Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is a wealth tax the only way?

356 replies

Cuppasoupmonster · 04/01/2023 16:36

…of raising capital for proper public service reform and not just sticking plaster ‘solutions’. Just interested to hear others thoughts.

YANBU = yes it is
YABU = no it isn’t

OP posts:
healthadvice123 · 05/01/2023 15:53

No absolutely not it would force people from their homes
My parents for example live in a nice 3 bed house that they worked there arses if for but its worth money like all houses but all they have is their pensions to live on , how would those and people like them pay tax
Also if rich people would up and leave to live elsewhere

AreOttersJustWetCats · 05/01/2023 15:53

I find it quite patronising that you assume that public sector workers couldn't possibly realise what private sector work is like. That may be true for some careers that are only really found in the public sector, but not for most in my experience.

AreOttersJustWetCats · 05/01/2023 15:51

Trianglesquarerectangle · 05/01/2023 15:47

Yes flexibility. Another day, another dollar.

If you work in many of those private practices they will probably give you a higher wage because you need to be on call over weekends, or stay late so you can't pick up your little cherub at 4pm. If you count up the extra overtime they do, that "day rate" probably drops quite a lot.

I've worked in private practice before, so Im familiar with it. It's common for people in these sorts of roles as having experience in different sectors can be very good for employability. E.g. Having experience at a government regulator is really useful if you then go into consulting in the regulated industry.

All jobs have their upsides and downsides. But if the pension goes, the public sector will lose its main upside, and will therefore lose people. Public services will get even worse.

Trianglesquarerectangle · 05/01/2023 15:47

Yes flexibility. Another day, another dollar.

If you work in many of those private practices they will probably give you a higher wage because you need to be on call over weekends, or stay late so you can't pick up your little cherub at 4pm. If you count up the extra overtime they do, that "day rate" probably drops quite a lot.

AreOttersJustWetCats · 05/01/2023 15:42

There are lots of e.g. lawyers in the public sector who accept the lower pay because the pension and flexibility is good. Remove the pension, and suddenly the private sector package looks significantly better.

AreOttersJustWetCats · 05/01/2023 15:40

Trianglesquarerectangle · 05/01/2023 14:17

Where do you get that 30% from?! I am genuinely interested - that's not a dig.

And do you think that anyone in the private sector is getting some kind of magic rise? If they do, it's because the business has made money because people have gone out to find more contracts/more business. It's not because the Govt is just throwing more at it so people don't strike.

The 30% increase is what the equivalent private sector pay is for my specialism. I can't comment on others, but it's likely to be similar for anyone working a career that has directly comparable roles in both the public and private sectors (and there are lots of them: accounting, tax, HR, project management, law, IT, procurement, commercial...).

Cuppasoupmonster · 05/01/2023 15:23

oioimatey · 05/01/2023 14:17

So somebody who bought their house in what is now considered to be a nice part of London working as an office clerk back in 1978 for £13k (four times their salary at the time) now has to pay an enormous tax because their house is now worth £1.4m?

That's a real life example, by the way. Please tell me how that would work in practice.

It wouldn’t be payable until the house was liquidised aka sold. You can argue it’s not ‘fair’ but then you could argue tax per se isn’t fair.

OP posts:
Trianglesquarerectangle · 05/01/2023 15:10

And you realise that some of the owners of said shareholders are pension funds that, astonishingly enough, don't only fund the pensions of millionaires, but little old ladies too?

On the schools/healthcare/CJS point, which services are run privately by which schools in the state sector? I can't find the data and I am genuinely interested as it would be good to know.

Can you also tell me what percentage of business this represents cos i think the point you were originally making was it doesn't matter if businesses have to pay more for the pensions for their workers compared to the public sector, cos the majority of businesses are skimming profits off the Govt anyway so anything you do spend on pensions is actually public money too?

Transferwaiting · 05/01/2023 14:51

Transferwaiting · 05/01/2023 14:51

That's not what I'm talking about. I'm talking about schools/healthcare/CJS services having to buy in privately owned ones such as payroll/IT/HR/ because those services are no longer provided centrally. It costs a lot more and ultimately it's still just the Government funding them but just paying the profits to shareholders too. Serco for instance who recorded a £230 million trading profit.

Trianglesquarerectangle

Transferwaiting · 05/01/2023 14:51

That's not what I'm talking about. I'm talking about schools/healthcare/CJS services having to buy in privately owned ones such as payroll/IT/HR/ because those services are no longer provided centrally. It costs a lot more and ultimately it's still just the Government funding them but just paying the profits to shareholders too. Serco for instance who recorded a £230 million trading profit.

