Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not let DD watch these programmes for school work.

165 replies

Whatswiththesmalltalk · 04/01/2023 16:04

Dd is 13 and is studying dystopian literature in English so I understand the connection but her teacher has asked the class to watch the handmaids tale, children of men and V for vendetta. I have only watched the handmaids tale myself but having looked online I really don't think they're all that appropriate for a 13 year old at all. AIBU would you let your 13 year old watch these?

OP posts:
UWhatNow · 04/01/2023 16:40

I am a massive fan of the HT TV series and I read the book as a teen but I would not let my 13 dd watch it. It’s visually very brutal and some scenes would be too much. Too traumatic. I can only imagine the sneering cynical posters haven’t watched it. Also the TV series, as people have pointed out, does not follow the book.

Moonlightdust · 04/01/2023 16:39

Well I’m quite hardcore from watching many a crime documentary (!) but even I flinched at some of the earlier Handmaid’s tales scenes and felt anxious watching it. I wouldn’t say it’s all that suitable for a 13 year old.

Piggywaspushed · 04/01/2023 16:39

Well. it's a grey area that one. It's not legal to buy it, for example - but with streaming that has been complicated. I don't play fast and loose with age ratings. They are there for child protection and MN is usually vey hot on safeguarding.

Blossomtoes · 04/01/2023 16:39

Piggywaspushed · 04/01/2023 16:31

And, if it's English, why are they watching films?? Is it a media unit? In which case, they should be studying them as media texts. Sounds more like lazy shortcut to me to replace reading, which makes me sad :(

They aren't even good films!!

It’s over 50 years since I left school but we were shown films of the texts we were taught. It’s hardly lazy if it’s used as a way of bringing literature to life and to supplement the written text.

IronicElf · 04/01/2023 16:35

Piggywaspushed · 04/01/2023 16:29

I'm a film teacher. Regardless of whether some parents allow it or how individuals might feel, it isn't legal to watch 15s in a private home. It's OK for 14 year olds to watch them 'for educational purposes' but in the classroom under teacher supervision.

I'd be asking the teacher/HOD if there are aware of the law on this, assuming these are 15s (I haven't checked).

At GCSE, I teach 15 films, but only form mid year 10 onwards and with clear communication to parents on the BBFC guidelines.

There is a wealth of more age appropriate dystopian literature out there!!

I think you mean it isn't ILLEGAL to allow children under this age to watch a 15 film at home. The law is that they aren't allowed to see it at a cinema even with their parents. At home you can watch what you like, but parents should be very aware of what is being watched and the nature of the child.

As a film teacher I would have thought you would know that - or maybe I'm quoting UK law and you're elsewhere.

re Children of Men. Dull, Dull, Dull. But I'd let me 13 year old watch it. She's been desperate to watch Hacksaw Ridge for a couple of years, and after she covers WWII again I might let her (with me watching too).

Twillow · 04/01/2023 16:35

There is an older version of the handmaid's tale which is less graphic. The book had a big impact on me in my teens, it is a very significant work.

Longtimelurkerfinallyposts · 04/01/2023 16:34

V for Vendetta and Children of Men both have a 15 cert.

The 1990 film version of the Handmaid's Tale was originally18-rated, then updated to a 15; the recent series were all 15-rated.

I'd be contacting the school management/ Head of Dept to check that they're aware the teacher's recommending these to a class of 13 (and possibly 14) year olds.

Needmorelego · 04/01/2023 16:34

The original Handmaid's Tale film is an 18. I did the book for A-Level and we watched the film. We were all 16 and 17. None of us were 18. "Don't tell your parents" our teacher said.
I've not watched the TV series but from what I know of it I would not want a 13 year old to watch it.
The 2 films suggested are both 15 certificate. Films are given a rating of 15 for a reason. 13 year olds in general really shouldn't watch them.
I would tell the teacher that she will not be watching them and could she suggest something more age appropriate.

Piggywaspushed · 04/01/2023 16:31

And, if it's English, why are they watching films?? Is it a media unit? In which case, they should be studying them as media texts. Sounds more like lazy shortcut to me to replace reading, which makes me sad :(

They aren't even good films!!

Piggywaspushed · 04/01/2023 16:29

I'm a film teacher. Regardless of whether some parents allow it or how individuals might feel, it isn't legal to watch 15s in a private home. It's OK for 14 year olds to watch them 'for educational purposes' but in the classroom under teacher supervision.

I'd be asking the teacher/HOD if there are aware of the law on this, assuming these are 15s (I haven't checked).

At GCSE, I teach 15 films, but only form mid year 10 onwards and with clear communication to parents on the BBFC guidelines.

There is a wealth of more age appropriate dystopian literature out there!!

