Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is a wealth tax the only way?

356 replies

Cuppasoupmonster · 04/01/2023 16:36

…of raising capital for proper public service reform and not just sticking plaster ‘solutions’. Just interested to hear others thoughts.

YANBU = yes it is
YABU = no it isn’t

OP posts:
MigsandTiggs · 04/01/2023 17:50

Redistribution of wealth is not achieved through increased taxation unless you want to go down the socialist/communist route. Actual redistribution of wealth is achieved through increasing social mobility and having a skilled workforce. It requires an infrastructure of good education, employment opportunities and a stable/growing economy. According to interviews I heard today, young people are already pushing back on the proposal to increase Maths classes in school. We are dropping steeply in world rankings for Maths and other STE (M) subjects.

Dunelmer · 04/01/2023 17:48

People on this site talk about the perfection of Nordic model, not realising that taxes for waitresses in Norway are often 25% - whereas in the UK it is almost guaranteed that a waitress would pay almost no tax but definitely claim from the state.

So a wealth tax - sure - why not levy it on everyone with property (indifferent to whether you have a mortgage or not) - 1% flat rate.

Can you imagine? All the boomers with 600k properties, all the 80k houses on 90% mortgages.

It is just unworkable in a country where so many people are asset rich through housing but with nothing else.

Motelschmotel · 04/01/2023 17:48

I've just seen your suggested threshold is 1.5 million.

Do you live in the UK?

Have you examined wealth disparity between London and, frankly, anywhere else?

Do you have any idea what you're talking about??

Motelschmotel · 04/01/2023 17:46

You have very little grasp of economics or politics, OP.

Stepuptowardsinfinity · 04/01/2023 17:46

So how would that work then? I come from a poor background and have a small property in London worth let's say 500k that I've worked my arse off for years to pay off the mortgage. I also have a small pension pot that will give me about three thousand a year plus I have some savings for a rainy day. I'm self-employed so the savings are to cover if I'm really ill or something like that. I have an income of about £1500 a month which I can live off because I have no mortgage. I can't work more than I do because of my health. A wealth tax would mean I'd have to sell my home and probably move out of London. If I move out of London I lose my client base, my income, my support network etc. Can you honestly tell me I'm rich and can afford the tax? How the fuck am I meant to pay it?

Cuppasoupmonster · 04/01/2023 17:44

Greatly · 04/01/2023 17:33

So? Nothing wrong with inheritance. There's already a stupid amount of tax on it despite most of it stemming from previously taxed income.

No there isn’t. People do an awful lot now to avoid paying IHT. And there’s a lot wrong with enormous amounts of money (and the resulting power) staying in the hands of the same families.

OP posts:
Treeeeeeee · 04/01/2023 17:44

The biggest issue with a wealth tax is people having the ability to pay it. Say I have a million pound property in London, purchased 60 years ago, and am now on a low pension, how would I pay it? Do I need to sell my home just to pay it?

Cuppasoupmonster · 04/01/2023 17:43

BlueKaftan · 04/01/2023 17:34

Redistribution of wealth comes from employers paying a living wage, not from taxing those already paying 40% on income over £50k.

Wealth tax doesn’t factor in income

OP posts:
Cuppasoupmonster · 04/01/2023 17:43

I suppose my threshold would be 1.5 million.

OP posts:
sneezums · 04/01/2023 17:41

What a load of tosh - we pay plenty enough tax as it is - tax your earnings, tax your pension, capital gains, inheritance - money needs managing better especially in the NHS. It was never envisaged that the model as it was set up would have to stretch to pay for eye-wateringly expensive treatments and drugs.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 04/01/2023 17:41

Wishawisha · 04/01/2023 17:38

That article shows how much would be raised by a number of different thresholds.. some very low and some very high.

I’m interested in where you would set that threshold, OP?

I only briefly scanned that but that was the flaw that I could see - and of course 'rich' and 'wealthy' are highly subjective judgments until you get to the billionaire level. Probably even then.

