Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lots of people go to A&E when they shouldn't

306 replies

Liz1tummypain · 04/01/2023 10:18

To be clear- I couldn't think of a way or wording this so I just came up with something that might attract some opinions. It isn't something I can spout about with any authority.

But is it true? My kids are older so I haven't had to go to A&E for ages. Very little experience. On the radio I heard they are trying to re-direct potential patients to pharmacies etc . So what is your view on it?

My mum worked in A&E , a long time ago and she says she thinks people wouldn't have dared to turn up with some minor injuries that she thinks people go in with now. She thinks people just tried home remedies and only went in with broken bones, trauma, sick children. But I think maybe she was just getting a bit worked up after seeing something on TV. She also hasn't been to A&E for a long time.

OP posts:
Diedre44 · 04/01/2023 13:05

PenelopeTitsDrop3121 · 04/01/2023 11:39

I honestly don't think that's the case. Would people really sit around in A&E for 14 hours if they didn't need to?

Yes. I worked in A&E for over 10 years. We would get whole families turn up, flasks of tea, full picnic hampers more or less prepared for a weekend camp out in waiting room turn up at 5pm and not be seen until 7am the next morning and sent home with a box of co-codomol for the back pain they'd had for the last ten years, happy that they'd had a good night's entertainment seeing reception staff shouted and screamed at, nurses and doctors spat at, verbally, racially and sometimes physically abused, drunk man passed out in wheelchair piss himself four times, the bride to be on her hen in town crying and screaming to be seen immediately because she snapped her acrylic nails after falling off a table top dancing and needs to get back to her friends, the little old lady that came in after getting three busses with an arm like a black banana after falling 3 days ago and didn't want to bother anybody and they saved a whole £2.80 as they could have quite simply gone to chemist and bought them over the counter. Hey-ho though, owt for nowt as they say. 🤷‍♀️

Seasonofthewitch83 · 04/01/2023 13:03

I was in A and E last month, 11 hours for an infected gallbladder. Over that time I saw plenty of people give up and walk out which to me, indicated it was not an A and E scenerio.

A bloke walked in because he said he had been using a screwdriver that morning and now his thumb hurt.

There was a bloke who must have taken 15 fag breaks while there for a chest issue, he went in before me and half an hour later a member of staff was walking him back out explaining he had to see his GP, not them, and he was going bananas and stropped off.

Obviously, people are showing up because they cannot get GP appointments.

Secondly, more needs to be done at triage to make an fair assessment if its an A and E situation that can be treated by them. Sore thumbs need to be redirected.

olivehater · 04/01/2023 13:02

I have turned up on Boxing Day before as I knew my son needed antibiotics for a chest infection and it was the only way of getting them quickly. He wasn’t that I’ll but he might have been if we had waited for the goa to open.

Mulhollandmagoo · 04/01/2023 12:59

I remember when there were minor injuries units and walk in centres though, which would have eased the pressure on A&E hugely, they should make a comeback - these were specifically for where neither a GP or A&E were appropriate (or you couldn't access a GP)

MaryMa · 04/01/2023 12:55

Definitely think people are using A&E for minor issues at the moment.

People often can't get an appointment with the doctor, so are sometimes then being directed to A&E.

My Ds was ill over Christmas and given medication for tonsillitis which didn't seem to be working. We spoke to 111 who said he needed to be seen and we should go to A&E if couldn't get an appointment.... we didn't go to A&E and did manage to sort things out ourselves.

I think 111 are covering themselves by directing people to A&E and people then think they need to go to A&E.

A senior paediatric nurse I know told me they normally see 50 children a day in A&E, but it was up to 150 due to panic over strep A. Many of the people she has seen in A&E haven't needed to be there.

BradfordGirl · 04/01/2023 12:54

@Orangesandlemons77 They don't.
They used to be viewed as a possible route to legal highs for drug seekers.

StopStartStop · 04/01/2023 12:52

I was in A&E five and a half hours last Friday after being knocked down. Triaged in five minutes, three and a quarter hours' wait for x-ray (after which they took me seriously at last) then manipulation, plaster, x-ray, a man from 'therapy' telling me I wouldn't be able to manage at home alone (so what do you expect me to do? It's manage or don't) and I'm out.

GPs and walk-ins dismissed my dd for years when she had an achalasia that was trying to kill her.

