Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not let DD watch these programmes for school work.

165 replies

Whatswiththesmalltalk · 04/01/2023 16:04

Dd is 13 and is studying dystopian literature in English so I understand the connection but her teacher has asked the class to watch the handmaids tale, children of men and V for vendetta. I have only watched the handmaids tale myself but having looked online I really don't think they're all that appropriate for a 13 year old at all. AIBU would you let your 13 year old watch these?

OP posts:
NotAnotherCrisis · 04/01/2023 17:22

YADDDDDDNBU - I can't watch The Handmaid's Tale, it's too violent.

I would say she could read it (I've always found reading less traumatic) but not watch it.

mast0650 · 04/01/2023 17:20

From memory, I don't think The Handsmaid's Tale is suitable for most 13 year olds. My husband and I gave up watching it during the second series as we found it too unpleasant to watch.
According to this it has a 15 rating.
www.ageratingjuju.com/the-handmaids-tale-age-rating-2021/
I don't know the others.
Just because it is "for education" doesn't mean it's appropriate!

darjeelingrose · 04/01/2023 17:16

The film is also an 18, I googled.

LadyMonicaBaddingham · 04/01/2023 17:14

The Handmaid's Tale FILM, yes. The series? No, because it has become so far removed from the canonical text that for educational purposes it is irrelevant.

HungryandIknowit · 04/01/2023 17:13

The only one I've watched and read is the Handmaid's tale. Imo it's too adult for a 13 year old, even the book. I think something like Animal Farm would be more appropriate. It also seems strange that they've been asked to watch them, rather than just read the books. Perhaps speak to the teacher.

darjeelingrose · 04/01/2023 17:12

Absolutely not The Handmaid's Tale. No 13 year old needs to see graphic violent rape scenes. But I would let my 13 year old read the book. V for Vendetta probably I would, and I haven't seen the other one.

MarvelMrs · 04/01/2023 17:12

V for Vendetta - yes.
Handmaid’s Tale - hmmmm, no. The ritual rape would be a no.

CakeCrumbs44 · 04/01/2023 17:10

I agree with those who say The Handmaid's Tale is an important piece of literature but I think it would be more appropriate, and better understood by year 11-13 rather than year 9 students.

There are a lot of young adult dystopian films and books which would be more accessible and appropriate for that age. Hunger Games as other have mentioned, The Maze Runner, Divergent, The 100. Or go for a classic like 1984 which at least doesn't have forced rape in it.

EpicChaos · 04/01/2023 17:10

@Piggywaspushed " Piggywaspushed · Today 16:31
And, if it's English, why are they watching films?? "

Sometimes a film is watched alongside reading the book/s. Had it not been for that, many of us would never have been treat to the pleasure of watching Cheggers play Fleance, lol :D ( Just a shame that it was a Polanski film! )

Anyhoo, V for Vendetta, i'd probably allow a 13 year old to watch. There is some violence but compared to other films, I don't think it's too bad.
The other 2 I have no idea about.

SirenSays · 04/01/2023 17:10

Very strange. For handmaids tale I'd expect the teacher to show clips in school, not tell the children to go away and watch it.

MrsCarson · 04/01/2023 17:08

I'd let a 13 year old watch Children of men and V for vendetta. Not Handmaids tale just yet.

BarbaraVineFan · 04/01/2023 17:08

I've been an English teacher for nearly 20 years and taught dystopian literature to year 9 many times. There is no way I would include The Handmaid's Tale in any unit for that age. There are plenty of dystopian texts that can be used without going into what is without doubt an A level text. I would be questioning the teacher's judgement and professionalism, to be honest.

zurala · 04/01/2023 17:07

No I wouldn't. I don't think any 13 year old needs to see rape. My 13 yo DD doesn't even know what rape is.

Favouritefruits · 04/01/2023 17:03

Are you sure her teacher has said this? This is the kind of tripe I would of made up to be able to watch stuff my friends had been going on about. My Mum would have fallen for it because it was ‘for school’

Eeve · 04/01/2023 17:03

Eeve · 04/01/2023 16:56

www.commonsensemedia.org/ says, 16+ for Handmaid's Tale, 17+ for Children of Men and 18+ for V for Vendetta.

Obviously, all kids are different, but I have a super-sensitive kid (she does have ASD) and I've found this site helpful

Apologies! I was quoting the wrong numbers. HMT parents' think 18 and kids 15; CoM and V both say 16+; VfV both say 14+

Flannan · 04/01/2023 17:02

I always find comments like "she's 13, she'll be fine" etc. a bit odd. There is a whole range of issues at play and someone's age is a really small part of it. I find that following my DC's lead with stuff is generally what works well.

My 14 year old would really NOT enjoy Handmaid's Tale - she'd find it harrowing. It's pretty obvious that some 13 year olds will be fine, and others won't.

YANBU OP.

NewUserName2023 · 04/01/2023 17:02

The awful ceremony/rape scenes are uncomfortable to watch as an adult - let alone a 13 year old! Are you sure she doesnt mean the older film version?

Eeve · 04/01/2023 16:59

Walkbyall · 04/01/2023 16:57

Find out the ratings and then contact the safeguarding lead with your concerns. If about 12 they definitely shouldn’t be watching in full (supervised clips are allowed) and the school could be in a lot of trouble.

Agreed. No 13 year old needs to see a rape scene.

BeautifulWar · 04/01/2023 16:59

This is the 90s version. I remember watching this when I studied The Handmaid's Tale for A Level.

m.imdb.com/title/tt0099731/?ref_=ext_shr_lnk

PossiblyOverstepping · 04/01/2023 16:58

Whatever happened to reading books! For a start, the tv version of AHT veers away from the plot of the book - continues it - so she won’t get the true plot anyway. And a lot of the menace in the book comes from the writing

Scotty12 · 04/01/2023 16:58

Oh dear, I don’t think a handmaid’s tale is appropriate at all for that age. It’s also either a 15 or an 18 rating. Something like the hunger games might be more appropriate.

CakeCrumbs44 · 04/01/2023 16:58

www.commonsensemedia.org/tv-reviews/the-handmaids-tale

Common sense media is a good one, it generally summarises the sex, violence and bad language in a TV show and has reviews from children and adults.

Personally I think the rape in Handmaid's Tale would be a reason not to watch it with a 13 year old.

Also on a practical note the first series alone is 10 hour long episodes, that's quite a commitment to watch it for homework.

Walkbyall · 04/01/2023 16:58

*above 12

Dogsogdog · 04/01/2023 16:58

Have they actually been asked to watch them or have they been given as examples of this genre ?

Walkbyall · 04/01/2023 16:57

Find out the ratings and then contact the safeguarding lead with your concerns. If about 12 they definitely shouldn’t be watching in full (supervised clips are allowed) and the school could be in a lot of trouble.

Swipe left for the next trending thread