Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School residential, school have said they have to go

456 replies

Y4GoingAway · 04/01/2023 12:39

School Year 4, but it’s a first school so the final year at the school.

Apparently it’s compulsory and there is no provision in school for those who don’t go as the class teachers plus several other staff go.

I don’t want DD to go. She has a genetic condition that affects her muscles and joints. She also has an EHCP due to SN (not ASD)

The trip is canoeing and rock climbing and zip lining and orienteering. Which all sound great but schools only adjustment for DDs condition is she can sit out if she wants to, which she won’t because she never does for Forest School or PE or anything else physical, school say they cannot force DD to sit out. They have PE, Forest School and the morning mile in one day at school and DDs generally screaming in pain by 2pm, I’ve asked for her to sit out of Forest School and the mile but been told that it’s up to DD to decide and she wants to be like her friends so will push herself until she can’t cope anymore – she’s missed school the next day because of the pain and school just shrug and say she needs to tell them when she wants to sit out, while in the next breath saying she seems to refuse to acknowledge her condition as she won’t talk about it!

This isn’t about DD being away overnight, she stays away from me with ExH EOWend for 1 night and he usually takes her away for 3-4 days in the summer holidays plus she’s just done a 3 day pack holiday with Brownies. Also it’s not a cost thing, the trip itself is free, we’re being asked to donate to transport there and back either by paying school for the bus or getting our DC there ourselves.
Brownies where brilliant, they let her choose one active activity per day and then put her in the group that wasn’t doing that activity after she’d done it, so she did crafts or similar, all the girls where given the same opportunity to sit out so no-one knew why DD only did 1 per day – and we’ve agreed that next time she goes she’ll do different activities so she’s tried different things which is a great compromise. Brownies also kept her topped up on her pain medication which school refuse to give her.

They’ve told me they have no provision for giving pain relief on the trip which is the same in school. They’ve also said if children sit out of an activity they will just have to watch everyone else do it, there’s no staffing for them to have a group at the centre they’re staying in doing something else – I even said DD would be happy to do worksheets or similar.

And before anyone says “But there’s more going with school” there’s the same number at Brownies and Brownies had a bigger age range as school only take the 90 year 4s, whereas Brownies had 60 Brownies (7-10 year olds), 30 guides (10-14 year olds), and a couple of Rainbows (7 year olds) who’re ready to move to Brownies soon.

School have said if she doesn’t go they will not be providing alternative work, she will be the only one in her entire year not going and she will be supervised by “whichever member off staff is free”. She does have 1-1 TA for parts of the day and one of her two 1-1s won’t be going and I’ve offered to get her tutor she has outside of school to provide work (tutor has already offered) and I’ve been told again the trip is compulsory. Apparently they've never had anyone not go ever.

So AIBU and just have to suck it up? The trip is after half term.

OP posts:
Runaway1 · 04/01/2023 16:23

Pumperthepumper · 04/01/2023 16:16

It is legal though, they only have to make reasonable adjustments and sitting at the side is a reasonable adjustment - it’s a shit one, but it means she can still go on the trip. To be clear, I’m not saying that’s ok.

I’d guess that the school are tied to this activity due to a discount being offered, which is why the PTA can cover the costs. If you can think of a way schools can introduce more staff and more training with no money, I’d love to hear it.

I don’t think it is a reasonable adjustment as it excludes her from the learning and is potentially damaging socially and emotionally.

Pumperthepumper · 04/01/2023 16:21

thing47 · 04/01/2023 16:19

God we had to fight these sorts of battle 15 years ago, can't believe nothing's changed in that time! It sounds like certain teachers at the school have no knowledge or understanding of disability discrimination @Y4GoingAway, you will have to educate them (oh the irony). It's quite simple really, under the 2010 Equality Act, the school has to make reasonable adjustments, failure to do so is illegal. Therefore, they HAVE to ensure that your DD has the opportunity to take a break if she needs one. There aren't any exceptions to this.