Wishawisha · 04/01/2023 17:38

Cuppasoupmonster · 04/01/2023 16:50

That article shows how much would be raised by a number of different thresholds.. some very low and some very high.

I’m interested in where you would set that threshold, OP?

BlueKaftan · 04/01/2023 17:34

Redistribution of wealth comes from employers paying a living wage, not from taxing those already paying 40% on income over £50k.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 04/01/2023 17:34

But in the south east it could be a modest terraced house

Where I live it buys you a flat. Two bedroom if you're lucky.

Greatly · 04/01/2023 17:33

Cuppasoupmonster · 04/01/2023 16:51

@Songlyrics many extremely wealthy people are where they are through inheritance, family wealth or unearned gains.

So? Nothing wrong with inheritance. There's already a stupid amount of tax on it despite most of it stemming from previously taxed income.

edwinbear · 04/01/2023 17:32

They had a go at this in Cyrpus, it didn't end well. www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-21814325

I had an old school friend living out there at the time, she'd just sold her house to move back to the UK and had the proceeds sitting in the bank. She lost a fortune.

Calmdown14 · 04/01/2023 17:32

How would you account for regional variations? A 500k house where I live would be about six beds and on a decent plot. I count those people as rich.

But in the south east it could be a modest terraced house.

And what would be the set level of annual spending? If you don't meet it would your threshold for assets go up? I have reasonable savings because I live in a cheap house and spend very little money. Would I be taxed a second time on that money?

It's incredibly complex once you get into the detail

Wishawisha · 04/01/2023 17:31

a tax on an entity's holdings of assets. This includes the total value of personal assets, including cash, bank deposits, real estate, assets in insurance and pension plans, ownership of unincorporated businesses, financial securities, and personal trusts

cannot imagine how on earth this would be calculated or levied.

I have a friend who had a tax investigation opened against them - she didn’t owe a penny more than she’d paid but it still took months and months. She had a less complicated set up than many people and was completely honest but HMRC still took so many man hours looking into her.

I personally don’t think a wealth tax is fair but even if it were, the burden on the government and tax inspectors would be astronomical.

edwinbear · 04/01/2023 17:28

I'm sure all the public sector works, doctors, nurses, teachers etc who are sat on very valuable defined benefit pension schemes, which on paper are worth an awful lot (far more than my defined contribution scheme) will be thrilled with that idea OP. A GP with a £1m pension pot (which is quite feasible) will be delighted to hand a % of it over in (even more) tax. Great idea. 🤔

DomesticShortHair · 04/01/2023 17:27

Well, if nothing else, what’s worse than having a zero hours contract and low levels of pay is having no contract at all and no pay.

CeciliaMars · 04/01/2023 17:27

For me, the main problem with a wealth tax is that it would hurt older people who own property but don't have much income - a pensioner for example whose house has gone up in value over the years to say £500k but they live on a pension.
Also, it's a great incentive to give wealth away - eg, pass inheritance on early etc to avoid paying the tax.
For me, the main thing is to make sure large corporations and the super rich are not able to keep avoiding tax through loopholes and expensive lawyers.

TodayInahurry · 04/01/2023 17:26

If your expensive London property is owned by a Jersey company and it is sold, you sell the company, not the property, no tax

Annabel073 · 04/01/2023 17:26

Porcinimushroom · 04/01/2023 17:25

Do you just really mean you’d like anyone with more than you to be taxed and have it taken off them? May as well just own it.

That's exactly what the OP means.

EndlessRain1 · 04/01/2023 17:25

DomesticShortHair · 04/01/2023 17:24

And making them pay more tax means they’ll have more money and a greater incentive to pay their employees more, will it?

While letting them off does what? Rewards them for their immoral practices I'd say.

Porcinimushroom · 04/01/2023 17:25

Do you just really mean you’d like anyone with more than you to be taxed and have it taken off them? May as well just own it.