Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People in small boats

329 replies

EndlessRain1 · 04/01/2023 14:58

With everything that is going on in the UK at the moment, can it really be true that one of the top 5 priorities in the country is to stop "people in small boats"?

I mean, I know a lot of people are against immigration in this form, but in the grand scheme of the shit show this country has been in the last couple of years that is in the top 5 priorities/ actions?

AIBU to think that's insane?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
MarshaBradyo · 11/01/2023 19:51

Lollipop999 · 11/01/2023 19:50

I agree that would seem a much fairer system but we would need good control of our borders and a limit on numbers.

How would you limit numbers in practise?

Say 20,000 would like to come but the cap is 10k - how do you decide?

Lollipop999 · 11/01/2023 19:50

BewareTheLibrarians · 11/01/2023 18:36

But @Lollipop999 if they are biometrically registered overseas (usually fingerprinted) then they wouldn’t be able to try and claim asylum by a different route, and if they came illegally to work on the black market they couldn’t access healthcare, housing and would be at risk of being trafficked/forced labour. That’s not what people want.

I agree that would seem a much fairer system but we would need good control of our borders and a limit on numbers.

EffortlessDesmond · 11/01/2023 19:49

Since May 2022 42% are Albanian. And 95% of those are male.
Albania is considered to be a safe country so why should the UK grant them asylum?

The UK is an appealing destination for people who want a better life. Most of the world learns a smattering of English at school and it's an easy language to speak badly and still be understood. It is also a pretty tolerant and diverse society, much more than many others. Plus there is no expectation that everyone should be able to prove their identity for employment or housing or healthcare or education. So it is a magnet, for a lot of people from less fortunate countries. More relevant those countries have huge populations of young people (17-30 age range) looking for a better future which together probably total a billion people. Where is the UK going to accommodate a billion asylum seekers and economic migrants?

We would all have to stand up 24x7 to fit them in physically.

You need to consider the importance of speaking English in this. France has not seen jobs offshored to French speaking West Africa in the same way that UK call handling is routinely forwarded to Asian call centres to work from scripts. Businesses will outsource low level jobs to the cheapest place possible, and it is simply easier to do so anywhere most of the population speak some English.

Clavinova · 11/01/2023 19:46

Lollipop999
Free healthcare immediately and dental care.
Do they get this in all European westernised countries?

MaryMcCarthy
Yes. And in far greater numbers than they do here.
Look at immigration numbers into France or Germany, for example.

Apparently not:

2019
Macron plans to bar refugees from accessing medical care.
French government promises to 'take back control' of migration policy with three-month healthcare waiting period.

www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/emmanuel-macron-migrants-refugee-access-medical-care-immigration-latest-a9188166.html

April 2022
The UK vs Germany
Uncharacteristically, in the case of healthcare, the UK’s provisions for ASRs are more generous than Germany’s...

in Germany, asylum-seekers’ and refugees’ exclusion from healthcare services is explicit and intentional. The Asylum-seekers Benefit Act states that after 15 months of residence in Germany, ASRs gain the same rights to healthcare as the general population, but for the first 15, they have only a basic entitlement to emergency and acute healthcare, and require a health voucher to access non-emergency care...

While Germany is comparatively liberal in other areas of asylum policy (for example, the right to work), it needs an expansion of access to health services before its rules can be considered to be mutually beneficial to ASRs and the German state. On the other hand, in the UK, the NHS is immediately available (notwithstanding its infamous waiting times) but not always inclusive of ASRs.

www.europeanfutures.ed.ac.uk/asylum-seekers-and-refugees-access-to-healthcare-in-germany-and-the-uk/

woodhill · 11/01/2023 18:52

Lollipop999 · 11/01/2023 16:37

@RoseslnTheHospital

“So, actions that might actually reduce crossings are needed.”………Agree with this

“Like providing legal routes of entry for asylum seekers who are not in the UK” …..this would be the equivalent of political suicide and would be hugely unpopular. This would likely lead to a huge increase in claims which would need processing.

“working with the French to tackle the criminal gangs involved”…… absolutely agree and wonder why there is not more effort to stop these gangs.

”like sourcing accommodation that isn't hotels or unsuitable barracks” ……good luck with this, there are already millions of people in need of social housing. Sadly those who arrive on boats will join the top of the queue due to having no family or place of residence which rightly and understandably angers uk citizens who feel they should be more of a priority. I agree in an ideal world there would be housing for all and different decisions should and could have been made but at the moment it is not possible.

