Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Perspective from staff within NHS

314 replies

lowercaseletter · 04/01/2023 04:44

Posted anonymously by an A&E doctor:

Im writing this because I’m angry. Actually more than that, I’m fu*king livid.

I’m an A&E reg with 9+ years experience in A&E both here and overseas. This morning was the first time EVER that I cried in my car after a shift.

I was on nights over this New Years period, but New Year was not the issue, every shift is like this now.

Where 5 years ago we had 50 patients in the department on handover at night, we now have 180. It used to be around 20 patients to see with a 1-2 hour wait for clinician, it’s now 60-70 with a 10 hour wait.

People used to lose their minds if patients were coming up to 4 hour breaches. Last night 60% of the patients in A&E had been there for more than 12 hours, some for more than 40. Many I saw the night before, still in the same place when I came on.

No triage or obs after 2 hours of arrival, no bloods or ECGs or gas for 4 hours. Regularly finding people in the waiting room after 4 hours with initial gases showing hyperkalamia or severe acidosis or hypoglycaemia.

87 year olds coming in after falls sitting on chairs for 18 hours. Other elderly patients lying in their own urine for hours because there’s no staff, or even room to change them into something dry. As the reg in charge of the shift, Ive had (on multiple occasions) to help the sole nurse in the area change patients by holding a sheet around the bed because we have to do it in the middle of a corridor. People lying on the floor because there’s no chairs left, trolleys parked literally wherever we can put them.

Things have been getting even worse for the last 3 months. 5 weeks I came home raging to my wife that people are sitting in their own piss for hours and it’s so inhumane. Now we’ve got to the point where people are actually dying. People who’ve been in A&E for 2-3 days,

The media and public might blame the A&E nurses and doctors for this, but honestly what the fu*k are we meant to do with 180 people in a department built for 50. With 8 nurses rather than the MINIMUM staffing of 12. 1 or 2 nurses per area, giving meds, doing obs, trying to provide basic cares to 25-30 people, an absolute impossibility. And there’s less nurses every week, because honestly why would you put yourself through this day after day?

Resus patients are quickly assessed and stepped down to make room for the next pre-alert, going to the area with those same poor nurses, already overstretched, now inheriting an severely unwell patient.

We need to accept the truth, the NHS isn’t breaking, it’s broken. And the same bastards who broke it are doing reality TV shows and writing books about how they saved the NHS whilst refusing to increase nursing pay. We try and shovel shit with spoons whilst they pour it in with dump trucks

The NHS as we knew it is dead, and it breaks my heart, because it’s a beautiful system. It shouldn’t be like this, and those of us who have been around for longer than 5 years know it wasn’t always like this.

The public have no idea, they don’t really know how dangerous this all is. When they come in they’re horrified, but most of the population don’t know how bad it is. This could be their mum on a trolley for 17 hours, or their wife or son or daughter.

I genuinely feel it’s now our responsibility to speak out. We don’t for fear that it will make our hospital look bad or harm our careers. But it’s not a hospital problem, it’s a national problem, and it’s a problem brought about by the politics of the people in power.

We need to shine a light on what they’ve done, make the public so angry that they demand a change. Massive recruitment of nurses through a proper wage/paid uni/free parking/free Nando’s if that’s what it takes would be a start.

If anyone has any idea how we could coordinate some kind of campaign to show the state of emergency departments in the UK right now please write a response, because I can’t work in this much longer, and more importantly I’m not sure the patients can survive it.

OP posts:
WeNeedMoreFairyLights · 04/01/2023 09:44

So many nurses and doctors are now so burnt out you’ll get loads quitting or being on long term sick. I’ve seen so many people posting ab encouraging them to move to Australia and New Zealand where they’ll get treated better as staff.
The public think the answer is to make broken people work 7 days a week for free?
GPs are broken and if you want them to work sat/sun then they need 2 days off in the week. You wouldn’t expect that in your office job and if you were told to come and work on your annual leave you would tell you boss to fuck off.

The problem is the 1/3 of people in hospital well that people don’t want to help out by looking after relatives at home for a few weeks and there are no carers.

MarshaBradyo · 04/01/2023 09:43

Everanewbie · 04/01/2023 09:26

A terribly eye opening account of the state of our NHS. Unfortunately the account loses credibility with me with cheap and no-specific parting shots at Matt Hancock and the Conservative Party, which indicate political leanings and ulterior motives. I find it frustrating how Junior Doctors and Nurses unions strike and pontificate about "saving our NHS" etc. but are quite open about their willingness to return to work if those evil tories give in to their pay demands.

As a country, we need to permit our government to really drill into what is causing these problems. Work out why there is such an increased demand. Work out where the system is broken down and establish a plan. There is so much failure demand in the NHS, i.e. cock ups and "not my job" situations lead to more visits, phone calls, letters, emails for things that an efficient organization could one-and-done. The NHS needs the tools to be leaner and more efficient.

Yes, its staff are at times incredible, but the orgainsation can be pig-headed, resistant to change. Better resourcing may well be needed in some areas, but despite the "tories running the NHS into the ground" narrative, real terms spending on the NHS has grown year on year since 2010.

These FB type posts / rants seem to have the same flavour.

Thatusernamewastaken · 04/01/2023 09:39

Yeah, my mum was about 8 hours in the back of an ambulance outside A&E recently as there was no space for her. It was like a warzone in there. Waiting room packed and people on beds in corridors.
In no way a criticism of the staff who were absolutely amazing and lovely. Felt so, so bad for them. I've worked some tough jobs but seeing that, and the expectation to having to go in to deal with it day in, day out, must be extremely draining and traumatic. I definitely couldn't do it. They deserve their pay increase, and some! and a system that works and is properly funded.

Falalalalalalaetc · 04/01/2023 09:36

One thing that could also be done to ease pressure on GPs is stop the ridiculous attendance policies that require if a child happens to be a sick a lot one winter / doesn't have that magical 97% attendance immunity that you have to make a GP appointment on the first day of every period of sickness thereafter. Massive waste of GP time.

Falalalalalalaetc · 04/01/2023 09:34

Thismonkeysgonetodevon · 04/01/2023 09:07

@lowercaseletter Unfortunately I have had far too many dealings with my hospital recently, first with my terminally ill parent and now my chronically ill child. I just want to say that my experience has been mixed but the A&E doctors have all, without fail, been truly amazing. So thank you.

It’s heartbreaking what the Tories have done to the NHS, their mismanagement of funds, corruption and complacency for NHS staff is unforgivable.

On the other hand, reading threads on here where, when people suggest things like compulsory masks in medical settings or clean air in schools (would cut down illnesses leading to hospitalisation), they get a barrage of patronising, sneery replies shutting them down. There is a real lack of collective responsibility or will for change from the public which is also to blame.

It all feels incredibly helpless. And I’m so sorry for everyone on the front line.

I just want to say I agree 100% with this. I was one of a group of parents who paid for air filters in our children's classroom and it's fairly clear that they're making a difference - despite elsewhere (including in my other DC's secondary, where they move between classes) viruses being insanely rampant the levels of sickness absence have been lower than last year and also compared to data pre-pandemic and most importantly the teacher less sick since the filters went in.

They cost about £100 each and the classroom (which is big, as in an old building) needed two. The cost of proper air filtration and ventilation in schools would be more than paid for by one winter's lower respiratory illness bill for the NHS, not to mention the human costs.

Went to my GP surgery recently. Despite all staff there still wearing masks, hardly any of the patients were (I did and always do - it seems like basic respect). I don't understand how people are so RUDE. If you're going to the doctor because you have a cough, surely the least you can do is make the most basic effort not give it to all the frail elderly waiting for blood tests in the waiting area? People sitting there coughing with no attempt whatsoever to cover their mouth. And then they moan because the GP surgery is understaffed due to sickness and wonder why the receptionists are now behind a door rather than sitting behind the desk with people coughing freely over them.

WiseUpJanetWeiss · 04/01/2023 09:34

PaterPower · 04/01/2023 09:12

Paying back PFI is about 2% of the NHS budget per year. And we did get something for that money - new hospitals after many years of Tory neglect during the 1980s and early 90s.

PFI was an artificial construct, purely designed to hide capex on the government’s balance sheet. It made private companies (all Tory / New Labour donors) an absolute fortune whilst supplying poorly built new hospitals at a massive mark-up.

The contracts also covered much more than the hospital buildings, which is why it ended up costing Trusts £100s to change a single light bulb. Anything that needed changing had to be approved by the PFI holder who could charge even more for the privilege.

Eventually even the Tories couldn’t keep pretending that PFI was a good deal for taxpayers, nor that it had / has brought any efficiencies into the UK health ‘market.’ That’s why they’re not being used now (although there’ve been attempts to rebadge it).

If you look at the various programs run over the years by private companies for Government, I think you’d struggle to find one that has delivered anything close to what was originally promised, for anything close to the original price:

Police radio systems, NHS & Blue light IT ‘modernisation,’ the Royal Mail’s computerised accountancy program, HS2, electrification of the main rail routes, Hospital replacements, school building modernisation, Armed Forces housing (an absolute shit show), Armed Forces recruitment, private prisons, privatised probation services… and those are just what comes off the top of my head.

Anyone deluded enough to think that putting more of the NHS into private hands is just that… completely fucking deluded (or intends to make a fast buck off it).

Well yes, you cropped my post to omit the bit where I said I wasn't a fan of PFI. I'm not. You only have to look at the Carillion fiasco in Liverpool...

PPs were saying "Oh PFI - it's Labour's fault the NHS has insufficient funding" as a cop out to avoid addressing the absolute devastation the Tories have visited upon the NHS. I was simply calling that out.

HappyTalkingTalkingHappyTalk · 04/01/2023 09:34

I was forced to go to a&e the other week because of a kidney infection. I wouldn’t have got to that point if I could get a GP appointment but they wouldn’t see me despite being pregnant. I tried all home methods of treating it but it progressed to the point of agony and still I couldn’t get seen so 111 sent me there. My Gp surgery is always the same, impossible to contact or get an appointment for.

and you can’t get a GP appointment because they are over stretched dealing with, not only acute conditions, but also dealing with patients who have been on waiting lists to be seen at the hospital for several months (or even 18+ months!) and are struggling with their conditions. Add in patients who book in for little Thomas who ‘has woken up with a cough this morning’ or someone with a rash who could see the pharmacist, it’s no wonder you can’t get a GP appointment. For info to save someone waiting to see the GP, pharmacist can prescribe for UTI’s these days.

marmaladepop · 04/01/2023 09:29

My GP surgery has an additional service offered by the Livi app. It's free and you can get antibiotics prescribed over the phone if deemed necessary. It's not the overall answer by any means but the service is excellent.

spuddel · 04/01/2023 09:28

I have no idea if the NHS is fixable, doubt it very much. It's always in crisis and money doesn't seem to be the answer. I think perhaps what it was set up to be is no longer what it's used for. There are too many people now, we live longer lives, demand is too high. Management are advertising for crazy roles at 100K. We probably do need to look at the French health model.

Everanewbie · 04/01/2023 09:26

A terribly eye opening account of the state of our NHS. Unfortunately the account loses credibility with me with cheap and no-specific parting shots at Matt Hancock and the Conservative Party, which indicate political leanings and ulterior motives. I find it frustrating how Junior Doctors and Nurses unions strike and pontificate about "saving our NHS" etc. but are quite open about their willingness to return to work if those evil tories give in to their pay demands.

As a country, we need to permit our government to really drill into what is causing these problems. Work out why there is such an increased demand. Work out where the system is broken down and establish a plan. There is so much failure demand in the NHS, i.e. cock ups and "not my job" situations lead to more visits, phone calls, letters, emails for things that an efficient organization could one-and-done. The NHS needs the tools to be leaner and more efficient.

Yes, its staff are at times incredible, but the orgainsation can be pig-headed, resistant to change. Better resourcing may well be needed in some areas, but despite the "tories running the NHS into the ground" narrative, real terms spending on the NHS has grown year on year since 2010.

Museya15 · 04/01/2023 09:24

So what do YOU think has gone wrong?

rookiemere · 04/01/2023 09:24

@latelydaydreams yes locum rates are ridiculous. I'm amazed any nurses or doctors actually stay in the NHS rather than going fully shift based and working much less for more pay.

