Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lots of people go to A&E when they shouldn't

306 replies

Liz1tummypain · 04/01/2023 10:18

To be clear- I couldn't think of a way or wording this so I just came up with something that might attract some opinions. It isn't something I can spout about with any authority.

But is it true? My kids are older so I haven't had to go to A&E for ages. Very little experience. On the radio I heard they are trying to re-direct potential patients to pharmacies etc . So what is your view on it?

My mum worked in A&E , a long time ago and she says she thinks people wouldn't have dared to turn up with some minor injuries that she thinks people go in with now. She thinks people just tried home remedies and only went in with broken bones, trauma, sick children. But I think maybe she was just getting a bit worked up after seeing something on TV. She also hasn't been to A&E for a long time.

OP posts:
GlassBunion · 04/01/2023 11:06

I wonder whether we ought to go back to the days of having cottage hospitals in every district.

It would ease the burden on general hospitals and be an extended support for GP practices that are , clearly, no longer coping with the volume of appointments needed.

Goldenbear · 04/01/2023 11:06

My DH's Grandad, uncle and Aunt were all GPs so my MIL knows quite a bit about medical conditions. She has a kidney issue recently, knew that it could be treated with a prescription from GP but she needed a physical check first and phone call would not suffice. They refused told my 75 year old mil to go to A&E but instead she went along to the surgery which is locked, she waited and entered when someone left, she waited in the waiting room, was seen by a GP, for her prescription and went home - one less person in A&E and also stopped the condition worsening to create more issues and potential hospital visit. DH's uncle was working up until a couple of years ago and would do out of hours visits for patients that rang him at home,old patients that he'd known for years. That kind of relationship stopped the admissions in the past. You need personal lists, attractive funding for medical students to commit to GP on leaving.

It seems a big coincidence that GP/patient appointments stopped in person in COVID, now we have an NHS crisis.

Ponoka7 · 04/01/2023 11:05

helpfulperson · 04/01/2023 10:35

I'll try and find the figures but I believe that the number of both A&E and GP appointments has increased significantly over the past few years suggesting people are attending for much less now. I'm always surprised by how often people on here seem to attend the GP.

Our population has gone up by nearly 3 million over the last three years, which could easily out demand the rise in appointments. Which is why councils are using the law to reject migration/asylum population because the local services won't cope.
All of the consultants, the BMA etc agree that the main issue is a lack of investment. Suddenly we ignore the experts on this and blame the people who have the temerity to use services.

Bepis · 04/01/2023 11:05

I'm ashamed to say it but when I was 17 (39 now) I went to A&E for an infected ingrowing toenail 🤦🏻‍♀️. I wouldn't dream of doing that now though.

fUNNYfACE36 · 04/01/2023 11:04

The problem is really not the fault of rhe patients!

Katapolts · 04/01/2023 11:04

Outandover · 04/01/2023 11:02

For most it’s probably an issue with getting a GP appointment, although for our surgery this has never been an issue even throughout the pandemic so we are clearly in the minority.

The health service also needs a major overall which also in turn means becoming a 7-day service, because people don’t just get sick conveniently Mon-Fri 9-5pm. GP surgeries should be required by law to be open 7 days, with at least one doctor and nurse available to deal with those who ‘inconveniently’ get ill on the weekend.

We have just spent 3 hours in our local Paediatric A&E after being told to go by the out of ours GP (child was admitted to hospital so not a fob off from this GP), and the small waiting room was full of young children stripped down to underwear and clearing running fevers, coughing and spluttering, and vomiting. If there was a 7-day GP service then I would suspect many of these children could have been seen without an A&E visit (obviously not all).

The A&E doctor also Strep A has always been around and the media are really ramping up the panic which then has the flow-on effect of people arriving at A&E worried sick. If they could see a GP then again this volume of people could potentially be reduced significantly.

What good is making a 7 day GP service a legal requirement if there aren't enough GPs and nurses to staff it? Who/how will enforce it?