Medics seem to be trained to disbelieve.

Orangesandlemons77 · 04/01/2023 12:50

BradfordGirl · 04/01/2023 12:38

Private GPs are fine for the worried well. People seeking reassurance.
But patients do better medically if they see the same long term. All the research shows that. GPs should never be an emergency service.

How do these private GPs know your medical history?

Orangesandlemons77 · 04/01/2023 12:49

StewPots · 04/01/2023 11:48

@Orangesandlemons77 sympathy and solidarity to you. It’s a shame that there isn’t another place for us to go and get sorted. It’s a horrid way to live :(

Thanks, you too. They stick me in SAU which is kind of like an extension of A&E.Surgical assessment unit. It's really busy and hectic.

Out of interest do you have any kind of letter to take in to A&E if you need to attend urgently? I think this could be helpful.

BradfordGirl · 04/01/2023 12:38

Private GPs are fine for the worried well. People seeking reassurance.
But patients do better medically if they see the same long term. All the research shows that. GPs should never be an emergency service.

BradfordGirl · 04/01/2023 12:37

Much of the country can only see a private GP online. I do not see how online a GP could diagnose say a chest infection and prescribe antibiotics. Indeed someone on this thread posted about seeing a private GP online and being sent to A and E to see someone face to face.

cyclamenqueen · 04/01/2023 12:36

I am always baffled by the advice to go to a pharmacy. I have tried this lots of times but the only response is ‘see your gp ’ or ‘we are not insured on advise on that ‘ .

FourTeaFallOut · 04/01/2023 12:36

Mydpisgrumpierthanyours · 04/01/2023 12:32

I do think pharmacist would be used more if there was an automatic private Place to see them not have to ask for a private word. That's what puts me off using a pharmacist for advice

Most do, you just have to ask.

Gooseysgirl · 04/01/2023 12:35

I miraculously avoided a trip to A&E recently with horrific UTI. By sheer good luck I managed to get a GP cancellation and got the antibiotics I needed. Things would have got a whole lot worse had I not seen dr and started the ABs when I did. I would have had no other option but to go to A&E for something that was so easily sorted by ten mins with GP.

Mydpisgrumpierthanyours · 04/01/2023 12:32

I do think pharmacist would be used more if there was an automatic private Place to see them not have to ask for a private word. That's what puts me off using a pharmacist for advice

JennyForeigner · 04/01/2023 12:32

Oher · 04/01/2023 12:28

@JennyForeigner do a £50 private online consult with a private GP, get antibiotic prescription then pickup from local pharmacy. At A&E you’ll be in a 6-7 hr queue surrounded by contagious people and wishing you’d paid the £50.

If you can’t afford the private consultation, call 111 and ask them to get you a GP appointment - they have the power to order your GP to see you.

Or walkin to your GP and make an appointment in person if they don’t answer phone.

Thanks, this is really helpful. For some reason I thought they didn't see kids and our son is three. Very happy to pay to avoid the NHS right now - I was thinking this morning about how we have moved everything we used to get such as contraception and a standing prescription for my husband to private providers to try and do our bit.

Oher · 04/01/2023 12:31

Redannie118 · 04/01/2023 12:28

A short while ago I woke up with horrific nerve pain in my leg. When I tried to put weight on it , it just wobbled and collapsed. I did everything you are meant to, rang 111 who made me an app at the local minor illness and injuries unit( it was a sunday morning) when i got there the place was completely empty, just me. A nurse came out and said they could make me an app with a doctor at 530, it was 830 in the morning at this point. I stated I was in agony, couldnt walk and wanted to stay. I got a mouthful about how I was wasting everyones time but whatever !

Doctor saw me 5 mins later, diagnosed severe sciatica, gave me strong painkillers and sent me home within 5 mins. Horrible nurse saw me sitting with doctor, and shouted through " I told her to go home !" Doctor went and gave her a stern telling off and apologised to me.

My point is, when GPs wont give you an app, and walk ins/111/minor illness units wont treat you, what else are you supposed to do?

I’m sorry that happened, the nurse sounds totally ignorant. I’ve had a 3rd degree tear in childbirth with no painkillers, and I’ve also had sciatica, and I’d rather go through labour with vaginal tears for an entire week with no painrelief than have sciatica again. I hope you’re ok now.

