Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for ADHD classroom experience from the other side

106 replies

Nimbostratus100 · 04/01/2023 09:24

More specific than other threads currently running

If you have ADHD, please tell me what helped you most at school

Secondary teacher off sick here, just pondering returning to work some time this year.

I do my best for my students with ADHD, but always wonder if there is something I could do better. Of course everyone is different, and what works for one student might not work for another. And I suppose I am most likely to get a female perspective here, which might be very different to the male one. But any mums to sons with ADHD, insights very welcome!

But imagine yourself back to sitting in front of me in a secondary classroom as a young teen

Please describe what you would most want from me.

Thank you

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
NeverDropYourMooncup · 09/03/2023 18:37

Less shit on the walls. You know those displays that *certain members of staff SLT are so intent upon having you cover every door, every wall, underneath, alongside and above the IWB/board and right up to the ceiling with? They're Kryptonite.

Natural daylight. Those bastarding fluorescent things flicker and buzz.

The multiple items of equipment, folders, things on surfaces, the state of the teachers' desks.

Painting rooms stupid colours, like bloody yellow, acid mint green or bright cyan.

Books that have to be covered with progress sheets that are a) appallingly designed for writing on, b) have been badly stuck on with generic Prittstik so have flappy bits and c) covered with that bloody school logo.

The above all create visual noise that is screaming at you constantly throughout a lesson.

The chairs that creak when you shift in them because you're uncomfortable physically and mentally.

Uniform. Those crispy jumpers that don't fit any known human being. Sodding ties. Skirts that rotate around your body. Blazers that are too long, too big and simultaneously too small. Shoes that squash your toes together instead of letting your feet spread out. Ugh.

Sit still, sit up, eyes forward - but staying still is really difficult with the irritating uniform, uncomfortable chairs, the Steps To Success/Our Ethos/Keywords/mounds of stuff to have on you at all times/the fucking lights all shrieking at you.

Having to concentrate your writing and condense every thought between the tiny lines on the page, rather than be able to think BIG and plan things with A3 pads and washable markers, is like putting your brain and body into a too tight inflatable lifejacket. And not those irritatingly thin presentation pads beloved of consultants either - you need proper paper. When you've got a brain that is pinging off in a thousand different directions and weaving around, interconnecting and linking concepts in 3D (if not 4 when you add Time), it doesn't fit in neat little horizontal spaces.

Movement. Waving arms, moving legs around, rocking helps you get the thoughts out - so almost impossible when there's somebody crammed in next to you, behind you and in front of you so that it's impossible to go anywhere without climbing over everybody, their bags and the desks.

If you're talking At me, I'm somewhere else after the first few words. No, I don't want to sit watching you click through a powerpoint and read out the scenario (even worse if it's a pre recorded thing). I've seen it, read it and understood in 2 seconds. I'm now dying a thousand deaths waiting for the slide to finish. See also 'Forcing people to read out loud'. Please don't make me sit through that.

Great lumps of text hold no interest. Space stuff out, make the font larger, use softer colours in tables rather than the generic bright red, bright green, yellow and blue. Look at occasionally flipping to a box with dark background and white text if you want me to notice something. And GET TO THE POINT.

Creating large poster presentations to condense knowledge into something that looks good, gets to the point and isn't going to kill my will to live in the process really helps - teach the skills to make them properly, rather than just a crappy drawing and no writing - a paragraph underneath a clear heading, so similar to a spider diagram made attractive/useful really helps.

Lovemusic33 · 09/03/2023 17:57

I think the classes I struggled with the most were ones that involved listening for long periods of time and taking notes, history was the worst as the teacher would just talk for the whole lesson, we would take notes and then write it up for homework, I couldn’t focus listening to one person talk for a hour/hour and a half so often zoned out meaning I didn’t take enough notes so then couldn’t do my home work. I think a lesson that’s broken up into different activities, some that involve moving around would have worked better for me. I struggled to focus and struggled to sit still. The lesson had to be interesting to hold my attention and usually involve some kind of art (not just written work). Art and textiles were probably my best lessons as we could move around and do different things rather than sitting and listening.

DisgruntledApothecarist · 09/03/2023 17:40

This is an interesting take and considers another dimension

Endpress · 08/01/2023 13:18

Just to know how things play out for adhd people where tasks and flash anger anre concerned and not shame them.

Onthecuspofabreakthrough · 08/01/2023 13:17

It seems an issue to me that for every one student with an adhd diagnosis in your class there are likely to be another 4 or so that have the same traits but have not been diagnosed (or are on the long waiting lists for diagnosis)

Willyoujustbequiet · 08/01/2023 12:47

Nimbostratus100 · 08/01/2023 11:41

I know there are no spares, and not enough for the students that cant write to have one each. If children cant write for whatever reason, we ask them to provide their own laptop

Would that be legal?

If a child has a diagnosis/EHCP it may be a reasonable adjustment and the school would have to provide one.

