Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there has been a shift in social attitudes towards the role of 16/17 year olds over the last few years

35 replies

Toomuchisnotenough · 04/01/2023 15:15

The governments new plan to make maths/English compulsory until age 18 has got me thinking about something. All the opposition to this plan has been based on it being unworkable/unnecessary not that you should be able at 16/17 to pick your own subjects. Last year I remember the marriage bill to raise the age to 18 and remove the right for 16/17 year olds to get married. This was met with overwhelming support and (including on MN) it was almost universally agreed that age 16/17 is far too young to be married. On MN a few years ago (probably about before 2018 time) any 16/17 year old who was restricted by their parents rules almost always the response would be that the OP was BU and should allow them to do what they want. Recently, it seems on more threads that the attitude is that 16/17 year olds are children and should be restricted by their parents still - often the “brain doesn’t develop until 25” is used as justification. Of course, mumsnet is not a hive mind. However, it is representative of a large section of public opinion and when over and over again the same narratives come up on threads vs what was said maybe five years ago I think that does demonstrate something about social attitudes. I don’t necessarily think this is a bad change but I just find it interesting how attitudes seem to have changed so much in just a few years. Aibu to think there has been a big change in social attitudes towards 16/17 year olds in the last few years?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Anonymous48 · 09/01/2023 20:29

Siameasy · 09/01/2023 19:12

IMO treated too much like young children. Just because they’re legally “a child” for the purposes of some legislation doesn’t mean there shouldn’t be a distinction between the type of child they are. It’s not just that age group, it’s all secondary aged children being infantilised. It’s contributing to anxiety in this age group.

Well of course there are differences between 16 and 17 year old children, and 5 year old children. But 16 and 17 year olds are still children.

Siameasy · 09/01/2023 19:12

IMO treated too much like young children. Just because they’re legally “a child” for the purposes of some legislation doesn’t mean there shouldn’t be a distinction between the type of child they are. It’s not just that age group, it’s all secondary aged children being infantilised. It’s contributing to anxiety in this age group.

Anonymous48 · 09/01/2023 17:21

Ruffpuff · 04/01/2023 19:54

I think young adults are often over infantilised in todays world too. Parents accept their 22 year old storming around the house, behaving like a spoilt teenager, refusing to do chores, demanding money and shouting at parents, ‘because their brains aren’t fully developed until 25’ (which is a huge misconception regarding the neural pruning phase the brain goes through at this time). I’m 25, moved out at 18 independently, went to uni and had a baby at 21. I didn’t have a baby at that age intentionally, but I dealt with it like an adult should and got myself sorted and made my own choices without input from parents. Whereas I think most people on here would have a fit if finding out their darling underdeveloped infant of an adult was in that position. I find it shocking how over involved and enabling some parents on here are with their older teens/young adults lives’.

I think there's a big gap between recognizing that young adults' brains aren't fully developed yet and they therefore don't always make the best decisions, and condoning them storming around the house refusing to do chores, demanding money and shouting at parents!

I have two children who are in that 18-25 age group. I know and accept that their brains aren't fully developed, but I also wouldn't accept them behaving like spoilt teenagers!

SantaCarlaCalifornia · 04/01/2023 21:15

I agree that a lot of teenagers have been infantilised in some ways, but in some others are being treated as way older and wiser than they are.

As someone said above, in Scotland 16-year-olds will be able to legally change their gender before they can even drink alcohol. Plus they want them to be able to be members of parliament at 16 and 17.

There seems to be simultaneous adultification of children much too young and infantilisation of teenagers much too old.

Oystersandwhelks · 04/01/2023 20:19

LlynTegid · 04/01/2023 17:02

I think you are right OP to say there has been a shift, some of which I agree with (minimum age of marriage for example), others not.

And it is disparate and inconsistent, for example in Scotland it could be that you could legally change your gender before you can drive a car.

In Scotland, the SNP wants to change the rules so that a 16 year old can become a member of the Scottish Parliament. So they would be representing constituents and voting on legislation while still at school. The advantage of children is that they don't know much, have little life experience and are extremely malleable.

Florenz · 04/01/2023 20:11

A friend of mine works in student housing and had a story about a mother of a student ringing up irate because the ignition on the cooker wasn't working and the housing officer had brought round a big box of kitchen matches for them to use for a few days until they got someone out to fix it. She "didn't want her daughter playing with matches".