18e6281o62 · 04/01/2023 11:03

I ended up in A&E unnecessarily over Christmas. 111 told me to go there as GP was closed and medication more effective within a certain amount of hours so couldn't wait for it to reopen. 111 were pretty sure of the diagnosis, as was the triage nurse. But had to wait to see a doctor as I needed a prescription. 5.5 hours later (which I consider good!), prescription received. Doctor said if it doesn't resolve to come back to A&E despite NHS pages on the condition saying GP should be the first point of call.

Bunchamunchacarrots · 04/01/2023 11:03

NYNewYou · 04/01/2023 10:41

Back in my home country when I got food poisoning I was taken to the a&e at a public hospital and put on some drips without any questions and this isn't a first world country. Last year my ds picked up a bug from nursery and had a very high temp for 6 days going up to 40.6 in the early hours and no gp appointments prior to that. Day 6, 3 am he has 40.6, cold hands and feet. I called 111, they arranged an appointment at the a&e and I took him there. My son barely able to walk from losing so much weight and hadn't eaten or had any fluids in his body for nearly a week, Dr's looked at me like I'm mental to bring him here and how dare I bring him despite being advised despite the website. When you are abroad, you are advised to go to a local a&e, we tell friends and family to take out travel insurance etc to cover unexpected things, but when you are here in this country as a taxpayer you get fuck all care unless you have a chainsaw poking out your chest. Tell me what are people meant to do. My then 2.5 yo was a stick insect barely able to walk, open his eyes or speak. No gp appointments, no one to see you. Instead of spying on people and questioning why they are here maybe people should question why people can't have access to basic health?

Agreed. I have found the lack of access to urgent medical advice for my toddler truly terrifying in the past year.

Friends in other countries have same day access to paediatrician community care for things like suspected ear infections. Meanwhile, I have taken DD to A&E with suspected sepsis and faced scorn from the triage nurse because she doesn't look at deaths door.

Ginmonkeyagain · 04/01/2023 11:03

@NYNewYou Indeed and that would have happened to me as I was basically told to go away as I think they suspected I was after a freebie from the emergency dentist. I was just very insistent and very middle class and demanded at least a couple of days of penicillin in case the infection took a turn for the worse and became sepsis.

As it tuned out I ended up on a two week course of metranidazole (which is VILE)

SomethingOriginal2 · 04/01/2023 11:02

Yes definitely but that's because we have no bloody GPs so no one can get appointments.

Outandover · 04/01/2023 11:02

For most it’s probably an issue with getting a GP appointment, although for our surgery this has never been an issue even throughout the pandemic so we are clearly in the minority.

The health service also needs a major overall which also in turn means becoming a 7-day service, because people don’t just get sick conveniently Mon-Fri 9-5pm. GP surgeries should be required by law to be open 7 days, with at least one doctor and nurse available to deal with those who ‘inconveniently’ get ill on the weekend.

We have just spent 3 hours in our local Paediatric A&E after being told to go by the out of ours GP (child was admitted to hospital so not a fob off from this GP), and the small waiting room was full of young children stripped down to underwear and clearing running fevers, coughing and spluttering, and vomiting. If there was a 7-day GP service then I would suspect many of these children could have been seen without an A&E visit (obviously not all).

The A&E doctor also Strep A has always been around and the media are really ramping up the panic which then has the flow-on effect of people arriving at A&E worried sick. If they could see a GP then again this volume of people could potentially be reduced significantly.

Godlovesall26 · 04/01/2023 11:01

Godlovesall26 · 04/01/2023 10:51

Telephone GP/111 calls are part of the problem. You can’t do the most basic examinations. So to be sure, it ends up being A&E. Or worse, calling an ambulance to get to A&E, which delays them for absolute emergencies (I was in a rather big city center, needed an emergency ICU transfer = absolute top of the emergency list (had stopped breathing literally), and it still took 1.5 hours for the ambulance : then stayed after reanimated for evaluation of potential hypoxia damage due to this delay. Then had to be discharged because no place in regular wards (so, the lack of social care issue also) because you obviously can’t keep an ICU bed. Was shattered, they gave me food for days and all meds, I never could have managed otherwise if alone at home.