Willyoujustbequiet · 08/01/2023 12:34

HairyKitty · 06/01/2023 08:53

Yes literally anything that you expect children to do outside of the lesson including in self study periods or homework needs to be given in writing.
Any time you tell the students in advance about a test, assignment, outing, anything, it needs to be given in writing (and electronically with parent access).

This. Literally anything or it gets forgotten.

I got it written into dc EHCPs that I had to be given notice of all exams/assessments/important events etc.. and grades have shot up.

FurryDandelionSeekingMissile · 08/01/2023 12:29

(I wasn't a teacher or anything to do with education in any way, just a rational, bored, curious individual who occasionally, while flicking through the high-number channels, would land on Teachers TV only to see some charlatan trying to convince professional educators that rubbing imaginary buttons on your chest would boost blood flow to the brain, and marvel at the fact that the government would think it worth funding the promulgation of this utter bullshit.)

FurryDandelionSeekingMissile · 08/01/2023 12:18

Brain gym

Thank you! I've been trying for about three years to remember the name of that particular brand of patent bollocks I saw being shamelessly marketed on Teachers TV back when it was a Freeview channel.

Nimbostratus100 · 08/01/2023 12:09

Cornishmumofone · 08/01/2023 11:30

again, this would be outside of any individual teacher control, schools have their own policies, based on whatever framework and research the management has chosen, you cant just unilaterally choose your own.

Even if you're working somewhere with a lot of restrictions, you should be able to use the framework when planning individual lessons.

not really, you cant impose one framework on top of another, even if they agree, but in fact this one contradicts some of the more current "in" frameworks - not that I agree or disagree, but school management being what it is, you often get some deputy head tasked with improving "learning and teaching" and they have to change things, in order to prove that they have changed things.

This leads to change for changes sake, and members of staff with no scientific literacy at all, staff who could not even define the word "research", evaluating total non-research marketed as "research" and choosing that will be their marker and imposing it on schools

Blame Gove. he was the one that decided managers have to justify their pay by showing what they have changed. Managers not qualified to judge the "research" they are acting on. Hence you get total quackery like Brain gym and learning styles imposed......

Sorry, rant over ! But no, I cant use that framework in any way

OP posts:
BobBobBobbing · 08/01/2023 12:05

25 later I still love my biology teacher- she recognised I had ability as I aced exams but struggled with routine things like homework/remembering kit. She would set me challenges in class to recreate the exam feeling and when I'd completed them she'd give extension work to keep pushing me. I was allowed to doodle (I'm actually paying close attention when doodling. If I'm looking at you and appearing to concentrate then I've gone off into my own world and am not listening at all.)
She was firm and had standards but never made me feel like a failure when I messed up. Shed also praise me when I did well, unlike most of the other teachers who'd say something like "see you can do it when you try".

My physics teacher accused me of cheating as "there was no way you'd get those grades on your own" and my RE teacher used to routinely humiliate me in class for forgetting stuff.

The big difference I notice with my kids is that homework is set on Teams. No bits of paper to lose and reminders are issued. That would have been a huge help.

Ds2 is awaiting an assessment for autism/adhd. I was really worried about him starting seniors as he's been behind all the way through infants and juniors and has sensory issues. He's done amazingly well and is absolutely flying- exceeding the standard for the year already and the teachers are full of praise for him. It turned out that all the noise and stimulation in classrooms previously was having a massive impact on him. He's got adjustments such as a piece of plastic to lean on as he hates the feel of paper under his hand. But most of the work is online which he finds much easier as it removes the sensory issue, means there's no paper to lose and removes the handwriting element.

Nimbostratus100 · 08/01/2023 11:41

FromTheFront2theBack · 06/01/2023 09:54

Female, inattentive type here. I'd definitely like to be allowed to fidget and sit how I wanted. It was difficult to sit still, I'd much rather be pacing (obviously not practical in a classroom) but was constantly told to uncross my legs, put my bag on the floor (much prefered it on my lap) and stop fiddling. None of these things affected anyone else and made it much easier to work.

I'd also avoid shaming. Often people with neurodivergence suffer from rejection sensitive dysphoria and have a very extreme reaction to negative judgment and shame.

Also not sure why you think most schools don't have spares. Lots of schools I work in have laptops for students who can't write clearly. In some classes there are four or five students out of 30 working on laptops.

I know there are no spares, and not enough for the students that cant write to have one each. If children cant write for whatever reason, we ask them to provide their own laptop

OP posts:
inthekitchensink · 08/01/2023 11:40

Doodling - helped me but got told off for not focusing
Quick quizzes at the end of every ten minutes learning - to pull back engagement and participation (easily would withdraw and disengage)
Movement breaks - I would be desperate just to go to the loo so I could be by myself and breathe for a moment
Weekly check ins with a nice teacher to check on how I was doing/keeping up - for 5 mins
Desk at the front or in a corner, preferably no other people in my immediate peripheral vision - too distracting/noisy/feel overwhelmed

Cornishmumofone · 08/01/2023 11:30

again, this would be outside of any individual teacher control, schools have their own policies, based on whatever framework and research the management has chosen, you cant just unilaterally choose your own.