MrsR87 · 04/01/2023 12:30

I think it’s a perfect storm of media frenzy and lack of alternatives.

Where I live (as most places) it is incredibly difficult to talk to a GP, let alone book an appointment. Many minor injuries units are no longer open and so people are turning to 111 and A and E. I think it must be a very frightening time, especially for first time parents, as the media are constantly reporting on the next thing that will get your child and with so many of these things having generic symptoms, they are scared and don’t know what to do.

The lack of proper/logical services is forcing people’s hands. For example, last year when I was pregnant I developed a urine infection. They gave me the appropriate course of antibiotics for a pregnant woman and said it may not clear up in one dose and to call back if it didn’t. It didn’t, so I called back and took another urine sample in. The receptionist said a doctor would call that day. I cleared it with my head teacher to have my phone on the desk to answer but they didn’t call when I was at work. I had my
hands free connected so I could answer in the car, they didn’t call when I was driving. Of course, they called in the 60 seconds of the day when I was getting my toddler out of the car and I missed getting to my
phone by seconds. My surgery do not phone back, if you miss your call that’s it. I called the surgery straight back and they said I would have to call back in the morning to get my name of the list again. I explained that I can only call up until 8.30 when I start teaching and in the past two years when I’ve called, I’ve never got connected before 10.30 after being on hold from 8am. They said that was my problem and I’ve have to ask for cover for my classes (this was the weeks leading up to the GCSES) to sit on the phone to try and get though. I didn’t do that as that’s outrageous but I kept trying to get through at various points (before work, break, lunch) but could realistically only stay on the phone long enough after 3pm which was too late. I called my midwife and she said the doctor needed to issue antibiotics. Fair enough. After three days of crying on the phone each time and explaining that I needed the toilet about 3 times per lesson which was less than ideal, the receptionist told me to set an alarm for 1am as that is when the online appointments are released and there would be none left by 7am. So that’s what I did and I managed to get an appointment for 3 days later. I checked at 6am when my alarm went off and all the appointments had gone! . So I spent several days in agony and wasted a face to face appointment just to get a doctor to represcribe antibiotics for an ongoing issue that they had the urine results for! I apologised to the doc for wasting an appointment…she just looked defeated and said I only needed a phone appointment but she bet I couldn’t get one…so clearly not a one off. A short while later I was hospitalised by my midwife for off the scale high blood pressure and I often wonder how much that added to it! Anyway…that’s a long story just to say, I was essentially forced to book a face to face appointment that I didn’t need that then takes that appointment from someone else who might then feel that A and E is their only option.

Once they sort basic issues in GP surgeries out, the pressure will ease elsewhere!

NeonBoomerang · 04/01/2023 12:29

A lot of people we get through the doors are people directed there by their GP surgery when they've been unable to see a GP the same day. The number of young healthy people we've had in recently with the flu is astounding - they should be tucked up in bed with paracetamol, not coming into hospital, and they're often told as much when they're eventually seen.

There are always ridiculous people in though. In the last week we've had a patient come in because they were struggling to sleep, and another who was in because they hadn't yet opened their bowels that day.

Oher · 04/01/2023 12:28

JennyForeigner · 04/01/2023 12:24

I barely set foot in a hospital between being born and having my own kids. Lots of medics in the family - everything up to stitching handled at home (and yes, those were different times).

I'm starting to wonder if we are going to be one of the families just turning up next week. My 3 year old son has nail bed infections. We've tried everything to avoid the NHS - seen a pharmacist and HV, 4x daily salt baths, bandages and air exposure...

They are getting worse and our doctor's surgery are now not answering the phone at any time of day. They have become completely non-responsive. The advice of everyone we have tried is that our son needs to be checked over before things escalate further.

We're reaching that balance point between feeling responsible if we do and responsible if we don't - which I imagine is 90% of people trying to get help.

@JennyForeigner do a £50 private online consult with a private GP, get antibiotic prescription then pickup from local pharmacy. At A&E you’ll be in a 6-7 hr queue surrounded by contagious people and wishing you’d paid the £50.

If you can’t afford the private consultation, call 111 and ask them to get you a GP appointment - they have the power to order your GP to see you.

Or walkin to your GP and make an appointment in person if they don’t answer phone.

Redannie118 · 04/01/2023 12:28

A short while ago I woke up with horrific nerve pain in my leg. When I tried to put weight on it , it just wobbled and collapsed. I did everything you are meant to, rang 111 who made me an app at the local minor illness and injuries unit( it was a sunday morning) when i got there the place was completely empty, just me. A nurse came out and said they could make me an app with a doctor at 530, it was 830 in the morning at this point. I stated I was in agony, couldnt walk and wanted to stay. I got a mouthful about how I was wasting everyones time but whatever !

Doctor saw me 5 mins later, diagnosed severe sciatica, gave me strong painkillers and sent me home within 5 mins. Horrible nurse saw me sitting with doctor, and shouted through " I told her to go home !" Doctor went and gave her a stern telling off and apologised to me.

My point is, when GPs wont give you an app, and walk ins/111/minor illness units wont treat you, what else are you supposed to do?

AndNowForSomethingCompletelyDifferent · 04/01/2023 12:27

People don’t want to be sick. That’s the impression I get from booking in patients. Colds, coughs etc that they have had for a day needs antibiotics now. Some come in and have done nothing at home. No paracetamol, no rest and are simply annoyed that they are unwell and want a quick fix. A few hours of vomiting that is ‘the worst ever’

To an extent this is true. Parents don’t have time for their children to be ill, they want them to be fixed so they bring them to a&e, sometimes without having given them any calpol. Everything has to happen now, these days.

Places like social media and mn don’t help. How many times have you seen ‘a&e now’ for a child with a temperature, or because they’ve had two doses of antibiotics and they haven’t improved ‘you need to take them back!’ Or telling people to ‘demand antibiotics’. None of that is helpful.

StuntNun · 04/01/2023 12:27

Last month we couldn't get seen by our GP, or by the online NHS GP service, or by the private GP service we have access to, or get through to a doctor on 111 for our child with a 41C temperature and suspected strep A infection. After 36 hours waiting for a doctor from 111 to call back, my DH decided to take him to A&E where, after a five-hour wait, he was given antibiotics. We didn't want to take him to A&E but there was no other care available and he was very ill. 111 finally called back while DH and our child were in with the A&E doctor but it still wasn't a doctor, it was a 111 call operator saying that there still wasn't a doctor available.

SnowlayRoundabout · 04/01/2023 12:26

I contacted my local Minor Injuries Unit after an accident a few weeks ago which needed medical attention - I phoned them first as it was around 5.30 pm and I wasn't sure when they closed. Although they were open till 8.30, they told me not to bother to turn up because they were already beyond capacity, so I was left with no choice but to go to A&E, which was absolutely heaving. There I was eventually diverted after triage to their Urgent Treatment unit, which I think is meant to be a sort of fast track for minor injuries but that too was really full and was being manned by one solitary doctor and nurse who were having to do all their own admin etc, and I eventually left at about 11.30 pm. Given the circumstances, I thought that really wasn't too bad.

My overwhelming thought was that no-one would seriously be there unless they needed to be. At times it was difficult even to get a seat, it's just not something you would put yourself through if there was any alternative.

Oher · 04/01/2023 12:26

I’ve taken DD to local minor injuries twice, straight after school, and both times (after waiting there more than 1hr) the nurse said I ought to take DD to A&E for an x-ray. Don’t you have an x-ray machine here I asked? “Yes but the x-ray operator goes home at 3pm.” I said that I really don’t think it’s broken, I think we just need antibiotics, can’t I come back here at 8am for the x-ray? “You could do but you really really ought to go to A&E right now.” Nurse then glared at me as if am terrible mother

-> Go to A&E -> keep child up past bedtime to wait 6 hrs with all the covid scarlet fever and drunk people -> be told by grumpy staff is not broken and all we need is antibiotics, just like I told the first nurse.

There is a problem with other parts of the NHS funnelling everyone to A&E. Similarly if you google a problem, the advice will often be go to A&e when what is really needed is a quick phone call with a GP.

Directing sick people to pharmacists is not the answer, my pharmacist is an idiot and all of his advice has been wrong. He just sells me expensive meds that don’t work and doesn’t give basic medical advice which luckily I eventually find on google.

What is needed is quick online access to GP. This already exists for private patients and the NHS should roll it out to the public instead of clogging A&E.