And @Pumperthepumper however much sympathy I have for the teachers and the lack of funding and resources, none of that trumps the law as it currently stands. If sufficient resources cannot be provided then the trip does not take place at all; again this is pretty clear in the legislation. I suspect the school know this and that's why they are trying to say the trip is 'compulsory' because if OP kicks up a fuss and insists that under the circumstances it isn't safe for her DD to go, the school has a legal obligation to provide her with alternative education back in school. If that means there aren't sufficient resources for the residential trip to go ahead because of staff-pupil ratios, then that is what has to happen.

@Parrotid sadly the school does not legally have to take responsibility for the administration of medicines, including insulin. Using the Brownie analogy on this thread, our Brownie pack were very good at making reasonable adjustments for DD but couldn't find anyone willing to her insulin injections – fair enough, it is a big responsibility. So she had to learn to do them (and her fingerprick blood sugar monitoring) herself at the age of 7 in order to go on her Brownie camp.

If sufficient resources cannot be provided then the trip does not take place at all; again this is pretty clear in the legislation.

I dont think that’s true. I think they just have to make ‘reasonable adjustments* and the OP’s kid being there could be considered ‘reasonable’ (although shit for her) because she’s physically on the trip. Again, I’m not saying that is reasonable.

I’d bet that it’s worse now than it was fifteen years ago, especially in education.

Adelant · 04/01/2023 16:21

School have said if she doesn’t go they will not be providing alternative work, she will be the only one in her entire year not going and she will be supervised by “whichever member off staff is free”.

Is this unreasonable? Seems ok to me as the other kids won’t be getting alternative school work either.

Zonder · 04/01/2023 16:20

Loudhousefun · 04/01/2023 16:16

If your daughter has an EHCP she will have a caseworker (LA), get her/him involved and ask for a meeting with school. They need to be making special provisions for your daughter to be at school, the fact that she will be the only one not going is irrelevant if she has an EHCP.

This is just what I said upthread. It's really important.

Spendonsend · 04/01/2023 16:20

Pumperthepumper · 04/01/2023 16:08

No it isn’t, it’s how much money the school can allocate to certain kids. In some schools that will be more, which results in better training and more one-on-one support.

But do these accommodations need money? Someone to give medicine and for some activities to be less physical and ensuring this child picks those activities. Think about the cohort when planning - its not always about expensive support and i say that with the user name spend on send!

thing47 · 04/01/2023 16:19

God we had to fight these sorts of battle 15 years ago, can't believe nothing's changed in that time! It sounds like certain teachers at the school have no knowledge or understanding of disability discrimination @Y4GoingAway, you will have to educate them (oh the irony). It's quite simple really, under the 2010 Equality Act, the school has to make reasonable adjustments, failure to do so is illegal. Therefore, they HAVE to ensure that your DD has the opportunity to take a break if she needs one. There aren't any exceptions to this.

And @Pumperthepumper however much sympathy I have for the teachers and the lack of funding and resources, none of that trumps the law as it currently stands. If sufficient resources cannot be provided then the trip does not take place at all; again this is pretty clear in the legislation. I suspect the school know this and that's why they are trying to say the trip is 'compulsory' because if OP kicks up a fuss and insists that under the circumstances it isn't safe for her DD to go, the school has a legal obligation to provide her with alternative education back in school. If that means there aren't sufficient resources for the residential trip to go ahead because of staff-pupil ratios, then that is what has to happen.

@Parrotid sadly the school does not legally have to take responsibility for the administration of medicines, including insulin. Using the Brownie analogy on this thread, our Brownie pack were very good at making reasonable adjustments for DD but couldn't find anyone willing to her insulin injections – fair enough, it is a big responsibility. So she had to learn to do them (and her fingerprick blood sugar monitoring) herself at the age of 7 in order to go on her Brownie camp.

Pumperthepumper · 04/01/2023 16:16

Elastigurl · 04/01/2023 16:16

If you have a DC with SEN who is also extremely academically able the provision is nil; they have no idea what to do in those scenarios. It's why mine are home educated now.

I agree. It’s shit.

Loudhousefun · 04/01/2023 16:16

If your daughter has an EHCP she will have a caseworker (LA), get her/him involved and ask for a meeting with school. They need to be making special provisions for your daughter to be at school, the fact that she will be the only one not going is irrelevant if she has an EHCP.

Elastigurl · 04/01/2023 16:16

If you have a DC with SEN who is also extremely academically able the provision is nil; they have no idea what to do in those scenarios. It's why mine are home educated now.

Pumperthepumper · 04/01/2023 16:16

ConkersandString · 04/01/2023 16:13

I strongly disagree. We had to move one of our DC to another school because of the attitude of her form teacher. She was a very experienced teacher who refused to make one reasonable adjustment (at no cost or actual teaching effort). Apparently DC went to school to 'improve in all areas including her disability'.

That's about attitude not money. And that teacher is now a head.

What was that adjustment she refused to make?

Pumperthepumper · 04/01/2023 16:16

Runaway1 · 04/01/2023 16:12

The attitude that has been described is nothing to do with funding. There are examples on this thread of great inclusive practice, despite the current challenges in education. The bottom line is that this school has not considered this child’s needs in planning the trip and that is not legal.

It is legal though, they only have to make reasonable adjustments and sitting at the side is a reasonable adjustment - it’s a shit one, but it means she can still go on the trip. To be clear, I’m not saying that’s ok.

I’d guess that the school are tied to this activity due to a discount being offered, which is why the PTA can cover the costs. If you can think of a way schools can introduce more staff and more training with no money, I’d love to hear it.

Dixiechickonhols · 04/01/2023 16:16

The solution in this case though won’t cost the school more money? It just needed thought when planning to pick a range of activities.
Thinking of ones DD been on there’s usually been build a campfire, bushcraft, escape room in rotation plus full on physical activities like climbing, kayak etc.

ConkersandString · 04/01/2023 16:13

Pumperthepumper · 04/01/2023 16:08

No it isn’t, it’s how much money the school can allocate to certain kids. In some schools that will be more, which results in better training and more one-on-one support.

I strongly disagree. We had to move one of our DC to another school because of the attitude of her form teacher. She was a very experienced teacher who refused to make one reasonable adjustment (at no cost or actual teaching effort). Apparently DC went to school to 'improve in all areas including her disability'.

That's about attitude not money. And that teacher is now a head.

Runaway1 · 04/01/2023 16:12

Pumperthepumper · 04/01/2023 16:04

That’s definitely not true for school. The fact is funding for disabled and SEN kids has been so relentlessly cut that schools can’t meet their needs. Absolutely nobody who works in a school wants that.

The attitude that has been described is nothing to do with funding. There are examples on this thread of great inclusive practice, despite the current challenges in education. The bottom line is that this school has not considered this child’s needs in planning the trip and that is not legal.

Elastigurl · 04/01/2023 16:11

Parrotid · 04/01/2023 16:08

That’s simply untrue. If it wasn’t, there wouldn’t be complaint after complaint about children being discriminated against because they’re not the same as the “norm.” The people behaving in this way don’t even think they’re being discriminatory. They just see “not norm” as a nuisance.

This 100%. People simply refuse to see it.

Elastigurl · 04/01/2023 16:10

Pumperthepumper · 04/01/2023 16:04

That’s definitely not true for school. The fact is funding for disabled and SEN kids has been so relentlessly cut that schools can’t meet their needs. Absolutely nobody who works in a school wants that.

From working in a school, from my experience of having my SEN child in a school, I don't agree. Many, many schools and individual teachers are fantastic, and yes their funding has been decimated, but IMO the overall attitude is still that accommodating needs is a pain in the arse, and sorry but this is not just because of funding. And it's not just schools, it's a general societal thing. I tried to sign my DS up to a trampolining class before christmas to be told that it wouldn't be possible for me to accompany him as "then all the other children would want to know why their parents couldn't be there too". That sort of thing happens constantly and it did when he was at school too. Not a funding issue. An attitude.

