Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School residential, school have said they have to go

456 replies

Y4GoingAway · 04/01/2023 12:39

School Year 4, but it’s a first school so the final year at the school.

Apparently it’s compulsory and there is no provision in school for those who don’t go as the class teachers plus several other staff go.

I don’t want DD to go. She has a genetic condition that affects her muscles and joints. She also has an EHCP due to SN (not ASD)

The trip is canoeing and rock climbing and zip lining and orienteering. Which all sound great but schools only adjustment for DDs condition is she can sit out if she wants to, which she won’t because she never does for Forest School or PE or anything else physical, school say they cannot force DD to sit out. They have PE, Forest School and the morning mile in one day at school and DDs generally screaming in pain by 2pm, I’ve asked for her to sit out of Forest School and the mile but been told that it’s up to DD to decide and she wants to be like her friends so will push herself until she can’t cope anymore – she’s missed school the next day because of the pain and school just shrug and say she needs to tell them when she wants to sit out, while in the next breath saying she seems to refuse to acknowledge her condition as she won’t talk about it!

This isn’t about DD being away overnight, she stays away from me with ExH EOWend for 1 night and he usually takes her away for 3-4 days in the summer holidays plus she’s just done a 3 day pack holiday with Brownies. Also it’s not a cost thing, the trip itself is free, we’re being asked to donate to transport there and back either by paying school for the bus or getting our DC there ourselves.
Brownies where brilliant, they let her choose one active activity per day and then put her in the group that wasn’t doing that activity after she’d done it, so she did crafts or similar, all the girls where given the same opportunity to sit out so no-one knew why DD only did 1 per day – and we’ve agreed that next time she goes she’ll do different activities so she’s tried different things which is a great compromise. Brownies also kept her topped up on her pain medication which school refuse to give her.

They’ve told me they have no provision for giving pain relief on the trip which is the same in school. They’ve also said if children sit out of an activity they will just have to watch everyone else do it, there’s no staffing for them to have a group at the centre they’re staying in doing something else – I even said DD would be happy to do worksheets or similar.

And before anyone says “But there’s more going with school” there’s the same number at Brownies and Brownies had a bigger age range as school only take the 90 year 4s, whereas Brownies had 60 Brownies (7-10 year olds), 30 guides (10-14 year olds), and a couple of Rainbows (7 year olds) who’re ready to move to Brownies soon.

School have said if she doesn’t go they will not be providing alternative work, she will be the only one in her entire year not going and she will be supervised by “whichever member off staff is free”. She does have 1-1 TA for parts of the day and one of her two 1-1s won’t be going and I’ve offered to get her tutor she has outside of school to provide work (tutor has already offered) and I’ve been told again the trip is compulsory. Apparently they've never had anyone not go ever.

So AIBU and just have to suck it up? The trip is after half term.

OP posts:
IsItThough · 04/01/2023 16:44

Someone upthread nailed it though - they need OPs DD's 1:1 to go on the trip for ratios. This is where the compulsory bullshit is coming from. That is a problem of the schools own making and it needs calling out.

Pumperthepumper · 04/01/2023 16:43

IsItThough · 04/01/2023 16:41

@Pumperthepumper If the PTA can afford to pay for all of this they can afford the minimal costs of additional provisions. Its a 4 night trip! for 8 year olds! presumably 3 nights would be cheaper. The school have ignored her needs in planning this - that is exactly what I mean by lack of imagination. Anyway hopefully OP will escalate it. I know you are coming from a place of saying the impact of cuts to education is disproportionately affecting SEND kids, and you are right. But that doesn't mean the school can ignore those needs.

I mean, I’m not privy to any of this information so I’m guessing but a lot of trips have a minimum-term booking so maybe they have to go for four? But regardless, saving money on the trip doesn’t mean they can employ a full-time member of staff for three days.

SnowlayRoundabout · 04/01/2023 16:43

CremeEggThief · 04/01/2023 14:20

Of course it's not compulsory to go on the trip, but I do think YABU to expect her to be able to still attend school if she doesn't!!

Speaking as a former teacher, it is now up to you to make whatever arrangements are necessary to take time off to look after her at home if she doesn't want to go on the trip.

With every respect, that is nonsense. If that is how your former school operated, and if it was any time within the last 20 years, the school was acting unlawfully. By law, the school has to provide education. It cannot make trips compulsory, and when planning any trip it has to make provision for those children who cannot go for any reason.

RudolphTheGreat · 04/01/2023 16:43

And I would recommend contacting someone like sossen or the Coram child law advice line who can offer free legal advice re the situation.

RudolphTheGreat · 04/01/2023 16:42

This may be helpful (chapter 6) especially section 6.59

www.equalityhumanrights.com/en/publication-download/technical-guidance-schools-england

Pumperthepumper · 04/01/2023 16:41

SnowlayRoundabout · 04/01/2023 16:34

And that is misinformation in itself. Duties under the Equality Act are not dependent on whether the school thinks it has adequate staff. The school is already part funded for 1:1, and it's not as if OP is asking for a lot - either her DD stays in school, in which case the likelihood is that she can be accommodated in another class, or she has someone on the trip who is basically keeping an eye on her to make sure she doesn't over-exert and takes painkillers when necessary.

If the school doesn't choose to comply with the Equality Act, it will sooner or later find itself on the wrong end of a discrimination appeal and a formal referral to Ofsted. If other schools can manage to run EqA-compliant trips, why can't this one?

That’s not true. If they don’t have adequate staff then they can’t provide 1:1 care for a full residential trip. I’ve already explained upthread why some schools can better support certain kids, but the bottom line is money.

IsItThough · 04/01/2023 16:41

@Pumperthepumper If the PTA can afford to pay for all of this they can afford the minimal costs of additional provisions. Its a 4 night trip! for 8 year olds! presumably 3 nights would be cheaper. The school have ignored her needs in planning this - that is exactly what I mean by lack of imagination. Anyway hopefully OP will escalate it. I know you are coming from a place of saying the impact of cuts to education is disproportionately affecting SEND kids, and you are right. But that doesn't mean the school can ignore those needs.

Spendonsend · 04/01/2023 16:40

Pumperthepumper · 04/01/2023 16:23

Yes. They’d need an allocated staff member who’s trained in administering medicine. They’d also need different staff ratios to either give the OP’s kid one-on-one support or take a smaller group. And more staff equals more money.

I dont understand why picking some quiet activities requires one to one support or smaller staff ratios. These places normally have a range on offer so you pick ones suitable for your cohort when booking. Administering medicines is tricky as you need a volunteer, but the course is a short online course that many schools will have as part of a package with TES, National College or The Key. And if not, its peanuts. My school was found to be in the wrong for not considering its cohort when planning a trip (where i work) its changed its practice now.

lieselotte · 04/01/2023 16:39

Oh I've just seen it's free but as they'll ask for money for transport, that's where you refuse.

How on earth is it free though, where on earth is the funding for it coming from?

SnowlayRoundabout · 04/01/2023 16:39

Pumperthepumper · 04/01/2023 14:00

And how do you suggest they do that without staff?

Why do you assume they haven't got staff? There is nothing in the OP's posts indicating that that is their reasoning.

Most school years will have one or two pupils for whom reasonable adjustments need to be made under the Equality Act 2010, and they know they have to take these into account when planning residential trips. I remember one with my children's school where there was a child who had a complicated pump feeding regime, and they manage it. If the school can't comply with those duties, it shouldn't be running the trip.

Loudhousefun · 04/01/2023 16:38

Making reasonable adjustments would be giving her alternative activities less likely to cause pain or additional help and support during the activity. Sitting out is not an adjustment it is exclusion.

lieselotte · 04/01/2023 16:37

I can't see how a residential can be compulsory - apart from anything else you've got to pay for it, so you just don't and you don't fill out the consent form. The worst that can happen is that it gets marked down as unauthorised absence but so what?

DS had a residential in Y8 that he didn't want to go to. However, we got conned into it (sort of) because there was another trip that he did want to go on, but he didn't get picked in the ballot. So the school said "oh we'll just use the deposit for the camping trip". Grrr. I could have refused but it would have been a lot of hassle. He still complains about having to go though (it was when the Brexit referendum happened and there was a tremendous thunderstorm that night - delicious camping weather!)

longtompot · 04/01/2023 16:35

The school are saying it's compulsory for her to go, that they won't stop her from doing certain activities, but if by doing those activities she is then in pain they won't let her have any medication to help her? My child would not be going, and all mine went to an activity, outdoor bound type place when they were in year 6, one had JIA then, but only did things she felt comfortable with and wasn't pushed to do anything she didn't want to do. I seem to think there were alternatives they could take part in instead.

SnowlayRoundabout · 04/01/2023 16:34

Pumperthepumper · 04/01/2023 13:32

Oh god, there’s always so much misinformation on these threads. The school isn’t being lazy - they can’t summon staff, and they won’t have funding to pay for any. You can complain all you like but you’ll get nowhere - this is what education in Britain looks like now.