Trianglesquarerectangle · 05/01/2023 14:48

@Limer Yes, in principle. The problem you have is that I remember one thread on here where people were being discouraged to give tomatoes to food banks on the principle that the poorest wouldn't have the money to run the hob to cook them. Therefore, you introduce a tax on what might be seen as "convenience foods" (let's say the pot noodle) and suddenly it's a tax on those who can't afford to buy anything other than, or the "processed food" because poorer people want more bang for their buck and politicians are out of touch. That's what happened to Osborne with his pasty tax.

Trianglesquarerectangle · 05/01/2023 14:40

@Transferwaiting I assume you are talking about the sale of publicly owned assets to private investors. As it goes these industries remain highly regulated – in several, regulators set the prices companies can charge and the amount they are expected to invest. Tbh though, I am not against the nationalisation of some of those services, if people understood that actually then it would be the Govt purse that would have to pay for them to be maintained ie: in 2019 the water companies invested £8bn in infrastructure. So that would something else the Govt would have to pay out for that they don't currently.

What it might be worth you remembering though is that corporation tax brought in almost £63bn last year and micro businesses brought in a turnover of £808bn by themselves. Having less than 9 employees probably means they aren't doing business in "devolved services". They are running shops, factories, tech, or some other such thing. The idea that they deserve to be hammered because a few are doing business in something you view as "bad" is not really sensible.

Transferwaiting · 05/01/2023 14:25

Trianglesquarerectangle · 05/01/2023 14:17

Where do you get that 30% from?! I am genuinely interested - that's not a dig.

And do you think that anyone in the private sector is getting some kind of magic rise? If they do, it's because the business has made money because people have gone out to find more contracts/more business. It's not because the Govt is just throwing more at it so people don't strike.

But it's the businesses making their money from that Government money too. Who pays for the devolved services now that they've been privatised? Except now we're paying for the profits for the CEO's as well as the service itself.

Limer · 05/01/2023 14:24

I think there's scope in tinkering with VAT. Introduce a higher luxury rate (or rates) covering e.g. jewellery, classic cars, high fashion, fine art, etc. Expand the sugar tax to include more foods. Introduce VAT on high-calorie junk and ultra-processed foods.

VAT is easy to collect - the nation's accountants already do it on behalf of the government.

Trianglesquarerectangle · 05/01/2023 14:17

Where do you get that 30% from?! I am genuinely interested - that's not a dig.

And do you think that anyone in the private sector is getting some kind of magic rise? If they do, it's because the business has made money because people have gone out to find more contracts/more business. It's not because the Govt is just throwing more at it so people don't strike.

oioimatey · 05/01/2023 14:17

So somebody who bought their house in what is now considered to be a nice part of London working as an office clerk back in 1978 for £13k (four times their salary at the time) now has to pay an enormous tax because their house is now worth £1.4m?

That's a real life example, by the way. Please tell me how that would work in practice.

Climatic123 · 05/01/2023 14:12

Trianglesquarerectangle · 05/01/2023 14:04

@Climatic123 So you say that every year you work in a university you get £500 a year.

So let's say you work those 20 years, and you get £10k. That pot, to guarantee that amount through retirement (of lets say 25 years) would have to be £250k strong as a basic. But that's not all as I assume it would be an equiv of the value of £10k for those years. Using a compound interest calculator to represent 2% inflation it would actually be a pot of £372k.

So, if you purely had to build that yourself as a business owner like myself, who has no one else to contribute to their pension pot, you would have to put in £18,600 a year. I accept that's not including possible gains in the stock market that I may have, but considering it's risky and can go tumbling to, for ease let's keep it a straight calculation and even if you say there is a 10% increase over that period, it would still be over £16.5k. Not exactly 10% of your salary huh.

But during that time you worked there you would have taken a 30% drop in salary from the equivalent private sector pay rate ‘because of the good pension’. Those that work in university legal departments, accountancy, HR etc are leaving in their droves because they can earn much more elsewhere. Lecturers are striking as there are few private sector equivalent roles.

Climatic123 · 05/01/2023 14:08

Thymely · 05/01/2023 14:01

The really rich find a way round all these things, it's the hard workers that managed to save a nest egg for retirement or to help their children that would get clobbered as usual. They are easy pickings, not rich enough to have fancy lawyers to protect their wealth or hide it offshore somewhere.

I used to think put more VAT on luxury goods, fancy cars, expensive jewellery, etc, or higher stamp duty on multimillion pound homes but I guess the really rich would get around those too.

Stamp duty never makes sense when you could raise council tax on ledge properties instead and not penalise people for moving house.

