Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People in small boats

329 replies

EndlessRain1 · 04/01/2023 14:58

With everything that is going on in the UK at the moment, can it really be true that one of the top 5 priorities in the country is to stop "people in small boats"?

I mean, I know a lot of people are against immigration in this form, but in the grand scheme of the shit show this country has been in the last couple of years that is in the top 5 priorities/ actions?

AIBU to think that's insane?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
6
verdantverdure · 10/05/2023 05:45

You know how Trump's

^"Build a Walll"
^
was just a slogan to manipulate the easily manipulated?

And that he didn't actually, at any point, intend to build a wall?

But he did do some performative cruelty involving separating children from their parents and detaining them in cages as a sop to the kind of people who rub their thighs over that sort of thing?

Well, in the U.K. we call that Stop The Boats and deporting children to Rwanda. .

verdantverdure · 10/05/2023 05:39

Little boats wouldn't make it onto my first sheet of A4 of priorities, but it's in the Tory government's Top 5 so let's all watch them solve it shall we?

Gets Popcorn 🍿

Because I suspect it's going to go about as well as their "Brexit Contract With The British People"

Or indeed, the other 4 priorities Sunak announced.

What were they?

  1. Halve inflation
  2. Grow the economy
  3. Reduce national debt
  4. Cut NHS waiting lists
  5. Stop the boats

Failing on one and all.

CabernetSauvignon · 09/05/2023 22:49

cosmiccosmos · 11/01/2023 20:43

Sorry but I don't agree about the language thing, I think it's something that trotted out by people looking to justify the influx. My local council are paying thousands on language classes and I'm no where near Kent.

I do think this is a priority. Immigration needs to be managed. I don't want the thousands of young men that are arriving, their culture is too different to ours.

I often hear how we should 'allow them to work' and they could fill all the vacancies we have - picking fruit, working in care homes. How many young men are going to work in care homes, how many have any qualifications, how many have good enough English? And so on ....,

Lastly, I have no doubt that expecting or asking these immigrants to fill these rolls will be against their human rights and the cries of 'you can't treat people like this' will ring around the country.

The millions of pounds quoted per day putting them up is a drop in the ocean compared to what the majority will cost the country in the long run - if you're a doctor, lawyer etc he well qualified you aren't hiding your quals.

Many young men can and do work in care homes, including the one where my father is. But, as you've pointed out, there are also vacancies in farming and numerous other industries. We have a long tradition of employing immigrants in things like construction and farming where language hasn't been a barrier, and indeed people from other countries are way better at learning English than we are at learning other languages.

We already have long-established rules in place about making access to benefits conditional on applying for work, so you have zero foundation for suggesting that anyone would object on human rights grounds

I must say, it puzzles me that you object so strongly to immigrants filling the vacancies which just aren't being filled by UK citizens. Surely it makes much more sense to process asylum claims quickly and, for genuine asylum seekers, get them into work and off benefits as soon as possible?

CabernetSauvignon · 09/05/2023 22:41

cosmiccosmos · 11/01/2023 21:02

Is it foisted on the French though? Many of those living in the camps must have medical issues, shown by the recent problems of arrivals. They are clearly not accessing medical help and presumably getting immediate help on arrival - unlike the UK population who can't even get a GP appointment.

And yet members of the UK population are attending GP appointments daily in their thousands. Strange, that.

CabernetSauvignon · 09/05/2023 22:38

woodhill · 11/01/2023 21:13

But the UK have continued to do their bit.

It's unsustainable

Why is it unsustainable? Employers in the NHS, care sector, hospitality sector, construction, cleaning and many others are crying out for staff. We desperately need more people just to keep our infrastructure going.

CabernetSauvignon · 09/05/2023 22:36

woodhill · 11/01/2023 22:01

We do though or more than our fair share

You only have to look around you

No, you only have to look at the statistics, which don't bear out what you say.

verdantverdure · 13/01/2023 14:08

@cosmiccosmos

Who are the language classes for?

verdantverdure · 13/01/2023 14:07

Unless there are unknown thousands coming in via the lorries we don't check since Brexit @woodhill none of the statistics bear out your claim.

All immigration is up since Brexit though.

Fraaahnces · 12/01/2023 01:55

We have the same media BS over here in Australia. As though the very few people arriving from SE Asia (a long and arduous trip involving spurious people, ridiculous amounts of money, incredible danger, and obvious desperation - and frequent death along the way. If they are caught, they end up in horrible detention centres… don’t get me started.) Anyhoe, thanks to the Murdoch press, we would be left to believe that most of illegal immigrants enter the country this way. In fact, that’s about 5%. Most of our illegal immigrants are English and Irish backpackers who have decided that they want to stay and work here illegally. This agenda of looking for “foreign-looking” illegals to blame for the increased cost of living has been going on since the White Australia policies and thank goodness fewer people are believing it now.

Capri3 · 12/01/2023 01:47

verdantverdure · 11/01/2023 21:16

I don't understand why some people think the sixth richest country in the world shouldn't take our fair share of the world's refugees and asylum seekers.

The UK is the sixth largest economy (total GDP), but only actually the twenty-fifth richest country (GDP per capita).

woodhill · 11/01/2023 22:01

verdantverdure · 11/01/2023 21:16

I don't understand why some people think the sixth richest country in the world shouldn't take our fair share of the world's refugees and asylum seekers.

We do though or more than our fair share

You only have to look around you

EffortlessDesmond · 11/01/2023 21:21

Good, I sometimes wonder what I should take seriously from the media. I am delighted to know that ID was required and available to provide bona fides.

BewareTheLibrarians · 11/01/2023 21:16

Kinnorafron · 11/01/2023 21:12

@EffortlessDesmond
Plus there is no expectation that everyone should be able to prove their identity for employment or housing
That's not true - most people renting a house or being employed by a law-abiding employer are required to furnish proof of right to work and immigration status - which in practise are met by demands for a passport or similar identity documentation.
Of course once you're in the black market, all bets are off, but ask anyone who's rented a flat or house or got a job recently and you'll find they have been asked to provide ID.

Agree with @Kinnorafron here. My dh is a non-EU immigrant, we rent, and at every tenancy renewal he has to show his passport with immigration status and biometric ID card.

verdantverdure · 11/01/2023 21:16

I don't understand why some people think the sixth richest country in the world shouldn't take our fair share of the world's refugees and asylum seekers.

woodhill · 11/01/2023 21:13

RoseslnTheHospital · 11/01/2023 20:57

It's "foisted" on all countries in the EU and elsewhere. When there is vast global inequality and unstable/failed states (partly caused by foreign interference) then there will be asylum seekers and economic migrants. It's a global responsibility to address it.

But the UK have continued to do their bit.

It's unsustainable

Kinnorafron · 11/01/2023 21:12

@EffortlessDesmond
Plus there is no expectation that everyone should be able to prove their identity for employment or housing
That's not true - most people renting a house or being employed by a law-abiding employer are required to furnish proof of right to work and immigration status - which in practise are met by demands for a passport or similar identity documentation.
Of course once you're in the black market, all bets are off, but ask anyone who's rented a flat or house or got a job recently and you'll find they have been asked to provide ID.

cosmiccosmos · 11/01/2023 21:02

Is it foisted on the French though? Many of those living in the camps must have medical issues, shown by the recent problems of arrivals. They are clearly not accessing medical help and presumably getting immediate help on arrival - unlike the UK population who can't even get a GP appointment.

RoseslnTheHospital · 11/01/2023 20:57

It's "foisted" on all countries in the EU and elsewhere. When there is vast global inequality and unstable/failed states (partly caused by foreign interference) then there will be asylum seekers and economic migrants. It's a global responsibility to address it.

woodhill · 11/01/2023 20:50

It's awful the way it is just foisted upon us

cosmiccosmos · 11/01/2023 20:43

Sorry but I don't agree about the language thing, I think it's something that trotted out by people looking to justify the influx. My local council are paying thousands on language classes and I'm no where near Kent.

I do think this is a priority. Immigration needs to be managed. I don't want the thousands of young men that are arriving, their culture is too different to ours.

I often hear how we should 'allow them to work' and they could fill all the vacancies we have - picking fruit, working in care homes. How many young men are going to work in care homes, how many have any qualifications, how many have good enough English? And so on ....,

Lastly, I have no doubt that expecting or asking these immigrants to fill these rolls will be against their human rights and the cries of 'you can't treat people like this' will ring around the country.

The millions of pounds quoted per day putting them up is a drop in the ocean compared to what the majority will cost the country in the long run - if you're a doctor, lawyer etc he well qualified you aren't hiding your quals.

Lollipop999 · 11/01/2023 20:42

EffortlessDesmond · 11/01/2023 20:06

It might help, but the pull factor of the language resonates. I don't think migrants come for the benefits or the NHS; I think most come with optimism that because they speak a little English they can get better and improve their life chances. It's Dick Whittington. The streets of London are paved with gold for the clever and the lucky. "I'm clever" or "I'll be lucky" is powerful for a young adult.

The nhs is a fairly big draw I think (god knows why if they knew the state it’s in) as many seem to know exactly what they are entitled to…

EffortlessDesmond · 11/01/2023 20:06

It might help, but the pull factor of the language resonates. I don't think migrants come for the benefits or the NHS; I think most come with optimism that because they speak a little English they can get better and improve their life chances. It's Dick Whittington. The streets of London are paved with gold for the clever and the lucky. "I'm clever" or "I'll be lucky" is powerful for a young adult.

Lollipop999 · 11/01/2023 19:55

EffortlessDesmond · 11/01/2023 19:49

Since May 2022 42% are Albanian. And 95% of those are male.
Albania is considered to be a safe country so why should the UK grant them asylum?

The UK is an appealing destination for people who want a better life. Most of the world learns a smattering of English at school and it's an easy language to speak badly and still be understood. It is also a pretty tolerant and diverse society, much more than many others. Plus there is no expectation that everyone should be able to prove their identity for employment or housing or healthcare or education. So it is a magnet, for a lot of people from less fortunate countries. More relevant those countries have huge populations of young people (17-30 age range) looking for a better future which together probably total a billion people. Where is the UK going to accommodate a billion asylum seekers and economic migrants?

We would all have to stand up 24x7 to fit them in physically.

You need to consider the importance of speaking English in this. France has not seen jobs offshored to French speaking West Africa in the same way that UK call handling is routinely forwarded to Asian call centres to work from scripts. Businesses will outsource low level jobs to the cheapest place possible, and it is simply easier to do so anywhere most of the population speak some English.

So shouldn’t France, Germany, Spain, Italy, uk, Scandinavia etc all provide the same basic package of emergency health care only, basic accommodation and food vouchers etc while claims are processed, for fairness ?

MarshaBradyo · 11/01/2023 19:54

Lollipop999 · 11/01/2023 19:53

No idea which is why I’m only an armchair critic not an actual politician!

Me either. I’m trying to envisage what capping 10k people would look like in reality. How many turn up to apply and where do they stay

Lollipop999 · 11/01/2023 19:53

MarshaBradyo · 11/01/2023 19:51

How would you limit numbers in practise?

Say 20,000 would like to come but the cap is 10k - how do you decide?

No idea which is why I’m only an armchair critic not an actual politician!

Swipe left for the next trending thread