

sst1234 · 05/01/2023 09:44

Wealth taxes do not work. If you actually stick your head out of Twitter and maybe look at some serious news on past economic policies in different countries, you will see that wealth taxes never work. People can, and do leave. Sure you may hate the rich, but they don’t care much for your hatred when they can just up and leave.

Francois Hollande introduced wealth taxes in 2012 in France and 16,000 millionaires deserted France, taking their taxes with them. Macron came to power and reversed the policy, calling France ‘Cuba without the sun’.

Threads like this make it clear that the reason we are in a mess is because the electorate knows about Love Island than how the economy works. So instead of holding the government to account on the economy, they spout nonsense like wealth taxes.

sst1234 · 05/01/2023 09:39

Cuppasoupmonster · 04/01/2023 16:39

Well, what else would raise the enormous amount needed for full reform of the NHS, transport and education?

Errrr, I don’t know, how about growth that’s better than 1% a year. Or better still, not being in recession.

I know, it’s crazy, right? How a bit of economic growth balances the books and automatically raised more tax. But never mind, who needs growth when you can tax your way deeper into a recursion and then ask ‘are wealth taxes the only way’.

Greatly · 05/01/2023 09:28

Scalottia · 05/01/2023 09:04

Exactly. Someone who works and already pays taxes, budgets better and saves more money or invests wisely should be penalised? Why should they pay more just because they are good in financial planning?

Frittering money away on pointless crap is just financial stupidity. Yet I see it with people all the time...then an emergency occurs and they don't have enough savings.

Well, my FIL believed this and was unbelievably tight and never frittered. Was obsessed with investing and saving. Then the stock market crashed, he lost a vast percentage and then he died and 40% went in inheritance tax.

I will certainly be spending money on my hobbies, house and holidays — enjoy it while you can.

RoseAdagio · 05/01/2023 09:27

"Wealth tax" is not a realistic, or fair, solution here, not least because in many cases it would amount to double taxation...

You do realise a lot of people you would consider rich, ie high net worth individuals, actually have much of their "wealth" tied up in assets where they cannot get the money out to pay tax on it? You mention pensions for eg. There are severe tax penalties if you are forced to withdraw money from your pension fund before you are 55. And plenty of wealthy people have much of their net worth tied up in their home. What if the only way they can afford to pay your one off huge tax bill is to sell their house?!

People with multiple properties will already be paying income tax on their rental income from said properties in all likelihood. They will definitely pay CGT on any profits if they sell said properties. Income from investments is still income and therefore income tax is payable on it.

Scalottia · 05/01/2023 09:04

Cuppasoupmonster · 04/01/2023 22:59

You shouldn’t be taxed extra because your good at saving your money and putting it away rather than frittering it away.

Why? Saving money isn’t a good thing for society, as it is just sat there and not in circulation. ‘Frittering’ money away means it is recirculating.

Exactly. Someone who works and already pays taxes, budgets better and saves more money or invests wisely should be penalised? Why should they pay more just because they are good in financial planning?

Frittering money away on pointless crap is just financial stupidity. Yet I see it with people all the time...then an emergency occurs and they don't have enough savings.

pocketvenuss · 05/01/2023 08:55

Violashift · 04/01/2023 17:09

penalise people who have worked hard enough, saved hard enough etc. to hold assets and funds. And let people who routinely blow all their money off the hook?

This is an ignorant comment.

No more ignorant than suggesting that people with money gained it through inheritance or nasty business practices. Truth is both statement are true for some and ridiculous for others.

pocketvenuss · 05/01/2023 08:52

Cuppasoupmonster · 04/01/2023 16:51

@Songlyrics many extremely wealthy people are where they are through inheritance, family wealth or unearned gains.

And many are wealthy through hard work, sacrifice and years of dedication.
It wouldn't work. You suggest £1.5m. Many people in the SE have assets above this due to their property values increasing. They haven't got the income to pay a wealth tax. They can't sell up to pay because then they won't be able ti rebuy where they live and work. In any case I very much doubt you are suggesting people have to sell their home to pay a one off tax. Someone with assets if £2m in Hull may indeed have the ability to pay without sacrificing their home. Someone in Wandsworth might not. It's just not feasible to blanket tax people over a certain asset threshold. All assets are not equal

Climatic123 · 05/01/2023 08:51

Stamp duty is the very worst tax. Taxing people for moving house? It’s bonkers! People move house for good reasons and we need to encourage them to do so.

and tax dodging corporations? What they are doing is perfectly legal! It will remain perfectly legal until countries all over the world decide together that companies should no longer be able to shift profits to the county with the lowest corporation tax rate. The OECD is doing the work on this right now. Ever heard of Pillar 2 / BEPS? No UK government could legislate to make companies pay more tax without the OECD cooperation. It just doesn’t work like that.