Eilan50 · 04/01/2023 19:59

In Scotland 16 and 17 year olds can marry and vote in elections for Scottish parliament. There's also a consultation going on about allowing them to stand for parliament 

Ruffpuff · 04/01/2023 19:54

I think young adults are often over infantilised in todays world too. Parents accept their 22 year old storming around the house, behaving like a spoilt teenager, refusing to do chores, demanding money and shouting at parents, ‘because their brains aren’t fully developed until 25’ (which is a huge misconception regarding the neural pruning phase the brain goes through at this time). I’m 25, moved out at 18 independently, went to uni and had a baby at 21. I didn’t have a baby at that age intentionally, but I dealt with it like an adult should and got myself sorted and made my own choices without input from parents. Whereas I think most people on here would have a fit if finding out their darling underdeveloped infant of an adult was in that position. I find it shocking how over involved and enabling some parents on here are with their older teens/young adults lives’.

postcardpuffin · 04/01/2023 19:46

MichaelAndEagle · 04/01/2023 16:20

This is so true. I really want my DS 15 to get a job when he's 16. But I'm not sure how it will be viewed?
He'll need one if he wants any decent spending money.

Interestingly, on this, I do university admissions, and in the 20+ years I’ve been doing it, between 2000 and 2020 it was really rare to see a 17 yo put a part time job on their UCAS form. Very few, those who did usually on the poorer side, had a job at that age. Last year and this year all of them had put jobs on their form - usually bar, retail or casual work, but the change was really striking. Didn’t seem to correlate to background, either - the wealthier ones also had jobs.

I’m guessing that for a fair number of teens, part time work was a way they could actually get out of the house during the lockdowns, and they didn’t feel too vulnerable to Covid, so it was attractive as something to do. I also reckon the post-Brexit labour shortage has a role to play - restaurants and pubs are hiring teenagers because of lack of staff, when previously they wouldn’t have done, maybe?

In any case, I think there’s a bit of a shift under way, and lots of young people are actually getting part-time jobs at the moment. There’s plenty that’s annoying about that generation - all the gender stuff and an obsession with mental health issues and so on. However, they party less, they drink much less and don’t tend to take drugs, they work hard at school, and they seem to be keen on getting out there to do part-time paid work, too, all of which is pretty admirable.

MargaretThursday · 04/01/2023 19:41

I think when a good proportion of people expected to leave school at 16 and get a job people did grow up quicker.
Among my Dad's friend/relatives there were a fair number who were married with a child by 18yo and he was considered the odd one because he went off to uni-the first one from his school.

But he was expected to fund himself, so he was working from young-I suspect from about 11yo if not younger. He worked pulling pints and on a farm from 14yo, and he was telling me the other day that when he was 15yo he had a weekend job as a landscape gardener at a local "posh" house. He saw an advert in a shop window, went round and told the lady what he'd like to do with her garden and she employed him. She used to introduce him as her "head gardener"! He used to go down to the local allotments if he didn't know how to deal with something in her garden and pick the brains of the people working there.

bellac11 · 04/01/2023 19:41

I think that over time, we have infantilised young adults and that has impacted on how we manage and enable young people transitioning to adulthoood as well. And of course there is a massive disparity in how people mature

Its really common on this site (and some others) to use the information about brain development as a reason why this cant happen or these decisions cant be taken, etc etc. But its not a simplistic as that, there is an evolutionary reason why our brains are more elastic in early adulthood because it means that we take more risks, are more impulsive are more able to think outside of established norms or routines. Given that life expectancy may have been around 35/40 in early humans, that makes perfect sense in that from the late teens onward, you would be procreating, building your family, developing your strength and skill without thinking 'oh I might hurt myself, better be careful and not chase that bison'

But as per usual modern people have used it to mean 'dont give a 20 year old any responsibility, their brain isnt finished growing'.

What do they think happened for centuries where from teens onward people were effectively adults, working and having relationships as adults, having children and families,, building business and careers and responsible positions.

Echobelly · 04/01/2023 19:37

Longer than the last few years, about the last decade attitudes have changed. I do get the 'brain doesn't mature until later' things, but I really dislike an attitude that seems to have built up in some quarters that anyone (or a lot of people) under 18 aren't responsible or capable.

I first noticed it in the 2012 Olympics when there was an article about whoever was providing a lot of Olympic support services (someone like Capita) was shock horror prepared to have '16 and 17 year olds do bag searches'. Now, Capita definitely was incompetent in many ways, but I remember it really bothering me how some parts of the media wrote as if searching a bag was beyond a 16-17yo's capability.

CitronVert22 · 04/01/2023 19:36

At school we were taught it's about the increasing complexity of society. And it's true. When all you had to do was farm some crops adulthood came earlier - although I do boggle at the odd teenage monarch who managed to not mess everything up - that is complex! But even then winning a battle is less complex than trying to oversee Brexit and the NHS.

