Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not let DD watch these programmes for school work.

165 replies

Whatswiththesmalltalk · 04/01/2023 16:04

Dd is 13 and is studying dystopian literature in English so I understand the connection but her teacher has asked the class to watch the handmaids tale, children of men and V for vendetta. I have only watched the handmaids tale myself but having looked online I really don't think they're all that appropriate for a 13 year old at all. AIBU would you let your 13 year old watch these?

OP posts:
Cakeandcardio · 04/01/2023 18:35

I wouldn't. I would question a teacher setting this as homework as they are 15 rated (I'm a teacher). I understand some parents let their kids watch stuff which isn't classed as appropriate for their age but that's your decision to make and you know your daughter best. The teacher is advising them to watch inappropriate material. Email the school to make them aware and if you don't want your daughter to watch them, state why.

GoldenCupidon · 04/01/2023 18:32

I'd let her watch V for Vendetta, it's political rather than horror. Personally I would give her a copy of the book of Handmaid's Tale rather than watch it. I think the telly version seems quite gratuitous from what I've seen.

AFS1 · 04/01/2023 18:32

I’m pretty chilled out about what my 14 year old watches but there’s no way I would let her watch The Handmaids Tale. I don’t know the other 2 so can’t comment on them, but I think it’s a bizarre request by the school.

Swimminginthelake · 04/01/2023 18:30

I would be okay with my 13 year old reading the Handmaid's tale but less okay with them watching the series... if she's studying dystopian literature surely it makes more sense to read the books rather than watch the films?!

BradfordGirl · 04/01/2023 18:29

FancyFanny · 04/01/2023 17:29

I don't think The Handmads Tale is appropriate for 13 year olds. It's on the A'level English Literature syllabus, where it's just about ok for 16-18 year olds.

I even think the subjects they expect A-level students to write about in detail is challenging. My dd's recent assignment was to write a detailed essay comparing how sex and sexuality is represented in two different texts: The Colour Purple with A Street Car named desire. For teenagers who have virtually no sexual experience yet of their own it's a big ask!

I totally disagree. It is teenagers, they are not going to write a mature analysis of this subject. But all the big themes of literature are ones that most teenagers will not have personally experienced.

AliceMcK · 04/01/2023 18:28

Surely there are more age appropriate dystopian movies to watch other than the handmaids tale, the hunger games, maze runner, minority report, divergent series...

The Handmaids Tale is very powerful but I'm not sure I'd let a 13yo watch it.

watchfulwishes · 04/01/2023 18:24

www.bbfc.co.uk/release/the-handmaids-tale-q29sbgvjdglvbjpwwc00odg2mtc

I wouldn't be happy about this being mandated by school - it is not easy viewing and everyone is different. I am surprised this is being asked of 13yo young people.

I think I would be asking the teacher about this.

Woozieadams · 04/01/2023 18:19

Hand maids tale is savage and as a 40 year old woman I find it a hard watch at times ! Makes me so angry how woman are treated ! I would not be advocating for my 12 or 14 year olds to watch it .

7eleven · 04/01/2023 18:17

I’m 58 and wouldn’t watch Handmaids Tale. I don’t think it should be a requirement for school.

ExhaustedFlamingo · 04/01/2023 18:17

greybuolding · 04/01/2023 17:56

What type of sketchy teacher / school who is supposedly educating on English literature is palming the kids off on tv programmes and films?

HMT is an A-level text. V for vendetta is a gothic novel. There's loads of their options they could actually read and discuss. Lazy teaching by the sounds of it.

Whether people think it's precious or not, schools should not be exceeding guidance for viewing so if they are 15s or 18s, definitely dodgy for the school to be asking 13yo to watch.

I agree with this.

I love English and I love reading. I did English Lit at A-level.

But honestly, I don't want to watch films, TV shows etc depicting graphic imagery or desperately tragic plots. It's not my thing and I really have to be in the right frame of mind to cope with it. If I had to sit through this stuff to pass my exams, I'd fail.

Books with hard-hitting plots are difficult enough, and a well-written book can leave me in floods of tears (and often do). I don't see why watching TV shows/films is compulsory or why it's part of studying literature.

I think it's pretty awful that a teacher has told 13 yr olds to watch a 15-rated show. Some might be OK, some might understand the nuances but there will definitely be those that are adversely affected, or just don't get the full gist (so being exposed to such adult content is meaningless anyway!)

Disclaimer: I'm autistic/ADHD so possibly struggle more with film content etc than others may do.

Pippa12 · 04/01/2023 18:15

Omg no way would I let a 13 year old watch handmaids tale, it really messed with my head never mind a 13 year olds! It’s my favourite TV programme but absolutely not appropriate for this age!!!

Dreamwhisper · 04/01/2023 18:12

There’s a rape scene but other than that it’s fine

That's not okay.

MysteryBelle · 04/01/2023 18:10

Agree. Not appropriate. And the slants presented should be discussed between parents and their children.

riotlady · 04/01/2023 18:05

Onnabugeisha · 04/01/2023 17:52

After RTFT I do agree that 13 is a bit young for Handmaids Tale, but as a pp said there are lots of YA dystopian classics out there. War of the Worlds is a good sci fi alien invasion dystopia that is age appropriate. Animal Farm or 1984 as well would fit the bill. Do Androids dream of electric sheep looks at AI and what it means to be sentient. The Road - post apocalypse book.

