Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are things in the UK really that bad?

392 replies

namechange10022002 · 04/01/2023 15:28

I’ve been living overseas for about seven years and I am lucky to have a very safe, easy, comfortable life here but for various reasons I really want to move back home to England. However I keep hearing about how bad the situation is over there, with the cost of living crisis, housing, energy bills, health service, etc. For example I was watching Triggernometry and the hosts were saying the next few years are going to be extremely difficult for everyone there. I was just wondering, is it really as bad as they say? If you never watched or read the news or looked at social media, would you notice the difference in your quality of life? What is the general feeling on the ground, so to speak?

I guess I just want to know if it would be a mistake to move back there.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 05/01/2023 10:26

kimshi · 05/01/2023 09:28

I see. I would compare us to other European nations or USA, Australia as you suggest.
Things have deteriorated in all those countries, yes, but not as rapidly or as badly as in the UK. Europe, in particular seems to be in big trouble but some countries which were previously less prosperous eg Poland are now in better shape economically.
I noticed that you take about British entitlement and arrogance on a later post and I agree with that. I think there is still a significant hangover from the empire which leads to this kind of thinking. What I am talking about is slightly different though, the rate of deceleration and the fact that prosperity has fallen significantly for a large proportion of people. Successive governments have managed the UK economy particularly poorly and this is the result.

I don't have Russian friends so I'm not sure what a range of Russian people may or may not think but the quality of life in China has certainly risen over the last 10 years or so (although they look to be in trouble now).

We have Russian friends.
A year ago dh was having a conversation with one about the fact his mum had to go into hospital for an operation. ‘You must be worried.’
’Yes, but luckily she’s not in England, she’s in Moscow.’
Obviously that doesn’t tell you what rural areas are like, Russia won’t have got any better since and there are many other reasons why life in Russia is worse (said friend has since applied for British citizenship) but it was a bit thought-provoking nonetheless.

Obbydoo · 05/01/2023 10:16

HotChoxs · 05/01/2023 08:47

Oh that's interesting so you've now called me childish, an idiot while providing no direct comparison between France and UK's private healthcare system

Do feel free to give us the exact breakdown then of GDP spend in the UK versus France on healthcare and the level of private care that's significant in France V the UK to justify your premise that these are comparitively different enough. You'll notice from that blue line that it strangely covers the entire population.

Also do feel free to let us know the number of strikes going on around Europe compared to the UK.

We can then draw conclusion as to whether you're just whataboutting or actually have an idea of what you're talking about which isn't evident from an "About France" link.

But you have already provided the comparison yourself! It's all in the article you quoted - France' healthcare is biased towards private and the UK is biased towards public.

MarshaBradyo · 05/01/2023 09:35

user1795437 · 05/01/2023 08:34

There are some strange things on this thread, Amazon Prime taking a week, struggling to return parcels and taking an item back to a shop. All things to make you not want to live here, how is returning things to shops in other countries. Myself I have never had a problem, maybe the stuff was worn or used and the buyer was refused a refund

Some people sound a bit extreme I agree. Lacking energy for basic tasks maybe.

SleeplessInEngland · 05/01/2023 09:33

The UK just suffered the lowest growth in the G7. Its real GDP contracted more than Japan, while the other 5 countires grew.

So no, it's not bad for everyone squally.

kimshi · 05/01/2023 09:28

Mezmer · 04/01/2023 22:29

Yes and yes. As well as Australia, most of Europe and the USA. Plus Russia and China.

which countries are YOU comparing it to that makes UK seem so shit?

I see. I would compare us to other European nations or USA, Australia as you suggest.
Things have deteriorated in all those countries, yes, but not as rapidly or as badly as in the UK. Europe, in particular seems to be in big trouble but some countries which were previously less prosperous eg Poland are now in better shape economically.
I noticed that you take about British entitlement and arrogance on a later post and I agree with that. I think there is still a significant hangover from the empire which leads to this kind of thinking. What I am talking about is slightly different though, the rate of deceleration and the fact that prosperity has fallen significantly for a large proportion of people. Successive governments have managed the UK economy particularly poorly and this is the result.

I don't have Russian friends so I'm not sure what a range of Russian people may or may not think but the quality of life in China has certainly risen over the last 10 years or so (although they look to be in trouble now).

SleeplessInEngland · 05/01/2023 09:27

Anytime someone uses 'scaremongering' in relation to the media you can be 99% sure what follows is an anecdotal waste of time.

DeadbeatYoda · 05/01/2023 09:24

BabyFour2023 · 04/01/2023 15:47

No. Media scaremongering as per usual. We’ve just had a lovely Christmas, I’ve had no problem getting GP appointments for my children, currently pregnant and my maternity care has been fantastic and my childrens school is still great.
We’re financially very lucky as to not feel the difference in bills and price rises but the shops, restaurants, pubs etc are all still packed so I’m sure the reality for many is not the poverty stricken image you’re all being shown.

'I'm fine so it must all be scaremongering' shocker! Some people struggle with funds, some with empathy.

Mamai90 · 05/01/2023 09:03

I'm in NI so obviously not England but still UK and in all honesty my quality of life hasn't changed. We are far from well off so definitely feeling the pinch more than usual but not enough to affect my quality of life. We can still be seen by a GP here, or where I am certainly. I had a baby last year and was worried about the state of maternity and the NHS but the care I received was fantastic. What I will say is I am worried about my loved ones getting ill, especially the state of the A&E departments and ambulance wait times. That is frightening. Though if I didn't watch the news etc then nothing much would have changed (for me).

SleeplessInEngland · 05/01/2023 08:56

Covid + a tory government that can't even be bothered to pretend it cares anymore is a dangerous combination.

PlinkPlonkFizz · 05/01/2023 08:55

Yes, it is that bad. It feels like all the public services have been slowly denuded since Thatcher and that's recently accelerated to crisis point. Brexit has been awful for us but in truth, the rot was already spreading. It's grim for many.

HotChoxs · 05/01/2023 08:52

Loving this, significant private funding. Despite the fact that it's such relatively trivial amount that they don't even submit it😂

HotChoxs · 05/01/2023 08:47

Obbydoo · 05/01/2023 08:32

Hmmm. Nice try! The detail below the graph explains that those without a red line are those that didn't provide information. You can't seriously believe that the French system is fully public funded?! 😂

Try this for an idiot's guide:

about-france.com/health-care.htm

Oh that's interesting so you've now called me childish, an idiot while providing no direct comparison between France and UK's private healthcare system

Do feel free to give us the exact breakdown then of GDP spend in the UK versus France on healthcare and the level of private care that's significant in France V the UK to justify your premise that these are comparitively different enough. You'll notice from that blue line that it strangely covers the entire population.

Also do feel free to let us know the number of strikes going on around Europe compared to the UK.

We can then draw conclusion as to whether you're just whataboutting or actually have an idea of what you're talking about which isn't evident from an "About France" link.

user1795437 · 05/01/2023 08:34

There are some strange things on this thread, Amazon Prime taking a week, struggling to return parcels and taking an item back to a shop. All things to make you not want to live here, how is returning things to shops in other countries. Myself I have never had a problem, maybe the stuff was worn or used and the buyer was refused a refund

Obbydoo · 05/01/2023 08:32

HotChoxs · 05/01/2023 08:15

Yeah? Strange lack of red line for what's considered the Best Universal Healthcare system..
www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpubh.2021.636750/full

Hmmm. Nice try! The detail below the graph explains that those without a red line are those that didn't provide information. You can't seriously believe that the French system is fully public funded?! 😂

Try this for an idiot's guide:

about-france.com/health-care.htm

HotChoxs · 05/01/2023 08:15

Obbydoo · 05/01/2023 08:03

It's not whataboutery at all. Comparing the UK to similar countries is a considerably more intelligent approach than comparing it to your own perdonal ideals then stamping your feet like a child because things are difficult.

You are right that France's health system is more successful than ours. Statistically the UK compares badly to similar countries in health... but all of those countries, including France, have a level of privatisation much higher than ours.

Yeah? Strange lack of red line for what's considered the Best Universal Healthcare system..
www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpubh.2021.636750/full

Are things in the UK really that bad?
Obbydoo · 05/01/2023 08:03

HotChoxs · 04/01/2023 22:54

Whatabouttery. Do you think Countries that strike frequently like France have decimated their health service

(Spoiler... they haven't!)