EweCee · 04/01/2023 19:29

Sorry, my post sounds really judgy! I don't mean it to - when I say horrified by behaviour of teenagers, I mean the freedom and then the problems that came with that freedom and them not knowing how to handle it plus the responsibilities placed on them - again with them not having the maturity, knowledge and skills to handle it then.

EweCee · 04/01/2023 19:25

I think it might be a UK thing as where I grew up (Commonwealth country), we were still 'children' until 18 and given the freedom within boundaries and I honestly think I had a better childhood and young adulthood because of it. I was allowed to mature without having to take on responsibility/ behaviour I wasn't ready for. When I moved here, I was horrified at some of the behaviour from teenagers (family members) and that their parents had no idea where they were/ what they were up to and weren't phased in the slightest about it. When I married my DH and were discussing having children, I said even then that there was no way any child of ours would be gadding about the city overnight with their mates when they were a teenager!

CiderJolly · 04/01/2023 19:22

zingally · 04/01/2023 16:59

I feel like I had a lot more confidence and independence at that age than teenagers now do.
When I was in sixth form, a lot of my mates were living in flats with boyfriends/girlfriends/friends and had full time jobs. You don't see that now.

That’s because the price of rent, bills, fuel, food etc is sky high and wages have not risen in proportion. They can’t afford it!

modgepodge · 04/01/2023 19:12

I agree OP. I’m 36. Most of my friends had part time jobs at 14/15, I was most irritated my mum wouldn’t let me get one til I had done my GCSEs so almost 17! From 16 I was out in pubs/bars/house parties most weekends, parents often giving me a small amount of alcohol to take or we bought it ourselves. This was very normal amongst my group of friends. Now on here people often seem shocked at 15/16 year olds having a single drink at home let alone under 18s drinking outside the house! And I guess stricter laws and ID checks mean underage pubbing and clubbing is far rarer. Hardly any 14-18 year olds seem to have jobs.

im a maths teacher (primary) and I disagree with everyone studying maths to 18. If everyone could just do what they are supposed to achieve by the time they leave primary school, they’d be alright in the real world I think.

Florenz · 04/01/2023 18:37

It's crazy to have compulsory Maths until 18. Kids who have no aptitude or interest in Maths would just be bored out of their mind and disruptive. I don't even think Maths should be compulsory at GCSE level. Once kids are able to recognise the numbers, count and do basic arithmetic, let them move onto vocational courses and get them into the workforce, earning money and paying taxes, not stuck in classrooms making things difficult for everyone.

Goosefatroasts · 04/01/2023 18:18

I’m 34. At 16 I was clubbing every weekend. Having casual sex, drinking too much alcohol.

I was also working full time in a solicitors office and making decent enough money. I still think it was too much too young. I think doing that at 18 would have been more appropriate I guess.

PuttingDownRoots · 04/01/2023 18:16

Another major outlier is that 16&17yos can join the Armed Forces in the UK. Although not go to war zones.

LlynTegid · 04/01/2023 17:02

I think you are right OP to say there has been a shift, some of which I agree with (minimum age of marriage for example), others not.

And it is disparate and inconsistent, for example in Scotland it could be that you could legally change your gender before you can drive a car.

zingally · 04/01/2023 16:59

I feel like I had a lot more confidence and independence at that age than teenagers now do.
When I was in sixth form, a lot of my mates were living in flats with boyfriends/girlfriends/friends and had full time jobs. You don't see that now.

Cinnabomb · 04/01/2023 16:43

@PuttingDownRoots i had a different experience with my parents expectations for university tho, and that was 15 years ago. They ‘shortlisted’ some I was allowed to visit, they basically chose my course for me (which I’ve ended up in a field/ job I hate) and came and stayed overnight etc took me to interviews. So completely involved.

NestingSparrow · 04/01/2023 16:40

The maths up to 18 thing won’t happen.
It is purely to distract people from talking about the NHS, cost of living and immigration crises. Classic government spin.

Georgeskitchen · 04/01/2023 16:38

Mid 70s as a young teenager living in a seaside town, most of us had holiday jobs from 12/13 onwards. Nobody really adhered to the child labour laws.
Kids nowadays seem.to spend many more years being supported by their parents . Those not in further education seem to only want to work part time. I got a Leo Sayer LP for my 18th. Now it seems to be a car, at the very least.
Too many IMHO, seem to be going to university for some pointless degree racking up 1000s in debt. The clever ones are those who take up apprenticeships in plumbing, electrics, hairdressing, tailoring/dress making.
They will never be out of work!!