LastTrainBeforeChristmas · 04/01/2023 16:29

@Whatswiththesmalltalk the film of Handmaids' Tale is terrible mind, that's why nobody talks about it any more.

Now Wall:E, there's a good dystopian film.

Mischance · 04/01/2023 16:26

If it is rated 15, then you should be talking to the school about this. It should not be recommended for 13 years olds.

And that is not treating her like a baby, as some PPs have suggested. It is recognising that a respected public body regards it as unsuitable for 13 years olds; and also recognising the fact that you cannot "unsee" things. It will stay with her.

Whatswiththesmalltalk · 04/01/2023 16:25

Thanks, lots of good suggestions. I wasn't even aware that there was a film version of the handmaids tale so will definitely look into that. I agree that a lot of the more problematic scenes in handmaids tale are too graphic for a 13 year old but will have a proper look at the other two.

I agree that it is unfair to expect them all to have access to films, I'm unsure why she has asked them to watch rather than read them.

OP posts:
ChekhovsMum · 04/01/2023 16:25

Dystopian Literature at the age of 13? Even in terms of exam board set texts and themes, that’s A level stuff. Most of the kids in her class won’t have the maturity for any of the ideas, let alone the TV series.

Beamur · 04/01/2023 16:22

Netflix version of the Handmaid's Tale is equivalent to an 18. Not suitable for a 13 yr old. My 15 yr old has seen it though - it has very adult themes.
The others come up with an R rating (US ?) which means not suitable for children... it's a restriction that suggests that a child should watch it with an adult supervising. Same as the HT actually now I look again.
i think it might really depend on the child in question.

Kfjsjdbd · 04/01/2023 16:21

Was just about to say the same as above, I watched the film version of the Handmaids tale in about year 8/9 at school. There’s a rape scene but other than that it’s fine.

FluffyYucca · 04/01/2023 16:19

I would assume that the teacher meant the film version of The Handmaid’s Tale, which is much less graphic than the series?

I think all the films are 15-rated, so guess it depends on your child.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 04/01/2023 16:18

My children are adult now but I'd have been a bit put out to be asked to have to take out a Netflix or similar subscription so they could watch Children of Men and V for Vendetta. I assume A Handmaid's Tale is on All4, so free. What about families that can't afford Netflix or similar? Does the school library have any resources they can draw on?

Also, I would have been very unhappy about a teacher directing 13yos to watch things rated 15 and 18. Aren't there any rules about this? What about kids who can get hold of these materials and will watch them alone, with no adult sitting beside them to talk about the adult and distressing content?

RoseslnTheHospital · 04/01/2023 16:15

I wonder why they aren't being asked to read these rather than watch the TV show or film versions?

Also, there's 50 plus episodes of the Handmaids Tale! Which ones should they be watching?

Both Children of Men and V for Vendetta are 15 rated, not 12A. I think it's not reasonable to ask parents to approve their children watching these films. I don't know what rating each individual episode of The Handmaids Tale is, but I'd think they were likely to also be 15 or higher. The rape themes in particular are disturbing and could be problematic for a 13 year old girl.

LastTrainBeforeChristmas · 04/01/2023 16:15

No I wouldn’t let my 13 year old watch The Handmaid’s Tale. I’d need to rewatch Children of Men to make a judgement on that, and I’d want to watch V for Vendetta as I haven’t seen it. Those are both 15s so I don’t think a teacher asking 13 year olds to watch them is a great idea to be honest. Books with that sort of content are very different to films and tv.

There are more age appropriate things they could suggest they watch. Hunger Games is dystopian fiction and is at least a 12A.

ILoveeCakes · 04/01/2023 16:15

We watched Schindlers List in Year 8 at the end of term. In German class, not history class. As the film was in English, there was no language lessons in it, so I guess we were shown it purely for entertainment

Whatsshecalled · 04/01/2023 16:15

I would NOT be happy about my 13yr old (yr 8) watching the rape scenes in handmaids tale and the general level of violence altogether needs an adult level of maturity to understand and contextualise. In not familiar with the other two, but that one would be a 'no' from me.

itsgettingweird · 04/01/2023 16:14

keepaweatheredeye · 04/01/2023 16:13

There are other versions of the Handmaids tale - film versions, that are perfectly suitable and match the book.

This.

I'd email teacher and ask for clarification of what exactly they are asking them to watch.

It's very good from a discussion and education POV but yes - some scenes are too much even to open conversation.

justmewithmylifetoday · 04/01/2023 16:14

@Whatswiththesmalltalk if it's of any help IMDB has a parents guide which is helpful. If you Google it alongside the name of the film you should come across it. All 3 listed above are rated 15.

Whatswiththesmalltalk · 04/01/2023 16:14

Iap90 That's a good idea, there are definitely episodes that would be more suitable than others.

OP posts: