Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask why there are such conflicting views on how we perceive young people and children on here.

54 replies

pillow56 · 04/01/2023 07:42

When an adult raises a voice to a child on mn it's seen as very wrong and traumatising for the child and by child I mean anybody under 18.

Yet mn seems to have a view that any child over 15 (and even 14 in some cases) it's fine for them to drink, stay out as late as they want or have sex/share bed with boyfriends and gfs. The thinking seems to be as they are mature enough at that age and parents who want to enforce rules and boundaries often get roasted as at 15/16 they can stay out all night if they want apparently and many here condone teen holidays abroad at that age with no parents as the thinking goes they have the maturity anyway and parents should back off...

On the other hand though if any adult in their mid 20s and up is dating a 17-21 yo it's seen as highly inappropriate as the 20yo is still a child, vulnerable and shouldn't be dating a 26 yo.

Can I ask why there is such a disparity on how we view our youth here?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Anisina · 04/01/2023 17:56

lightand · 04/01/2023 14:00

People are pushing a woke agenda.

Now we know people on MN and elsewhere on social media, push the Meghan agenda, it doesnt take much of a leap to assume there are posters on MN who push all sorts.

Eh?

girlmom21 · 04/01/2023 14:40

lightand · 04/01/2023 14:00

People are pushing a woke agenda.

Now we know people on MN and elsewhere on social media, push the Meghan agenda, it doesnt take much of a leap to assume there are posters on MN who push all sorts.

You ok?

3WildOnes · 04/01/2023 14:17

I think most people are somewhere in the middle. I wouldn't be letting my 14 or 15 year old stay out all night drinking but once they are 16 and have finished their GCSEs then they can go on holidays and to festivals with friends.
Likewise I won't allow them to have sex in my house under 16 but I would probably allow it over 16.

longestlurkerever · 04/01/2023 14:03

I think you're conflating loads of issues there OP. Sharing beds raises totally different issues from staying out all night. And 15 and 16 raise different issues too as one is below the age of consent and one is the age where you can legally get married and have a child of your own. I do think you have a point though that there's a difference between accepting that ultimately if your teen is determined to flout your rules there's not an awful lot you can do and shrugging off as pointless any notion of boundaries. I don't really recognise the MN consensus against boundaries that you describe though.

lightand · 04/01/2023 14:00

People are pushing a woke agenda.

Now we know people on MN and elsewhere on social media, push the Meghan agenda, it doesnt take much of a leap to assume there are posters on MN who push all sorts.

GeneticallyModifiedGrump · 04/01/2023 13:58

I've never had to do this but my point was that there is a consensus on many mn threads that 15-17 yos can stay out all night if they want to and it's controlling for a parent to demand them home at a certain time
Well I've not noticed this OP, it's mostly parents trying to work out how much freedom to give their kids ie asking if posters would let kids attend certain parties etc. Its mostly just asking for opinions (like we would have done with a network of friends and family years ago but now we've moved online)
Sharing beds with boyfriends/girlfriends is down to the individuals involved, of course some people will say never under my roof even if their children are married! Most 14 year olds are not sleeping with their partner in my experience but you will always have some that do, I don't think it's necessarily wrong to assume they are safer doing it at home than sneaking around doing it. The outcome will be the same, they are still going to have sex if that's what they want!

BabyOnBoard90 · 04/01/2023 13:28

Crazies have a more a voice here

girlmom21 · 04/01/2023 13:26

pillow56 · 04/01/2023 13:25

Your OP said nothing about kids staying out all night

Yes it did ''Yet mn seems to have a view that any child over 15 (and even 14 in some cases) it's fine for them to drink, stay out as late as they want or have sex/share bed with boyfriends and gfs''

Staying out late is different to staying out all night.

Staying out late is fine if there's communication.
All of this is about respect and communication

pillow56 · 04/01/2023 13:25

Your OP said nothing about kids staying out all night

Yes it did ''Yet mn seems to have a view that any child over 15 (and even 14 in some cases) it's fine for them to drink, stay out as late as they want or have sex/share bed with boyfriends and gfs''

OP posts:
BiasedBinding · 04/01/2023 13:23

“I've never had to do this but my point was that there is a consensus on many mn threads that 15-17 yos can stay out all night if they want to and it's controlling for a parent to demand them home at a certain time”

I have never never seen this as a “consensus”. Different opinions on different individual situations perhaps, but the consensus you describe - no. And I have been on MN a long long time.

pillow56 · 04/01/2023 13:21

I am by no means soft on my children OP and they are very well behaved however I don't do this by controlling their social interactions (to the extent that you seem to feel is acceptable). I know who there friends are and where they are going/what time they will be home...this works as the kids respect me and understand I have a reason for wanting to know. I have never had to threaten to call the police to get them home on time, Is this something you have actually told your children you would do

I've never had to do this but my point was that there is a consensus on many mn threads that 15-17 yos can stay out all night if they want to and it's controlling for a parent to demand them home at a certain time

You still sound controlling (to me) and overly disciplinarian

for not thinking it's appropriate to have 15-17 yo having sex in my house. Or for not allowing a 15 yo to stay out all night...

OP posts:
girlmom21 · 04/01/2023 13:20

pillow56 · 04/01/2023 12:48

You can't suddenly give them a load of freedom at 18 and expect them to behave like adults if they've never been allowed to before. We need to prepare them for adulthood gradually

letting a 16 yo stay out all night and have no idea where they are etc isn't a ''prepare them for adulthood gradually'' though. It's irresponsible yet many on mn say it's no problem.
I'll be told I'm being unreasonable here but if there was a news story about a 15 yo dying of alcohol poisoning at 6 in the morning after an all night bender mn be up on arms blaming the parents, saying their kid would never have the chance to be out that that time etc...
Likewise if a 19 yo brought home a 25 yo boyfriend on mn it's seen as outrageous as they are still a kid etc.

Your OP said nothing about kids staying out all night.

GeneticallyModifiedGrump · 04/01/2023 13:16

I am by no means soft on my children OP and they are very well behaved however I don't do this by controlling their social interactions (to the extent that you seem to feel is acceptable). I know who there friends are and where they are going/what time they will be home...this works as the kids respect me and understand I have a reason for wanting to know. I have never had to threaten to call the police to get them home on time, Is this something you have actually told your children you would do?
You still sound controlling (to me) and overly disciplinarian, as I mentioned before my mother was exactly the same with me and ages 18-20 were tricky for me as I really enjoyed my new freedom and definitely made the most of it without the background knowledge of how to behave in more adult situations/company.

SirenSays · 04/01/2023 13:16

I've never seen a thread where every poster was completely happy letting a 15 year old completely vanish for the night.

BiasedBinding · 04/01/2023 13:06

pillow56 · 04/01/2023 12:57

I don't think conservative parents get any particular stick on here, certainly no more than any other type of parent

I've seen alot of threads where the parent is having an adult child return for a holiday with as partner and wishes for there to be separate beds. There appears to be a huge backlash on here against this rather than people having respect for others views. Like it's fine to disagree with it but I've seen ops get flamed more often than not for having these views.

The general consensus appease to be to appease them at every cost and let them do what they want. There also appears to be a massive drama created on mn if a parent/teacher ever raises their voice at a child. Like yes we shouldn't shout constantly at kids but we are all human and kids can push boundaries yet the whole thinking that it will psychologically destroy them is nonsense.

There appears to be a softie softie approach on here and yet then when an op says her friend's kids are out of control the parent is condemned for not being firm enough, being too soft etc.

I don’t see what you see at all on here. There isn’t a consensus. You are an MNer, you are posting here, you are part of the community and contributing to any “consensus” such as there is. It isn’t you vs the rest of MN.

pillow56 · 04/01/2023 12:58

i can imagine the laughter at the police station when the OP calls the police saying my 15 year old wont wash the dishes

I meant staying out all night, think you are being deliberately trolly here.