It seems obvious that you'd put a cap on that and use the money to up nurses salaries and pay generous overtime instead of insane locum rates.

MarshaBradyo · 04/01/2023 09:21

Gymgo · 04/01/2023 09:15

Yes cause nhs Wales and nhs Scotland is run so well

How would any other government do it ?

I know someone who has been suspended for 6 months pending a investigation band 8 full pay , do you really think this would happen in a private business and I'm sure this happens a lot

Yeh I don’t want Wales or SNP versions

latelydaydreams · 04/01/2023 09:20

totally agree @Kazzyhoward.

Pensions, 100k threshold withdrawal and IR35 are ridiculous.

I do think though that there should be some control of effective locum/bank rates. Incentivising rates that promote locuming rather than staffing is ineffective long term.

The money would be better used for improvements in long term pay and conditions.

Advicerequest · 04/01/2023 09:20

I now routinely pay for a private nhs doctor consultation and then send the letter to the gp to action (eg prescriptions, further I investigations).

Had to pay privately for physio after an accident as I can't get continuing appointments on the nhs ... I'd seen the ohysio but when I go to rebook next appointment they never have any spaces coming up!

Fuwari · 04/01/2023 09:20

The public sector as a whole is broken. I’m in the criminal justice sector. Not enough police to investigate crime, no Court slots for hearings, no prison places to put anyone, so all but the most serious of crimes get community sentences but there’s barely any probation officers left to supervise those. Staffing in prisons at dangerous levels.

The problems in the NHS affect more people, obviously. But it’s across the board in the public sector. Teachers are leaving in droves, as are social workers. All of these services need more money but there isn’t any.

Everything is broken.

XingMing · 04/01/2023 09:19

GPs need paying by the appointment, instead of for the number of people registered or hitting targets for prescribing statins. A modest charge, taken over the phone when making the appointment, would discourage DNAs.

But yes, my (late) DMIL spent 27 hours with suspected fractures on the floor of her nursing home before an ambulance arrived, in September 2022.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 04/01/2023 09:18

torquewench · 04/01/2023 06:03

Whats happened locally to this doctor over the last 5 years that's caused such a massive increase in people coming in to A&E?

Hush your mouth

Kazzyhoward · 04/01/2023 09:17

PaterPower · 04/01/2023 09:12

Paying back PFI is about 2% of the NHS budget per year. And we did get something for that money - new hospitals after many years of Tory neglect during the 1980s and early 90s.

PFI was an artificial construct, purely designed to hide capex on the government’s balance sheet. It made private companies (all Tory / New Labour donors) an absolute fortune whilst supplying poorly built new hospitals at a massive mark-up.

The contracts also covered much more than the hospital buildings, which is why it ended up costing Trusts £100s to change a single light bulb. Anything that needed changing had to be approved by the PFI holder who could charge even more for the privilege.

Eventually even the Tories couldn’t keep pretending that PFI was a good deal for taxpayers, nor that it had / has brought any efficiencies into the UK health ‘market.’ That’s why they’re not being used now (although there’ve been attempts to rebadge it).

If you look at the various programs run over the years by private companies for Government, I think you’d struggle to find one that has delivered anything close to what was originally promised, for anything close to the original price:

Police radio systems, NHS & Blue light IT ‘modernisation,’ the Royal Mail’s computerised accountancy program, HS2, electrification of the main rail routes, Hospital replacements, school building modernisation, Armed Forces housing (an absolute shit show), Armed Forces recruitment, private prisons, privatised probation services… and those are just what comes off the top of my head.

Anyone deluded enough to think that putting more of the NHS into private hands is just that… completely fucking deluded (or intends to make a fast buck off it).

All of that is poor procurement practices. If the public sector are stupid enough and incompetent enough to hand out contracts that aren't value for money, don't understand contract wording, and don't control the contracts, then obviously the firms providing the services aren't going to complain, are they?

All those things NEED private firms in one form or another. If a trust decides to build it's own hospital, it still needs private firms to actually build it, doesn't it? Or do you think the NHS should start employing bricklayers, plumbers, etc directly on their books?

