Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are things in the UK really that bad?

392 replies

namechange10022002 · 04/01/2023 15:28

I’ve been living overseas for about seven years and I am lucky to have a very safe, easy, comfortable life here but for various reasons I really want to move back home to England. However I keep hearing about how bad the situation is over there, with the cost of living crisis, housing, energy bills, health service, etc. For example I was watching Triggernometry and the hosts were saying the next few years are going to be extremely difficult for everyone there. I was just wondering, is it really as bad as they say? If you never watched or read the news or looked at social media, would you notice the difference in your quality of life? What is the general feeling on the ground, so to speak?

I guess I just want to know if it would be a mistake to move back there.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
scaredoff · 05/01/2023 16:02

Sure. They’re much worse than they used to be. Waiting times aren’t the only determinator of a good healthcare system, though. If they were, we’d have to conclude that the US hits it out of the ballpark and offers the best healthcare model in the world. I doubt you agree with that conclusion (and nor does the broader hard data.)

No sure about that, given the number of Americans for whom "waiting time" is basically "forever".

ComtesseDeSpair · 05/01/2023 15:38

SleeplessInEngland · 05/01/2023 14:53

Cool, now look at the data of NHS waiting times compared to... its past self.

www.nuffieldtrust.org.uk/resource/chart-of-the-week-how-has-the-waiting-list-changed-over-the-years

And we can't even blame it on covid.

Sure. They’re much worse than they used to be. Waiting times aren’t the only determinator of a good healthcare system, though. If they were, we’d have to conclude that the US hits it out of the ballpark and offers the best healthcare model in the world. I doubt you agree with that conclusion (and nor does the broader hard data.)

BabyFour2023 · 05/01/2023 15:35

Thepeopleversuswork · 05/01/2023 15:10

I really loathe the phrase “media scaremongering”. It’s the badge of the moron.

Juat assume for the sake of argument that the media did have an explicit mandate to “scare”, they would need content to back that up.

Yes of course the media cherrypicks angles and facts. But we have yet to reach the point where the media doctors pictures of ambulances queuing outside hospitals. Or invents quotes from extremely reputable and senior clinicians.

Why weren’t they printing those photos 12-15 years ago of said ambulances? It was certainly happening then.

Zebedee55 · 05/01/2023 15:21

MilkyYay · 05/01/2023 12:36

If you earn a lot in the south east its fine.

If you are a teacher, nurse, police officer etc, your quality of life and standard of living has plunged in the last 5 years.

No, it's not. Because the cost of living in London and the SE is so high. For those on pensions or benefit/top ups, the disposable income for other regions is higher, because they are not regionalised.

Thepeopleversuswork · 05/01/2023 15:10

I really loathe the phrase “media scaremongering”. It’s the badge of the moron.

Juat assume for the sake of argument that the media did have an explicit mandate to “scare”, they would need content to back that up.

Yes of course the media cherrypicks angles and facts. But we have yet to reach the point where the media doctors pictures of ambulances queuing outside hospitals. Or invents quotes from extremely reputable and senior clinicians.

SleeplessInEngland · 05/01/2023 14:53

ComtesseDeSpair · 05/01/2023 12:32

In healthcare terms, the Commonwealth Fund ranked the UK 4th in its 2021 study of 11 countries - below Norway, the Netherlands and Australia, but above Canada, France, Germany, Switzerland, New Zealand, Sweden and the US); and placed it in first place for five years prior to that. The Legatum Index placed it 10th last year - below the Scandinavian countries, Germany, New Zealand and Ireland, but above Canada, France, Australia, Belgium, Spain and South Korea. The WHO reckoned it was 18th in performance terms - putting it still ahead of Ireland, Germany, Canada and Denmark.

Which tells us that a) hard data available to three renowned and internationally respected bodies led them to believe the NHS is not “appalling” and that b) performance ratings and statistical studies apparently aren’t reflective of anecdotes and people’s experiences on the ground.

Cool, now look at the data of NHS waiting times compared to... its past self.

www.nuffieldtrust.org.uk/resource/chart-of-the-week-how-has-the-waiting-list-changed-over-the-years

And we can't even blame it on covid.

CakeCrumbs44 · 05/01/2023 14:47

Life is pretty much the same as always here. Energy costs have gone up obviously but for us it is affordable, and none of my friends and living on beans and having to sit in the dark and cold house.

I needed NHS treatment recently and was seen the same day by the doctor, was referred and seen by a specialist about 10 days later and had minor surgery about 6 weeks later to sort out the problem. No long waiting times, all good.
If it wasn't for the media and people complaining on Mumsnet I wouldn't know that the UK was "a mess".

Jacketandbeans · 05/01/2023 14:40

Shortage of eggs is annoying

Zebedee55 · 05/01/2023 14:31

My son lives in America, and they have a lot of the same problems, with higher prices, interest rates etc.

I don't know - I did the recession of the 70's, winter of discontent, as an adult, with rocketing inflation, interest rates, fuel and food prices, crap NHS, etc;

This recession doesn't seem as bad, although it might be for those who aren't old enough to have lived through the previous ones.

They pass in the end. It'll probably get worse before it gets better though.😗

DonnaBanana · 05/01/2023 13:55

SleeplessInEngland · 05/01/2023 09:27

Anytime someone uses 'scaremongering' in relation to the media you can be 99% sure what follows is an anecdotal waste of time.

Spy the Daily Mail reader.

Clavinova · 05/01/2023 13:48

immigrant002
Do other European countries tell you to drive someone with a suspected heart attack to the hospital

This doesn't sound good either -

November 2022
A man with a suspected heart attack was forced to spend three days on a chair in the emergency department of a major Dublin hospital

www.independent.ie/irish-news/man-with-suspected-heart-attack-spent-three-days-on-a-chair-in-hospital-emergency-department-42149339.html

MilkyYay · 05/01/2023 12:42

If I avoided mumsnet then it would really only amount to a bit of grumbling about rising food and fuel prices amongst friends and colleagues.

This. We live in an affluent area and the pubs and restaurants are full, the neighbourhood kids are racing round on brand new christmas bikes, lots of people are moving job and getting payrises.

MilkyYay · 05/01/2023 12:38

I would agree with PPs that its bad everywhere. My colleagues are in the US, germany & Switzerland and have many of the same concerns as us. Relatives live in Canada and Australia and say the same.

MilkyYay · 05/01/2023 12:36

If you earn a lot in the south east its fine.

If you are a teacher, nurse, police officer etc, your quality of life and standard of living has plunged in the last 5 years.

ComtesseDeSpair · 05/01/2023 12:32

SleeplessInEngland · 05/01/2023 12:10

I am aware of how lucky I am, and am not in any way trying to deny the problems in the NHS - it's clear there are some real problems there and change is needed. But for me and for most people I know things are fine, quality of life is still pretty good, and it is nothing like the hellhole that I am seeing described by PPs.

Anecdotes are nice. Hard data is better. And it shows that NHS waiting lists are appalling.

In healthcare terms, the Commonwealth Fund ranked the UK 4th in its 2021 study of 11 countries - below Norway, the Netherlands and Australia, but above Canada, France, Germany, Switzerland, New Zealand, Sweden and the US); and placed it in first place for five years prior to that. The Legatum Index placed it 10th last year - below the Scandinavian countries, Germany, New Zealand and Ireland, but above Canada, France, Australia, Belgium, Spain and South Korea. The WHO reckoned it was 18th in performance terms - putting it still ahead of Ireland, Germany, Canada and Denmark.

Which tells us that a) hard data available to three renowned and internationally respected bodies led them to believe the NHS is not “appalling” and that b) performance ratings and statistical studies apparently aren’t reflective of anecdotes and people’s experiences on the ground.

Clavinova · 05/01/2023 12:17

immigrant002
Do other European countries tell you to drive someone with a suspected heart attack to the hospital cause he is young and is probably fine and there are no ambulances

No idea - but this sounds like a plan;

Hospitals in France are to charge a fixed-rate sum of €19.61 from January 1 [2022] for patients who go to the accident and emergency ward (urgences) but are not then admitted to hospital.

www.connexionfrance.com/article/French-news/French-hospitals-to-set-flat-fee-of-19.61-for-A-E-care-from-January-1

Not something we should copy;
2018 Riot police clash with ambulance drivers in France...

www.standard.co.uk/news/world/riot-police-clash-with-ambulance-drivers-in-france-a4006951.html

MarshaBradyo · 05/01/2023 12:16

If you never watched or read the news or looked at social media, would you notice the difference in your quality of life? What is the general feeling on the ground, so to speak?

The op asked for personal accounts though. So posters are saying how it is in their area, with people they know.

SleeplessInEngland · 05/01/2023 12:10

I am aware of how lucky I am, and am not in any way trying to deny the problems in the NHS - it's clear there are some real problems there and change is needed. But for me and for most people I know things are fine, quality of life is still pretty good, and it is nothing like the hellhole that I am seeing described by PPs.

Anecdotes are nice. Hard data is better. And it shows that NHS waiting lists are appalling.

Kinnorafron · 05/01/2023 12:09

A lot of Russian citizens seem to think their Country is great and everything is good and that the UK is a joke. Which goes to show you how useful comparisons are.
What are their gas prices like?