And that is misinformation in itself. Duties under the Equality Act are not dependent on whether the school thinks it has adequate staff. The school is already part funded for 1:1, and it's not as if OP is asking for a lot - either her DD stays in school, in which case the likelihood is that she can be accommodated in another class, or she has someone on the trip who is basically keeping an eye on her to make sure she doesn't over-exert and takes painkillers when necessary.

If the school doesn't choose to comply with the Equality Act, it will sooner or later find itself on the wrong end of a discrimination appeal and a formal referral to Ofsted. If other schools can manage to run EqA-compliant trips, why can't this one?

Pumperthepumper · 04/01/2023 16:32

RudolphTheGreat · 04/01/2023 16:31

Being there or sitting out is not a reasonable adjustment Hmm

It is though. She’s on the trip, the adjustment is she can’t take part. It’s garbage, but it’s true.

RudolphTheGreat · 04/01/2023 16:31

Being there or sitting out is not a reasonable adjustment Hmm

Englishash · 04/01/2023 16:31

Put the cat amongst the pigeons and ask to see the risk assessment.

Dixiechickonhols · 04/01/2023 16:30

I really don’t think pulling her out is any sort of solution. The girl is 8 and wants to go. She has been on a similar holiday and really enjoyed it.
It’s their leavers trip. Everyone going. It will be talk of the school.
My DCs primary yearbook had photos from the trip and they put them on screen in leavers assembly.

toomuchlaundry · 04/01/2023 16:28

I think if it was only one activity the daughter had to sit out of, and she could take part in all other activities and events on the trip then they could possibly argue it was a reasonable adjustment. But if she has to sit out of everything, particularly if this is down to their refusal to administer medicine, then I don't think it counts as reasonable adjustment.

GabriellaMontez · 04/01/2023 16:28

They know they cant force her. They're trying to bully you into it.

They're showing themselves to be utterly lacking in compassion. They won't give her pain relief on a trip that's likely to cause her pain due to a disability? I wouldn't treat a dog like that.

Put in a complaint.

SnowlayRoundabout · 04/01/2023 16:27

Dryandirriatble · 04/01/2023 13:09

Totally unacceptable. I mean taking aside everything else, what about people who can't afford it?

It's free, which is why the school can call it "compulsory". It's not compulsory to send you child of course, but as all children are included, the school can say that's the only provision on offer for those days.

They still need to make sure it's suitable for all, but I think saying DC doesn't need to participate probably does tick that box. It could be done much better, but I don't think the difference between just watching and doing a worksheet (as OP suggested) while she sits out is going to cause anyone concern on discrimination grounds.

It's not free- parents have to pay for transport. The school has to provide full time education, which includes providing for pupils who can't go on the trip. Just saying it's compulsory is meaningless and doesn't absolve them of that duty.

Saying that OP's child doesn't have to participate doesn't tick any boxes. They have a duty to keep her safe, which includes making sure that she does not over-exert and exacerbate her condition, and making further adjustments to ensure that she can take part as much as possible, and that, if she does, she is safe. Reasonable adjustments also include being prepared to give her medication when she needs it, and having someone trained to look out for her. If Brownies can manage it, the school can.

PolishedShell · 04/01/2023 16:26

Pumperthepumper · 04/01/2023 13:21

I’d imagine it’s due to lack of staff, which is a funding issue. It’s shit though.

It’s this. Her 1-1 is needed on the trip, hence telling you it’s “compulsory”.

Fuck. That.

WhatHappenedToYoyos · 04/01/2023 16:26

Are you in Bedfordshire?

Make a complaint to the Local Authority SEND team about it. They are not being inclusive and are discriminating against her.

Alternatively, take her out of school for a few days at the same time as the trip and go on a nice, relaxing break away together instead. That would be nicer than sat alone in school not doing much for hours on end.

Pumperthepumper · 04/01/2023 16:24

Runaway1 · 04/01/2023 16:23

I don’t think it is a reasonable adjustment as it excludes her from the learning and is potentially damaging socially and emotionally.

I don’t think it is either because she’s not able to take part in the trip, but ‘reasonable’ is a very broad term.

Pumperthepumper · 04/01/2023 16:23

Spendonsend · 04/01/2023 16:20

But do these accommodations need money? Someone to give medicine and for some activities to be less physical and ensuring this child picks those activities. Think about the cohort when planning - its not always about expensive support and i say that with the user name spend on send!

Yes. They’d need an allocated staff member who’s trained in administering medicine. They’d also need different staff ratios to either give the OP’s kid one-on-one support or take a smaller group. And more staff equals more money.

Swipe left for the next trending thread