Yes it's not fair on those already here working and paying into the system

They should have priority

MavisMcMinty · 11/01/2023 18:47

The most xenophobic/anti-immigration people I know live as far from an immigrant as it’s possible to live, it’s an entirely abstract fear. All Tory Brexiters of course.

oviraptor21 · 11/01/2023 18:43

Tholeont · 04/01/2023 17:39

To @allboysherebutme you are blaming these people for a lot of things! What would you do to stop them coming? Starve them? Send them back to, say, Afghanistan where the Taliban would shoot them? We already expect them to live on £40 a week, don’t allow them to work, take a couple of years to process their asylum claims and are trying to send them to Rwanda - how do you suggest we treat them worse to stop them coming?

www.gov.uk/government/statistics/factsheet-small-boat-crossings-since-july-2022/factsheet-small-boat-crossings-since-july-2022

Since May 2022 42% are Albanian. And 95% of those are male.
Albania is considered to be a safe country so why should the UK grant them asylum?

BewareTheLibrarians · 11/01/2023 18:36

But @Lollipop999 if they are biometrically registered overseas (usually fingerprinted) then they wouldn’t be able to try and claim asylum by a different route, and if they came illegally to work on the black market they couldn’t access healthcare, housing and would be at risk of being trafficked/forced labour. That’s not what people want.

RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 11/01/2023 18:33

Rosalindisafuckingnightmare · 04/01/2023 15:20

Watch “Years and Years” by Russell T. Davies for one of the most heart wrenching fictional portrayals of this. I hadn’t been aware of a lot of the particular issues and mechanics and this did really make me think

I found it incredibly distressing

mainly because the character played by Russell Tovey is my now 24 year old to a T

i’ll never watch it again

but you are completely correct, it was very ‘educational’

Lollipop999 · 11/01/2023 18:30

Educated guess.

I agree it would be easier to process overseas, ideally as close to their home country as possible so that it minimises the chances of them losing Id and documentation on the way.

However, those who do not qualify are still likely to try and come illegally and disappear into the black economy.

BewareTheLibrarians · 11/01/2023 17:01

This would likely lead to a huge increase in claims which would need processing.

Is there any evidence for this? Even if there was an increase in claims that needed processing, one way of using these safe routes is to firstly ensure claims would be processed overseas. So an increase in claims wouldn’t affect any communities in the UK, as all the claims would be decided before people came to the UK.

Lollipop999 · 11/01/2023 16:37

@RoseslnTheHospital

“So, actions that might actually reduce crossings are needed.”………Agree with this

“Like providing legal routes of entry for asylum seekers who are not in the UK” …..this would be the equivalent of political suicide and would be hugely unpopular. This would likely lead to a huge increase in claims which would need processing.

“working with the French to tackle the criminal gangs involved”…… absolutely agree and wonder why there is not more effort to stop these gangs.

”like sourcing accommodation that isn't hotels or unsuitable barracks” ……good luck with this, there are already millions of people in need of social housing. Sadly those who arrive on boats will join the top of the queue due to having no family or place of residence which rightly and understandably angers uk citizens who feel they should be more of a priority. I agree in an ideal world there would be housing for all and different decisions should and could have been made but at the moment it is not possible.

Edinburghmusing · 11/01/2023 16:03

Oh that’s very interesting and I didn’t realise they all. I suspect most people dont

in Australia there is a theoretical option to apply overseas at least

im quite shocked.

so how does the uk say that it fulfills it’s international refugee obligations??

BewareTheLibrarians · 11/01/2023 15:33

@Edinburghmusing I’m not the poster you tagged, but I hope it’s ok to jump in.

Effectively, for most asylum seekers there’s no way to make an overseas asylum application.

I think Suella Braverman’s comments sum it up the best here (the article linked has more context):

Mr Loughton pressed [Braverman] and asked how this hypothetical orphan could get to the UK if they are not from Syria, Afghanistan or Ukraine, which have official programmes for asylum with the UK.

"If you're able to get to the UK you're able to put in an application for asylum," the home secretary admitted.

"If you put in an application for asylum upon arrival that would be the process you would enter."
But Mr Loughton pointed out that they could not get to the UK legally in the first place so said they would be forced to come illegally across the Channel.

Mrs Braverman could not answer how that asylum seeker could come over legally.”

news.sky.com/story/amp/suella-braverman-fails-to-explain-how-asylum-seekers-can-get-to-uk-safely-and-legally-12753780

BewareTheLibrarians · 11/01/2023 15:18

@StubbleAndSqueak Housed in the community includes hotels and hostels - just to differentiate from detention centres and processing centres.