Forgot to mention, as I had a long severe pneumonia consequently, I was sensitive (still am) to any respiratory infection for a while, and so any symptoms related I was always directed to A&E : they can’t examine anything by phone, and good luck getting a GP appointment. I did go, although I figured it would be nothing, it’s hard to be told go and think no I won’t (after a réanimation stay especially, but really the stuff was minor risk, it’s just that by phone they can’t check the most basic stuff)

Franticbutterfly · 04/01/2023 11:01

I used to work on the same reception as A&E, I've seen people come with an ingrown toenail, people coming because their baby has a slight temp or has D&V, I've seen lots come because they've had a slight bump in their car and need to see a dr to enhance the likelihood of a future car insurance payout (no injuries recorded); women who pretend to fall so they can get an early scan (this was a pretty regular thing to do for ladies from a particular country - I'm not racist, it just is what it is), I could go on a while..

luxxlisbon · 04/01/2023 11:01

Emmamoo89 · 04/01/2023 10:58

Mastitis can be life threatening so its understandably getting sent to A&E

I wasn’t sent to A&E because it can be life threatening, if my GP was worried about it being life threatening I’m sure they could have offered me an appointment sooner than 2 weeks.
Then the OOH doctor refused to see me too.
A&E did a basic exam and prescribed a standard course of antibiotics - there was no need for me to clog up A&E.

NYNewYou · 04/01/2023 11:00

@Ginmonkeyagain your case basically sums up the situation in a lot of people, to not end up waiting around for sepsis to take over your body when you have no access to a gp or walk in clinic. These things tend to happen at night and weekends and you don't want to risk waiting for the next day or Monday in case the situation takes a dark turn and it's too late. We read about these stories every once in a while don't we, hell even people who have turned up to the a&e and was sent home that had died at home.

daisyjgrey · 04/01/2023 11:00

I work with young people (16-25) and the amount of things that 'guidance' tells us that we need to recommend they attend a&e for us absurd.

Things that if they were my own children I'd be giving them a paracetamol and just keeping an eye on it. It's all arse covering and it's just adding to the chaos. Guidelines for things like this need reassessing and putting into context.

fUNNYfACE36 · 04/01/2023 10:59

SilverHydrangea · 04/01/2023 10:29

I was recently at A&E due to a nasty fall and fracture. In front of me in the queue at the triage desk was a man who reported a red/?infected hangnail and another who said he had hurt his knee at football a few weeks previously and it was still playing up - he had a couple of days off so thought he'd pop in. IMO neither of those should have been at A&E.

A septic finger needs prompt antibiotics ,or ir x5an lead to sepsis.How could you diagnose the footballers knee accident?

Anisina · 04/01/2023 10:58

We used to have a couple of walk in GP hubs. They are no longer walk ins and you have to get an appointment through 111. I think introducing walk in GP clinics again might take some of the pressure off A & E. Getting an urgent GP appointment is very difficult.

Emmamoo89 · 04/01/2023 10:58

luxxlisbon · 04/01/2023 10:30

Three times in the past 12 months my GP tried to direct me to A&E for mastitis (which in the end I had to go in for as GP wouldn’t see me and I was massively unwell with a 3 week old to look after) a chest infection for DD, and an ear infection for DD. The two last times I had to push incredibly hard got to to be seen and made it clear A&E was not the appropriate route for a child with an ear infection!

So yes some people go to A&E when they don’t need to, either because they don’t know how to access the right care, they aren’t sure how serious the situation is and they are worried or they cannot access care through other means.

Mastitis can be life threatening so its understandably getting sent to A&E

Sparklesocks · 04/01/2023 10:57

You may get a very tiny minority of people who have hypochondriac tendencies going there, but as others have pointed out the wait time is so long that the vast majority will only be there if they really have to be.

