Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are things in the UK really that bad?

392 replies

namechange10022002 · 04/01/2023 15:28

I’ve been living overseas for about seven years and I am lucky to have a very safe, easy, comfortable life here but for various reasons I really want to move back home to England. However I keep hearing about how bad the situation is over there, with the cost of living crisis, housing, energy bills, health service, etc. For example I was watching Triggernometry and the hosts were saying the next few years are going to be extremely difficult for everyone there. I was just wondering, is it really as bad as they say? If you never watched or read the news or looked at social media, would you notice the difference in your quality of life? What is the general feeling on the ground, so to speak?

I guess I just want to know if it would be a mistake to move back there.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
lemmein · 04/01/2023 18:50

I think the general mood of the country is low and people seem more tetchy than before (or maybe that's just me 🤔) I'm certainly noticing massive increases and am living paycheck to paycheck each month, even though we're on decent incomes for our area. I honestly don't know how those on NMW/disability benefits are surviving.

For me though the biggest worry is the NHS. Luckily we are all healthy at the moment but the thought of requiring any sort of healthcare the way things are is scary. My DD has a chronic condition so we've spent a lot of time in and out of hospital - luckily she's been ok for the most part throughout covid and since - but even before covid things were dire so I dread to think what it's like now. It genuinely scares me.

The other thing that i find really frustrating about the UK is the apathy....it really worries me that no matter how low we sink people will just carry on voting for more of the same.

So I'm a nutshell - unless you're in somewhere like Afghanistan I'd probably stay put.

socialmedia23 · 04/01/2023 18:46

ComtesseDeSpair · 04/01/2023 18:32

Does it make any difference whether you state you’re affected or unaffected, when the outcome is the same? Like most people, I go about my life as best I can and I pay my thousands of pounds a month in tax and NI without complaint having been told this is what provides the services the poor and vulnerable I know exist need. I’m not personally affected much by things in the UK; I “care” in an abstract sense about others, hence see my previous point about paying my dues without complaint. What, if you walk around caring deeply about everyone you see struggling, does that deep care actually achieve that my abstract but somewhat disinterested caring doesn’t? Your tax and my tax all go into the same pot.

traditionally the middle class have been the ones to fight for change within the system. Spreading awareness of the poor is important. Particularly because there are many people who may not personally know any poor people. i don't personally know anyone choosing between eating and heating (I do know people cutting back on heating) nor do I know anyone who is starving. But I know they exist somewhere so it helps to know their stories.

I know one homeless person but she technically can stay at her dad and also suffers from addiction issues so not straightforward. the state spending more money on her is not an automatic solution either since she has frittered away 160k due to her addiction issues! Though it would massively help if nhs mental health was better funded but at the same time, she has to want treatment! What would actually really help is if there was less easy access to street drugs (she uses it to self-medicate with disastrous effects) but neither Labour or the Tories are going to do anything about that!

MysteriesOfTheOrganism · 04/01/2023 18:43

Yes, it feels like the country is slowly disintegrating. The 2008 financial collapse, Brexit, COVID, and the Russian invasion of Ukraine have left the UK reeling. Even if we had a government that wanted to fix it, I think it will take a good 10 years to turn it round.

Stunningscreamer · 04/01/2023 18:41

Yes.

Brexit
Pandemic
One of the worst, most self serving Governments in living memory
Everyone on strike, so public services barely providing even an emergency service
A population that doesn't like paying for public services while at the same time demands the Government sorts out everything.

It's really, really bad.

longestlurkerever · 04/01/2023 18:40

Though some of these replies were in answer to the specific question of whether you could tangibly feel the difference on the ground.

MarshaBradyo · 04/01/2023 18:37

op if you’re really thinking about it it also depends where you’ll be living and working

itsgettingweird · 04/01/2023 18:35

The real issue isn't necessarily if you can afford your lifestyle on 90k.

It's what type of lifestyle you could have.

For example, teachers actually earn 15% less in real terms than they did in 2010. Budgets have just been restored to 2010 levels but you have to bear in mind that's still a 15% drop. So their work load has changed and increased, the budgets to do their job are decreased and their quality of life has decreased. We have a recruitment and retention problem. But yet the government cannot work out why.

It's a similar situation in healthcare.