The problem is down to the fools negotiating the contracts!

Advicerequest · 04/01/2023 09:16

I needed antibiotics for an animal bite and was told by the GP receptionist to go to A and E as the gp didn't have any appointments!!!!

Didn't go to a and E as a and E over stretched . By the time i'd fought my way back into the gp system the following day the infection had spread into my hand which was shiny and swollen and was heading down towards my wrist.

BillyMurphysFace · 04/01/2023 09:16

Sadly it's not just hospitals or GPs which are suffering. I work in an NHS psychology department (not general mental health, nor crisis service). Our service opened in July 2022 and we already have a waiting list of what must now be 700 people. People wait months just to be first seen. People wait months for medication reviews. We have little to no triaging system and the service is generally quite badly run. Raising problems to our superiors doesn't really get us anywhere - the assistants are more or less running the service, and there's only a handful of us. Our waiting times are constantly going up and up, and there's nothing we can do. There's just not enough people, not enough time in the day, and we're not commissioned as much as we should be. Not to mention there are at least 2 posts in my service sitting empty, because they can't recruit anyone for whatever reason. It's all such a massive mess.

Gymgo · 04/01/2023 09:15

Lalliella · 04/01/2023 08:32

Anyone who voted for the Tories and/or Brexit - this is your fault. Don’t vote Tory ever again.

Yes cause nhs Wales and nhs Scotland is run so well

How would any other government do it ?

I know someone who has been suspended for 6 months pending a investigation band 8 full pay , do you really think this would happen in a private business and I'm sure this happens a lot

Kazzyhoward · 04/01/2023 09:13

@rookiemere

Exactly- the doctors pension situation needs changing and fast, surely that's a quick win to implement.

IR35 also needs to be scrapped. I had several clients who were retired doctors operating their own personal service companies to provide locum services, mostly back to their previous practices to cover holidays and sick leave, etc. Because of IR35, they can't do that anymore, so now don't do any locum work at all. A massive loss to the NHS!

People who constantly carp on about "taxing the rich" need to understand what that means. With IR35, the doctor's pension problem, and the withdrawal of the personal allowance when income tops £100k, it's just become "too expensive" for doctors to work more than they need to! "Rich" people don't need to work as much, so the likes of experienced doctors need to be incentivised to work, not punished!

PaterPower · 04/01/2023 09:12

Paying back PFI is about 2% of the NHS budget per year. And we did get something for that money - new hospitals after many years of Tory neglect during the 1980s and early 90s.

PFI was an artificial construct, purely designed to hide capex on the government’s balance sheet. It made private companies (all Tory / New Labour donors) an absolute fortune whilst supplying poorly built new hospitals at a massive mark-up.

The contracts also covered much more than the hospital buildings, which is why it ended up costing Trusts £100s to change a single light bulb. Anything that needed changing had to be approved by the PFI holder who could charge even more for the privilege.

Eventually even the Tories couldn’t keep pretending that PFI was a good deal for taxpayers, nor that it had / has brought any efficiencies into the UK health ‘market.’ That’s why they’re not being used now (although there’ve been attempts to rebadge it).

If you look at the various programs run over the years by private companies for Government, I think you’d struggle to find one that has delivered anything close to what was originally promised, for anything close to the original price:

Police radio systems, NHS & Blue light IT ‘modernisation,’ the Royal Mail’s computerised accountancy program, HS2, electrification of the main rail routes, Hospital replacements, school building modernisation, Armed Forces housing (an absolute shit show), Armed Forces recruitment, private prisons, privatised probation services… and those are just what comes off the top of my head.

Anyone deluded enough to think that putting more of the NHS into private hands is just that… completely fucking deluded (or intends to make a fast buck off it).

HopefullyBePregnantViaIUI · 04/01/2023 09:10

Another example of this aswell - a family member of mines under 40 years old. Attended the GP time and time again with issues in relation to abnormal vaginal bleeding to be fobbed off, thrown medication. It was so bad we attended one night to a and e and were refused to be seen by gynae due to their workload - 3 days before xmas she was diagnosed with cancer at the outpatient clinic.