Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sister "lectures" my son

108 replies

Jollofrice · 04/01/2023 08:50

Sister has son similar age to mine who we visit twice a year or so. Everyone gets on well. When her son does something "wrong" whether major or minor and on every instance he will get a long talk about why he had to say please/not run/how he was careless for dropping his good...Her voice is not raised,generally fair though the talks get repetitive. She does the same to my son and generally I let it pass whether I think fair or not however yesterday it just got to a point where I thought it's just sucking the fun out of the day/visit and the talks should be reserved for unsafe/important issues.

I see her son unhappy with these talks but not my place to comment on style of parenting.

I guess my tolerance for letting certain things go are higher than hers.

Example: My son was getting the last pizza slice from a box and asked if he could have it. He did lift it out of the box and Sister from halfway across the room said "No, that is John's" and walked towards him so being startled he tries to pass the slice to her and dropped it. Instantly she said "you dropped it because you were rushing. Stop rushing so much!".

I knew John already had a slice and my son also only had once slice. So I asked why was it John's as they both had a slice so maybe they could have shared it? She said I don't who had what and that is irrelevant here. He was rushing so dropped it which is strictly true.

AIBU - Sister is doing me a favour so that my son learns?

AIBNU - Sister has over reached her boundaries?

OP posts:
rainbowstardrops · 04/01/2023 13:02

I'd like to hear her side of the story!
Maybe she gets frustrated that you don't explain to/discipline your child 🤷🏻‍♀️

threeowlsonashelf · 04/01/2023 12:51

I don't think we should be raising children who aren't corrected. But also I don't think everything needs to be corrected. Especially if it was a mistake. That way Leads to low self esteem I think. Depends on how often she does it - if you adopt a different approach and it is only on the odd occasion your child has to deal with it, I would leave it. Your child will get what he needs from you and this is in fact a lesson in how to handle difficult people but just starting young

SnowlayRoundabout · 04/01/2023 12:45

She's very unwise. My mother had a tendency when we were kids to back us individually into a corner and lecture on whatever her perception of our shortcomings was. It was totally counter-productive. We'd sit there in dumb silence and then carry on and ignore her. To this day I and my siblings remember those lectures as one of the worst elements of our childhood, and we all have a tricky relationship with our mother. The only relief was when I got older and, having heard the lectures so often, I had responses prepared which my mother wasn't expecting and couldn't deal with - after that she drew back in a big way

It might be worth a mini-lecture to your sister about how she is going the right way to alienate both her nephew and her son.

euff · 04/01/2023 12:28

I'm all for polite kids and correcting behaviour but your sister sounds tedious and doesn't sound like she treats them the same when together.

mewkins · 04/01/2023 12:18

As others have said...it all sounds quite tedious. People aren't machines. Accidents happen and they don't need an 'I told you soon top of everything else. She is overparenting both kids which is annoying. Train your kid to tell her to f* off? (Just kidding...ish).

Kanaloa · 04/01/2023 12:14

Chickenly · 04/01/2023 12:02

I’m beginning to see why I keep getting comments that my very normal 3yo is very well behaved everywhere we go. Apparently politely asking a child, without shouting or raising your voice, to not rush after throwing pizza onto the floor means that the child is a poor, frazzled, shocked, startled victim of controlling, abusive and intimidating relatives. Most parents I know find parenting hard enough and now we’re not even allowed to ask children nicely to behave themselves? Okie doke then…

The child didn’t throw pizza onto the floor. Did you struggle to read the op? He was trying to pass it to his aunt, who wanted her own son to have more, and accidentally dropped.

And the first person rushing was the aunt. Perhaps if she hadn’t rushed to conclusions and tried to bluster in deciding who should get what without the appropriate information, he wouldn’t have dropped it. Maybe she needs to not rush in without actually knowing anything.

LateAF · 04/01/2023 12:13

Which bit’s the lecture?

She made a mildly annoying comment if there’s a backstory, a non-issue without a backstory. But there doesn’t appear to be any lecture given to your son by your sister.

Kanaloa · 04/01/2023 12:12

I think the thing is that it wasn’t really about rushing though. She likely felt annoyed because op picked her up on the unfairness of her jumping in to tell the boy he couldn’t have the pizza because she wanted her son to have more, and insisted it ‘wasn’t relevant.’ She wanted to tell him off for taking the pizza, realized she couldn’t because she’d been in the wrong, so moaned about him ‘rushing.’ She basically ended up looking quite stupid because it had been pointed out that she was incorrect and didn’t know the full information, so blistered in about something else.

Really, op should have said ‘you’re always jumping to conclusions without the full information. Maybe in future you should not jump to conclusions - if you hadn’t been rushing you would have had the fill information and would have known the pizza slice was not just for John.’

arethereanyleftatall · 04/01/2023 12:10

Yanbu, I know exactly the type of parenting, well over parenting, you're describing and not only is it irritating, I don't think it does the child any long term favours.
And it's so hard to articulate it to that parent because, as can be seen from this thread, that parent is putting loads of effort and never raising their voice, so think they're parenting perfectly.
It doesn't work
It doesn't work because the child doesn't learn to think. I'm sure your child could have worked out that he rushed and thus dropped a bit all by himself. He'll be more careful in future. Save the lectures till they're needed, otherwise they don't get listened to. And to those saying it isn't a lecture, it is, because it's constant.

Chickenly · 04/01/2023 12:02

Newmum0322 · 04/01/2023 12:00

😂 this!!

Username checks out 😂🤣

Chickenly · 04/01/2023 12:02

I’m beginning to see why I keep getting comments that my very normal 3yo is very well behaved everywhere we go. Apparently politely asking a child, without shouting or raising your voice, to not rush after throwing pizza onto the floor means that the child is a poor, frazzled, shocked, startled victim of controlling, abusive and intimidating relatives. Most parents I know find parenting hard enough and now we’re not even allowed to ask children nicely to behave themselves? Okie doke then…

Newmum0322 · 04/01/2023 12:00

Holly60 · 04/01/2023 09:02

It would wind me up too. Everyone knows why he dropped it, it doesn't need pointing out.

Plus if you wanted to get into it, you could say he was only rushing because she incorrectly told him he couldn't have it.

The correct response to a child dropping something is 'oopsy daisy. Grab a cloth for me sweetie we'll mop it up'. 😀

😂 this!!

CovertImage · 04/01/2023 11:58

He didn't drop it because he rushed, he dropped it because his aunt startled him.

As soon as she started correcting him again I imagine his heart sank & he felt exposed & clumsy.

Jesus christ. We'll be hearing that he didn't feel "safe" soon

Whowhatwherewhenwhynow · 04/01/2023 11:57

I have a SIL that picks up on every single thing her child did/does. It’s tiring and feels awful. Sounds like your sister does similar. My niece (now an adult)has anxiety and has had periods of self harm. Obviously the causes of that are probably complicated, but I can’t imagine having a constantly highly critical parent, picking up on every mistake you make helps.

As you visit so rarely Incant imagine it would be harmful to your son. However he may well choose to stop visiting when he is older. Because who wants to visit someone who jumps on everything you do.

I’d probably just jump in (verbally) and sort it with my own parent style. “Ooops the pizza fell. Could you pick it up and wipe the floor please”?

SuperSleepyBaby · 04/01/2023 11:56

Your sister sounds annoying and overly serious

ZeroFuchsGiven · 04/01/2023 11:52

KettrickenSmiled · 04/01/2023 11:40

He's startled by her because this is not the only incident of her being unfair, hectoring, & more concerned with her rules than a child's feelings.

If you'd ever had an adult like that in your life when you were a child, you'd understand that it makes the child nervous, watchful & flustered.

Get a grip ffs.

It is stated in the opening post they all get on well, Her Sister doesnt raise her voice and what she says is generally fair.

Its honestly no wonder the world is turning into a weird place where resilience is becoming obsolete.

She literally done nothing but tell him not to rush, there was no bullying, no controlling, no unfairness or hectoring. The words used on this thread are ridiculous.

BabyOnBoard90 · 04/01/2023 11:51

People are so sensitive and easily offended these days.

YABU

KettrickenSmiled · 04/01/2023 11:40

ZeroFuchsGiven · 04/01/2023 11:15

I dont understand the 'its her fault he was flustered' responses tbh, What on earth was there to be flustered about? Also in the op about him being 'startled' as she walked towards him, what is startling about someone walking towards You? Confused

He's startled by her because this is not the only incident of her being unfair, hectoring, & more concerned with her rules than a child's feelings.

If you'd ever had an adult like that in your life when you were a child, you'd understand that it makes the child nervous, watchful & flustered.

mbosnz · 04/01/2023 11:38

When my nieces and nephews were kids, if my sister wasn't there (i.e, I was in loco parentis), I'd say something. If she was there, then I wouldn't. And I'd bite my tongue at her droning a lecture at her children for every little thing.

If I weren't there, I'd expect my sister to say something, if my kid were doing something really rather wrong - something that could harm others, or themselves, anything else,possibly utter a brief opinion on, if asked (realistically I'd expect her to go on and on as she normally would with her kids). If I were there, I'd expect my sister to shut the hell up and do the courtesy of allowing me to set the rules and enforce the rules with my child in my house.

KettrickenSmiled · 04/01/2023 11:32

I knew John already had a slice and my son also only had once slice. So I asked why was it John's as they both had a slice so maybe they could have shared it? She said I don't who had what and that is irrelevant here. He was rushing so dropped it which is strictly true.

It's not true, strictly or otherwise.
He didn't drop it because he rushed, he dropped it because his aunt startled him.

As soon as she started correcting him again I imagine his heart sank & he felt exposed & clumsy. The way we all do when somebody is obsessively telling us how we are going wrong all the bloody time.

I'd pick your sister up on this in the moment - & I'd be doing it every time. Just a simple "give it a rest, you are droning on again & nobody wants to hear it." I'm amazed that you haven't done so already - does she dominate you, are you scared to put her straight?

MichelleScarn · 04/01/2023 11:24

How is saying no to pizza throwing weight around?!

girlmom21 · 04/01/2023 11:23

@RudsyFarmer she literally told him to stop rushing...

RudsyFarmer · 04/01/2023 11:22

ZeroFuchsGiven · 04/01/2023 09:13

Controlling?

A Bully?

Am I reading a different thread? 😂

Someone who unnecessarily throws their weight around, particularly to someone more vulnerable than themselves is to my mind a bully. Leave the kid alone.

MichelleScarn · 04/01/2023 11:18

ZeroFuchsGiven · 04/01/2023 11:15

I dont understand the 'its her fault he was flustered' responses tbh, What on earth was there to be flustered about? Also in the op about him being 'startled' as she walked towards him, what is startling about someone walking towards You? Confused

It all sounds quite dramatic! Is he not used told 'no' generally? What type of things do you let go?

ZeroFuchsGiven · 04/01/2023 11:15

Chickenly · 04/01/2023 10:23

He asked a question, he shouldn’t be flustered that someone dared to respond to it 😂asking a child not to rush is not discipline either

I dont understand the 'its her fault he was flustered' responses tbh, What on earth was there to be flustered about? Also in the op about him being 'startled' as she walked towards him, what is startling about someone walking towards You? Confused