My friend who is a lawyer has had a pay rise of just 4k (about 5%) in 12 years.
Maybe that doesn't sound as bad but again - that means her actual quality of life has decreased - but the worst bit? She's had 2 promotions in that time and if she hadn't she'd be worse off in real terms iyswim?

So I'd look beyond actual costs to what pay is like, will it increase, will you have a better standard of living (than you had or you had now)

Because it isn't as simple as "but covid" as our government like to try and boil it down to. It's a culmination of 12 years of cuts and bad management of public funds and a pandemic speeding up the crisis we were already heading to.

HotChoxs · 04/01/2023 18:35

ComtesseDeSpair · 04/01/2023 18:32

Does it make any difference whether you state you’re affected or unaffected, when the outcome is the same? Like most people, I go about my life as best I can and I pay my thousands of pounds a month in tax and NI without complaint having been told this is what provides the services the poor and vulnerable I know exist need. I’m not personally affected much by things in the UK; I “care” in an abstract sense about others, hence see my previous point about paying my dues without complaint. What, if you walk around caring deeply about everyone you see struggling, does that deep care actually achieve that my abstract but somewhat disinterested caring doesn’t? Your tax and my tax all go into the same pot.

You are personally affected though, neither here nor there whether you realise it or not.

ComtesseDeSpair · 04/01/2023 18:32

HotChoxs · 04/01/2023 18:28

Seriously? Who lives here and is wealthy but has no friends or family here? That would be a total outlier. Even then do people actually walk around seeing people struggling and not care?

I think my original point was sound really that you can't be living here and unaffected by this unless you don't care about anyone else. Really the third option of whisking everyone away to another Country is impossible anyway.

Does it make any difference whether you state you’re affected or unaffected, when the outcome is the same? Like most people, I go about my life as best I can and I pay my thousands of pounds a month in tax and NI without complaint having been told this is what provides the services the poor and vulnerable I know exist need. I’m not personally affected much by things in the UK; I “care” in an abstract sense about others, hence see my previous point about paying my dues without complaint. What, if you walk around caring deeply about everyone you see struggling, does that deep care actually achieve that my abstract but somewhat disinterested caring doesn’t? Your tax and my tax all go into the same pot.

KnutonHardz · 04/01/2023 18:31

The situation will be different for different people depending on their circumstances, and things will vary a lot by region too. On a personal note I'm happy with things, due to having a good job in medical/tech area. The last decade has been tough for UK overall, and it certainly looks like that will continue to be the case going forward.

Working remotely for almost 12 months now, I'm based back in the area I grew up in Northern Ireland (north east) to help out with some family care issues. Being based here after 30 years for has been an eye opener for me. Apart from the "traditional" rampant sectarianism in these parts, there are a lot of things that seem much worse than our home area in south east England. Aging population with not so great hospital care and subpar outpatient/home support (thus the main reason I'm here), limited opportunities for talented young people, poor quality local schools, lots of school drop outs, serious drugs/crime, what was a fairly prosperous market town is basically a sh1thole with about 2 nice coffee/tea shops . There is so much potential being wasted in an otherwise lovely part of the country.

Selfishly I'll be happy to be back "home" in England later this year. So in my personal experience location can also be a factor.

MarshaBradyo · 04/01/2023 18:30

I answered the question re not reading media or SM - we socialise etc and I based my answer on that

theworldhas · 04/01/2023 18:29

@AngelinaFibres
This is true for lots of people. It isn't true for lots of other people. My high street has no empty shops. The food I want to buy I can afford . Some people are struggling, some are not. The situation is no different in Europe

Yeah, my impression is that while the UK is probably among the worst affected in Europe (blame austerity and Brexit for that) it is by no means alone in going through a very shit period: due to Ukraine war, the cost of Covid, huge slowdown of Chinese economy etc etc.

The advantages of elsewhere in Western Europe is that their governments aren’t by and large ideologically driven to making things even worse than they needed to be (the Tory masterplans of slowing economic growth and wrecking public services with austerity, and then further crippling the economy with Brexit) … and also mostly have better weather.

