Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think buying and receiving gifts is just stressful these days

39 replies

AboutTheYoungIdea · 04/01/2023 08:39

Really felt this over Xmas, I appreciate that not everyone is so fortunate but in general nobody ‘needs’ or often wants any of the stuff we exchange over Xmas (or on birthdays).

Many people these days are in the position to just buy what they want. Things that would once have been a treat to receive can now be picked up easily at any time and no longer feel particularly special.

When receiving gifts, I appreciate the thought but very few people know me well enough to choose something I’d really like - and tbh most things I’d really like are more than my friends/family’s budgets (not talking hundreds of £ either).

There’s also the waste aspect - if I’d like eg a pair of silver earrings there are certain styles that suit me and so on but unless I specify exactly which - taking all the fun and surprise out of the gift buying - I end up with something I’m unlikely to wear.

It’s also stressful buying gifts, spending money on things just for the sake of giving ‘something’. I try really hard not to go overboard and choose something thoughtful but it just feels a bit pointless knowing people probably feel like I do. It’s often suggested on here to give consumables but who needs more food hanging round - our office kitchen was full of people’s leftovers yesterday and it’s just wasteful and depressing.

I know this sounds spoilt and ungrateful and it’s really not meant to be but I have a small home and limited budget - it depresses me to spend money on things other people don’t really need or want while receiving things I won’t use and don’t have space for.

AIBU to say that gift giving just doesn’t work any more? Or ask for ideas how to improve it!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Happygirl79 · 23/04/2023 10:38

MeMyBooksAndMyCats · 04/01/2023 10:39

Completely agree.

I also find it quite upsetting when you spend time on trying to find something that someone would like as a present and you do not even get so much as a "thank you" or acknowledgement that they've received it through the post!
I will just be doing dc this Christmas coming. I'm fed up of it.

I think the same. My grown up grandchildren don't feel it's necessary to say thank you either so I will not buy anything else for them from now on

AppleDumplingWithCustard · 05/01/2023 00:49

Ragwort · 04/01/2023 23:14

But Apple how do really know that the recipients of your gifts really love them? I am over 60 and can probably count on one hand the the number of truly great (& I don't mean expensive) presents I have received. Of course I always look pleased and thank people profusely but in most cases it's just not something I would have chosen myself. Like Original you then have the awkward situation of having to wear/use something that is just not quite right.

I had a friend who thought she was a great present giver ... she really wasn't and it got quite embarrassing as she had such an over inflated opinion of herself as being great at choosing gifts Confused.

I buy for only a very small number of people who I know very well and spend lots of time with. I would soon know if they didn’t like their gifts.

Ragwort · 04/01/2023 23:14

But Apple how do really know that the recipients of your gifts really love them? I am over 60 and can probably count on one hand the the number of truly great (& I don't mean expensive) presents I have received. Of course I always look pleased and thank people profusely but in most cases it's just not something I would have chosen myself. Like Original you then have the awkward situation of having to wear/use something that is just not quite right.

I had a friend who thought she was a great present giver ... she really wasn't and it got quite embarrassing as she had such an over inflated opinion of herself as being great at choosing gifts Confused.

OriginalUsername2 · 04/01/2023 19:04

Completely agree and have felt that way for years! This year was the first year there was nothing to unwrap. The kids got digital gifts, none of us adults did presents at all.

I don’t like receiving presents either!I don’t like the “having to emote” (these reactions I swear we all just copy from each other!) and I keep telling people over the years that I don’t like “things”. I am really minimalist with my (carefully chosen!) belongings.

A friend sent me a themed tshirt she thought I would like randomly in the year and it gave me a lot of anxiety. Let’s say I have a random cup with in the house with a cheesy pop star on it and she’s got me an expensive tshirt with the same pop star on it, saying she saw it and just had to.

I hate it. hate themed t-shirts, I’m not actually, really a fan of the person, and the design is just hideous.

All this gift did for me is make me feel a bit like a child who’s been given an ugly dress, give me guilt over the money spent, make me feel like an asshole for being ungrateful for a gift, put me in a position where I had to be a complete fake and send a gushy thank-you message and make me have to keep a horrible item in case it’s mentioned one day in person.

AppleDumplingWithCustard · 04/01/2023 18:26

I love buying gifts. I put a lot of thought into the gifts I buy and enjoy the recipients getting pleasure from them.

LoobyDop · 04/01/2023 18:23

So instead of seeing something I want, thinking carefully about whether I need it, have room for it and can justify the cost, and then buying it at the point in time I want it, I have to do all that research and thought, wait until the right time before Christmas, communicate it to loved ones in a way that isn’t confusing or demanding, find an alternative because it went out of stock months ago, negotiate three-way plans for it to be delivered… how is that in any way not just adding unnecessary difficulty to the entire process?

Fairislefandango · 04/01/2023 18:13

People on MN seem full of angst around presents but I honestly never experience that in real life.

Same here. It seems we're in a minority! My family do wishlists. Fairly specific ones for the children in the family, compiled by their parents. More generic, less specific ones from the adults, so that quite a bit of personal choice remains for the gift-giver. Nobody gets things they don't want. Nobody is getting stressed out trying to think what to get. It's pretty easy tbh.

LoobyDop · 04/01/2023 18:06

I’ve got about six wooden chopping boards, most of which were presents. All lovely, each very useful. How many do I have to gratefully accept before I can say I’ve got more wooden chopping boards than I can reasonably store or use?

I couldn’t agree more with the OP. We moved house recently and while packing I realised that I have an entire chest of drawers filled with presents from my family and inlaws. It’s all nice stuff, carefully selected. Candles, stationery, purses, gloves, toiletries… I don’t need or want any of it, I just keep it all out of guilt, until one day soon I’ll get sick of it and bin it all and then feel guilty about the landfill. And I know that they run themselves ragged every year racing round buying more of this shit that nobody needs and be too busy and stressed to enjoy Christmas.

It’s a situation that very much reminds me of Caitlin Moran’s rule that you should always ask “are the men doing this? And if not, why not?” And the answer is, no, they aren’t. Men don’t buy each other presents, they just go for a pint instead. Which is affordable, non-wasteful, supports a local business, and is stress-free and genuinely makes both of them happy. We need to stop piling this stupid guilt on each other, it’s just a ridiculous self-perpetuating cycle.

Boombaker · 04/01/2023 17:52

I'm not that surprised at the chopping board, most people who want a chopping board would already have a chopping board so it's either throw the one you have away (wasteful) or donate the brand new one. Unless you want to have 2 hanging round. Yes it's personalised but hopefully less wasteful to donate that one, someone might buy it.

Porcinimushroom · 04/01/2023 15:52

I really don't understand the example given up thread by the person who work in a charity shop - being donated a wooden chopping board with a personalised name - why would anyone donate that

I was very surprised by that too. I was given, a few years back, a personalised wooden cheeseboard set. I use it often, either for nice dinners at home or when I have guests. I can’t imagine giving away a chopping board like that.

Porcinimushroom · 04/01/2023 15:48

I’d also add, I agree with a pp if you’re not close enough to know what they want or would like then you shouldn’t be buying gifts.

for one of my friends this year I bought her cashmere socks and a body lotion to go with her favourite perfume. She got me silky shorts pyjamas as she knows I wear short,pjs to bed. For another friend I bought a book by her fave author that I know she doesn’t have and a large woollen scarf in her colours, she got me my fave diptyque candle.

if you don’t know the person well enough, you shouldn’t be buying them gifts. And vice Versa. It’s an exercise in futility, lip service being paid for etiquette reasons and nothing more. And that’s not what gift giving should be.

and that’s what it sounds like for you, giving folks you don’t know very well random gifts and them you for the sake of it. And if that’s the case, knock it on the head.

Boombaker · 04/01/2023 15:47

Completely agree. We don't exchange with adults in the family, just buy for children. We're all capable of buying what we like but even if it was the case that we weren't in that position I'd rather people spend their hard earned cash on themselves or their own families than buy me a gift. It's all so wasteful and the amount of "stuff" associated with Christmas gets me down, there is too much stuff in the world.

I don't want more 'stuff' to have it hanging round until the next school fair so it can be donated and hang around the next person's house and on and on. Just stop with all the stuff! I have a friend who insists on buying us biscuits because 'they have to give something'. I don't want more biscuits! And the tin goes in the recycling, I've no space for random tins. Waste! (And calories!). Its lovely just to be with people over Christmas, eat and drink together and play games, make time for each other which doesn't tend to happen for the rest of the year, that's the best Christmas gift.

Itemremovedfromthebaggingarea · 04/01/2023 15:26

Completely agree.
A lot of gift giving just feels unnecessary, transactional and box ticking.

luckylavender · 04/01/2023 15:22

I don't find it stressful, no. But if I did, I wouldn't be doing it.

NegroniLover · 04/01/2023 15:20

I understand the sentiment when it comes to buying for wider family/ acquaintances etc. In these cases it's 'generic' gifts & I'm not a fan.
We gave up buying & receiving these years ago thankfully although if we're seeing friends over the hols we'd always bring flowers / wine / chocolates & perhaps a tin of fancy biscuits etc but we do that anyway if we're invited to someone's house.

We do chriskindle on dh's side so each adult buys & receives 1 gift to a specified value. Dh ALWAYS ensures he buys something lovely to that exact value however his siblings don't & each year he's received something of far less value. The principle annoys me but it's his family & I just leave him.to it. I'm not part of the process anyway as they just buy something for him as opposed to for us a a couple. Suits me.

I always receive very very lovely gifts from dh. He's very generous & thoughtful. And we love to surprise each other. We listen intently to things the other might mention in passing & squirrel that info away till its needed. Yes we could buy the same stuff ourselves but our presents to each other are usually on the more luxurious side so they're not usually things we just randomly buy. I received very expensive perfume & a beautiful bag this year.

We love buying for teen dd & we discuss what to get her & again we listen & take note of things she mentions during the year. She doesn't have an income & it's nice to spoil her with some luxuries.

Generic gifts we receive seem to be mostly alcohol or candles & we always use both up.

I have never given an unwanted gift to a charity shop in my life (we have of course donated other things) & I really don't understand the example given up thread by the person who work in a charity shop - being donated a wooden chopping board with a personalised name - why would anyone donate that? It's something that can be used & is practical & it seems like a v churlish thing to do to give it away immediately after Christmas. I blame the donater not the giver in that instance.

People on MN seem full of angst around presents but I honestly never experience that in real life

amusedbush · 04/01/2023 15:16

AboutTheYoungIdea · 04/01/2023 14:10

I'd love to do a Secret Santa/wishlist type of thing, that way everyone has the fun of giving but people still get something they'd like. But my family wont consider it 🙄

I feel exactly the same as you do about gifts and was happy when a family member suggested Secret Santa this year. However, out of about 20 people involved, I was the only one who ended up kind of stiffed.

DH and I have a long-standing agreement that I sort gifts for my family and he sorts his family. So I chose thoughtful gifts (which appeared to be well received) for the people he and I pulled out of the hat, and DH was given a lovely, personal present that he really likes. I opened mine and it was a voucher for a food delivery service, which I’m obviously going to end up sharing because I don’t order takeaway by myself Xmas Hmm

I just can’t be arsed with any of it and would rather people saved their money!

healthadvice123 · 04/01/2023 15:01

Some of my extended family within their family group incl older neice and nephews just do a £50 secret santa and they write a list of things they may like and that works well
Everyone sends x anount and get something they want or need

healthadvice123 · 04/01/2023 14:59

Only adults we buy is parents and my brother and wife we do a token gift no more than £10 so may be some nice bubble bath or a bottle drink they like etc
No other sublings or aunts and uncles
Some neices / nephews are technically adults but still living at home , uni etc so just do a gift voucher but will stop when they become a little older
Dh & I have not bought each other gifts for most years occasional times if money has been better and something we want, birthdays we spend on nice meal out or something

Porcinimushroom · 04/01/2023 14:53

I don’t find it a waste, I love buying gifts for friends and family and I love the fact people go to an effort to buy me gifts, it is not about the what it is about the thought.

for my husband and daughter I ask explicitly what they wish and I buy it, they are still delighted to receive it. For friends and wider family it’s about the thought of giving and same back

AboutTheYoungIdea · 04/01/2023 14:10

I'd love to do a Secret Santa/wishlist type of thing, that way everyone has the fun of giving but people still get something they'd like. But my family wont consider it 🙄

OP posts:
BigMadAdrian · 04/01/2023 14:08

I completely agree. I find it quite stressful when all the texts from family start coming in November 'what can we get the dc for Christmas?' when they really don't want anything. People end up buying stuff for the sake of it. I sometimes randomly buy things that I see and think someone might like - but shoehorning into a particular time of year is much harder and ends up feeling a bit transactional.

Sparklesocks · 04/01/2023 14:01

We do secret Santa with the adults in my family for about £30-35, we use an online draw thing where you can add wish lists or ideas so everyone gets a nice gift and there’s no faffing trying to sort everyone and nobody takes home loads of excess stuff they don’t want/need. Works quite well.

Fuwari · 04/01/2023 13:54

I said this on another thread but it's only waste if its not something the person wants. I don't want alcohol or chocolate as I'm trying to give up drinking and I so rarely eat any chocolate, so that type of gift is wasted on me.

Mostly gift buying is limited to myself and adult DC. They know me well enough to know what gifts I'll love and vice versa. We all have lots of hobbies which is a good source for gift buying. I think if you're not close enough to know what someone will appreciate, you're probably not close enough for gift buying! I don't agree with buying something just for the sake of it. I'm with you on that.

AboutTheYoungIdea · 04/01/2023 11:28

@Fuwari completely get that and sorry you're having a tricky time. You're right that it's a fortunate position to be in although I'm far from loaded but even if I was I'd still hate the waste and unnecessary spending - fair enough if it's what people want but I often dont think they do.

OP posts:
TeddyTrucks · 04/01/2023 11:28

Having spent hundreds of pounds that I could ill afford on my nephew and niece's birthday/Christmas/christening presents, then when I had my own children my brother suddenly thinks it's a great idea to ditch presents altogether, I am 100% with you.