Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If the Tories are responsible for the failing NHS, why is the picture no better in Wales under Labour?

131 replies

Namechanged2023 · 04/01/2023 08:16

I have never voted Tory, never will. I don’t support anything they stand for.

But I don’t buy this narrative.

The NHS has been rubbish for years. I work in a different public service, that is also rubbish. Too many people talking instead of doing, no performance management, too much leeway with full paid sick leave.

I’ve had mixed experience of the NHS like most. Some excellent staff who want to help and save time, some of the same role who do things completely differently, in a much more time consuming and resource intensive way (think simple tasks like administering antibiotics to a small baby). Some really empathetic, compassionate staff; some the complete opposite. Proactive GPs, and some who refuse to budge.

Their processes are just ridiculous though. I have waited hours to be discharged. Everything has to be done on paper. Letters sent out for everything. Phone lines only open for 2 hours on 3 days a week, so impossible to get through.

OP posts:
DerangedViper · 23/01/2023 17:58

Justaboutalive · 23/01/2023 17:55

I’m fairly certain the devolved nations have tax raising powers and could raise tax. Also, the funding is given over health, education…….. so maybe cancel the free university places and free prescriptions to pay higher nhs salaries.

I actually think prescriptions and education should be paid for, but it is always about competing choices.

Yes, health is devolved, and the situation in Wales in particular has been dire for rather longer. I think its pretty parlous in Scotland too

Hbh17 · 23/01/2023 17:58

Because the problems in the NHS are intrinsic to its flawed and outdated structure, and absolutely nothing to do with party politics. So many people who have worked in the NHS for the last 20 or 30 years would say the same.

Justaboutalive · 23/01/2023 17:55

BHRK · 04/01/2023 16:02

Because the UK Government sets the funding, sets the workforce plan to grow the number of staff, mostly sets salaries?

I’m fairly certain the devolved nations have tax raising powers and could raise tax. Also, the funding is given over health, education…….. so maybe cancel the free university places and free prescriptions to pay higher nhs salaries.

I actually think prescriptions and education should be paid for, but it is always about competing choices.

BHRK · 04/01/2023 16:02

Because the UK Government sets the funding, sets the workforce plan to grow the number of staff, mostly sets salaries?

MarshaBradyo · 04/01/2023 16:00

Agree with majority yanbu.

potniatheron · 04/01/2023 15:58

GPTec1 · 04/01/2023 13:55

@potniatheron

I ve either not made the point well or you have missed it.

All what you mention is predicted and can be planned for... by politicians - they set the parameters, advisors will say we will have xx number of older people, xx number of social care staff, politicians can then plan for all of this OR in the case of the UK, not plan for it.

Every country has had to prepare for these challenges and benefits, remember that the NHS had far more beds and staff years ago, medical advances meant shorter or no stays in hospital, far more people can be treated at home too.

Politicians though chose to keep cutting beds and buildings beyond what was safe.

These are political choices - the removal of Bursaries was a choice made by politicians, they were advised at the time not to do this.

This is why we should all have some interest in politics, has so much influence on our daily lives.

Thank you. I guess we both made our points badly :-) as mine doesn't seem to've come across either.

My point was more about the STRUCTURE of the NHS. Parts of it are too centralised. There is too much management. Too many pay bands and no ability to reward according to performance. Very toxic culture with bullying rife IN MY HUMBLE OPINION (I worked in it in South Wales when I lived there). Too much difference in quality by postcode. Very poor and slow procurement practices. Too difficult to get rid of underperforming staff. Few mechanisms for helping staff who are struggling. Too clinically focussed on point of need rather than prevention. Now encompasses too many services. Makes full use of private sector but doesn't maximise their input for best results.

It needs reforming, Blair tried to make it more responsive to performance but as he said, scars on his back. Andrew Lansley tried to decentralise and got pilloried. It should not be free at point of use for wealthy, they should contribute more upfront according to means test (NOT income test). GP as gateway to services no longer working.

I agree that stopping bursaries was bad BUT the real mistake was making nursing a degree requirement. That is when the numbers going in really fell of a cliff. It should not be a degree we should go back to the two year hands on training.

Twiglets1 · 04/01/2023 14:59

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 04/01/2023 11:57

@Twiglets1 you can set out your wishes for treatment etc so for example if I was to get dementia I wouldn’t want treated with antibiotics for every illness going I’d rather just be kept comfortable same goes for if I get cancer at 80 I wouldn’t want investigations or treatment just kept pain free. I will also ensure my family are on board as a lot of the time I’ve come across patients who do not want treatment but are over ruled by family wanting to keep them alive

Thank you, that sounds very sensible.

My 86 year old Dad was diagnosed with advanced prostate cancer last year and he has opted for no invasive treatment (just pain relief when he needs it) and I don't blame him at all. But yes, it's important to get family on board so they know what you want.

Blankscreen · 04/01/2023 14:30

I think the NHS is now so fucked it needs to stop being a political football and there needs to be an urgent cross party independent task force set up.

Scoring point off the back of this mess is not helping.

I heard a couple of weeks back that health planning is usually only done for 5 years. That needs to stop and it needs proper strategic planning for the long game.

NewspaperTaxis · 04/01/2023 14:23

Well, my late mother had advanced Parkinson's, was in several care homes in Surrey, we were self-funding not 'rich' and we got turned over, it seemed they were trying to kill her off via dehydration and if you complain the care home fobs you off and then if you persist accuse you of abuse and intimidation, they get cocky because at that point they'll have got the Council's Social Services involved aka the local mafia.

So don't imagine if you pay for it, you're in the clear. We were paying around a grand a week, week in week out, for the care system to kill her. We were giving up our lives to go in daily to give her drink and barely tolerated by staff - we were lucky they were letting us do it!

You could argue that legally Surrey County Council were allowed to do it because we'd neglected to get LPA in Health and Welfare for her, so once she was deemed to have lost mental capacity - though she wasn't nuts or off her head or anything, just quietened down - they were the decision makers for her care, not us, though we were the ones paying out!

Welcome to Conservative Britain.

ILoveAllRainbowsx · 04/01/2023 14:13

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

socialmedia23 · 04/01/2023 14:09

GPTec1 · 04/01/2023 13:55

@potniatheron

I ve either not made the point well or you have missed it.

All what you mention is predicted and can be planned for... by politicians - they set the parameters, advisors will say we will have xx number of older people, xx number of social care staff, politicians can then plan for all of this OR in the case of the UK, not plan for it.

Every country has had to prepare for these challenges and benefits, remember that the NHS had far more beds and staff years ago, medical advances meant shorter or no stays in hospital, far more people can be treated at home too.

Politicians though chose to keep cutting beds and buildings beyond what was safe.

These are political choices - the removal of Bursaries was a choice made by politicians, they were advised at the time not to do this.

This is why we should all have some interest in politics, has so much influence on our daily lives.

i have had people tell me that it doesn't matter if the NHS fails, they would go private or go overseas. Rich people don't die from lack of healthcare apparently.

Umm.

I think there are just some individualistic people who are so confident in their own abilities that they can't bear to think that we all function as a society and sometimes we are only as strong as our weakest link. They want to believe they are masters of their own destiny.

Blossomtoes · 04/01/2023 14:00

edenhills · 04/01/2023 08:38

Wow the Tories are getting desperate this morning 😂

Aren’t they just? It’s hardly plausible to blame Labour when they’ve had nearly 13 years to improve it.

GPTec1 · 04/01/2023 13:55

@potniatheron

I ve either not made the point well or you have missed it.

All what you mention is predicted and can be planned for... by politicians - they set the parameters, advisors will say we will have xx number of older people, xx number of social care staff, politicians can then plan for all of this OR in the case of the UK, not plan for it.

Every country has had to prepare for these challenges and benefits, remember that the NHS had far more beds and staff years ago, medical advances meant shorter or no stays in hospital, far more people can be treated at home too.

Politicians though chose to keep cutting beds and buildings beyond what was safe.

These are political choices - the removal of Bursaries was a choice made by politicians, they were advised at the time not to do this.

This is why we should all have some interest in politics, has so much influence on our daily lives.

potniatheron · 04/01/2023 13:44

GPTec1 · 04/01/2023 13:01

What it’s also fair to say is that we’re not going to solve the problem with party politics

See, i really don't get this.. Politics is exactly why services are good or bad, nothing else really matters.

Politics decides when and where to build a hospital, to remove or reinstate bursaries, to fund social care or not.

Why else is there a dept of health, a minister an NHS budget?

The current Tory party believes in the market, small state, private enterprise good, public sector bad.

These beliefs are not compatible with a free at the point of use, Health Service.

That is way overslimplifying when it comes to healthcare systems. Demographics and medical advances are just as influential as party politics.

the NHS was set up to replace the old community cooperatives with the idea that everyone puts in a little bit so they can have free care at the point of urgent need eg broken arm, pneumonia, cancer. Long term care was still carried out by families or not done at all. Mental health was not covered.

Fast forward 80 years and we have a population that's 20 million larger than it was back then, each individual living 20 - 30 years longer, medical advances meaning that severely disabled people can live much longer with very advanced and expensive care, and the needs very different pivoting towards more long term treatment than spot treatment at point of need. Medical advances leading to very innovative but extremely expensive treatments. Patients becoming more like consumers in their attitudes, wanting choice and empowerment. Way more actionable diagnoses and prescribable drugs than we had back then.

The system was set up for a very different reality and it has been becoming less and less fir for purpose since the mid 80s. We need a new system.

GPTec1 · 04/01/2023 13:01

What it’s also fair to say is that we’re not going to solve the problem with party politics

See, i really don't get this.. Politics is exactly why services are good or bad, nothing else really matters.

Politics decides when and where to build a hospital, to remove or reinstate bursaries, to fund social care or not.

Why else is there a dept of health, a minister an NHS budget?

The current Tory party believes in the market, small state, private enterprise good, public sector bad.

These beliefs are not compatible with a free at the point of use, Health Service.

socialmedia23 · 04/01/2023 12:48

NewspaperTaxis · 04/01/2023 12:18

It's interesting to learn about how Canada's NHS-style model is as bad as the UK's because when the hours advance on my Twitter feed and Canadians log on I get a lot of Tweets about how awful and genocidal Canadian care homes are with the elderly, just like over here frankly. It seems they run folk into the ground to cut costs. That seems to be the case here in my experience, deaths of the elderly and vulnerable simply save money on pensions and prescriptions as well as making for a nice inheritance tax.

But for thinking it would be better under Labour, well, it's a bit of a myth to think that MPs are that powerful - State-led forces and beyond are the real power. It's hard to get stories about how awful Surrey County Council are in the local press, I think they can nobble local advertising for private healthcare so the paper suffers financially. They're all in cahoots.
The Tories' USP is low taxation, they're kind of the Ryanair Government, it's run on the cheap, no frills. And a good many like that, it's only if you come a cropper you may think, right, I'm never flying Ryanair again! They've treated me appallingly! But for whole swathes of passengers, it doesn't affect them, they get cheap bookings and arrive on time, so their custom continues.
Ditto with the Tories, after seeing what Mum went through in seven Surrey care homes and the way Surrey County Council and my local MP Chris Grayling behaved, I'll never vote Conservative again. But that's just me, one voter, and Grayling has a safe seat, so they can afford to throw us under a bus and dispense with my vote. It's ruthlessly efficient.

Thing is, after 10 years a heck of a lot of people are now in that category of having found out how bad things can be, it's catching up with them. But that's okay, the Tory ministers had their hands in the cookie jar long enough.

This concerns house prices but look at the column comparing wages in 2010 vs 2020. The UK has had barely any wage growth. This is the real elephant in the room- as NHS is funded by taxes, low wages automatically mean less money for the NHS since tax is progressive... Even if there is waste in the NHS, we cannot pretend that universal healthcare is a cheap endeavour. It isn't, which is why countries with High quality universal healthcare are almost universally wealthy countries.

This is the Tories' greatest failing- how can you claim to be good for the economy if we had near zero economic growth for the past 10 years and stagnant wages? What is the point of voting Tory if they aren't even good at the economy? I think many people may not mind low taxes/substandard public services as much if they had more social mobility (so could pay to go private etc), but if you have neither, you are in a pickle.

Cos Labour would be worse? That is a terrible argument and I think most people know it.

If the Tories are responsible for the failing NHS, why is the picture no better in Wales under Labour?
MyGrandmaLizzie · 04/01/2023 12:29

Just trying to distract us from the state of the NHS and the other public sector strikes and the cost of living.
Also there's a shortage of math teachers.
Just fiddling while Rome burns. The Tories are out of ideas and should F off into oblivion. They have screwed up big time over the last 12 years. The

Suedomin · 04/01/2023 12:23

The overall funding pot still comes from Westminster if funding is not adequate then of course there will be issues.
Also Brexit resulted in many EU nursers and care workers leaving and/ or being unwilling to come to the UK. We have a huge shortage of staff and there is nothing Wales or Scotland can do about that.

NewspaperTaxis · 04/01/2023 12:18

It's interesting to learn about how Canada's NHS-style model is as bad as the UK's because when the hours advance on my Twitter feed and Canadians log on I get a lot of Tweets about how awful and genocidal Canadian care homes are with the elderly, just like over here frankly. It seems they run folk into the ground to cut costs. That seems to be the case here in my experience, deaths of the elderly and vulnerable simply save money on pensions and prescriptions as well as making for a nice inheritance tax.

But for thinking it would be better under Labour, well, it's a bit of a myth to think that MPs are that powerful - State-led forces and beyond are the real power. It's hard to get stories about how awful Surrey County Council are in the local press, I think they can nobble local advertising for private healthcare so the paper suffers financially. They're all in cahoots.
The Tories' USP is low taxation, they're kind of the Ryanair Government, it's run on the cheap, no frills. And a good many like that, it's only if you come a cropper you may think, right, I'm never flying Ryanair again! They've treated me appallingly! But for whole swathes of passengers, it doesn't affect them, they get cheap bookings and arrive on time, so their custom continues.
Ditto with the Tories, after seeing what Mum went through in seven Surrey care homes and the way Surrey County Council and my local MP Chris Grayling behaved, I'll never vote Conservative again. But that's just me, one voter, and Grayling has a safe seat, so they can afford to throw us under a bus and dispense with my vote. It's ruthlessly efficient.

Thing is, after 10 years a heck of a lot of people are now in that category of having found out how bad things can be, it's catching up with them. But that's okay, the Tory ministers had their hands in the cookie jar long enough.

picklemewalnuts · 04/01/2023 12:13

I'm looking at a relative who's spending all his savings so he won't have to pay for care. He's refusing care which he needs because he doesn't want to pay for it. He's in and out of hospital like a shuttle, and they discharge him somewhat casually because they know he'll be back soon (I was there, I saw them rattle through the changes to his meds there was no way he'd remember.).

He's had ambulances and week+ long visits several times since I last saw him there in October.

There's no way the system can function like that. My mum will likely go the same way. She's currently got her heating set at 10 degrees despite being extremely wealthy. Stubborn and feisty.

MiL is back and forth to the GP, taking FiL because he's slowing down and she wants him fixed. She's investigated- and diagnosed with- more conditions than I can list. Some of them should have meant she was no longer with us by now. Honestly it's beyond remotely sustainable.

When I see someone being sensible in their declining years, I'm sadly shocked.

Willyoujustbequiet · 04/01/2023 12:11

GPTec1 · 04/01/2023 08:55

Wales isn't a separate country, can't control its borders, its own immigration policies or reverse Brexit.
Yes can raise some taxes but with no other controls on fiscal policy i.e raise lower interest rates or have its own central bank and currency, how would that work?

We are one UK and Governed as such.

We should make comparisons with other European countries, that the Tories wont do that is very telling.

The NHS used to work, might not have been brilliant but no one waited days for an ambulance or died waiting outside AE because there was no staff to treat them.

We ve had 12 years of the Conservatives, if its not on them, what exactly is the point of a Government or even another General Election?

This.

It stil all comes down to the Tories.

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 04/01/2023 11:57

@Twiglets1 you can set out your wishes for treatment etc so for example if I was to get dementia I wouldn’t want treated with antibiotics for every illness going I’d rather just be kept comfortable same goes for if I get cancer at 80 I wouldn’t want investigations or treatment just kept pain free. I will also ensure my family are on board as a lot of the time I’ve come across patients who do not want treatment but are over ruled by family wanting to keep them alive

socialmedia23 · 04/01/2023 11:51

ComtesseDeSpair · 04/01/2023 11:45

By any measure, the NHS is in a far worse situation than any other comparable economy in Europe.

The Commonwealth Fund ranked the UK 4th in its 2021 study of 11 countries (UK, Canada, US, France, Germany, Netherlands, Norway, Switzerland, New Zealand, Sweden) and placed it in first place for five years prior to that. The Legatum Index placed it 10th last year - below the Scandinavian countries, Germany, New Zealand and Ireland, but above Canada, France, Australia, Belgium, Spain and South Korea. The WHO however currently places South Korea top of the list and the UK and France don’t even feature. Go figure.

So it’s probably fair to say that a) it’s not an easy question to answer and b) performance ratings and statistical studies apparently aren’t reflective of anecdotes and people’s experiences on the ground.

What it’s also fair to say is that we’re not going to solve the problem with party politics.

NHS scores very highly for access to healthcare. if you think about it, its pretty marvelous. You do not need to have paid a penny in NI or tax to access it. My American BIL calls the Israeli healthcare system single payer (it is similar to the German model- universal healthcare insurance which is deducted as a percentage of salaries but with private health insurance being a major player too). But in reality it is a hybrid insurance model and while it may mean that everyone by default gets access to healthcare, it is not single payer and 100% funded by the state the way it is in the UK.

ComtesseDeSpair · 04/01/2023 11:50

what countries would you say are coping well?

If your measure is simply consumer satisfaction then I believe the OECD data points to Sweden, Norway, New Zealand and Denmark. As per my post above though, if the measure is broadened and includes a wide range of other statistics, your mileage varies.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 04/01/2023 11:49

edenhills · 04/01/2023 08:38

Wow the Tories are getting desperate this morning 😂

Thank you for your well reasoned contribution to the argument