It would be interesting if we could all have household VAT rates. Low income asset poor household? You can have a VAT rate of 10%. High income asset rich household you can have a VAT rate of 30%. Swipe your card at the checkout to have your individual VAT rate applied. Obviously the tax system needed to administrate this id a long way off.

Trianglesquarerectangle · 05/01/2023 14:04

@Climatic123 So you say that every year you work in a university you get £500 a year.

So let's say you work those 20 years, and you get £10k. That pot, to guarantee that amount through retirement (of lets say 25 years) would have to be £250k strong as a basic. But that's not all as I assume it would be an equiv of the value of £10k for those years. Using a compound interest calculator to represent 2% inflation it would actually be a pot of £372k.

So, if you purely had to build that yourself as a business owner like myself, who has no one else to contribute to their pension pot, you would have to put in £18,600 a year. I accept that's not including possible gains in the stock market that I may have, but considering it's risky and can go tumbling to, for ease let's keep it a straight calculation and even if you say there is a 10% increase over that period, it would still be over £16.5k. Not exactly 10% of your salary huh.

Thymely · 05/01/2023 14:01

The really rich find a way round all these things, it's the hard workers that managed to save a nest egg for retirement or to help their children that would get clobbered as usual. They are easy pickings, not rich enough to have fancy lawyers to protect their wealth or hide it offshore somewhere.

I used to think put more VAT on luxury goods, fancy cars, expensive jewellery, etc, or higher stamp duty on multimillion pound homes but I guess the really rich would get around those too.

logicisall · 05/01/2023 14:00

@Mark19735 "Taxing corporations is morally and conceptually no different to taxing people."

I flew that argument on another thread on windfall taxes for greedy energy companies. IDK why so few people have any idea of economics, fiscal policy and finance.

Tanith · 05/01/2023 13:44

I'd prefer to see a "Thieving Bastards" tax for all those greedy swindlers that made fortunes out of the Covid pandemic.
It could be extended to the liars who sold Brexit to line their own pockets, too.

LemonSwan · 05/01/2023 13:33

Sunsetintheeast · 05/01/2023 08:41

Well in many European countries IHT is much higher. It is seen as divisive and anti society, which in many ways it is.

Stamp duty doesn’t exist in US, but property tax is higher - weirdly!

I too will inherit a large estate (c£5m) how lucky am I? Should I be allowed to be this lucky? It certainly won’t benefit anyone apart from my DC and DGC.

If we don’t want higher taxes, we need to stop pretending we are European in service levels, whilst taxing like the US. Give up on our European attitudes and let the market rule. Half of the outraged middle on here may well sink. That’s capitalism for you!

First. Shut the NHS, bring in the market.

Second. Stop funding schools nationally. Reorg school funding so local taxes can be applied so we start funding the schools are kids attend. My kids school will
improve no end.

Third. Stop taxes at the higher rates and stop limiting pension funds to a £1m ceiling.

Cut labour controls so you can hire and fire at will, irrelevant to time served. No statutory minimums.

Cut benefits after 12 weeks. Get a job.

This free market thing is great. We will be booming very soon.

I haven’t a problem with you inheriting that amount.

I know what you mean about not benefiting. Whilst we probably could do with the money I would do my best not to touch it. I have a young son and unfortunately due to previous health condition not eligible for life insurance.

It gives me some comfort that’s there for him if anything awful were to happen to me.

And I am not convinced about the circulation of money being sacrosanct. Sure money needs to circulate, but sadly in the age of multi national Corps and huge umbrellas the top billionaires cream off vast amounts of our cash every time it does get circulated. Sure frittering means different things to different people but do not mistake that every time you buy something in Amazon the majority of that profit is going into Jeff bezo bank account never to see the light of day ever again. It’s a game of diminishing returns for the public.

Why should the general public be discouraged from putting away in the same way. At worst this gives them financial security and independence. At best the public is driving inflation to try to eat up some of Jeffs deep value and reduce our public debt.

Mia85 · 05/01/2023 13:18

£18k a year!

Mia85 · 05/01/2023 13:16

ImaginaryDragon · 05/01/2023 11:13

80% of final salary for life, providing you have done the requisite number of years doesn't really seem much of a downgrade.

That is not remotely close to the university pension benefit and never had been.

First it switched from a final salaray to a career average scheme years ago. Second, the benefits are far lower. The defined benefit part gives you 1/85th of your salary per year up to a cap of £40k. So even if you got a £40k job straight out of your pdD (unlikely given the casual contracts and poor treatment of young academics) the maximum you could get in your pension over a long career would be around £18 a year. Better than many people have but a very long way from where it was a decade ago and nowhere near your post.