Parrotid · 04/01/2023 16:08

Pumperthepumper · 04/01/2023 16:04

That’s definitely not true for school. The fact is funding for disabled and SEN kids has been so relentlessly cut that schools can’t meet their needs. Absolutely nobody who works in a school wants that.

That’s simply untrue. If it wasn’t, there wouldn’t be complaint after complaint about children being discriminated against because they’re not the same as the “norm.” The people behaving in this way don’t even think they’re being discriminatory. They just see “not norm” as a nuisance.

Pumperthepumper · 04/01/2023 16:08

nilsmousehammer · 04/01/2023 16:06

It is so much down to the individual attitude and experience of the staff in each individual school. Some are absolutely outstanding. Some really don't get it at all.

No it isn’t, it’s how much money the school can allocate to certain kids. In some schools that will be more, which results in better training and more one-on-one support.

nilsmousehammer · 04/01/2023 16:06

Pumperthepumper · 04/01/2023 16:04

That’s definitely not true for school. The fact is funding for disabled and SEN kids has been so relentlessly cut that schools can’t meet their needs. Absolutely nobody who works in a school wants that.

It is so much down to the individual attitude and experience of the staff in each individual school. Some are absolutely outstanding. Some really don't get it at all.

Pumperthepumper · 04/01/2023 16:04

Elastigurl · 04/01/2023 16:02

No, I think generally society simply views disabled people as a nuisance and can't be bothered to adjust any aspect of how it operates to accommodate their needs properly beyond something cursory which isn't an inconvenience to anyone else. Schools are complicit in that IMO.

That’s definitely not true for school. The fact is funding for disabled and SEN kids has been so relentlessly cut that schools can’t meet their needs. Absolutely nobody who works in a school wants that.

Dancingdragonhiddentiger · 04/01/2023 16:03

My SEN child has a similar trip ans the school could not have been more accommodating. They are even paying for a room and board for my husband so that he has that support- we’re happy for that just to be ‘on call’ whilst my husband works remotely or for my husband to take part with him as a helper. They listened fully to my concerns. I honestly think your school’s threatening approach would make me doubt your child’s safety with the school.

Elastigurl · 04/01/2023 16:02

Pumperthepumper · 04/01/2023 15:44

So you think they just hate disabled people and want to make their lives a bit more shit?

No, I think generally society simply views disabled people as a nuisance and can't be bothered to adjust any aspect of how it operates to accommodate their needs properly beyond something cursory which isn't an inconvenience to anyone else. Schools are complicit in that IMO.

Parrotid · 04/01/2023 15:59

As for not administering drugs, that’s also bollocks. How do they imagine other children with chronic conditions manage? Diabetes for example.

Parrotid · 04/01/2023 15:58

Gosh there are some dicks out there.

in a past life as an advisor for a SEN charity I took a call from a parent whose child had had his electric wheelchair confiscated and told he had to use the school’s push one because they said there was no room for it and it was too noisy and too fast. What they meant was “we don’t want your child. Please go.”

nilsmousehammer · 04/01/2023 15:57

She doesn't have to go, it is not compulsory. It is understandable that they don't have staff or availability to provide for children not able to come, but a blanket policy for children regardless of SEND needs isn't good practice, and they should be a bit embarrassed really at their lack of accessibility. Just including by 'yeah she can tag along if her needs don't present us with a challenge ' is not ok.

Tbh, rather than fight and get into unpleasantness with school at this point, if you're able, I would take that time from work, and plan an appropriate holiday with dd based on her interests that you two will take in that week while the others are away. And document with photographs etc that she can share with school etc as to what she did. Make it something fun that she'll always remember and which did not involve her watching able bodied people having fun she couldn't, and enduring pain that they aren't, and experiencing a lot of exclusion in varied ways. Not an 'educational' experience any child should be expected to endure.

Swipe left for the next trending thread