NHS services are so strained and stretched people aren’t getting the treatment or care they need, or put off trying to get a GP appt as they know it’ll be a nightmare and then by the time they relent they’re much sicker than they were and A+E is the only option. A few years ago our local minor injuries clinic was very well staffed and treated people who were in need but it wasn’t an emergency, often things like mild falls, burns etc. It took a lot of strain off the local A+E but it’s now closed - so people who would’ve gone there have no choice but to go to A+E and add to the pile.

Katapolts · 04/01/2023 10:54

There are some idiots out there, but the big problem is we don't have enough GPs.

GPs are actually seeing more people than ever, but can't keep up with demand. Like every other area of the NHS, it's understaffing, high levels of stress - not worth it for the money.

You can't get through to 111 a lot of the time. Patchy access to OOH GPs.

Along with the Tories closing lots of urgent care, minor injuries and A&Es, it means intolerable pressure on the services that are left.

Ginmonkeyagain · 04/01/2023 10:53

I'll admit I once walked in to A&E and would have looked like a timewaster as it was for a gum infection.

HOWEVER - I had seen my dentist earlier that week about a mildly infected gum around a wisdom tooth. He advised rinsing it out with Corsdyl or salt water and coming back if it got worse.

It got a worse and by the weekend (when my dentist is closed) to the point at 3am on the Saturday I woke up drenched in sweat, shivering and with a very high temperature. My gums were inflamed red, painful and hot to touch. Mindful of the link between infected teeth/gums and sepsis I went to A&E (at the time I lived a 10 min walk from a major London A&E unit). I basically waited three hours and argued with the triage nurse until I was sent away with a small handful of penicillin.

When I saw my dentist on Monday I was diagnosed with acute necrotising gingivitis and my dentist said it could have easily and quickly turned in to sepsis had I not got hold of antibiotics.

Pickingmyselfup · 04/01/2023 10:52

I think it's a minority of people who go to A&E off their own back for something minor and haven't tried other options first.

The majority of "unnecessary" cases are sent there by the doctor or 111 or go because it's their last resort.

During covid my friend tried to get a GP appointment for her sick child. She was refused because she had to take her other children with her as she had no childcare options since we weren't allowed to see other people. They told her to take all of the children to A&E instead and get the sick one seen there. So basically spend hours waiting in a waiting room full of sick people Vs 10 minutes in the other with barely any people in because it was strict appointment only. It just seemed absolute madness but our doctors is still very reluctant to see people and the place is still like fort Knox.

It's not so much the patients that cause the issue but the system itself.

Godlovesall26 · 04/01/2023 10:51

Telephone GP/111 calls are part of the problem. You can’t do the most basic examinations. So to be sure, it ends up being A&E. Or worse, calling an ambulance to get to A&E, which delays them for absolute emergencies (I was in a rather big city center, needed an emergency ICU transfer = absolute top of the emergency list (had stopped breathing literally), and it still took 1.5 hours for the ambulance : then stayed after reanimated for evaluation of potential hypoxia damage due to this delay. Then had to be discharged because no place in regular wards (so, the lack of social care issue also) because you obviously can’t keep an ICU bed. Was shattered, they gave me food for days and all meds, I never could have managed otherwise if alone at home.

crackofdoom · 04/01/2023 10:50

TugboatAnnie
Absolutely. I'm a veteran of children's head injuries- counting it up, my 2 have had to have medical attention 6 times between them for either massive bleeding head wounds or signs of concussion. I've always taken them to MIU, who have either glued them back together or kept them under observation for the time required.

This time, DS2 fell over in the playground at school, bled profusely and showed signs of confusion, and they called a bloody ambulance, who insisted on whisking us off to A&E at the County hospital, where he underwent the same period of observation, except rather than having a bed in a bay to recover, he had to sit in the waiting room, because of course they're much busier there.

It was only afterwards that I found out that the local MIU is only open part time now ☹