But I agree with your point about where in the community and that British people are struggling to rent (I’m one of them!) and find social housing. However, I’ve said upthread as well that the blame for this is on the government not providing funding for social housing for so many councils during their 12 year tenure, and for pushing money into private asylum accommodation (and in some cases Tory linked) company’s profits, rather than putting that money into local communities.

Can you imagine the difference if the millions of £ was directed into healthcare and housing in communities rather than the pockets of Clearspring and the like?

StubbleAndSqueak · 11/01/2023 15:10

Housed in the community? where though @BewareTheLibrarians ? Where can they be housed? Genuine question as many working people in the SE are struggling to rent homes, everyday on SM you see people begging for help

BewareTheLibrarians · 11/01/2023 15:07

thereisonlyoneofme · 11/01/2023 14:35

As far as I am aware these things are happening or planned

I would love this to be the case, but I haven’t heard anything about these plans. Do you have any further information?

The government are theoretically working with the French to increase patrols and intelligence sharing about trafficking gangs, but I don’t know if this has been or will be effective given that it doesn’t really differ from previous deals.

And @RoseslnTheHospital makes a good point about the lack of safe routes. Not only are they very few in number, but the Afghan citizens resettlement scheme, which opened last year for these groups of people has only assisted 4 people in the last 12 months.

“those who have assisted the UK efforts in Afghanistan and stood up for values such as democracy, women’s rights, freedom of speech, and rule of law
vulnerable people, including women and girls at risk, and members of minority groups at risk (including ethnic and religious minorities and LGBT+)”

People who should have been helped by this scheme have been living in hiding from the Taliban, and some have made the journey by boat to the UK as the assistance that the UK government promised hasn’t become reality.

Because the journey to the UK is dangerous and physically challenging, it’s not an option for many women and children. So, effectively, the government is prioritising those strong enough to get here on their own, while leaving the women and children to suffer under the Taliban. This is why we need safe routes.

Edinburghmusing · 11/01/2023 15:06

@RoseslnTheHospital is there no way to make an overseas application for uk asylum?

RoseslnTheHospital · 11/01/2023 14:37

There are no plans to create legal routes of entry for asylum seekers that are not in the UK (apart from the existing Ukrainian scheme).

thereisonlyoneofme · 11/01/2023 14:35

As far as I am aware these things are happening or planned

RoseslnTheHospital · 11/01/2023 14:31

thereisonlyoneofme · 11/01/2023 14:23

Roses My point is that we cant even house our own people so where are we going to house refugees

Yes I understood your point. My point in response is that is down to deliberate policy decisions by government over the last decade. It won't be changed or improved by lip service quotes from Sunak about passing new laws in an effort to reduce boat crossings. That's not an effective strategy to begin with, plus it does nothing to address the actual issue of a lack of investment in housing.

So, actions that might actually reduce crossings are needed. Like providing legal routes of entry for asylum seekers who are not in the UK, like working with the French to tackle the criminal gangs involved, like sourcing accommodation that isn't hotels or unsuitable barracks, etc etc.

thereisonlyoneofme · 11/01/2023 14:23

Roses My point is that we cant even house our own people so where are we going to house refugees

BewareTheLibrarians · 11/01/2023 13:05

@VoiceOfCommonSense where on this thread have posters been called racist for pointing out facts?

And is it pointing out facts like the asylum system is massively underfunded and backlogged and wasting taxpayers money due to the Home Office’s terrible decisions that gets people called racist (no)

Or is it claiming baselessly that all asylum seekers are “illegals” or economic migrants or must be bad because they’re foreign and young that gets people called racist? (Yes, although I’d say “ignorant” also works as well here).

VoiceOfCommonSense · 11/01/2023 12:55

OhPeggySue · 04/01/2023 15:06

£7 million a day spent just on hotels housing people who are in the immigration system. I think it absolutely must be a priority.

Careful, pointing out facts on here makes you a racist apparently..

RoseslnTheHospital · 11/01/2023 12:53

thereisonlyoneofme · 11/01/2023 12:49

Just been on the news we have27,000 homeless people in the South East, they were referring to UK residents I believe.

Which will be caused by a lack of social housing, a lack of affordable rentals, a lack of rental housing in general producing high private rents. Also by the general CoL situation, wages rises being lower than price rises. And so on. A situation that would be happening regardless of the numbers crossing the channel in small boats.

Swipe left for the next trending thread