HotChoxs · 04/01/2023 18:28

socialmedia23 · 04/01/2023 18:22

I am not sure it does. If you are rich and healthy, your partner is rich and healthy and your kids are also healthy, perhaps the NHS collapse isn't so bad. You have money for expensive gym memberships (and also childcare during your gym sessions) and a good diet. Your parents are also in fairly good health as they can eat well and have a comfortable lifestyle post retirement. Perhaps they also have a summer home in Spain so they can use Spanish healthcare (with the correct visas so that they can access healthcare as residents).

Perhaps it is possible to be completely blinkered if you are in that situation. I have private healthcare but I worry about the NHS collapse as DH's sister has a chronic illness.

Seriously? Who lives here and is wealthy but has no friends or family here? That would be a total outlier. Even then do people actually walk around seeing people struggling and not care?

I think my original point was sound really that you can't be living here and unaffected by this unless you don't care about anyone else. Really the third option of whisking everyone away to another Country is impossible anyway.

socialmedia23 · 04/01/2023 18:25

IAmTheWalrus80 · 04/01/2023 18:23

You’re right. I have some friends who are fairly well insulated from the cost of living crisis in the sense that they both have great jobs, lots of equity in their house, private medical insurance through work, etc.

But their two year old broke his leg badly (freak fall at home, as toddlers are prone to do) a few weeks ago and required emergency care. Their experience was horrific and they are all traumatised by it. It was so indescribably bad I don’t think you’d believe it if I typed it out. And our local hospital is generally considered quite good - it isn’t even one of the ones that has declared a critical incident.

When my friend told me about it she said that she’d seen the stories on the news but somehow thought our hospital would be different, that it wouldn’t happen to them, etc. But it did. It’s very real. Healthcare is just rolling a dice at the moment.

Has it changed their mind about the government? If they previously supported the Tories, that is?

IAmTheWalrus80 · 04/01/2023 18:23

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 04/01/2023 17:44

I am not amazed- if you don’t need it the state of the NHS is very easy to ignore.
I am however depressed by the people who can read post after post of bad first hand experiences and still insist it’s just media scaremongering.
If it doesn’t affect you there’s nothing wrong with saying so, but claiming that means there is therefore no problem is ridiculous and insulting.

You’re right. I have some friends who are fairly well insulated from the cost of living crisis in the sense that they both have great jobs, lots of equity in their house, private medical insurance through work, etc.

But their two year old broke his leg badly (freak fall at home, as toddlers are prone to do) a few weeks ago and required emergency care. Their experience was horrific and they are all traumatised by it. It was so indescribably bad I don’t think you’d believe it if I typed it out. And our local hospital is generally considered quite good - it isn’t even one of the ones that has declared a critical incident.

When my friend told me about it she said that she’d seen the stories on the news but somehow thought our hospital would be different, that it wouldn’t happen to them, etc. But it did. It’s very real. Healthcare is just rolling a dice at the moment.

theworldhas · 04/01/2023 18:22

Ten years of sabotaging public services and the economy with austerity, followed by sabotaging the economy with Brexit. That’s all on the government. Then throw Russia and Covid into the mix.

socialmedia23 · 04/01/2023 18:22

HotChoxs · 04/01/2023 18:15

yeah that falls under option b

I am not sure it does. If you are rich and healthy, your partner is rich and healthy and your kids are also healthy, perhaps the NHS collapse isn't so bad. You have money for expensive gym memberships (and also childcare during your gym sessions) and a good diet. Your parents are also in fairly good health as they can eat well and have a comfortable lifestyle post retirement. Perhaps they also have a summer home in Spain so they can use Spanish healthcare (with the correct visas so that they can access healthcare as residents).

Perhaps it is possible to be completely blinkered if you are in that situation. I have private healthcare but I worry about the NHS collapse as DH's sister has a chronic illness.

HotChoxs · 04/01/2023 18:17

ILoveeCakes · 04/01/2023 18:08

At least the number of binary options has grown by 50% vs your last proposal

It never grew at all you just misclassified it as binary by not reading my original post.

HotChoxs · 04/01/2023 18:15

socialmedia23 · 04/01/2023 18:14

option d: think you are too invincible to get sick.

I know someone like that, he thinks that because he exercises regularly, he is immune to illness and if he is, he is very rich and can get healthcare in another country. In his words, even if he has to undergo chemotherapy, he can come up with his brilliant ideas from his sick bed.