OP posts:
pillow56 · 04/01/2023 12:57

I don't think conservative parents get any particular stick on here, certainly no more than any other type of parent

I've seen alot of threads where the parent is having an adult child return for a holiday with as partner and wishes for there to be separate beds. There appears to be a huge backlash on here against this rather than people having respect for others views. Like it's fine to disagree with it but I've seen ops get flamed more often than not for having these views.

The general consensus appease to be to appease them at every cost and let them do what they want. There also appears to be a massive drama created on mn if a parent/teacher ever raises their voice at a child. Like yes we shouldn't shout constantly at kids but we are all human and kids can push boundaries yet the whole thinking that it will psychologically destroy them is nonsense.

There appears to be a softie softie approach on here and yet then when an op says her friend's kids are out of control the parent is condemned for not being firm enough, being too soft etc.

OP posts:
chipsandpeas · 04/01/2023 12:54

i can imagine the laughter at the police station when the OP calls the police saying my 15 year old wont wash the dishes

BiasedBinding · 04/01/2023 12:49

I’m not talking about what maybe ought to happen in an ideal society - I mean literally what do you do with your own teenager if they break the rules, you call the police, they tell you they can’t help you?

pillow56 · 04/01/2023 12:48

You can't suddenly give them a load of freedom at 18 and expect them to behave like adults if they've never been allowed to before. We need to prepare them for adulthood gradually

letting a 16 yo stay out all night and have no idea where they are etc isn't a ''prepare them for adulthood gradually'' though. It's irresponsible yet many on mn say it's no problem.
I'll be told I'm being unreasonable here but if there was a news story about a 15 yo dying of alcohol poisoning at 6 in the morning after an all night bender mn be up on arms blaming the parents, saying their kid would never have the chance to be out that that time etc...
Likewise if a 19 yo brought home a 25 yo boyfriend on mn it's seen as outrageous as they are still a kid etc.

OP posts:
BiasedBinding · 04/01/2023 12:47

pillow56 · 04/01/2023 12:27

no police time in Britain would be allocated to breaking the house rules, unless it was a safeguarding concern they wouldn't care

if a 15/16 yo is out drinking or refusing to come home it is very much a safe guarding issue

it may well be, but if the police aren’t actually able to do anything about it (because other priorities or whatever) it’s not a useful option in terms of consequences for your own teenager. What is your backup for if you call the police on your teenager who has disregarded your rules, and they tell you it’s up to you to deal with, they can’t do anything right now?

Lockheart · 04/01/2023 12:41

It's an unconscious bias called adultification and how people are perceived depends heavily on the circumstances and the perceiver, and what the perceiver wants to convey and wants others to think.

For example, if a 17 year old male commits a crime, he would likely be described by many on here as a man. Describing him as a man makes him easier to hate / be angry at in that circumstance. It justifies it more.

If a 17 year old male is conversely the victim of a crime, he would likely be described as a child. It is an emotional trick that elicits sympathy, in a direct opposite of the scenario above.

WhatNoRaisins · 04/01/2023 12:36

I'm not convinced there is anything that suddenly happens at 18, I've seen young adults who were babied as teenagers for the benefit of their anxious parents and they really struggled at this stage. The idea that you've just got to get them to this age and then it's all fine isn't realistic.

You have to let go, let them make more and more of their own decisions, let them take reasonable risks and potentially make mistakes. I think it's better that they make their mistakes while they're still young enough to have people's sympathy rather than at an age where they're expected to have their shit together.

girlmom21 · 04/01/2023 12:31

pillow56 · 04/01/2023 12:29

So does that change in 2 years time, as soon as they reach 18

I was waiting on this, yes there is a huge difference between a 16 yo and an 18yo in maturity, development, decision making etc.

And there is between 14 and 16. At some point you need to take a step back. You can't suddenly give them a load of freedom at 18 and expect them to behave like adults if they've never been allowed to before. We need to prepare them for adulthood gradually.

pillow56 · 04/01/2023 12:29

So does that change in 2 years time, as soon as they reach 18

I was waiting on this, yes there is a huge difference between a 16 yo and an 18yo in maturity, development, decision making etc.

OP posts: