Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there has been a shift in social attitudes towards the role of 16/17 year olds over the last few years

35 replies

Toomuchisnotenough · 04/01/2023 15:15

The governments new plan to make maths/English compulsory until age 18 has got me thinking about something. All the opposition to this plan has been based on it being unworkable/unnecessary not that you should be able at 16/17 to pick your own subjects. Last year I remember the marriage bill to raise the age to 18 and remove the right for 16/17 year olds to get married. This was met with overwhelming support and (including on MN) it was almost universally agreed that age 16/17 is far too young to be married. On MN a few years ago (probably about before 2018 time) any 16/17 year old who was restricted by their parents rules almost always the response would be that the OP was BU and should allow them to do what they want. Recently, it seems on more threads that the attitude is that 16/17 year olds are children and should be restricted by their parents still - often the “brain doesn’t develop until 25” is used as justification. Of course, mumsnet is not a hive mind. However, it is representative of a large section of public opinion and when over and over again the same narratives come up on threads vs what was said maybe five years ago I think that does demonstrate something about social attitudes. I don’t necessarily think this is a bad change but I just find it interesting how attitudes seem to have changed so much in just a few years. Aibu to think there has been a big change in social attitudes towards 16/17 year olds in the last few years?

OP posts:
redskydelight · 04/01/2023 16:36

ILoveeCakes · 04/01/2023 16:05

When I was a teen, pretty much every one at school had a part time job - even if their parents earned good money. It was seen as part of growing up - good experience, earn own (drinking) money etc.

These days, I come across so many parents who discourage their teens from working and pay them generous pocket money - and buy them a car a decent amount of the time.

I think this is an area (or possibly a school) thing.
Just about everyone in Year 12 at my DD's school has a part time job.
At my niece's school I'm told that virtually no one does.

SeenAndNot · 04/01/2023 16:24

Nordix · 04/01/2023 15:30

I agree there has been a shift. I feel pretty morally neutral about it but it’s definitely there.

It feels like a few decades ago (90s/00s maybe 10s) a 16 or 17 year old would have a lot of freedom to go out with their mates, dating, maybe get their own flat or get a job if they’re fed up with school. Maybe be mates with an older group of friends. Have their own car and drive themselves to college etc (does this still happen?)

It seems to me that all older teenagers (15-17) seem to have less freedom these days though. Albeit I have seen a limited sample.

I don’t necessarily agree that if two 17-year-olds want to be daft and get married, they shouldn’t be allowed to get on with it. You live and you learn. Based on the “brain not developed before 25” theory I shouldn’t have got married, had my first child, and a whole host of other things I did in my early 20s! (None of which were bad choices btw!)

Could this be part of the general societal shift towards keeping young adults younger for longer (young people living with parents longer, advised to put off kids/marriage until older etc?). Reminds me of a thread yesterday about the 29-year-old BIL who still lived with his mum
and left wee on the toilet seat at other people’s houses. Maybe he’d have been better off moving out at 17 and supporting himself/a girlfriend. Your brain can’t develop if you never have to use it!

There’s been a big shift with every generation since the war in my opinion. I was talking to my Gran last week - teen during the war. The norm then was to live at home with parents until you got married, unless you were one of the very few who could afford university. She moaned her husband left home to marry her when he was 26 and he never learnt to cook and expected her to do everything. She’s very impressed my husband cooks and cleans.

in the 60’s I think free love made a massive change to society. Suddenly it’s ok to shack up and leave home unmarried. Coupled with more young people going off to uni to study. Teens rolled up skirts and off they went.

Maybe it’s only now we are realising that our grandparents had some wisdom in their old fashioned ways. 16 is too young to make some decisions such as marriage. I certainly think back with horror at what our parents let us do in the 90’s - off to house parties with a crate of beers at 14, didn’t bat an eyelid to us going out on the town drinking at 16. We got in a lot of mess doing that.

MichaelAndEagle · 04/01/2023 16:20

ILoveeCakes · 04/01/2023 16:05

When I was a teen, pretty much every one at school had a part time job - even if their parents earned good money. It was seen as part of growing up - good experience, earn own (drinking) money etc.

These days, I come across so many parents who discourage their teens from working and pay them generous pocket money - and buy them a car a decent amount of the time.

This is so true. I really want my DS 15 to get a job when he's 16. But I'm not sure how it will be viewed?
He'll need one if he wants any decent spending money.

PuttingDownRoots · 04/01/2023 16:14

Before the 2nd World War, school leaving age was 14. Now its effectively 18. Society's expectations evolve constantly.

One of my biggest Mumsnet shocks is how much input some parents expect to have into University choices for example. My very involved parents.. . Made sure I could get to open days and interviews, read my personal statement to check for grammar etc, and commiserated and congratulated me for my rejections etc.

ILoveeCakes · 04/01/2023 16:05

When I was a teen, pretty much every one at school had a part time job - even if their parents earned good money. It was seen as part of growing up - good experience, earn own (drinking) money etc.

These days, I come across so many parents who discourage their teens from working and pay them generous pocket money - and buy them a car a decent amount of the time.

AceofPentacles · 04/01/2023 15:52

I think the general infantilising of young people has led to less confidence - they lack a lot of general independence skills compared to previous generations which seems to leave them with the idea that 'someone else will do it' . My observation based on working with 16+ teens

redskydelight · 04/01/2023 15:44

We've had issues with the NHS assigning under 16s to paediatric care and 18s and over to adult care. The areas we've dealt with don't seem to have a consistent policy for 16 and 17 year olds. So not just individuals that don't quite know how to treat them!

Greeneyegirl · 04/01/2023 15:40

I dont agree with forcing teens to study maths until 18 exactly but i have always thought it odd that to some extent we expect 16 year olds to choose their entire futures. By this i mean they are expected fo choose their 3 a level subjects at 16 which will inform their degree options afterwards and therefore their choice of career. I know 3 friends who have absolutely bankrupt themselves in their late 20s redoing alevels in evenings and then going back to uni full time for 3 years in order to do a degree (one midwife, 2 teachers so the degree is needed). Its so odd that we expect 15/16 year olds to have a career path mapped out

Anonymous48 · 04/01/2023 15:32

There probably has been a shift, and I think that's a good thing. The science on brain development has become better understood in the past few years. It wasn't that long ago that we didn't know that the brain wasn't fully developed until about age 25.

Nordix · 04/01/2023 15:30

I agree there has been a shift. I feel pretty morally neutral about it but it’s definitely there.

It feels like a few decades ago (90s/00s maybe 10s) a 16 or 17 year old would have a lot of freedom to go out with their mates, dating, maybe get their own flat or get a job if they’re fed up with school. Maybe be mates with an older group of friends. Have their own car and drive themselves to college etc (does this still happen?)

It seems to me that all older teenagers (15-17) seem to have less freedom these days though. Albeit I have seen a limited sample.

I don’t necessarily agree that if two 17-year-olds want to be daft and get married, they shouldn’t be allowed to get on with it. You live and you learn. Based on the “brain not developed before 25” theory I shouldn’t have got married, had my first child, and a whole host of other things I did in my early 20s! (None of which were bad choices btw!)

Could this be part of the general societal shift towards keeping young adults younger for longer (young people living with parents longer, advised to put off kids/marriage until older etc?). Reminds me of a thread yesterday about the 29-year-old BIL who still lived with his mum
and left wee on the toilet seat at other people’s houses. Maybe he’d have been better off moving out at 17 and supporting himself/a girlfriend. Your brain can’t develop if you never have to use it!

Swipe left for the next trending thread