A lot of 'self-made' people have a very high opinion of their own abilities. Including their ability to stay healthy since health and wealth are often inextricably linked. Its not easy to get rich with poor health! This isn't to denigrate their achievements but it can be a blind spot!

No one likes to think of themselves getting sick and old, hence why rich people are often the ones who invest most heavily in their health. However there is no magic drug or exercise regimen that can protect against all illnesses.

yeah that falls under option b

socialmedia23 · 04/01/2023 18:14

HotChoxs · 04/01/2023 18:03

Either you're
a - affected by what's going on in this Country
b - don't care about anyone else
c - can whisk everyone you care about off to another country

if there's another option I'm all ears, otherwise I'll assume you're just trolling and fall into category b

option d: think you are too invincible to get sick.

I know someone like that, he thinks that because he exercises regularly, he is immune to illness and if he is, he is very rich and can get healthcare in another country. In his words, even if he has to undergo chemotherapy, he can come up with his brilliant ideas from his sick bed.

A lot of 'self-made' people have a very high opinion of their own abilities. Including their ability to stay healthy since health and wealth are often inextricably linked. Its not easy to get rich with poor health! This isn't to denigrate their achievements but it can be a blind spot!

No one likes to think of themselves getting sick and old, hence why rich people are often the ones who invest most heavily in their health. However there is no magic drug or exercise regimen that can protect against all illnesses.

scaredoff · 04/01/2023 18:13

All the people saying everything's fine with the health service because you got a same day appointment easily last week, or your kid went to A&E, got treated promptly and follow-up appointments etc, I'm not doubting your experiences, but -

When things like this break down, the breakdown tends not to be uniform? The NHS is a hugely complex organisation taking in GPs, hospitals, specialist services etc. over the whole country, some things centrally coordinated some run locally and subject to different local stresses and effects upon funding. Some services in some places have clearly become completely dysfunctional, some just barely hanging on, some still OK.

Thing is, for a service as crucial as healthcare to be judged even "OK" as a whole, the vast majority of it should be OK and departures from that a rarity. It's clear that the opposite is the case: most of it's highly problematic at best, but there are certain lucky spots where it hasn't fallen too bad, yet.

If you happen to be experiencing one of those, great. It doesn't mean by any stretch that the widespread perception of severe decline is just in peoples' imaginations.

BigMandysBookClub · 04/01/2023 18:12

Yes, it's bad, but i havent known any different. I grew up in a low income family and worked during the Blair years in a low paid job as a young single person, so didnt benefit from the economic growth years, but I expect if I had my family and was my age now in the 90's/early 00's I would have had a very good life before housing went crazy in the mid 00's.

I think the difference now is the level of corruption and the expectation that working people bail out the government's mistakes constantly. This government only want to help elites and just see the electorate as a means of funding them and their friends lifestyles. They don't do their job, which is to work for us. It's very depressing and I really lack hope for the future. 40 and still can't buy a house with an above average income. Can't get my son assessed for SN. Have to threaten to complain/chase referrals to get anything done. Paid thousands in childcare and missed the best years of my son's life as we need two FT incomes to survive. Pretty frugal too as we have to be. This was not the case for my mum's generation. Things have definitely gone backwards.

I think things have been deteriorating for decades, but this has really gathered pace since 2016.

I have said to my other son that he needs to learn languages so he can work abroad. I feel trapped in the UK and hate it. I just want to see things moving forwards.

ILoveeCakes · 04/01/2023 18:08

HotChoxs · 04/01/2023 18:03

Either you're
a - affected by what's going on in this Country
b - don't care about anyone else
c - can whisk everyone you care about off to another country

if there's another option I'm all ears, otherwise I'll assume you're just trolling and fall into category b

At least the number of binary options has grown by 50% vs your last proposal

HotChoxs · 04/01/2023 18:03

ILoveeCakes · 04/01/2023 18:01

Because you're obviously trolling. Which is fine, but try to at least be funny in future

Either you're
a - affected by what's going on in this Country
b - don't care about anyone else
c - can whisk everyone you care about off to another country

if there's another option I'm all ears, otherwise I'll assume you're just trolling and fall into category b

uncomplicatedish · 04/01/2023 18:03

I think if you're worried about how bad the UK is then stay where you are in your cushy life and be one less person for the NHS to cater for.