It's not whataboutery at all. Comparing the UK to similar countries is a considerably more intelligent approach than comparing it to your own perdonal ideals then stamping your feet like a child because things are difficult.

You are right that France's health system is more successful than ours. Statistically the UK compares badly to similar countries in health... but all of those countries, including France, have a level of privatisation much higher than ours.

BabyFour2023 · 05/01/2023 07:57

Champere · 05/01/2023 05:45

Services just don’t work properly or efficiently. Calling a bank, returning a parcel, making an appointment, arranging a trade, taking an item back to a shop; it’s all made harder by rubbish systems and generally people who are paid too little to care (and I don’t blame them!).

Things are too expensive and the cost of housing keeps us trapped in jobs. As a nation we eat poorly, don’t exercise enough and we accept poor standards to avoid making a fuss.

If we could afford to leave, we would.

How on earth are you struggling to return parcels :/

Wallywobbles · 05/01/2023 07:02

I've been in France for 27 years. Services have declined here a bit over that time particularly the health service post covid. But I've always been able to get a same day gp appointment despite living rurally. And no hospital appointments were canceled due to covid.

Kids had school all the way through covid apart from the first lock down.

Gas has gone up but capped at 15% for 2023. Our electric bill has actually gone down. New nuclear plants are planned to meet future demand.

Animal feed for the farm has gone up a lot.

Legal services still functioning at normal speed.

Police service doesn't feel like it's declined.

We can live comfortably on our salaries. Foreign holidays cost more due to flights costing a lot more.

Food banks exist but no one with a job needs access.

The number of homeless doesn't seem to have increased in our closest big town.

I'm always shocked by the state of the Uk roads and the litter along them.

The British press seems to delight in painting Macron/the French as devils but my experience is in stark contrast.

Champere · 05/01/2023 05:45

Services just don’t work properly or efficiently. Calling a bank, returning a parcel, making an appointment, arranging a trade, taking an item back to a shop; it’s all made harder by rubbish systems and generally people who are paid too little to care (and I don’t blame them!).

Things are too expensive and the cost of housing keeps us trapped in jobs. As a nation we eat poorly, don’t exercise enough and we accept poor standards to avoid making a fuss.

If we could afford to leave, we would.

MrsEdnaWelthorpe · 05/01/2023 03:35

darjeelingrose · 04/01/2023 17:10

That's really not true for retired people though is it? They could have moved and now can't.

I don't know about other EU countries, but pensioners can definitely live in Spain on a non-lucrative visa if they have an income of around £24k.

blackpearwhitelilies · 05/01/2023 01:38

I used to get so, so homesick living abroad. I really love the UK. We came home in 2010. I do now, though, wonder if we would have come home if we’d been able to foresee Brexit and the terrible damage done by the Tories. It’s not the country it was twelve years ago.

AnuSTart · 05/01/2023 01:33

We live in Europe and I get so homesick sometimes but I just don't feel like I can come home. Things are comparatively ok here (Germany) and the kids are getting a good education. I can see a doctor whenever I want and although food prices have rocketed it still seems manageable. That said we are on a good income.

I miss the UK and Britons very much. I was hoping it wouldn't be that bad. This thread has made me so sad.

socialmedia23 · 04/01/2023 23:32

Mezmer · 04/01/2023 23:24

Kind of the point I was making: that it’s all in the eye of the beholder.

what we tend to do in Britain is believe we are above every other country. That somehow we should preside over the rest of the world in terms of what we should be doing and deserve.

It’s arrogant but totally opposite to Russia and China where people are brainwashed with propaganda to believe they have it good and they are lucky.

our press and media brainwashes us into believing our governments are crap and that we all deserve to much better and that we are being let down.