BethDuttonsTwin · 05/01/2023 12:08

Rotherweird · 05/01/2023 11:56

I think I must be living in a different country to many posters. I live in a slightly crappy inner suburb of a big city (not naice). Things are fine. I can go to the local discounter supermarket and buy plentiful cheap good quality food. I have an NHS appointment tomorrow for a minor injury. I had to go to A and E a few months ago and there was a longish wait but it was fine and staff were extremely kind. My child is on track to get good GCSEs in a distinctly average comprehensive. I saw lots of friends over Christmas and everybody was cheerful and talking about their plans for the NY, not bemoaning the state of the world. We are all moderately-paid public sector workers.

I am aware of how lucky I am, and am not in any way trying to deny the problems in the NHS - it's clear there are some real problems there and change is needed. But for me and for most people I know things are fine, quality of life is still pretty good, and it is nothing like the hellhole that I am seeing described by PPs.

Same. I am a single parent with a part time job and a child with additional needs who has an EHCP and gets a lot of assistance in school. It wasn’t always like that for her I will admit but once in secondary where they had processes in place it all got easier - she is sitting GCSEs, which I never thought possible. I took her to the doctors yesterday - I called at 8.15 and was in at 9. I’m at my NHS dentist right now about to have treatment, I had to wait two weeks - Christmas though. I’m in social housing and when something goes wrong, I log into my housing account and request repairs, they’re usually completed within a week. Maybe I am just really lucky but most of my friends and family seem to be going along ok as well. The only thing I have noticed is an increase in my food shop, that is admittedly fairly significant, costs about 15/20% more than it used to.

SofiaSoFar · 05/01/2023 12:00

I completely agree, @Rotherweird

It's the same where we are. No major issues with anything that I've seen being posted about on this thread.

Rotherweird · 05/01/2023 11:56

I think I must be living in a different country to many posters. I live in a slightly crappy inner suburb of a big city (not naice). Things are fine. I can go to the local discounter supermarket and buy plentiful cheap good quality food. I have an NHS appointment tomorrow for a minor injury. I had to go to A and E a few months ago and there was a longish wait but it was fine and staff were extremely kind. My child is on track to get good GCSEs in a distinctly average comprehensive. I saw lots of friends over Christmas and everybody was cheerful and talking about their plans for the NY, not bemoaning the state of the world. We are all moderately-paid public sector workers.

I am aware of how lucky I am, and am not in any way trying to deny the problems in the NHS - it's clear there are some real problems there and change is needed. But for me and for most people I know things are fine, quality of life is still pretty good, and it is nothing like the hellhole that I am seeing described by PPs.

Champere · 05/01/2023 11:42

BabyFour2023 · 05/01/2023 07:57

How on earth are you struggling to return parcels :/

40/50 minute queues in local post offices, no empty slots in local InPost lockers.

Not to do with sellers refusing returns…as a PP implied.

YeezyPeasy · 05/01/2023 11:36

namechange10022002 · 04/01/2023 19:15

@TakeYourFinalPosition Where did you move back from?

We’re in Quebec. As much as I have complained about having to live here, we are lucky to have a beautiful home, an OK car, private healthcare and dental, high quality daycare with class sizes of about 8 kids or fewer, that only costs about £27 per week per kid. I’ve heard the healthcare system here is overwhelmed but I haven’t experienced it for myself.

I want to move back to England for many reasons like family and also I just love the culture and the countryside and London, etc. but perhaps I should wait.

I would urge you to stay in Canada. The England you left is no more.
Would it be possible to visit for 2-3 weeks to see what you think before planning a move back? Visit some GP surgeries, A&Es, supermarkets, get on the tube, busses. Not sure where you’d be moving back to but London, Birmingham, Manchester, Leicester, Bradford, etc. are shitholes.

HotChoxs · 05/01/2023 10:37

Obbydoo · 05/01/2023 10:16

But you have already provided the comparison yourself! It's all in the article you quoted - France' healthcare is biased towards private and the UK is biased towards public.

I have absolutely zero idea what you're on about and that's obviously complete nonsense when the French system is Universal with a slight privatisation for people who aren't particularly ill. Much like getting a private Dr's appointment here when you can't get a GP appointment now ironically only it would still be subsidised in France.

But you can make this clear by giving a direct GDP percentage contribution from both publically and privately funded if you want, you'll find that France makes a higher public contribution towards it's health services and has done for years which has led to better investment of resources hence it's not falling apart.

Basically France's health service has not been mismanaged ours has, and even though there have been strikes in France there have been frequent ones which have led to better investment. Not so here, junior dr strikes were nigh on ignored.

Swipe left for the next trending thread