I think The Road is probably even more traumatising than Handmaid’s Tale tbh!

Phineyj · 04/01/2023 18:02

I taught a course on Game of Thrones once but I just used clips. I have read the books but never fancied seeing it visually depicted. As a PP said you can't unsee horrible stuff. It worked fine with clips - and the point was to pique interest in some relevant history, geography, science etc, not to spend teaching time watching telly! It was year 12 though.

riotlady · 04/01/2023 18:02

V for Vendetta would probably be fine but as a pp said it is a bit of a shit film! Surely if you’re going to teach 13 year olds about dystopian literature the obvious film choice would have been Hunger Games?

NumberTheory · 04/01/2023 18:01

I wouldn’t start by refusing. I would start by asking the teacher what consideration they have given to the impact the harsh treatment of women, in particular the rape and threats of rape, especially Every’s sexual assault by State actors given the widely reported actions of Wayne Couzens, might have on the kids in the class and how she intends discussing such scenes and supporting the kids in her class to ensure they aren’t harmed.

And similarly what consideration has been given to the more brutal violence, (I would highlight the killing of the kid in V for Vendetta and the hangings in the Handmaid’s Tale) will have on 13 year olds and how that will be discussed.

See what she says. It may be there are good ways to handle these more brutal aspects (I can’t think of them, though), or you may give her something to think about. But it’s more constructive than simply saying “No”.

Phineyj · 04/01/2023 17:56

I read Children of the Dust at that age at school. OMG it was disturbing (post nuclear holocaust). I'm 50, have read lots and have never forgotten it. But no rape, torture etc and the most impressive character is a young girl.

The teacher needs to consider a wider range of literature!

greybuolding · 04/01/2023 17:56

What type of sketchy teacher / school who is supposedly educating on English literature is palming the kids off on tv programmes and films?

HMT is an A-level text. V for vendetta is a gothic novel. There's loads of their options they could actually read and discuss. Lazy teaching by the sounds of it.

Whether people think it's precious or not, schools should not be exceeding guidance for viewing so if they are 15s or 18s, definitely dodgy for the school to be asking 13yo to watch.

Onnabugeisha · 04/01/2023 17:52

After RTFT I do agree that 13 is a bit young for Handmaids Tale, but as a pp said there are lots of YA dystopian classics out there. War of the Worlds is a good sci fi alien invasion dystopia that is age appropriate. Animal Farm or 1984 as well would fit the bill. Do Androids dream of electric sheep looks at AI and what it means to be sentient. The Road - post apocalypse book.

Athenen0ctua · 04/01/2023 17:49

Year 8 or 9? I'd expect year 9 to be able to watch 15 rated films with guidance and for educational reasons.

Onnabugeisha · 04/01/2023 17:48

YANBU
If it’s a dystopian literature class then why is the teacher telling them to watch adaptations loosely inspired by the literature?!

Your DD should be reading the original literature.

The Handmaids Tale show is an excuse to show violent torture porn. I was disgusted when I watched the first season and stopped there because what they show is not the Handmaids Tale that Atwood wrote. I’m shocked a teacher would even suggest students watch it as some sort of intro to dystopian literature. Unless the teacher hasn’t actually compared book ti show?

Children of Men isn’t bad, but again it doesn’t follow the book very closely.

V for Vendetta is a shit film. It has not aged well at all. There is so much wrong with it. V imprisons the heroine (pretending shes been arrested by secret police) and then literally tortures her for months..once he frees her all she says is ‘you shaved my hair’ and then promptly falls in love with this much much older man. There’s a subplot where lesbians are targeted and killed. The heroine is more of a weeping pathetic damsel in distress, not a strong female character at all. V is also a domestic terrorist in his plot to overthrow the government by filling tube trains with explosives to kill anyone who happens to be around. I’d be objecting to my 13yo watching that.

Im also a bit hmmmm at them only looking at dystopian literature that involves oppressing/torturing/killing women. There’s so much to choose from when it comes to dystopian literature.

Why not have 1 book be Handmaids Tale, 1 book be a climate disaster dystopia, and 1 book be a nuclear war fallout dystopia?

Thefrogwife · 04/01/2023 17:45

I'm an English teacher and I think this is weird. As people have said, The Handmaid's Tale is a long established A Level text. It's about institutional rape. A 13 year old will not understand what aspects of modern society the dystopia is reflecting.

I can understand a teacher using well judged extracts of the novel, or well judged extracts from the film versions even, to talk about what dystopian fiction is, but there are so many better YA dystopian books to actually study...

OnGoldenPond · 04/01/2023 17:44

Can't see the point of watching the film version of The Handmaids Tale as it doesn't really stay very close to the book. The first season of the series covers the original book and is pretty close to it. Subsequent series are newly written material inspired by the original book.

I agree the series is not really suitable for a 13 year old. This is because the book itself is not really suitable for that age group. I read it at that age though - got it from the library and the librarian was quite reluctant to let me have it. Mentioned I had read it at that age to DD's English teacher and she was a bit shocked as she thought it was a bit young. Probably a bit of a misjudgement on the part of the OP's DD's teacher studying this book with this class.

Edwina83 · 04/01/2023 17:42

They are all 15 rated so I'm surprised 13 year olds are being asked to watch them. I wouldn't want my child watching them, though realise all children are different.

Swipe left for the next trending thread