Even if you're working somewhere with a lot of restrictions, you should be able to use the framework when planning individual lessons.

FromTheFront2theBack · 06/01/2023 09:54

Female, inattentive type here. I'd definitely like to be allowed to fidget and sit how I wanted. It was difficult to sit still, I'd much rather be pacing (obviously not practical in a classroom) but was constantly told to uncross my legs, put my bag on the floor (much prefered it on my lap) and stop fiddling. None of these things affected anyone else and made it much easier to work.

I'd also avoid shaming. Often people with neurodivergence suffer from rejection sensitive dysphoria and have a very extreme reaction to negative judgment and shame.

Also not sure why you think most schools don't have spares. Lots of schools I work in have laptops for students who can't write clearly. In some classes there are four or five students out of 30 working on laptops.

katepilar · 06/01/2023 09:21

I wonder if the timetable could also be easier. I have the impression that the breaks are very short and the lessons long and the day is also long.
(I am educated outside of UK and only have a rough idea what the school day is like here)

Overthebow · 06/01/2023 09:13

Be mindful of all the different needs in the room. No two people with ADHD or other diagnoses are the same. I wouldn’t have been able to cope with others humming or tapping or lying on the floor or pacing.

whitebreadjamsandwich · 06/01/2023 09:01

*even now

whitebreadjamsandwich · 06/01/2023 09:01

Oh and I procrastinated like hell - shorter deadlines suited me better, rather than waiting 3 weeks then bashing out 2000 word essays in an evening (and because I was a relatively high achieving student), no one ever realised I was doing this.

Oh, and revision....even know, I can't note take, I still just write EVERYTHING out from a textbook...its the only way it goes in -support with that would have been helpful

whitebreadjamsandwich · 06/01/2023 08:58

Undiagnosed in school but things that stand out...

  • In Primary, teachers getting annoyed I'd only write and read about my hyperfocus (horses). I was always at a level way above my peers
  • I could never 'show my working' in maths - I just knew the answer was x, but how I'd got to that was difficult to explain
  • I did everything fast - not having to sit for 45 mins while everyone else finished would have been good!
Nimbostratus100 · 06/01/2023 08:58

Cornishmumofone · 06/01/2023 07:43

It's worth planning your lessons using the UDL framework which supports the development of executive function skills and offers pupils options for action and expression.

again, this would be outside of any individual teacher control, schools have their own policies, based on whatever framework and research the management has chosen, you cant just unilaterally choose your own.

OP posts:
HairyKitty · 06/01/2023 08:53

Yes literally anything that you expect children to do outside of the lesson including in self study periods or homework needs to be given in writing.
Any time you tell the students in advance about a test, assignment, outing, anything, it needs to be given in writing (and electronically with parent access).

HairyKitty · 06/01/2023 08:51

“2. Be handed a written sheet to take home at the end of each class which sets out what was covered in class, any homework and when that homework is due”

This one is essential. But on paper isn’t enough as it would inevitably get lost. Would need to be on paper and electronically, preferably sent to a place (with students agreement) that the supporting parent also has access to.

ADHD kids often can’t separate or tune out sounds, hence any background sound is distracting and then they forget what they are even doing. This is why noise cancelling headphones can be really good for self study.

Some also can’t manage visual distraction. Invite them to sit in the front row. Invite them to use those cardboard screens on the desk (kind of like horse blinkers).

romdowa · 06/01/2023 08:51

For me now as an adult with adhd having the material printed and not having to take notes is a huge one. Having accesses as well to the notes digitally would also help because I'll 100% loose the sheets.

Keeping the information short sweet and to the point. I had teachers who used to go off on tangents and my god I used to just want to die from boredom.
Also being allowed to leave the class room to use the bathroom was always such a help as well. It gave me that break from being cooped up. Even just knowing I could go used to help that trapped feeling.

Nimbostratus100 · 06/01/2023 08:49

SHNBV · 06/01/2023 07:37

The biggest tell that I had ADHD at school was my constant need to nip to the loo. It gave me a chance to move, for my brain to do something else and it also offered me a small piece of quiet time.

It didnt disrupt my learning as the sensory hell of school made it impossible to learn unless my teachers made the entire class sit in silence, so a lot of my learning took place independently at home.

I have always had a policy of allowing toilet trips in lessons, even in schools were it is officially banned. I agree with sometimes a child just needs a walk. However, my school has hugely tightened up on this now, due to the level of vandalism during lessons when toilets are unsupervised. I dont know what the answer is here, maybe some sort of key system when a child signs the key out of reception to go, but I cant really see the school agreeing to this.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread