Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask why there are such conflicting views on how we perceive young people and children on here.

54 replies

pillow56 · 04/01/2023 07:42

When an adult raises a voice to a child on mn it's seen as very wrong and traumatising for the child and by child I mean anybody under 18.

Yet mn seems to have a view that any child over 15 (and even 14 in some cases) it's fine for them to drink, stay out as late as they want or have sex/share bed with boyfriends and gfs. The thinking seems to be as they are mature enough at that age and parents who want to enforce rules and boundaries often get roasted as at 15/16 they can stay out all night if they want apparently and many here condone teen holidays abroad at that age with no parents as the thinking goes they have the maturity anyway and parents should back off...

On the other hand though if any adult in their mid 20s and up is dating a 17-21 yo it's seen as highly inappropriate as the 20yo is still a child, vulnerable and shouldn't be dating a 26 yo.

Can I ask why there is such a disparity on how we view our youth here?

OP posts:
LolaSmiles · 04/01/2023 07:49

A lot depends on the topic at hand.

A 16/17 year old is mature enough, in my opinion, to be allowed to drink alcohol in certain circumstances.

If a 21/22 year old was dating a 16 year old then I'd argue that's not appropriate as there's a maturity gap between a child in Year 11/12 and an adult.

A 20 year old woman in a relationship with a 34 year old man are likely to be in different places and my concern would be a man in his 30s is hoping to settle down with kids at the very time a 20 year old could be building their own career and financial security.

Relationship dynamics matter because get it wrong and we are sending teens and young adults into relationships with an increased risk of unequal power dynamics due to the age difference. Some people will always say "I met DH when I was 17 and he was 27 and we are happily married with 4 kids", and it's good it worked for them, but it's not something I'd promote for my children.

heldinadream · 04/01/2023 07:48

Anyone can post on mumsnet. Unless previously banned (and even then they slip through sometimes). Literally anyone. It's not some tiny cohesive community. It's the world. Full of views, diverse, conflicting, thoughtful, ludicrous, sensible, bonkers, mature and childish. 'Mumsnet' does not 'have a view'.

Flatandhappy · 04/01/2023 07:48

I think most people just give a gut reaction to the question asked so you get wildly different views.

upfucked · 04/01/2023 07:44

There are literally millions of users of MN. There will be some who agree with the above and some who don’t. As within In group this large there won’t be a consensus.

Swipe left for the next trending thread