No other country in the world has a press like the uk does. It’s poison.

one poster up thread blamed all the ‘gullible brexit voters’ for ruining Britain. Like everyone is gullible but her. Yes of course. Couldn’t possibly be that she’s been reading too much guardian and spending too much time on Twitter. No. It has to be that what she has washed her brain with is far more worthy and ‘truthful’.

i think living in Britain is shit. It’s always been shit. The weathers crap and its too overcrowded. the nhs needs reforming and public services need a shake up. But I’m not dim enough to think that’s there’s some paradise somewhere that has it all. And it’s not money that the uk needs it needs leadership on all fronts.

but nobody will do anything for fear of doing a ‘truss’ and igniting a Twitter war. The end result is that we have mediocrity in government meaning nothing ever gets solved or shaken up.

that’s down to the social justice warriors and small but vocal minorities. At least brexit voters were up for changing the status quo.

Oh i love the weather.

The Russian and the Chinese person may not be wrong. After all what you have as your basis of comparison is your past experiences and the past experiences of your parents. Perhaps for the Russian and the Chinese, its not the propaganda but its just that genuinely life was terrible in the past, so they treasure that small amount of economic security they now enjoy (and the property they now own) and are willing to overlook their rulers' foolish experiments with imperialism.

From what I can see, many British people seem to have rose tinted views of the past. I am an immigrant so I can't really tell if life was better in the past and the UK has truly gone downhill (i came here in 2011 but I do feel everyone was much more optimistic when I first arrived). My DH grew up here and his life is definitely better now, his mum was a bohemian raising 4 kids so life was always very tough. Mumsnetters seem to recall a past where very ordinary people could buy houses in nice parts of London which does not correspond with DH's mum's experience- she had to raise 3 kids in a 1 bed flat before she could afford to upsize in London and money was always very tight. we both bought our flats at the same age and we both had to live at home before buying so nothing has changed on that front. Also she needed family help to upsize.

Mezmer · 04/01/2023 23:24

socialmedia23 · 04/01/2023 22:56

yes i once watched a documentary about Russia where a guy who worked on an oil rig said someone like him had a car, owned an apartment in the city as well as a dacha in the countryside, a stay at home wife and a son and daughter. What more can a man ask for, and Putin is great etc etc

You could interview an urban dweller in China and he would probably say something to that effect as well. And compared to what his grandparents and parents have, it would seem like heaven. Even with the covid restrictions.

Kind of the point I was making: that it’s all in the eye of the beholder.

what we tend to do in Britain is believe we are above every other country. That somehow we should preside over the rest of the world in terms of what we should be doing and deserve.

It’s arrogant but totally opposite to Russia and China where people are brainwashed with propaganda to believe they have it good and they are lucky.

our press and media brainwashes us into believing our governments are crap and that we all deserve to much better and that we are being let down.

No other country in the world has a press like the uk does. It’s poison.

one poster up thread blamed all the ‘gullible brexit voters’ for ruining Britain. Like everyone is gullible but her. Yes of course. Couldn’t possibly be that she’s been reading too much guardian and spending too much time on Twitter. No. It has to be that what she has washed her brain with is far more worthy and ‘truthful’.

i think living in Britain is shit. It’s always been shit. The weathers crap and its too overcrowded. the nhs needs reforming and public services need a shake up. But I’m not dim enough to think that’s there’s some paradise somewhere that has it all. And it’s not money that the uk needs it needs leadership on all fronts.

but nobody will do anything for fear of doing a ‘truss’ and igniting a Twitter war. The end result is that we have mediocrity in government meaning nothing ever gets solved or shaken up.

that’s down to the social justice warriors and small but vocal minorities. At least brexit voters were up for changing the status quo.

immigrant002 · 04/01/2023 23:18

Pollyforever · 04/01/2023 21:54

I live in a predominantly working class Northern city. I dont know anyone experiencing the hardship that posters are on Mumsnet. I'm a SAHM as are many of my friends so we are single income households. All have our heating on, still doing the weekly shop, days out with the kids, we are overpaying substantially on our mortgage and have a european holiday booked for the summer. None of us have two cars. We have a credit card that we clear in full each month. Who knows what lies ahead but things where I am aren't as bad as on mumsnet. I've needed 3x GP appointments in December, one for each child, seen same day. I had to cancel two hospital appointments in December because I had norovirus and they were rebooked straight away for early Feb. The people I know who are struggling (a couple of relatives) have always struggled and aren't more so now. All their children have the latest iPhone etc so they certainly could cut back if they wanted to but have never lived any other way. This is only my personal experience.

Where is this ??